Tried this place for the first time after picking up an order for a group. They have some fun and…read moreinteresting pizza options, and I decided to go with the classic personal pie. A heads-up if you're driving: parking can be a little difficult. There's a sign pointing to parking in the rear, but the lot is pretty small. You may be better off parking on a side street and walking over. I went just before the lunch hour, and the line was already out the door. They were also getting plenty of phone calls, so they definitely seem to have a busy business going. As for the pizza, the taste was good overall. The dough was a little tough and seemed possibly overdone, and the type of cheese they use made the pizza feel a bit greasy. That said, I'd be willing to try it again. Next time, I might skip the personal pie and try a different size or style to see if that makes a difference. Staff were very kind!!!! * I didn't see any slices on display, but people were ordering by the slice.

Grumpy's Sourdough Pizza Co. 522 Saddle River Rd…read more Saddle Brook, NJ 07663 Hot Honey Heaven Grumpy's Triple Threat Multiple people have reached out to me and suggested I explore this locally owned pizzeria located in the heart of Saddle Brook. As I entered the parlor, it is a hole in the wall with minimal seating and no AC unit. Regardless that it wasn't fancy, I still had a very gut instinct the quality of their pies was going to be on the money. When I arrived a weekday afternoon to place my order, the cashier informed me there will be a 40 minute wait. For the fact that the wait is this long indicates there are in demand and their pizza is top quality. I also saw framed plaques along their table counter showing they received positive media recognition from The Record, northjersey.com, and bestofnj.com. Hot Honey Heaven: I was initially skeptical about the appearance of this pie because it looks kind of messy. However, I took a single bite and was immediately hooked. This pie was topped with pepperoni, crispy chicken, and ricotta cheese. Mike's Hot Honey was generously poured over the top. It has a combination of sweet and spiciness. I never anticipated honey would enhance the flavor of the pie; I wish I requested an extra cup! Grumpy's Triple Threat: Named after the restaurant, this pie is prepared with pesto, grandma sauce, and pink tomato sauce. The sprinkled parmigiano reggiano added a nice touch. I especially liked the artistic appearance. The three colors were visually appealing, especially with the swirls of pesto. All pies are prepared with their signature sourdough pizza crust. Each slice had a perfect undercarriage and a firm crunch. Customers have the option to bake the pies may light, medium, or well-done. I chose medium because a majority of the customer base prefers this style. As a bonus, Grumpy's offer complimentary crust upgrades. I opted to add garlic butter brush; the outer crust edge was literally brushed with hot, garlic-infused butter. While it is common to throw away the top portion of the pizza, the upgrade is definitely an incentive to eat the crust. San Marzano tomatoes are the primary ingredient for the sauce. It's not overly sweet and has a light tang. This pizzeria is geared for take out, but there are plenty of benches only minutes away at Saddle River County Park. You can enjoy your pie while admiring the beautiful scenery of the park. The parking lot has limited spaces, but you can easily find a spot on the street. Grumpy's may be a hole in the wall, but the pizza was outstanding. I'm really exuberant that I had a pristine experience exploring sourdough crust for the first time! I was far from "grumpy" after dining here! #grumpys #grumpyssourdoughpizzaco #grumpystriplethreat #hothoneyheaven

Five stars to all three, food, service and ambiance…read more I will definitely recommend restaurant

OUTSTANDING!!! If…read moreyou like authentic Italian food and not the sauce heavy oil laden foods most local places make then try this place!!! We grabbed a table on a Saturday night we were immediately impressed by the amazing smells upon entering . I spent my summers in Italy growing up and this place took me back . Our wonderful waitress and over and left some bread and oil while we looked at the menu. We agreed upon the califlower as an app . Hubby had the eggplant parm and I did the pasta with shrimp and broccoli . We also got a side of broccoli rabe, the meals also came with a nice side salad . The portions are a realistic smaller size and delicious. Unbelievably so! Fresh and great quality olive oil is used you can taste the difference. We were going to splurge and get dessert but they only had chocolate cake or ice cream so we declined . It is a byob. We honestly already said we will be going again next week! Please do yourself a favor and visit!

Went to rays at around 2 pm and got myself a white pizza, my daughter a buffalo chicken and my son…read morea plain. We were all pleased with our one slice. The slice size in my opinion is generous, price wasn't bad either considering two speciality slices and one plain being around 12 something. I haven't been here in a while but service was excellent and quick. They have a dining room area where you can sit and eat. They have so much food options I def need to come back and try!

So-so but its always there if you want a slice or take-out. There is no decor. It is convenient to…read morethe surrounding towns.

Really enjoyed my pizza today . I had 2 slices a few weeks ago and I decided to order the pie today…read more. The texture is perfect and the cheese and sauce are made just right! I really look forward to this pizza.

A good pizza with very gracious customer service. I ordered 3 pizzas from here before, a plain,…read morebuffalo chicken, and chicken cutlet. I would say the buffalo chicken was the favorite, especially since it is different from buffalo chicken pizzas I've had from other pizza places. Here, it was a creamy buffalo sauce that replaced a traditional plain tomato sauce and not just hot sauce drizzled over a regular chicken pizza like in other pizza places, and it tasted pretty good. Plain and chicken cutlet were pretty good but not outstanding. To quote another reviewer here, I am no pizza expert, so I cannot offer a more detailed critique. That being said, even their plain is a bit different from many other pizza places and it may even be to the preference of some, so credit must be given where it is due, and I believe it is due to their sauce and crust mainly. To taste a bit of a different pizza is refreshing and enjoyable. And the owner of the restaurant (at least who I presume the guy behind the counter to be) seemed very nice to me also, so I believe they are worth giving a shot. In conclusion, Two Guys is an underrated pizza place that is quite deserving of the business it gets.

This is another pizza place we love visiting. We came here twice in just two weeks of time span,…read morebecause it was too good the first time. It's a small place with outdoor seating. We didn't have any issues as it was only two of us. For large groups, it would be much better to get it to go. The service is prompt. Food delicious.

This is definitely a spot worth visiting. I love that everything is made in house -- you can really…read moretaste the freshness in the food. The restaurant itself is beautiful and aesthetic, and the atmosphere is warm and inviting enough to keep you coming back. The meatballs were incredibly tender and full of flavor. While the pasta wasn't the best I've ever had, I did appreciate that it wasn't too heavy on my stomach. Overall, it's a great place for a nice meal and a great dining experience.

My family enjoyed a perfectly cooked Sicilian pizza last night. Sauce has a nice flavor and cheese…read moreslightly brown. Highly recommend.

Simple local pizza place. Limited options and slices but thin and tasty. Staff were polite. Good…read moreoption for a quick plain slice.

The best pizza flavor that we have ever tasted in the United States. The family owned staff is warm…read moreand welcoming and is quick to tell you what the best food is on their menu is today

Great pie and drinks ! Service is ok, the atmosphere is perfect for an old joint we will be back…read moreagain

I came here with my two friends. Together we are the big guys and we based our order on what we…read moreorder at other pizza restaurants. Two pizzas and wings at other places and we'll leave with no leftovers and still feel hungry. Let me lead you to our mistakes here. The servings are bigger here. We ordered 20 wings and meatballs as our appetizer and 2 16" pizzas- carnivori and a meatball and ricotta. We left with about half of each. The favorite was definitely their wings. 10 original and 10 buffalo. The bishop was just your basic buffalo wing sauce with a touch of heat, maybe a 7.5 out of 10 for having the extra dribbling of sauce and bread to soak it up. The original was the best. Original sauce with no heat behind it but it's paired with caramelized onion and some dip. It's a unique flavor that I enjoyed with no heat but it's the sweet salty combination that makes meat good. That flavor gets a 9.5 out of 10. We kinda opted for a traditional meat lover type pie and more experimental meatball ricotta as a let's try it out. Again, the meat lover pie was just a basic pizza but on a nice crust. It's not a thin NY style or Chicago style deep dish- it's in a goldilocks spot of crust thickness. The star of the night was the meatball pizza. Mini meatballs scattered around. Chunks here and there do if you wanted a meaty slice or cheesy slice it was all there. Sauce is spot on. Italian plum tomato sauce- just a perfect balance of sweet... for a chain, it's probably one of the best. 9/10 on the pizzas. Meatballs were a nice mix. Not a heavy breading mix but not just a ball of ground meat. Also not a meatloaf heft of breading but it's still well seasoned. It's a good meatball parm sandwich type of meatball. The food came out fast but service was just needs some improvement by checking in for drinks/refills but they also had a few large parties going on so I'll let it slide. Overall it's a place my friends enjoyed and said that they would take their kids to. I would recommend it to friends and families with kids.

Went to Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza in Fairlawn (actually meant to head to the Wayne location --…read morewrong address in the GPS, but ended up here) and had a pretty disappointing experience at the outdoor bar. We asked to change the TV from a Spanish-language soccer broadcast to something else since none of us could follow along. Simple request, but the manager seemed put off by it. He handed the remote to a young bartender, who struggled with it for a while before handing it back to him. Instead of just asking what we'd actually want to watch, he put on baseball -- never asked, never checked in, just picked something and moved on to chat with what looked like regulars at the bar. It came across like our comfort wasn't really a concern once he'd "handled" it. Service issues aside, the real letdown was the attitude. As I was leaving and pushing in my barstool, a waiter dropped a can and some silverware near my feet. I told him not to worry about it, nothing got on me -- and the manager, who was nearby chatting with another regular, chimed in with a dismissive "no harm, no foul." Not exactly the tone you want from someone managing customer relationships. The food is fine, but the way this manager handled two small, easily fixable moments left a bad taste. A little more attentiveness and basic customer service awareness would go a long way here.

Good food, good service good for you!…read more I like the past and Pizza they are so delicious.

Try it for first time, asked for well done it was well done. Great sauce and cheese ratio. Not…read morethin or thick just right. Great taste will be going back to my new pizza spot. Great customer service very personable and friendly.

Service was great. There was a young lady named Tina who was very pleasant and polite when taking…read moremy order. This place seems like a nice small spot with workers who care. Ambiance: it's pretty small inside however they have some seating available. I would say it's good enough for a quick bite to get with family or friends. Food: I had the grandma pie and it was delicious, tasty, saucy, and cheesy! I can see why this is a popular item. It was prepared fresh to order and I was pleasantly pleased that it was not drenched in oil. Cant wait to stop by and try out other items on the menu. I was recommended the drunken grandma next time !

The food here is quite good but do check your bottom line price when you order. I was charged $28…read morefor a personal pizza that was listed as $14.95. Even with a small charge for toppings this differential was never explained to me, nor did the owner make an effort to return the overage. Do not plan to return.