Food was very good. I had the special, it was a stuffed veal chop. Tasty, plenty of the entrees, but the appetizers were a little skimpy. There were 4 of us and ordered the soft shell crab (1of them) fresh mozzarella (3 of them) and shrimp (3 of them) For the entrees my wife had the Chilean sea bass special. 4 of us went to dinner. No wait and the waiters were accommodating and personable. I thought the prices were steep though. $360 for 4 people without any cocktails. Pretty sure we were charged for every cola, dont know how else it could've been this pricey, someone said earlier...Tribeca prices but not Tribeca overhead. Overall I gave it a 2 because of the cost. Also the place was a little crowded. read more

THIS PLACE SHOULD HAVE NO STARS! The sauce was watery and looked like Olive Garden and our food was so salty we couldn't even eat It, we feel there had to be a mistake because we were sweating salt for two days and drinking so much water because our mouths were so dry. This was the WORST $60 i ever spent. We believe someone accidentally dropped a salt shaker in our food because there is NO way the food was supposed to taste that way. Once we ordered sodas instead of drinks we magically had no server except the host and a lady who came once. We felt really disrespected, we are both in the restaurant business and my fiancé is a restaurant manager and she couldn't believe how we were being treated. Never in my life have i felt like such a burden in a restaurant( mind you It was only 720 when we sat) i really wish we said something because we tried to contact them the next day and could not get anyone. I wouldn't come back if It was free. The man who was our "waiter" or "order taker" was so rude. The food was not even edible. We are half and got the heck out of there. read more

Place is nice inside if you overlook the cobwebs on the lights on the walls. Stuffed artichoke was stuffed with salt soup. I sent it back and the owners daughter brings it back to me with no stuffing and burnt. I send it back again and she told me she took it off the check. When they should take it off the menu. Thank God the wait staff was excellent so my 1 star goes to them. They brought me a glass of wine to apologize for the kitchen. read more

Love their new space it has a Manhattan vibe. we ALWAYS got the stuffed artichoke but passed last time and I was sorry we didnt order it, the table next to us did and it was HUGH and looked so good. The Eggplant parm is to die for and a very large serving.also the arugla parm salad was ligt and dressed perfectly. i like that they give you warm biscotte cookies at the end of your meal read more

I love this place!! small family restaurant....great delicious italian food...the owners and workers make you feel right at home..they are so friendly and the service is amazing!! everyone I've reffered keep going back...and the food...AMAZINGLY DELICIOUS!! fresh tastes amazing....perfectly cooked. I love it!!! read more

For a local, this place is a great spot. It does get crowded on Friday and Saturday nights so I try to avoid those nights as much as possible, as the restaurant itself isn't that large in size. The owners are always so friendly and warm. We like to go on Sunday's or even on Monday nights when the owner cooks. The baked clams to start are good, but pretty small. I once got the chopped salad, but wouldn't get that again. Nothing really comes in it and it's just not worth it. Plain tasting and not worth the money. Their chicken parmigiana is one of my favorite dishes. I always ask for the cheese to come well done, but that's just my own preference. Excellent choice and highly recommend. Their chicken scap. is mediocre. I would try it again, but the last time we ordered a full order it happened to have been quite dry. I love at the end of your meal when they give you these Italian biscottis. Definitely makes the dinner that much better. They don't rush you and you do feel very relaxed there. A must try if you're looking for good quality Italian food. read more

My family and I had an amazing dinner! A friend referred us and Im critical being in retail....but was pleasantly surprised! Food was awesome, prices great, and waitress Margo treated us very well. I highly advise you try this great resturant. You wont be disappointed! read more

Just left and enjoyed an excellent meal. Our entire table of 6 enjoyed everything the kitchen put out. Shrimp oreganata over capellini was excellent - plump jumbo shrimp, tasty sauce not drowning in butter! Chicken and shrimp special I can't remember name but it was with melted mozzarella and spinach very very good. Large portions - overall a solid Italian restaurant. Attentive staff. We will definitely be back! Small restaurant so try to beat the rush or make a reservation for party of six or bigger only. Full bar and decent wine list. read more

The red snapper is very fresh every time and Prepared to order. The spinach salad is crisp and delicious with Parmesan shavings on top. They give complimentary warm biscotti for dessert. The drinks are ample and cold with a vibrant bar. Ted and Donna can't do enough to make this dining experience top notch. read more

Not a fan from a take out view. We got the frutti di mare. I asked if they were little necks. They said yeah they were all huge. The muscles were huge. Just not impressed for the price. Also order a house salad and it was so plain. Best part was the free biscotti. Just disappointed read more

Bella Notte - Italian Near Me - Bellmore, New York

My wife and I had reservations for molte Bene. We were told along with many other people at the bar that we be waiting a long time. The hostess could care less that they are not overbooked. We called Bella Notte and they stated they would try to accommodate us as best as possible. We went there directly and then waited 10 minutes to be seated. We enjoyed a delicious meal with great service. We will be going back to Bella Notte. read more

Went here on recommendation of a friend. I was extremely pleased. Excellent food and great service. Prices very reasonable and portions very large. I will definitely be returning. read more

Truly traditional Italian cooking. The best baked clams, shrimp oregganate, and veal parmegian I have had in years! Thank god there are still people on Earth who know how to do this. The lasagne was a bit weak, but enjoyable. Strong wine list, good espresso, and great biscotti and napoleans. If you love real old-school Italian food, and are willing to cough up the bucks, this is one of the rare places you can still get it. read more

Bella Notte never disappoints!!! Service is always amazing... food is always beyond amazing !!!!

Excellent service Cheerful atmosphere Beautiful bar Food delicious Very good menu choices read more

The food is wonderful. Best chicken parm I've ever had. Drinks are full size. No skimpy martini glasses at this place. The owner and wife are so nice. They make you feel like family. Love Bella Notte. read more

I came here with my family of 6 over the summer when it first opened and the owner teddy treated us with a round of drinks while we were waiting at the bar. The food phenomenal. We ordered veal chops, seafood pasta, mussels, shrimp, and salmon. The portions were big, the food was fresh and the waiter was very pleasant. It was an overall great experience. read more

I have been to Bella notte several times. Best Italian food is you can find on Long Island. The service is just as wonderful as the food. Waiters are very knowledgeable about the menu. This restaurants reminds me of all the Italian restaurants I used to go to in Brooklyn with my family when I was younger. Very traditional- which is hard to find these days. Love Bella notte ! My go to spot when I'm craving Italian outside of my own kitchen ! read more

Bella Notte - Filet of sole & chicken sorrentino - Italian Near Me - Bellmore, New York

This was our first trip to Bella Notte and it won't be our last. We found the service to be great and the food excellent. More than once the wait staff come by to ask if everything was satisfactory and the owner came by to apologize for our main courses being a little tardy. I am very big on concerned service. If there is one criticism that I can make it is that the restaurant can get noisy. read more

Love this place! My husband and i love to order their grilled calamari arribiata to start. So fresh always! For dinner i can't help but order their frutti di mare! It's so good, the fish sauce is to die for! My husband loves food so he's been lucky enough to try many of their dishes and I'm lucky i get to taste them all. Tonight He ordered the eggplant parmigiana and it was amazing. Definitely one of our favorite places to eat! Don't miss out! read more

Really not a fan at all. Just a typical Long Island, mediocre, run of the mill Italian restaurants. I've ordered seafood here twice & both times it was really fishy & frozen tasting. Actually I got really sick the night I ate the mussels here. I know it was the mussels because that's what came back up!! Best part of the meal was the complimentary bruschetta & biscotti. read more

I will NEVER return to this place, for several reasons: 1. Service was TERRIBLE - and for this I blame the owner. None of the staff members were trained, not even in the most basic way. For example: - before we were finished eating each of our courses, bus boys kept trying to remove our plates. Don't they see we are still eating??? Extremely rude, and made us eat in a rush / be stressed while we are trying to have a nice dinner. - the head waiter was perspiring so much, his sweat kept dripping everywhere. - in an attempt to clean the crumbs from the table, the bus boys spread them all over our laps like it was the right thing to do, did not apologize, or anything. 2. Prices are EXORBITANT. Red Snapper $39.95??!!! Why?? By comparison, Perry Street Restaurant, one of the finest restaurants in Manhattan, owned by renowned chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten, charges $36 for a Sea Bass entree made with the finest ingredients money can buy. Bella Notte's prices are completely unjustified, the food was mediocre at most, everything covered in cheese or oil. 3. Ambiance: this place is unbelievably LOUD, we had to shout across the table if we wanted to have a conversation (we ended up eating in silence and as fast as we could so we could get the hell out). Tables have no tablecloths or place mats. Tables are crammed and waiters keep jamming into tables. I just read the other reviews for this restaurant and they must have been written by friends of the owner. This restaurant has absolutely no vibe, no class and is completely overpriced. read more

As I eat a midnight snack from the takeout we had last night. This restaurant is always consistent! Great food and great staff! The Best!

Not good. 3 of us Went on a friday night. Chicken scarparello was just roasted chicken and potatoes nothing else. No sauce or anything with it. Misnamed dish ! Chicken Marsala was oversauced but tasted ok. Chicken Milanese was bland and the breading tasted funny/stale. Red sauce for pasta sides was watery and tasted canned. Even bread was below average fresh. Just poor execution of simple italian dishes. Note: The specials were priced quite a bit higher and seemed "overpriced" so we stuck to menu. Many better choices in area. If you are a foodie or make italian food at home you will figure this place out quickly. The free cookies at end were nice touch but they served with a side of cool whip instead of fresh whip cream. I guess we cant complain about freebies but overall not recommended. read more

One of my favorite restaurants. Owner and staff treat you like family. I now go at least once week. Love sitting at bar with john the bartender. Food is always amazing. Love complimentary bruschetta and homemade biscotti. Portions are huge so we usually share something. Must try. read more

Most were satisfied with the quality of the food. Very crowded and super noisy. The back of my husband's chair was hit at least 3 times. Ordered Caesar salads and they were small for $10and bland. The specials ranged from $39 to $45. Bread basket uninspired. Service was fine. Just not a place I would go back to. read more

I hate giving bad reviews. I want people to succeed. But we left after being seated for 10 minutes with only the busboy giving us bread and water & the place was not crowded. We had enough time to look at the unreadable menu (black print on blue paper). $21 for most traditional pasta dishes. 22 for chicken parm! Some as high as $45. Maybe I went to NYC w/o remembering? $9 a glass for house Chardonnay & $14 for Sutter Home! Crazy. It's always crowded and I was shocked by not only the exorbitant prices but the uninspired menu. A pizza place like Stella's gets you much more in variety & for the price. read more

The food was wonderful, the wait staff was great however do not plan on having a conversation. The noise level was the highest I have ever have experienced. They must hire an Acoustic engineer before I ever return. read more

We had our daughter's bridal shower at Bella Notte and it was a huge success, Ted and Donna were so accommodating to all our requests! Providing the valet parking for our 50 guests and Ted arriving earlier than expected so we had more time to set up. We can't thank them enough and their wonderful staff! Our guests loved the food the huge portions, the ambiance of there modern, new, beautiful restaurant and so comfortable for our guests. We highly recommend Bella Notte! read more

Unprofessional service. Long wait. Cocktails were not great. Food lacked taste. Tried this restaurant twice, giving it another chance for improvement but I Would rather go to a nice pizzeria instead. read more

This place is a must! The food was nothing but fantastic, and the service was very attentive throughout the entire meal (without being annoying). I highly recommend if you want great Italian cuisine, a warm environment, and great service. I wish I could give it more than 5 stars! read more

Went for the first time today and loved it. The service and the owners were just wonderful. Had the baked clams and stuffed mushrooms for appetizers followed by chicken Parmesan and fettuccine Alfredo. Delicious. Owners sent a napoleon dessert. Homemade and fantastic. Gets crowded and a little noisy but well worth it. read more

We recently had a function at Bella Notte in Bellmore. The owner, Teddy, was very accommodating. The food was exceptional and the service was wonderful. All of our guests talked about the food and atmosphere. We will be dining at Bella Notte for many years to come! read more

Corny atmosphere decorated with pictures from the movie Casino. Food was very salty. The calamari was way too salty some of the macaroni in the penne ala vodka was over cooked the chicken parm was not that good either. Not just saying everything wasn't good it really was not. I have never wrote a review before but needed to for this restaurant. I do not recommend this restaurant I don't know how it gets a large crowd on the weekend. read more

Best baked clams ever!! The stuffed artichoke to die for!!! The bartender Joe... The best!!! Great food.. Very friendly and warm staff... Very clean! Can't wait to go back !! read more

unbelievably over priced. ..go to la piazza up the block for better food and half the price.....not at all worth it ...

went to bella notte for the first and last time ordered family style meals that were not family style food was ok we ordered the veal dish chicken dish and a pasta for four people not enough food read more

I threw my wife a surprise graduation party at Bella Notte in May 16. We invited about 45 people. I have been to this restaurant several times while in the smaller location and in the new space. It is always good, but this time the exceeded my expectations. I opted to rent the entire restaurant on a Sunday afternoon. They offered this option and have a catering menu for private parties. You get the room from about noon until about 4:30. I chose the highest food level which is all family style and included baked clams, mushrooms, and calamari as an antipasto. They were all prepared very well and flavorful. The meal also included a salad, rigatoni and family style entrees. These included veal, chicken, salmon, sausage and peppers, and I think one more chicken dish. The entrees were exceptional and there was a lot of food. They would have brought out more of we asked, but everyone was full and a lot of guests brought home food. After dinner, we had fruit plates which they let us bring in without charge. We also had homemade biscotti which we also brought in at no charge. Then came the Napoleon cake which was included in the package. This was not a generic free cake, but more like a nice dessert you get from a restaurant. The meal also included unlimited coffee and soda. They also served magnum bottles of white and red wine for about $60 each. The cost for food less wine was about $47 per person. We also had about 15 kids which were half price of the lowest food option( About $15) . The kids meal was chicken fingers and fries. Not frozen tenders but fresh cut and dried nicely cutlets. The owner and his wife were very friendly and accommodating. They really made the whole event very pleasant and stress free. I highly recommend this spot for anyone that wants a unique intimate experience for a family get together In my opinion, the food was much better than a generic Long Island catering hall. read more