Food was great and the hostess gave us such amazing customer service. Above and beyond We will be…read moreback! thank you Eve!!

We stopped by chance at 5:30 with no reservation and were immediately seated at the bar! Our…read moreBartender was awesome! The scallops were amazing and when I requested polenta rather than mashed potatoes my substitution was graciously accepted without hesitation. The tender meatball and sausage bowl was also delectable with its rich dark sauce and do not get me started on their toasted bread which is a little slice of Heaven! (Note our bartender advised us in that you can order a side of bread *not on the menu) My suggestion is to order two sides of their bread! Our bartender's service was very attentive and personable, and she made us feel very welcomed!! I just wish I remembered her name so I could post it here but alas we are senior citizens and barely remember our own names! Save room for Splashes Butter Cake with fresh strawberries and whip cream, I will place it in the top 10 desserts of my life and I'm 65! You only have a few days left to try this place before they close for this season! Do yourself a favor and make a reservation now you won't be disappointed!

Great golf course. Lawn kept "like a golf course" hence the pun!!!! They serve the most best…read morefood at this gulf course. If you're a beginning or a pro come here. !

Food and service top notch. Wide selection of adult beverages. The view of the golf course is so…read morenice to look at while you eat. We go often.

Update (2026): Last year I gave Heirloom three stars because I loved the setting but thought the…read morefood fell well short of the experience. This year, our friends told us they had a great meal here, so we decided to give it another try. I'm really glad we did. The menu felt much fresher, with several interesting choices. I ordered the risotto, and while I wish it had been served a little hotter, it was delicious. The salmon was also excellent. At the end of dinner, I asked our server if Heirloom had hired a new chef because the food was so much better than I remembered. She said it was the same chef, but the team had worked together to improve this season's menu. Mission accomplished. I'm happy to update my rating to five stars. If you're staying at the Athenaeum, Heirloom is once again a restaurant I'd recommend.

Some of the prior reviews were of concern, but we had no other choice today if we wanted to eat…read moreindoors and experience the insides of the Athenaeum Hotel. We ended up quite satisfied ... delighted, even. We were greeted by the hostess, and seated promptly (this was important because we had a bit of time pressure), and had a very short wait for the server (Miranda, who will feature prominently later in this review!). We ordered, the strawberry/charred-peach/burrata/arugula salad for me, the ahi-guacamole + chips for my spouse (it was a light lunch that was needed). The food came promptly, and meanwhile another staff person had come by to verify that we didn't need to order drinks. The food was delicious, although I have just a couple small complaints: the guacamole overpowered the ahi tuna, so I think they'd be wiser to have the ahi in larger chunks. When the server came by to ask how we were doing, I mentioned that I liked the salad very much, but was disappointed to have only one strawberry (4 slices) on the salad. Miranda said, "Let me get you some more." She returned soon after with a small bowl of sliced strawberry (still only one, but I was pleased with her response and the good taste of these Albions -- which normally make a nice color appearance but rarely have good flavor). Anyway, if you are looking for a cheap lunch, go grab a sandwich at the other lunch venues. If you are looking for an experience -- the views outside of the lake and and boats, etc; the spacious dining room with overhead fans; the attentive but not intrusive service -- then do come here. At least for the lunch menu, I can recommend it very highly. And ask Miranda for an extra strawberry...

Fantastic, knowledgeable server! The menu never disappoints! Everything has that wonderful…read morehomemade touch!

Another birthday celebration (wife), we were greeted warmly and seated, Kerri our knowledgeable and…read morekind server took our drink order. We ordered appetizers, my wife had the tuna crisps and I had the she crab soup. Entrees My wife ordered the lasagna bolognese and I ordered the Cajun salmon and smoked Gouda grits. Everything was delicious and would (have) order again. Atmosphere was wonderful, Kerri was great!!! Could not have been a more memorable experience!!

I think people are a little harsh on Yelp sometimes. So here it is,a one and a two are really bad,…read morea 3 is not very good but four is expected, thats why I give it a four . I thought it was good and it is exactly what I had expected for what they projected, and think that is the key. The service was pleasant, fast and it was clean. I really liked sitting outside looking at the boats and everyone working and listening to the music, what a lively place. There was a very good clean energy. Great job thanks for having us.

We visited on a midweek evening, and we sat outside. It was a lovely view of the lake. The menu is…read morecomprehensive with plenty of options. Service was prompt and genial. The food was typical quality, nothing outstanding but also nothing bad. Will probably visit only on wing special night, Wednesday, in the future.

Twice Disappointed…read more We have now dined at this restaurant on two separate occasions, and unfortunately, both experiences left us very unimpressed--especially for a restaurant located in such a nice hotel and charging these prices. Our first experience was lunch in the spring of 2026 while we were staying at the hotel. We were extremely impressed with the hotel itself--the room, staff, and location were wonderful--so naturally we expected the restaurant to be of comparable quality. Sadly, it was not. Our food came out fairly quickly, but it was cold, and several items we ordered were missing. We then had to wait quite a while for someone to return so we could ask for the missing items and condiments, which were definitely needed to help the already subpar flavor. We left disappointed but decided perhaps it was simply an off day. We gave the restaurant another chance in August 2026 while celebrating my father-in-law's 89th birthday. Since this was dinner service, we hoped for a much better experience. His prime rib was actually very good, with no complaints other than the mashed potatoes being served cold. I ordered the Charbroiled Frenched Pork Chop, and unfortunately, it was awful. It had very little flavor and was dry and badly overcooked. The three onion rings served with it were rock hard, overcooked, and cold. They tasted as though they had been deep-fried much earlier and left sitting rather than being prepared fresh. I did send the onion rings back, but I chose not to send the pork chop back because I didn't want my 89-year-old father-in-law, who tires easily, to have to sit and wait while my meal was remade on his birthday. The coffee was another disappointment. At $15, even with a carafe provided, I certainly expected it to at least be hot. It wasn't. Our waiter was adequate and did nothing particularly wrong, but the level of service simply didn't match what I would expect at this price point. The interaction lacked the warmth, attentiveness, and polish you would normally associate with a higher-end dining experience. After two visits with many of the same issues--cold food, poorly prepared food, missing items, and service that doesn't match the prices--I don't think we can chalk this up to one bad night. The hotel itself is lovely, which makes the restaurant even more disappointing. With its location and atmosphere, this restaurant has the potential to be very good, but the kitchen and service need considerable attention. At these prices, guests should be able to expect freshly prepared, properly cooked, hot food accompanied by attentive service. Sadly, twice disappointed.

Have stayed here lately. Have had dinner and breakfast at the restaurant. Both were very good…read more Service is outstanding. Hotel is top-notch. The view is the best on the lake I think. Amenities are great.

Food was good after it was sent back because it came to the table cold. I had to send my salad back…read morebecause steak and fries were cold. The huge baked potato that was also served was not cooked thoroughly. On a positive note the food once returned was delicious. Cook needs to look at what goes out , and a plumber may need to look at the bathroom fixtures.

This is what I ordered: Seafood Stuffed Whitefish…read moreFlaky broiled whitefish filet filled with seafood stuffing topped with creamy Old Bay white sauce. Served over wild rice pilaf with choice of vegetable. What I got was a large portion of rice that was not cooked well. A large order of green beans that were good but cold. The fish was a very small very thin white fish filet that was overcooked with hard crispy edges. I could not identify what it was stuffed with but whatever it was it was MINIMAL. Would I order it again. No. Will I go back, absolutely not. Save your money, go somewhere else.

Guppy's Restaurant and Tavern arches point near the Finger Lakes in New York is a great place to go…read moreto eat. The staff is wonderful and the menu is extensive . Everything is delicious!!!!

We had the aesthetically pleasing Bloody Mary-that was garnished like no other Bloody Mary I have…read morehad in my entire life! Delicious!!!---and the service was impeccable. The atmosphere was amazing and I felt Disney World vibes! Love this place!! The only drawback is the restroom situated in the main dining room with no privacy once entered for female guests. The outside bar-- was heated and so were the gondola's--but no restrooms available unless you travel outside to main dining room. If it's not pouring rain, or snowing---it's not an issue. Just something to consider with varying physical needs. Again-we were treated like royalty and I love this place!!!

FIVE STAR for food and for quality of the food and price. The service is always friendly at the…read morecounter. It is a super place for any espresso or energy drink as well as quality coffee. HOWEVER I witnessed an employee dismiss the request for the floor to be cleaned stating "this is going to be what it is". The elderly couple seemed to be sad and accepted the comment. I asked for more help from a different employee who did offer the help. A manager needs to be kind and understanding and customer focused. Do not let that stop youn from trying this wonderful cafe. !

This place did not disappoint! Came here with our 2 year old son for breakfast and it was…read moredelicious! Also loved the atmosphere and ability to sit in or outside. We had great breakfast sandwich's, iced lattes, and our son enjoyed every bit of his peanut butter crunch toast. Highly recommend!