Six years ago we were stranded in Casper when the interstate was shut down on our way home from…read moreThanksgiving in Montana. We watched the tree lighting parade and stumbled through frigid weather hauling a baby carrier and two toddlers in search of a warm meal. Racca's actually had availability and shocked us with their fabulous food and warm atmosphere. We never expected such incredible Italian food in sweet little Casper. Fast forward to tonight, where once again we stayed in Casper after a Thanksgiving in Montana, and finally got to re-visit Racca's. It has got to be some of the best pizza I've ever had! The service is also perfect, with knowledgeable waitstaff who are proud of their establishment and give you the delicious details of why their food is so, so good. Do yourself a favor and come here, any time, any day, and try anything on the menu. Casper is very fortunate to have such a gem.

Ambiance: extremely noisy, so not a place if you want to converse…read more Service: okay except you have to choose between waiting for the rest of your group (we were 5 people) to get their food or eat it cold. Everything came out at different times over 15 minutes and the 18 dollar pizza loses all heat. Service: the server who took our order didn't deliver it, so it was clumsy, at least with everything not arriving at the same time we were able to get the food to the right person

Stopped in again while in Casper for an amazing crust. Excellent customer service and probably the…read morebest pizza in Wyoming. Keep up the good work!

We came 3 deep for lunch today and as usual the pizza was delicious, now the service.... The…read moreteenage boy who took our order was a challenge to speak with as he had zero communication skills, but again the pizzas was good, i know how hard it is to get good help and that is why i still have left 5 stars but seriously this needs to be better.

Go and get the southwest bites! So delicious. We dropped in late so only fried food and pizza was…read moreAvailable but I'd go back just for that any time. Lots of dart boards and pool tables. We had fun and the food was great.

The "bartender" was horrible! And on my birthday! We regret going in there. One drink was one too…read moremany!

The food here is superb! Pizzas are unique and the bowls and salads nicely crafted. We ate…read moreeverything to the last bite!

Liked the Detroit pizzas and the whipped ricotta. Nice local place. Would reccomend.read more

This guy is a flat out raciest denying service animals and service to Veterans and their families…read more This is one of multiple customers. Avoid this place and this owner at all costs. Here is one story. Yesterday I took my Service Dog and 4 year old grandson to Benny's pizza. As I immediately walked in the "owner" Jerry shouted at me from behind the counter that I'm not allowed to enter with my dog. My service dog was wearing his vest and I'm a Disabled Vet. This individual continued the the rhetoric, stating that he doesn't care what the laws are he doesn't want my dog in there. I stated that this is a trained service dog and I'm a DV. He went on to say he will deny me. When I began to record he got really angry, scaring my dog and grandson whom is 4 yo. When I insisted that he serve me he held his ground and told me to call law enforcement. I continued to state that it is against the law for him to do this to us. Jerry( the older male) then told me to have my grandson and dog wait outside. I was in absolute shock because my grandbaby is 4yo. When I questioned his requests he stated....well he is old enough to wait outside with the dog, isn't he? I looked at him with disbelief and told him he was four years old! He went back and fourth denying his words then reiterating them. It's all on video. Finally, he agreed to serve us but stating that it will take him 30 minutes to warm up one slice of pizza for my grandson and I it was around 11 o'clock'ish and we were the only ones in the restaurant. I responded with .... Oh really? Then I'll wait and document this Sir, no worries. I also said I know how long it takes to warm a slice up or even make a new pizza and told him his behaviors are so very wrong. I sat down with my grandson and waited about 5-10 mins for my slice. The other gentleman there stayed neutral and called me when the slice was ready. My service dog stayed at my feet lying on the floor the entire time, he caused no problems. In fact, another couple came in and asked if they could pet him and I brought him to them and they enjoyed the interaction. My grandson said to me while sitting at the table.... Grandma, tbat man is mean! He was shaken and I taught him a life lesson on standing your ground when you are in the right.

The pizza here is great, i am torn about this and maybe should have just made it 3 stars but the…read morepizza is really good. My complaint is that the dine in experience is so poor, we came in Saturday 04/19/25 at about 6pm and the place was empty, no greeting, no smiles and zero service, the pizza dining experience is better at Sams Club. Again we will have the pizza in from here again but from delivery, not driving here again for this.

We come to Casper often for shopping and Old Chicago has become our favorite place to bring our…read morefamily. The servers are incredible. They go out of their way to make the kids' extra happy, they are very polite and it seems to be all of them. Our food is always good and service is prompt. This is not a one time thing. It's been the past five times we have eaten here. Keep up the great work OC!

I don't think I've been to an Old Chicago that left me dissatisfied. They're all consistently…read moregood -- the pizza is fantastic. Comes out hot, super doughy, great portion sizes, fair prices -- what's not to like? You'd think someone like me living in California would want a steak when visiting Casper. I'd actually rather go for a pizza and great beer -- which is definitely on tap at Old Chicago. The only real question you need to decide here is: Ale Crust or OC Thick! I've had both and they're both excellent. Big decisions! I love the informal booth settings around the bar -- first come first serve -- great options! Perfect for someone like myself who travels solo for business. This is my go-to stop when visiting Casper. You cannot go wrong with the massive menu. Enjoy!

Hailee was great. She would ask if we needed another beer before we we finished. She knew when she…read morewas needed and when she was not

Would not recommend- food was expensive, but it was also not good. Slow service, not super…read morefriendly. Skip it.

We bought pizza at their Centennial location. The employees messed up our order and when we called…read morethem about it they proceeded to blame it on us even though we have the receipt. Will never order from them again.

Horrible! Look at my cold pizza. It took over an hour and showed up looking like this. I don't…read moreusually complain but...

I haven't had a papa Murphys pizza in probably 6 years but today scrolling Instagram I got an ad…read morethat they now had vegan/dairy free cheese. I was already thinking about takeout to start the weekend off easy so I decided to check out the website. The website is easy to navigate and clearly states allergens with (DF) next to all toppings that are dairy free. That seems self explanatory enough but the salami wasn't dairy free so it's good to know they're looking out. Ordering was easy and I saved a few bucks signing up for their rewards program. We ordered the gourmet vegetarian with red sauce and a regular (dairy free) cheese pizza to get a taste of the cheese without too many toppings. The veggies almost look overwhelming and usually I'm a "less is more" with pizza but this was great. My wife liked it more than the plain cheese pizza but both were good. Baking instructions are simple and took about 15 min in a preheated oven. Please keep the new violife vegan cheese at your Casper locations. We'll definitely be back!

I have absolutely loved this location and concept since the day it opened. Best pizza in Casper by…read moremy opinion. I grew up, making pizzas at Brunetti's in Chicago. This is a great concept. It has always been a great product. It is up to you to bake it correctly! I've never been able to get what I want on a half of our family pizza order. I've always had to settle for either pepperoni or Hawaiian with extra pineapple. Yuk! Then along came the calzone !!!!! And I can pick my fillers!!! Keep up the good work !

Service was slow it took a long time to get my food but the food was good and breakfast was great…read moreand the ambiance was beautiful

Cool place for events requiring a large space. With a staff that aims to please, I totally…read morerecommend this location for a kid party. They will setup a cool arrangement of bounce houses and serve pretty good food at a fair price, overall. Thank you all for delivering a fun and festive experience for our 4 year old birthday party!