Overall great ice cream place. We've visiting both the Vineyard Heaven and Oak Bluff location and…read morethey both were great. The staff at both locations were very friendly and while it gets busy, they are very fast and efficient. They offer a rewards card so you can earn a free ice cream. Ambiance is like your classic ice cream shop and they have a great selection of flavors. The Oak Bluffs location is bigger, which allows for more inside seating.

I visited Mad Martha's in Oak Bluffs around 8PM today (8/18) and asked to sample the black…read moreraspberry flavor before purchasing it since I had never tried it before. The employee refused. Normally, that wouldn't be a big deal--except I had just watched several white customers on either side of me receive samples without any issue. They were treated kindly and allowed to sample flavors, while I was denied the exact same courtesy. As a Black customer, the stark difference in treatment was impossible for me to ignore. Based on what I personally witnessed, I felt singled out and treated differently because of my race. I don't make an accusation of racial bias lightly, but when customers immediately around me are being accommodated and I'm denied the same basic service, it's reasonable to question why. What makes this even more disturbing is that after my experience, I came across another review from a Black customer describing a remarkably similar experience at this same location involving samples and differential treatment. Seeing that after experiencing it myself was extremely concerning. Whatever the reason, customers should receive the same level of courtesy and service regardless of race. Absolutely unacceptable experience.

My favorite ice cream shop in Edgartown! You should try the peanut butter pie ice cream! It's the…read morebest! Lots of flavors to choose from and a great addition is the candy section.

cute place and good candy. my sister loved the swedish candy (and so did i). they give you a LOT of…read moreice cream for what you pay for as compared to other places nearby. great service too!

A lot of ice cream flavors! The ice cream is great! Prices are high but expected due to the island…read more Wish the portions were bigger

Absolutely delicious ice cream in an adorable setting. We went midafternoon (2:30 ish) which meant…read morethere were no crowds

Everything was perfect! From the people to the atmosphere! We Loved all the different choices of…read moreice cream and creative ways to indulge!

Mad Martha's Ice Cream sells homemade ice cream and has locations in Edgartown, Oak Bluffs, and…read moreVineyard Haven. I was catching the Steamship Authority's ferry out of Vineyard Haven and stopped by here to get a scoop of ice cream prior to boarding. There were many flavors to choose from. I ordered a small M&M Cream and my husband ordered a small Catboat Crunch. Each were $7.50. There was a queue, but more staff came out to help and the queue moved. There are a few tables inside to enjoy the ice cream. The ice cream was very creamy. The M&M Cream had M&M pieces which I enjoyed.

Great ice cream shop right on circuit ave amongst all the other stores. Spacious layout and has a…read morevariety of ice cream flavors and treats to choose from. Service was fine with polite workers serving the ice cream. Opted to try their vanilla soft serve and it was very good. Recommending trying this place if you're looking for a new ice cream place to try since there's quite a few on circuit Ave. Can't go wrong with this place.

After a quick slice of pizza we treated ourselves to some ice cream at the CarouselIce Cream…read moreFactory in Oak Bluffs. My father got a large twist in a cone that was so large it appeared to be ready to topple over. With lots of yummy licks he was able to avoid losing a drop of delicious ice cream. I chose the chocolate chip ice cream in a kiddie cup thank goodness as it was a good size for an adult despite the name "kiddie cup". They had benches out front in the shade to enjoy our afternoon snack. Run, don't walk to this place.

Stopped in with my mom and aunt for a quick ice cream before heading home. No wait when we arrived,…read moreand I got to sample a few flavors before choosing sea salt caramel and campfire s'mores on a waffle con, so so good! The shop was clean, had nice outdoor seating, and the staff was very friendly. Great stop in Vineyard Haven!

We wanted to recreate an evening from last summer: dinner at The Net Result and ice cream here,…read moreespecially since the owner wrote us a nice comment on Yelp after our last review. Just like last year, this place was empty when we went despite the crowds next door and at Rocco's. We had heard murmurs about waffles being on site, but there was a sign saying something about regulatory issues, so that was a no go. Everything started well enough. Our daughter got a cone with the campfire s'mores again (it is still *really* good). The two of us wanted smalls, but if you want more than one flavor, you need to size up and get a medium. OK, so the guy who was working scooped those flavors out for the two gentlemen in our party. And for $8.50, yeah, you expect those cups to be full. The girl who was working also helped one of us and here's what happened: literally HALF of the cup is full. So, while the two other mediums are scooped past the rim, this one was barely half full. When it was sitting by the register, we had to ask for her to pass it to us, and she goes, "Oh, yeah, sorry, I'm training." Well, that definitely shows! Here's what could have happened with better training: 1) She could have asked her trainer: "Hey, is this right?" 2) She could have said, "Hold on, I'm training, so he'll be right with you." 3) She could have seen with her own two eyeballs that the portion she scooped was half the amount of the other two items of that very same size. 4) The guy training her, who saw that cup, could have said, "Oh, let me get you some more since this isn't right." Such a shame because the ice cream here is delicious (tried the chocolate lovers this time, and it was rich and deeply flavorful), so it's not like we're saying bad things about the product itself. It's not even about getting "more." It's about charging customers almost $10 for what was practically one measly scoop! It's insulting. We gave this place another try, but we will not be back again. After many, many years on this island, we have decided that there really are only two places left to get your best frozen treats: Ben and Bill's in Oak Bluffs and The Ice Cream Candy Bazaar in Edgartown. Yes, parking will be a nightmare, but at least it will be worth it and you'll get good value. We've never had any issues at either of those locations ever, sigh. Ah well.

Was a 5 star but it has been closed this season due to, sadly, the poor health of the local…read moremanager. Ownership seems to have abandoned this island must-visit.

Um, I think the stores in Edgartown and Vineyard Haven are closed!!!! The Edgartown one is pretty…read moreempty. Too bad

Tisberry is super super good! The employees are really sweet. The Francesca Frenzy is really good…read moretoo. The ambiance is pretty.

The girl behind the counter was so sweet brought my yellow lab out some ice cream:) the pumpkin and…read moreapple ice cream was a real treat! A must visit when your in Martha's vineyards!