Stopping in right at opening, we were greeted by kind staff members. We wanted to try everything,…read moreso we put in an order for brisket, pulled pork, bacon, and kielbasa. Alongside the meats, we wanted to try their sides as well which consisted of mac and cheese, baked beans, corn bread, cole slaw and salt potatoes. For the brisket which we looked forward to the most, we found these to be drier than we would have liked. Paired with sauce, they were just okay. For the pulled pork, we found this to be phenomenal. Smoky and delicious all on its own. Definitely a highlight for us. For the bacon, we ordered 3 different kinds, and we found the flavors didn't really shine through. Although generously thick cut and cooked perfectly. The kielbasa was a bit of a letdown. We found these to be on the dry side, but the flavors were okay. For the sides, the mac and cheese we found the pasta to be a bit overcooked and overall, on the bland side. The baked beans tasted great, no complaints there. The corn bread wasn't anything special and neither were the salt potatoes. Although we did enjoy the salt potatoes and found they were exactly how they ought to be. The cole slaw was also on the bland side and tasted more of the fridge than any flavor. We've heard good things about their smoked wings which we had to try before leaving. We ordered a 5-piece with their spicy Asian sauce. The wings were delicious, the smokiness flavor penetrated throughout the entire wing, but the sauce was very salty which took away from the natural delicious taste of the smoked wings. Overall, a good experience which some seasoning issues but would revisit if we were back in the area.

Delicious bbq lunch, immediately off Rte 104 West, Sodus. We've heard rave reviews and now we know…read morewhy. Friendly staff. Clean cozy indoor dining or you can eat outside on the many picnic tables. BBQ smoked wings, pulled pork sandwich, BLT salad with smoked turkey....so good. Plenty off street parking. Limited hours so check their website. Enjoy!

Wow is all I can say. We found this place on another baseball tournament trip. So first impressions…read morewere the staff was knowledgeable and friendly. Second impressions was they have beautiful artisan bread and desserts that were definitely made on site. So I had the beef in weck. It was delicious the horseradish sauce was so spicy that my nose was on fire! It's like when you eat too much wasabi. Only knock was the salt level on the roll was overdone by a good amount. My wife had the spicy peppered turkey with pepper jack cheese chipotle sauce and jalapeños. She had it on a wrap they had two or three flavors and everything was super fresh. My son had the peppered turkey Italiano and he ate the whole thing. He loved it. I also had a bowl of clam chowda and it was on point! Definitely would recommend this to everyone.

Great soups and sandwiches, fair prices, really nice staff, and a 5 minute walk from most of the…read moreCity and County offices and downtown businesses. Clam chowder and chili are outstanding. A gem.

Tried their whit pizza for the first time and it is absolutely delicious. Top sub and pizza shop in…read morethe area.

I was so excited to find an authentic Italian deli not far from my destination in Farmington NY. I…read morewas especially intrigued upon seeing they use Boars Head products. So I placed an order for 5 sandwiches to sample. I guess my Philly roots compromises my ability to not judge this kind of stuff against the originals, Philly hoagies. Alas, I still haven't found bread or rolls outside of Philly that deserve to be used on a decent hoagie. (Hoagies and cheesesteaks ARE about the roll, the taste and texture, above everything else.) This place is no different. It's hard to judge what is inside a sandwich made with really awful rolls. Sorry, but wherever these slightly crusty versions of white bread come from...not good. That said, they offer a fair quantity of Italian goods, I guess for this area, I should be happy just find some Cento products. Way better than Dario's in Farmington, but not even as good as very mediocre Jersey Mike's, solely on the basis of comparing the rolls used. If you're starving have at it. Otherwise, just a notch above Subway.

Fresh home made food by people that care. I love spending my money here. I've had hot sandwiches…read moreand cold sandwiches, they are all stacked with freshness and are a great value. A large is truly large! I have also had some of their pre packed meals and they are worth every penny as well. The chicken riggis are my favorite. It's a large portion and hits the spot if you are hungry. The salads are all hand made and a great adder to your sandwich. It is not a huge place but they get you in and out quickly. They are 5 star all day. If pressed to find something I would change I would say add Cheddar cheese as a choice and bring in soft rolls... but they don't have this and it doesn't much matter because everything is so fresh and delicious.... Keep it up Shortys..

Im hooked on their roast beef sandwiches. Prices are moderate. They only have two small tables so…read moreits mostly take out place.

Fantastic New York deli with all you can think of and then some! Quick service too.Lots of soups…read moreand desserts.

Take-out review only, but what a deli! Typical deli format…read more Walk down to the end to order and then work your way back towards to front to pay. This place gets busy, but they are working hard to take care of everyone. We ordered two specialty sandwiches to go yesterday and we were out the door in 10 minutes. Ma Bailey (grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, feta, tomatoes, red onion, mixed green w/ caesar dressing in a wrap). Red Hatter (smoked turkey, provolone, roasted red peppers and pesto on toasted focaccia bread). Both were very, very good, but that Red Hatter was the winner! Thanks for feeding us on such a hectic afternoon.

Fresh sub rolls with delicious fresh deli meat!! Highly recommend if you are looking for a fresh…read moredeli sandwich

Friendly people and delicious sandwiches, what more can you ask for for a place right across the…read morestreet from Watkins Glen Gorge. Service was a bit slow even after the lunch rush, which was a little annoying, but the pastrami reuben was one of the best I've ever had in my life.

He'll service was great but who microwave mayonnaise got the momberger and they microwave the whole…read moresandwich what more can I say flavor none in the meat. Very disappointing but service was great

Everything I have ordered from here has been delicious. I usually get subs that's the only place I…read morecan get an egg and olive sub which I love and I love capicola it was excellent.

My boyfriend and I go there frequently, my favorite thing to get is the Italian Panini super…read moredelicious

This is the definition of deli! Funky decor-not hipster-chic funky, just downright funky. I had a…read morewrap and deli salads, my sweetie indulged in hot dog and fries. All were over the top. He lost himself in the dozens of hot sauces. Greeted by such friendly people; can't wait to come back.

Stopped for a sub on the way home from finger lakes. This Italian market is basically a small…read moregrocery store and carries a bunch of canned goods along with spices and ingredients. The sandwich menu includes both hot and cold subs. I had a roast beef sandwich with lettuce tomato and mayo.

This place bills itself as an "Italian Market." I called a few days ahead and asked for an…read more"antipasto platter" with assorted meats and cheeses, etc. When I got it home, the only cheese was cubed Swiss. And, there was no soppresatta, no prosciutto, no peppers. Seriously? No provolone? No mozzarella? Has the "Italian Market" ever met an actual Italian? What a disappointment. How about even a little effort to construct something Italian.