Went here yesterday and had a great experience! Made a reservation for 8 and they accompanied great. Everyone at the table had amazing meals and the waitress was so kind and attentive. Everyone thought their food was amazing. I got the baked cod and it was delicious read more

Black Lantern Tavern - Baked Cod - Salad Near Me - Plymouth, Massachusetts

i visited with 2 guests on a busy summer friday afternoon, and they had a few seats left inside, but no luck on the patio. luckily they have plenty of seating, two dining rooms and a decent sized bar. one of my guests and i both ordered their rib-eye (mp). the ribeye was good, no bone, but extra fatty (even for a rib-eye). it was cooked nearly perfectly with delicious compound butter. the asparagus was cooked perfectly, mashed potatoes were good but needed a bit extra whipping, salt, pepper & butter. price was great, market price at $42 each. fish & chips were great, really fresh cod/haddock. for dessert we tried their apple crisp was huge even for 3 people & amazing. service was great, although it was very busy and at the end, i did get locked out from the dining room after going to the restroom which is in an attached building? it took almost 10 minutes to get anyone's attention. they should probably not lock the doors while people are still dining in that room. still, i chatted with a few of the servers and bartenders and they were great. ribeye 7.8/10 fish & chips 10/10 apple crisp pie 10/10 black lantern tavern is a great restaurant in the area. we had a good meal overall, and pleasant experience. ambiance: 5/5 food: 4.6/5 drinks: 5/5 service: 4.8/5 black lantern tavern: 4.8/5 read more

See all

Came here just for drinks with my boyfriend and my cocktail was amazing! His smelled amazing too. They were presented very nicely with perfect garnishes. The ambiance of the space is a little odd---the decor and furniture doesn't seem to flow with the space, but the bar was nice. Kirsten took care of us and she was wonderful. We will def come back! read more

Black Lantern Tavern - Salad Near Me - Plymouth, Massachusetts

See all

This was not far from some friends so we stopped in here for dinner one day. It was pouring rain outside but inside was warm and welcoming, we got a table right away. We all got something different and shared among the group and all the food was delicious, I had order a pizza and it came out nice and hot and we all enjoyed our dinners. read more

Real service. We have been grateful (after 20+ yrs) to have a local restaurant come into our neighborhood. Fresh food, great cocktails and consistently done. On a few occasions using the Toast app for takeout it's has created confusion/wrong orders and last night we finally drove back with our pizza. Previously we just sucked it up. (order black olives=received kalamata olives?? Add ricotta to your pizza=it removes the regular mozzarella blend chz so no cheese??) You always anticipate push back on a return however the staff appreciated the feedback about last nights order and the feedback of previous orders we had not shared. While waiting for our new pizza multiple staff members asked if we needed assistance and kept us aware of the status of our order. What a great team of people and the new pizza was delicious. If you plan to order take out... I recommend calling it in. ;) read more

Depending on the time of day/day of the week you stop by, it can be kinda busy here. BUT TOTALLY WORTH IT AND HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! We went for lunch last week (got seated right away- bonus!) and split some onion rings while we waited for our meals: I got a custom pizza and my fiancé got the fajita bowl. We didn't wait long at all and the food was absolutely phenomenal! Service is impeccable, they make you feel very taken care of. The inside of the restaurant is super chic- some rustic and some modern elements- and it's very pretty and open. The bar is huge too. We will definitely be going back again soon! 12/10 read more

Black Lantern Tavern - Build your own pizza: vodka tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, and garlic - Salad Near Me - Plymouth, Massachusetts

See all

Absolutely one of my favorite places... The food is always great with new specials all the time. The wait staff and the bartenders are super nice. Comfortable and cozy atmosphere. read more

I have been meaning to try this neighborhood establishment for sometime, but until recently they have not had a website just a Facebook page so being able to determine what they offered in hours wasn't always the easiest We went there for dinner on Saturday night and the place was fairly busy. The young kid at the host stand was a little inexperienced and unsure of himself. Our waitress was friendly and efficient I'm not sure how many tables she had as we did not see her that often at our table did see her hustling around the entire time. Food was good I had the fish and chips which was a nicely fried beer battered piece of fish in the fries were unique in a good way. The only negatives were that there was no salt, pepper or ketchup on the table. We requested salt, pepper, ketchup vinegar. But only received salt and ketchup. For some reason, the fish and chips was not served with a side of tartar sauce, which I had to request. It didn't show up until I was almost finished. Beer selection seemed a little limited Overall, it was a decent experience and I would give the place another shot read more

Ordered several items to give it a fair try, but wasn't enjoyable food except for a good shrimp cocktail.

So I was looking for something new in the area and read some reviews on this place and decided to give it a try. We were a little early for dinner so decided to get an appetizer and some salads before the dinner menu was offered. We ordered the tater tot kegs with bacon cheddar and chives, they were very tasty with a nice crispy outside and a really pillowy inside. None of the components overpowered the other which made them that much better. The salads were very fresh and the dressings were great. When the mains came out I was pleasantly surprised at how fresh and hot everything was, my steak was cooked to perfection and the potatoes wedges were a very nice touch instead of the same old mashed potatoes. The green beans were not overcooked and had a nice garlic taste too them as well. My wife's meal was nicely prepared and the mushroom sauce was excellent and the braised short ribs were very flavorful and very tender, and the onion rings were excellent as well. I can't wait to return and try the other items on the menu! read more

Black Lantern Tavern - Ribeye Steak - Salad Near Me - Plymouth, Massachusetts

See all

Food is always good. Always greeted with a smile. Wait staff is attentive and friendly. Pretty restaurant with comfortable seating. read more

We've been back a few times since my review. They had a great chef and now he's gone. Since then the quality and portion size has gone way down. Not nearly as good as they once were. This is a tough update to write because we like the owner. They had an award winning chef and BLT has suffered from his absence. Drama in the kitchen and, according to employees, the wrong person was terminated. read more

Excellent food and service. We will certainly be repeat customers . Very few upscale dining options in South Plymouth. Great to have BL here. read more

Wings are off the charts and the atmosphere is first class, must stop Heard they do Sunday brunch as well definitely will be back soon read more

Had dinner with my Wife this past Saturday. Called to make a last minute reservation for dinner, hostess was friendly and accommodating. Dining room is nicely designed in a modern way. Service was exceptional from start to finish. Cocktail was perfect, beer was fresh and tasty. Dinner was amazing! We had Salmon and Roast Chicken, both were perfect. I would highly recommend! read more

Do love the atmosphere and the food but...went last night around 8:30 Was told the place closes at 10:00 which is definitely not on the web except for Sunday Around 9:45 ordered another round of drinks and was told last call was a half hour prior We were not made aware of this! Seems like the staff really wanted to leave Ongoing IF we go there and this happens the tips will reflect our experience The bartender and waitress blamed Google! Thinking not true read more

I have been to this restaurant a few times since it opened and had a good experience every time. As I write this review they have 1 review and a 2 star rating. That had not been my experience. Mine had been a 4 star experience on at least 3 visits. I am rating them a 5 to help their average. I have had the burger, salmon and steak as entrees and all were tasty and well prepared. I have ordered the hummus platter every visit and it is great. There is a very good selection of wine beer and cocktails. I like the house Malbec. Please see the pic I posted of the menu. The decor and ambiance is nice and is well done. The bar area is spacious and the seating is plentiful. So is the outdoor seating area in good weather. My service has been exceptional on every visit. I would be happy to come back here any time ...and will. If I had one ding it would be to have a few better vegan options. I am not a vegan but dine with them and like to eat this way sometimes. A vegan protein for salads would be an easy add. So would an entree or too. Fried tofu, some local squash, maybe skip the feta on the hummus plate, ... and I hear quinoa is popular with the vegan set. Anyway, really like this place overall. Very pleased to have it in this part of Plymouth. Not sure what happened with other reviewer. Every time I am in there are plenty of happy diners. Two thumbs up. read more

See all

Don't expect to online order take-out (e.g. pizza) at 8 pm on a Saturday even though place doesn't close until 11 pm.

We celebrated an 87th birthday there, the youngest attendee being 8 . Everyone easily chose a meal they liked including from a kids menu. The menu is well thought out. Parking is readily available and there is play area outback for the kids. The whole area is impressive. read more

Fabulous food. Great brunch buffet for Easter and Mother's Day. Highly recommend. Sahin ( the owner) is great.

Food was okay. Nothing special. Service was not friendly or welcoming. Only good thing to say is that is a comfortable space with adequate room between tables so you don't feel like you're eating with your neighbor. read more

Staff was very friendly and attentive. The owner came by and chatted. We took our time and enjoyed the atmosphere. Nice to have such a friendly place close to home! read more

Dined at the Black Lantern Tavern with a party of 11 this past week. It was a great experience - everyone was friendly and welcoming. Our server was attentive the entire evening. Everyone in our party enjoyed their food. The appetizers were delicious. We got the fried calamari, wings, tater kegs, steak and cheese egg rolls and the bang bang cauliflower. The scallops for my main course were perfectly cooked and the other members of the party all enjoyed their meals as well. Give this place a try, and I think you'd be glad that you did. read more

Food quality is very good, try the mussels, Service is consistent and above what most people expect and ambiance is upscale & friendly.

Great addition to Redbrook Community. Welcoming atmosphere, great food and drink and a responsive staff.

My husband, another couple and I decided to try a newly opened fine dining restaurant in the Redbrook Community in Plymouth, MA. The furnishings and lighting were very tasteful and the ambiance comfortable and serene. Our male companion was very satisfied with the seafood cioppino dish he ordered along with a rather dry Caesar Salad. My husband and I shared a flavorful Capresse salad to start and decided to try something new: a short rib poutine entree. We were sorely disappointed and left most of it uneaten. It turned out to be a bowlful of mush containing about four minuscule pieces of meat with soggy French fries, and tasteless melted cheese covered with what tasted like canned meat gravy. Given that the first words for this entry on the menu were short ribs, we expected a decent portion of meat on the bone and got neither. When the waitress checked on us, I explained our disappointment and she just apologized, not offering to give us a substitution or remove the charge for the dish. She could easily tell we were unhappy with the choice, yet made no effort to check with the manager to make things right. Since this restaurant has only been open a few weeks, and it wasn't overly crowded, I would think the owners/manager would make a concerted effort to make sure customers left feeling well fed and pleased with their dining experience. But since neither occurred, it will be a long time, if ever, that we will return. read more

The food here is very good! The ravioli are so good! My husband enjoyed his salmon. They always accommodate my BBQ chicken loving boy..the sangria and cheese cake are also an A+. The service is always friendly and fast! read more

Food is good, service is good, ambiance is great! I think it's a solid 4 - the building is fairly new and the design is a very nice tavern. We enjoyed the Thursday night special the last time we went - a nice bottle of wine, an appetizer and 2 entrees for $75. read more

Had such a great experience here visiting from Florida. A little off the beaten path but a must see place. Next time we are in town we will make sure to be here again read more

We tried Black Lantern tonight. It wasn't overly crowded and they had live music. Very cute place with a modern atmosphere. Food was average. The steak tips had no flavor other than charcoal. The Tater Tots were good, but over priced. The fish tacos were very good. The service was very good as well. read more

Service was mediocre. Out of 10 of us, no one was satisfied with food. Steaks were asked to be medium, and all came out overdone

Black lantern is one of my favorite spots!! Food is always consistently amazing as well as the service!! Joey is the best and always has a smile on his face! Couldn't recommend more! read more

Truly one of our favorite places. Food is outstanding, atmosphere is absolutely beautiful and service is friendly and quick. So glad this place is top notch and only 2 mi from where we live in Wareham. Favorite date nights for myself and hubby is at the Black lantern. read more

I really don't understand the 5 star reviews. The restaurant itself is beautiful and it has a great ambiance and the service is good but the actual food is mediocre at best. I've eaten here a dozen or so times since moving to Redbrook and I've yet to get a really good meal. Extremely overcooked burgers, short ribs that are tough as nails, flavorless seafood, meatballs and steak tips. I think I've tried most of the menu hoping it gets better but it never does. I've repeatedly left disappointed. I'll definitely keep coming here for a few glasses of wine because it's so close but I don't think I'll be ordering the food anymore. read more

I am not a person to leave negative reviews on anything, but my experience at Black Lantern Tavern was disappointing. We sat outside, and while the patio was beautiful, our service was honestly terrible. I have worked in the restaurant industry for years, and it seemed they did everything wrong. It took 10 minutes for our waitress to even approach us or take our drink order, and while we were there our waitress came to our table maybe 3 times (apart from the issue I will mention later). Our appetizer was served by a food runner who was surprised we hadn't been served silverware or plates yet, and our appetizer started to get cold because we had no silverware to eat it with. Our food was another issue- my partner ordered steak frites which was overcooked but she enjoyed nonetheless. I ordered chicken parm with ziti and received eggplant parm with linguine. It took a few minutes for a waitress to come out so I could inform her of the mistake, and then another few minutes for new food to be delivered. She informed us that was not the first time that happened even that night. I received my food after my partner had already finished. Our waitress offered no remedy, and I was very surprised nothing on the bill was taken off, not even a free app, drink, or dessert was offered despite having a consistently annoying experience. While the food was pretty good and our waitress was friendly, the service was disorganized and made our experience overall negative. Hope they can fix this in the future. read more

last night the prime rib was delicious! the Sunday brunch is the best in town. Great drinks too