Pizza is good .lots of young people there.comes out piping hot.parking reasonable.staff ok read more

Benny's brick oven - Kosher Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I'll start with the good : the food is above average usually. Now the bad : This business is not being managed well. It is filthy and most of the staff is rude. I get that kosher food is hard to come by even in Brooklyn, but don't assume you have a monopoly and can completely shit on your customers. Where is the owners pride in his business ? I'm done with this place . read more

So dissatisfied and disgusted how this place can charger $9 for onion rings and it comes with so little.im not one to rate places and this is actually your first time ever doing this!!!!!! read more

Benny's brick oven - I can't believe that I just paid $9 for these onion rings!!!!! Business that think they can cheat ppl like this???? - Kosher Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This restaurant is serving what may well be the most delicious kosher pizza in NY City. Indeed, all of the food here is delicious. But, if you have never eaten here, know before you go not to expect a fine dining experience: the restaurant is usually busy and crowded, and a lot of its patrons are school-age children who excel at being noisy. If you can get used to eating at close quarters, you will have no problems enjoying the great food. read more

This place would be a 4 star place of it wasn't so disorganized. I routinely order pizza and fries which are delicious btw. Pretty much everything I've had Is great. But there is never a straight line to get into, food us never ready when I order it and the order of spicy fries is almost always wrong fur regular fries! read more

This is one of my most favorite pizzerias in all of New York. As far as a regular slice, I really loved what they made. The pizza was thinner than most corner Pizzerias and was also crispy. Not the crispiest but MUCH better than the majority of corner pizzerias I've been to. Originally, I was gonna give this place 4 stars. It's definitely not the best nor perfect when compared to more famous places or gourmet pizzerias but it's great nonetheless. Now what made me reduce the rating by a star is that when the price went up last week by 50 cents, I figured it wasn't too big of a deal since other places definitely are much more expensive. However what I didn't like is that the service has gotten worse. The usual cashier is a blonde kid who's really nice and professional but the day I went when they changed their service, they had this younger kid with black hair who was clearly a brat handling the cash. There were these young kids shopping for a slice there and the guy made fun of them for being disappointed the price was raised. Sorry but I don't support douchebaggery. Get rid of the kid and maybe I'll go back for a few slices. Overall the rest of the staff is pretty nice. read more

, great pizza amazing prices stops family the food is good go kosher you can't go wrong

If the nature of your religiosity demand that you keep kosher than by all means stop in and grab a bite to eat. If not, I think there are probably equal quality and less pricey options around. The deep dish speciality pies are pretty good albeit 5 dollars a slice is absurd if you don't have to keep kosher. read more

My family and I love this pizzeria. Delicious food and many options available. They serve salads, pizza, all kind of wraps, pastas, and more. Service is quick and efficient. If your looking for a phenomenal slice in the area definitely try Benny's. read more

They have good food but are too expensive for my taste and I found the customer service to be a little lacking.

They say bennys pizza is the best kosher pizza in Brooklyn. And they, there totally right!! From the soups to the salads to the pizza it's all fresh clean great tasting quiet enjoyable not many pizza stores in Brooklyn are as elegent as bennys. Let me give you a tip though because it's soo good there's times when there's just too much people that's usually on Sunday afternoon so just know read more

The pizza was pretty good but I was turned off because they would not serve me tap water. I know some religious Jews think tap water is not kosher, but this is NYC. I'm not going to eat anywhere where I am forced to buy bottled water because tap water is not an option. Rediculous. Why is tap water not kosher? I don't think when Judaism originated thousands of years ago people were prevented from drinking water because microscopic organisms are not kosher. RIDICULOUS, PEOPLE, THIS IS RIDICULOUS! read more

When it comes to kosher pizza, I've always been disappointed - to say the absolute least. Benny's isn't just decent or good for kosher pizza, it's actually really good! If it has to be kosher, this is your absolute best bet - hands down. read more

I'm not the biggest fan of a regular pizza - read cheese - but this place, Benny's, makes an amazing cheese pizza. It's affordable ($15 - cash only though), kosher, so no meat but it's absolutely delicious. The pizza reminds me of authentic Italian pizza where it's not as greasy as your standard ny pizza. Highly recommend it. read more

One of he best kosher pizzas in Flatbush. Go there every single time and get the alla vodka pizza which is to die for. Service is amazing and great. The seating is amazing very family oriented. Would suggest it to anyone and everyone. read more

Ordered three slices of baked ziti pizza. The price is quite steep but my mother and I were filled after one slice each. I was able to take the third to work with me the next day. It microwaved pretty well. The interior is the same as it was when I first went there in high school, clean and simple. There are enough tables to fit about 16 people comfortably. I enjoyed these specialty slices and haven't seen them anywhere else. If you want a baked ziti slice, go to Benny's (it's kosher). read more

I am updating my review from three stars to one! The past four times that I've gone to Benny's pizza, the service has gotten worse and worse. The teenagers working behind the counter are distracted and snarky. We have yet to go there and get what we order. I am also completely fed up with the attitude that I receive when ordering, enough eyerolling and teeth sucking to drive you insane. For the amount of money that they charge per slice they should be able to afford a more mature staff. read more

I tried dialing the number listed here and Astoria Bank came up on my phone. 718-787-0050 works better. Aside from that this place makes fantastic pizza. They use fresh mozzarella, great sauce, and the crust is always well down. They also have tasty, affordable fish, pasta, and a salad bar. read more

I have to start with, this is possibly the best pizza Ive ever tried! It was fresh and bursting with flavor. I only held back one star for the lack of service. They didn't really do anything wrong, but they could be more friendly and ask customers what they want instead of waiting for you to get their attention. Even so, I forgive them :) their pizza made up for it and more! read more

This is great pizza for the price! it was quick and tasty. The only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 is because the pizza isn't as good as some of the other pizzerias around. Also, the wings I ordered were gross. They were heavily breaded and the sauce was on the side and no Bleu cheese. Odd. Butm I was happy with everything else. I will order from them again. read more

I walked into this pizza place because it was kosher and had a special on the door for students. 2 slices of specialty pizza with a soda for 6 or 7 dollars. I was with my 7 and 4 year old sons...When I ordered the special, I was told that they did not qualify as students because it was only for high school and college students...Seriously..both of my children are indeed students! In addition, as I was walking in, I noticed not one table had been cleared off... They also only take cash..... In an area that abounds with kosher fast food, I would think that t his place would be out of business. read more

Food is great, service SUCKS!! Alan who claims he's the manager at the M location is extremely rude and lazy. Not sure why they would hire idiots to bring down their ratings when their food is that great!! When ordering over the phone, they will place you on hold for over 15 minutes and then hang up on you. If you try to call back you'll get the busy signal for about half hour. The "manager", Alan told my co worker that he cant take her order over the phone since the store is very busy so if she wants something she needs to come to the store and hung up on her face. That was the last time she ever attempted to order from Bennys. I will be sure to let everyone know how terrible the service is!! What's good food worth with crappy service??!! read more

The pizza with the pasta on top is delicious! This place used to be cash only, but now they take cards, which is awesome. Definitely check them out. read more

Delicious pizza, bit pricey for the average kosher pizza but it's worth it. You must try they're pizza pasta, it is amazing & they're pasta in general is great as well. They have good deals now for a pie like 16 or 17 dollars, it's usually like 22 from what i remember. It isn't a place to stay, it's meant for take out mostly in my understanding. The people that work there are usually bit rude which is why i didn't give it 5 stars & they don't bring the food to you if you plan on sitting down. read more

I guess it depends on what you're looking for in a pizza. I think the pizza is Ok but my boyfriend LOVES it. I've seen people order pasta and soup there and it looked good but I never tried it. It's usually pretty busy. They also have a special I think Monday to Wednesday a large pizza for $11.99 so try it out. read more

Best kosher pizza in the neighborhood... was there yesterday, we had the classic it was amazing !!!!! We ordered 2 pies and 2 huge salads. Their ceaser salad is also amazing !!!! Worth every penny ! Will definitely be coming back here read more

Best kosher pizza in all of Brooklyn honestly I've never had a better slice of pizza than that

Best kosher pizza I ever had, and one of the best pizzas period. Decor is nice as well for a pizzeria. But i almost wanted to give it 4 stars for: -Terrible terrible terrible order takers on the phone. The guy barely speaks english. Not sure if it's changed, but this was super aggravating for me when I ordered from them. -Expensive. (Totally worth it, though) read more

This is the best pizza I have ever had. I'm craving some right now as I type... Only thing is it is annoying that they don't accept credit or debit cards. So worth it though for this delicious pizza! Can't speak for the rest of the menu - I always get the pizza! read more

Best pizza... u get what you pay for. .. and it is not a 8 dollar pie... it's a 4 dollar slice... gr8 real gourmet food.

Awesome place. Try the zito slice -- penne a la vodka on a slice. Expensive but amazing!!! Regular pizza is great too. Full salad bar and indoor seating. A good date idea! read more

This place has amazing pizza. It is as good cold as it is hot. The store is a bit small and seating is very limited but the food here is worth every second of trying to find parking. One of the best pizza places in NYC hands down. read more

Love this place, gourmet kosher pizza at its finest. I have tried many things at Benny's and have never been disappointed. Some of my favorites include pasta fasul soup this soup tastes like it is made in a high end restaurant rather than a pizza store, the regular slice is super cheesy and cooked to perfection, their salads are always fresh and fully customizable, last but not least the Benny's pasta rivals the most expensive pasta you will find in kosher restauraunt sin the city read more

The service is horrid but the mushroom slice is really good. Gotta wait like 3 hours for delivery which is probably the most ridiculous thing on the corner of east 18th and Ave M but that mushroom slice tho...the gnocchi isn't bad but overpriced af. read more

Tried the tomato spinach, and this other pizza that's thicker crusted with lots of cheese. I saw the reviews on bad service, but the service for me was efficient and fast. The pizza was great and honestly pretty filling. They don't really skimp on slice size. read more

For Kosher Pizza in NY, I think this is by far the greatest tasting pizza. Thank you! read more

The food here is pretty solid. I've had salads, mozzarella sticks, slices, and other items here, but the prices are very, very high, outrageous even. With what they charge, I can go to Bravo's in the city and get a better slice. read more

My Benny's experience was limited to a solitary Sicilian slice but what a slice it was! Sizable and genuinely flavorful, it was pricey (~$3) but well worth it. My significant other enjoyed her slices as well (a plain and something else...I'm sure she'll correct me). The staff was courteous and friendly. All in all, it's great to see a kosher place that justifies higher prices with quality. read more

I joined Yelp to give this review. Many of the reviews say the pizza was good. Unfortunately, we never had a chance to try it. We went about an hour after pesach (admittedly, an extremely busy time for them). We weren't given a time estimate for our order. We ordered and waited about 30 minutes. Based on how fast they were processing orders, it appeared like it could take another 45 minutes to an hour. That's certainly longer than we've waited at other pizza stores post-pesach, but this one was taking calls so it's understandable. However, we were incredibly dismayed by what happened next. A few other customers also felt the wait was too long and asked for their money back. After some reluctance, they did return it. However, they refused to refund our purchase. We found this disparate treatment completely unacceptable and will certainly not be frequenting Benny's again. I'm sure the service is better at normal times, but for a store to treat its customers in such an arbitrary way is both inappropriate and poor business practice. There are several other kosher pizza shops in the area. I highly recommend any of them over this one. read more

They deserve 5 starts because I love this place. Been eating here forever and there food is consistently good. Very underrated especially there pastas etc. However they used to have good managers, but there last one or two seem to care less about the business and even less about the customer. I'm sorry but it's unacceptable for a manager to tell a customer who is willing to pay more money to upgrade the dish that it's "simply too late". Last I checked more money is never an issue to make something happen. Very disappointing to see a good place start aiming downhill. I hope they change the manager soon :( read more