Best little dive bar with a deliciously tasty menu of pretty much anything you'd hope to find on a…read more"bar menu" (burgers, fries, A LOT of other fried things etc). The fried pickles are super yummy!! Best thing about this place is the staff. Jackie & Todd are both very friendly and make you feel right at home! Also, the price is RIGHT. This is, by far, the most adorable place to stop for a drink and a bite in the Hamptons!!

Great wings. Good place for lunch .. then stop by the smoke shop in your way to Montaukread more

We ordered take out in the way back from the beach. The food is very good. The atmosphere is a…read moreclassic pub with wood walls, memorabilia and such. There's a bit of an out door seating situation happening and a full bar. Staff is welcoming and friendly. I love the local feel it has in that area and the casualness of it all. The food was really good. I'd return to dine in or have drinks.

Well..... we ordered guacamole and chips as an appetizer. The plate had tons of warm and yummy…read morechips. The plate came with and I kid you not possibly 2 Tablespoons of guacamole!!!!! I called the waitstaff over and asked if there was an error in the portion of guacamole. THERE WAS NOT. I am not exaggerating- 2 TABLESPOONS OF GUACAMOLE in a tiny little vessel. REALLY???? Do not order this appetizer for the rip off price of $13!!!!!!!!!

The two appetizers and one entree we shared were the best or equal to the best we've ever had…read more Regularly ordered: Zucchini chips: Tied with the best in Venice Italy where it included calamari which was not as good as her. Calamari (a favorite) and banana peppers were perfectly cooked, nice lingering heat ... as good as anywhere. Japanese pizza! the reason for the 5 stars. Crisp, tasty rice crust, generous sashimi, avocado, elegantly presented. Friend had Pasta Bolognese. Generous portion. Didn't taste it, but It's the way I learned it (and cook it) a rich, slow cooked meat, cream and butter sauce. 95% places serve a tomato based sauce, barely distinguishable from standard meat sauce. My only small gripe is the martini glasses are the smaller ones! My wife had a wonderful Cucumber Cosmos. I really have no gripe about the service. but had to request refills on my water. One person wanted bread and it was extra, but generous. Nice flavored butter, but olive oil to dip it in would have been nice. The check included tip (large party) was clearly marked and labeled and was based on the tab, sans tax. Suggested tips often suggest tipping up to 50% as some restaurants imply when they print the suggested amounts of 20-25% on the total tab which already includes a service fee.

Food here was really good!! Definitely recommend!! I will say a lot of stuff was not available but…read morewe still had a good experience and service was quick!!

Food was phenomenal! Service was even better!! I'm from the west coast & these wings are why I…read moretravel to the East!! The vibe was super chill too!

Extremely disappointed. We made a reservation for 8 people, yet when we arrived, our table had been…read moregiven away. I have never experienced that before. What was most frustrating was the lack of effort to make the situation right. While we ultimately stayed, our party was split between separate tables, and there was no attempt to accommodate us by rearranging or combining tables so that our group could sit together. We received little more than a brief apology and were left to make the best of a situation that shouldn't have happened in the first place. Unfortunately, the service issues continued throughout the meal. Our appetizers and main courses were brought out at the same time, making it feel rushed and poorly coordinated. As local residents, we were especially disappointed. We try to support local businesses and chose Southampton Publick House for a gathering with friends and family. Instead, a reservation we planned around wasn't honored, our group couldn't sit together, and the dining experience felt disorganized from start to finish. A reservation should mean that a table is reserved. Unfortunately, this experience left a very poor impression.

Food was excellent. Service was excellent. Highly recommend if you're in the Greenport area.read more

This was such a pleasant surprise !…read more I was in the area with my fiancé and my parents and we wanted some lunch. We stumbled upon this place and it didn't disappoint! I had the Asian tuna wrap. It was good, but I felt it needed more inside the wrap other than just lettuce. I think some avocado would be perfection! It was good though. I got sweet potato fries as my side and they were great. My fiancé and my mom both got a half rack of ribs. They both enjoyed them and stated they fell right off the bone! My mom got the house made chips as her side and my fiancé got regular fries. Both were yummy! My stepdad got a burger which he also enjoyed. Beers were nice and cold too. Service was decent. I do wish our waitress came back to check on us after we got our food..but it's okay! We all agreed we would come back!

We weren't sure where to eat this weekend and passed Rowdy Hall. It was pretty crowded in the…read moredining room so we opted to sit outside under a GIANT umbrella which kept us protected from the chilly air. HUbby had a pork Chop on top of wheatberry salad and French fries. I had a burger with sweet potato fries which were the best!! We had a Hugo spritz although we wanted a limoncello spritz but the restaurant didn't have limoncello which was surprising Yusuf was our waiter and he was terrific, very attentive

Still good. We loved RH went it was in East Hampton. New location in Amagansett. Solid menu and…read moreexecution. Everything we ordered was good: fish and chips, Rowdy burger had great charred beef flavor, the mussels were excellent, and the daily special of French Dip was good (beef was a tad bit dry). Would order the burger and mussels again. Friendly service. Fun pub atmosphere.

Still a four star as I reviewed last year! Baked clams, calamari, burger, and sirloin steak were…read moreall great tasting and a great value. The service was excellent!! Just remember it is very casual and a Sports Bar- not a place to propose.

The Food and service was great. Maryanne was terrific as our server…read more We had a great time at the restaurant.

Our fave place! Best hidden gem in the Hamptons and the owners have a new place opening in town…read moresoon! The energy is always great whether we are watching the Knicks or having dinner with all our favorite friends. The food is so good and the menu has so many choices!!! Shout out to Alex and his dad! Love talking to both of you!

Great little tavern on the side of the road in the spring. They have an indoor outdoor restaurant…read morewith a full service bar and lots of TVs. Outside the picnic tables all have umbrellas and in the fall, they keep the windows and doors open to the outside. If you participate in Blackbird, make sure to check in. Great prices for bottles of wine and their fish and chips are so flaky and tender. There's a little bit of something here for everyone and a great value for the amount of food that you're getting!

Foods great. Service is awesome. Shagwong IS Montauk. The people are like family. Some actually…read moreare. Definitely a must-go.

We visited on a rainy Columbus Day, and the place was packed. Despite being clearly overworked, the…read morestaff was great, the beers were cold, and the clam chowder was excellent. Unfortunately, there's no accessible toilet. I understand that Shagwong is an older, tight space, and I'm not expecting miracles. But no grab bars? Not even an attempt to make the bathroom accessible? The food and staff deserve the praise. The lack of accessibility deserves to be called out.

Great restaurant, locally popular serving up some good pizza and a fun loving bartender‍read more

The decor and built ins and bar and walls look like they're mostly original from the 1940s which…read morewas very cool. Service was easy breezy, greeted pretty promptly, given a wait time and sat down within it. We came for the main event, the pizza. It was pretty darn good. The table ordered a pepperoni and a sausage meatball onion garlic and I went for the most esoteric options- the Sam's (add anchovies) and the Bonac filled up with the shellfish and I liked it, though it's probably not for everyone. I think the pizzas were a little underdone and the crusts weren't as bubbling and perfect as a lot of NY pizza would be