The Bent Prop Pub is a great little restaurant located right on Coldwater Lake. It has ample parking across the street and a boat dock that can accommodate ~6-7 boats for lake access. We dined upstairs (Pub on lower level) and had some excellent food. The Garlic Breaded Cheese Curds are amazing (cubed cheese) and recommend either/or Marinara and Ranch. The Pretzel was also very good, but the standout was the bar cheese sauce, which appears more of a creamy fondue than straight cheese wiz and was very flavorful. Main dishes were the Pollock Fish Basket with Fries, Chicken Quesadilla with Lime Rice and the Steak Bites App with a side of Broccoli. Everything was very good,l and the food was hot and service super fast. Staff was extremely friendly and knowledgeable and dining right on the lake is always a plus. Plus we didn't have a wait arriving at 6:30ish on a Saturday evening. Bent Prop Pub earned a five star review due to its food, ambiance, staff and being a nice little gem of a restaurant and pub tucked away in a sleepy section of the Eastern shore of Coldwater Lake. Would definitely go back when we are back up in the area. read more

See all

They've closed unfortunately before the season. Was great! It's now called something new. Tipsy turtle I believe haven't been yet.

It's been a few years since I've been here, but we were out on Coldwater Lake and wanted some lunch for the boat, so we thought pizza would be good. You can dock up, walk in and either dine in or take your food out. Ordering by phone was easy and they texted us when they were ready, pretty quick. Unfortunately the pizzas themselves were a let down. 2 large with toppings and 1 small cheese for $70. The toppings were sparse, compare our pizzas va the photos on their website, and the cheese on the cheese pizza was cheddar. The crust was thin and crispy, similar to Dominos thin. Probably will pass on pizza here next time. The ambiance seems nice here. Also, they serve The Chocolate Shop ice cream from Wisconsin which I did not get to try, but it is says super premium ice, which is ice cream on another level. A few examples of super premium include Costco brand vanilla, Trader Joe's vanilla, Members Mark super premium at Sam's, and Aldi Super Premium vanilla. I think the Kirkland is the best. read more

See all

We came here with a group last Friday and everyone really enjoyed it. The food and service were both excellent. The liked the location on the lake and would definitely come back if we were back in the area. It was a casual atmosphere and overall I'd highly recommend especially in the summer. read more

Bent Prop Pub - American Near Me - Coldwater, Michigan

Awesome ambiance! This is right on the water. If you go downstairs you can sit outside in the screened section looking right at the lake. Or you can choose to sit inside. The food was good! For our appetizer, We got the Prop Bites (Cheese Curds) they were good but quite salty. My husband and I both got the Grouper strips. They were really good. The breading was a little thicker than we like but it was good, as were their chips and coleslaw. Anna was great! The service was very quick! We had our apps within 5 minutes! Our meals came shortly after! Our server was very attentive too! read more

I'm shocked at these high reviews! We went to lunch there today, and it was BAD. Everything is ridiculously overpriced. I realize it's on the lake, but geez. 6 bone in wings are $17! I had the chicken club which was rubbery and super overcooked. The menu says it's hand breaded, but it sure wasn't. The young lady serving us was super snippy. We tried the cheese curds as an appetizer which were strangely chalky and definitely frozen product. The only passable thing was that salmon my friend had on her salad was cooked nicely and a good portion. What a waste of money. read more

The Appetizers were ok, cheese curds hard in the middle. Main dishes were so so, shrimp were greasy, fries were greasy, fish ok, Cole slaw tasted off. Not sure if the limited kitchen help was the shortcoming or what? read more

Awesome steak special with a chimichurri sauce! Glad I stopped there after being on that lake a few decades ago. read more

Bent Prop Pub - Steak with special sauce - American Near Me - Coldwater, Michigan

See all

Well, apparently they had an off night, 1st clue was downstairs was closed: Hum, possible staffing issues??? service was good, some of the food was good and others were worthy of being sent back but it appeared the kitchen was struggling as it was. Bar tenders need to learn how to make a Margarita. read more

Previous experiences this place has been great, but this time we were super disappointing. The power went out and no one came out to tell us anything that was happening. We ordered out food and waited LITERALLY 30 minutes before they came out and told us they cant make our food. So we were sitting there with no information for awhile. Then they finally told us and made us pay for our drinks and we had to leave. Very rude and disappointing. Manager needs to do better. read more

Good food, nice people and a great view. Had lobster wrap and would get it again. And there is an ice cream shop to top off you night.

Coldwater could use more flavor and customer service like they've got at the Bent Prop. We rarely make it out there, but have declared it far superior to our other regular spots in branch county. The food was ALL delicious, the pretzel was the size of my face and actually came with beer cheese instead of nacho cheese. The staff checked in on us frequently and always with a smile. There were lots of staff buzzing around interacting with their tables. And the people there all seemed very happy to be there. It's just a great ambiance to be around cheerful people and great food, and especially when they have a live band playing! 10/10 recommend the Bent Prop! We will be back very soon! read more

Bent Prop Pub - Prop pretzel was huge and they have actual beer cheese! - American Near Me - Coldwater, Michigan

Great place to eat and drink by the water, friendly attentive waitress, decent fish and chips. read more

See all

Beautiful atmosphere and super friendly staff. The fried avocados and fried cheese were delicious and the candy kiss drink was AMAZING! The view of Coldwater Lake is gorgeous even on a cold day!! read more

Great atmosphere. Love that they do carry out to the boats! Food is always good. Service is fast, great group of workers.

Great atmosphere and the staff is so fun! Love the weekly specials too always something new to try! And let's not forget the best view ever! read more

Bent Prop Pub - Best dining view ever from the patio at the Bent Prop - American Near Me - Coldwater, Michigan

Excellent food! Fantastic service! Clean! Our group of 6 were in and out in one hour! Well done Bent Prop! We will be back. read more

Was heading somewhere else to eat only to learn they weren't open on Sunday. Detoured to this place and had an amazing meal. Food was fantastic. Service was great. View was amazing read more

Great view and nice bar! Food was ok. Had heard many wonderful things, but wasn't overly impressed. Guess we pay for the view, little above average bar food. read more

Very good. Good service. Cool ambiance. Everything tasted great. Wish bands were on Fridays.

Visiting from out of town and came here after reading the yelp reviews. Cool spot right on the water. Sat outside and enjoyed a warm evening. Food was delicious. Our server, Peyton, was very personable and responsive. Would visit here frequently if we lived closer. read more

Bent Prop Pub - Patio seating - American Near Me - Coldwater, Michigan

After a long day on the boat The Bent Prop is the best place to be. With 2 levels of fun for live music and a classy dinner on the water. The staff is absolutely amazing, and the owner does a wonderful job. My favorite restaurant in town. Not only that but the food is amazing and the service is very quick 5/5 stars. read more

Views were awesome, service was extremely attentive and friendly, and food was great! Cheese curds were phenomenal and the cocktail menu was creative and strong with fair prices. Will be back. read more

Michigan cherry salad with perfectly cooked salmon. Lobster wrap with a side salad. So hard to pick which one ! I come here every weekend when we are at Coldwater lake. Very enjoyable read more

May 2021 - Great view of Coldwater Lake and great food. I had the Cuban and my wife had the Michigan cherry salad (she loved it: "a nice mix of different kinds of lettuce and lots of candied pecans"). The service was friendly and attentive. We live down a ways in Indiana, but we'll come back if we're in the area. read more

Bent Prop Pub - View of the lake - American Near Me - Coldwater, Michigan

See all

My amazing DIL found this spot for us to have lunch between a wedding and a reception. It was a gorgeous sunny fall day and the view was amazing. We had too many in our party to sit on the outer area but we had a view from everywhere inside. The staff were friendly, the appetizers were delicious. We had the fried avocado, lobster bites and cheese cubes and they were hot, fresh and delicious. I had the crispy chicken chipotle wrap and it was very good. We all were pleased with our meals. We will be back but next time we will come by boat. read more

Great service,our food was perfect as ordered. Will return,easy to find plenty of parking,view of lake and a lot to the ambience.

Good food. Good service. Nice view of the lake. They have food choices at different price point's.

Restaurants come and go at this beautiful restaurant that has a wonderful view of Coldwater lake. I hope the Bent Prop makes it at this location. The food and service was amazing. We will be back! read more

This meal was ready in about 40 minutes, it was perfect timing. However, when I got it back to the house and opened everything up, I had asked for extras like ranch for fries and ketchup, mayo and mustard on the side for the Cuban so it didnt get soggy, and none of that was in the bag. I also ordered the $5 mac and cheese and it was Kraft mac and cheese with extra cheese sprinkled on top. The meal was decent, but it was lacking in a few areas. It was good if you need something when you are running late. I am giving this a 3 but if I were to eat there most likely would change this to a 4. read more

Great place. Great food. Great staff. We had the brisket nachos, cheese curds, wings , fried vegetable platter and of course the bender drink. Highly recommend. read more

After many failed attempts at making this million Dollar view a dining destination, I give a Round of Applause to the new owners. The Quesadilla is something to Crave. I don't eat red meat, but I substituted out Chicken to enjoy the classic wharf burger, Delish, the only thing that would make it better is house baked brioche The staff is fantastic - Service is Quick - hours are consistent - prices are fair and they serve food late with no complaint. Curbside. Boatside and hopefully sandbar delivery in the future. Key West Sunset in Pure Michigan, just be careful if traveling by boat - the name is a warning reflecting that this lake is not easy to get around unless you are familiar with the pop up beaches. Great Job on the ReVamp read more

This is getting 4 stars based on the awesome service of our waiter. We sat on the porch downstairs and this dark haired young man let us know that the kitchen was swamped and how long entries would take. We opted for an appetizer that the kitchen still couldn't handle in a timely matter but our server continued to check on us and let us know what was going on. Once the kitchen catches up to the service this place will be amazing. read more

The food is great, the service is great (Caleb), and the staff is very helpful. We had a health incident happen while there and I couldn't believe how helpful the staff was. We will definitely be back!!!! read more

Lakeside atmosphere and food is incredible, good local musicians on Thursday nights. Highly recommend.

Location, Location,Location...Was looking for a place to sit outside on the water to get a Bloody Mary and a beer and the Bent Prop did not disappoint. The staff was great with timely service. Only ordered the nachos and they were great...seen lots of food being served and that sealed the deal to stop back to check out the rest of the menu. read more

The lobster wrap did not disappoint. I'd drive the hour to get here from Fort Wayne. Great deck along the water and great service. I'll be back. read more

Fun time at the lake! Good food! Fun with the bands that come some nights! Wish there was a way to have outside seating when it's nice out!

So this is as honest a review that I'll ever do with pictures included. I have always wanted this venue to succeed, but their staff is very new and getting used to the job and the demands. I'm not saying they aren't friendly but they lack in the servicing experience field. This place is a sweet venue with a great view of Coldwater lake and plenty of space for a large party or if you're by yourself and you want to belly up at the bar. Now digging in, their appetizers may be their best value pick. The pretzel and spinach dip is a must before your meal with drinks. I wouldn't suggest their pizza if you are a connoisseur because it doesn't live up to the price. Now the boneless wings are fantastic, whether you go hot sauce or bbq! We would love if one level of the establishment was dedicated to a younger crowd and another was for more family reservations or an older crowd! My party felt like that would continue business coming through the summer and beyond! We will always be customers here because I love how the wait staff grinds to make sure you're taken care of! Check it out if you're in the area! read more

Bent Prop Pub - Great views of the sunset - American Near Me - Coldwater, Michigan

See all

Glad to have a new place to go in the Tri state area,fun atmosphere. Tried the brisket nachos,yummy, easily split amongst 4 people for this app. I had the ceasar salad w/blackened salmon-very tasty. Neighbor had shrimp tacos also good. Be patient as we could tell the servers are new & adjustments have been made as they get busier. Hope they can make it,as this location has had 5 different names since I've been coming to this location. We will be back. read more