Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Bay Pizzeria

    3.7 (6 reviews)
    Closed • Closed

    Bay Pizzeria Photos

    BAY PIZZERIA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Dogs allowed
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Bay Pizzeria

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    The best club sub I have ever had. Twice the meat and great service. My husband had the Cudighi sub which was excellent also.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ned O.
    0
    11
    1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Bay Pizzeria

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,480 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Roman Wheel Pizzeria

    Roman Wheel Pizzeria

    3.9(95 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    •$

    Great food option in Suttons Bay with unbelievable prices, a great location, and hot subs so good…read morewe went back and ordered seconds. The Italian sub was amazing, and as I said, it was so good and so affordable my girlfriend and I decided to order a second one (not that the first wasn't a good portion to begin with). Thick pieces of flavorful Italian sub meat, crispy, melty, tasty cheese, toasty, fresh bread, and some solid veggie toppings. Couldn't quite tell if they actually put Italian dressing on ours, but it didn't matter. We loved it regardless! Compared to some of the other places in town, this place offers really great flexibility. You can take some subs, pizzas, or salads to go down to the beach, or do what we did and enjoy them in their very cute and peaceful restaurant. They also have a nice outdoor deck seating area with great views of the water, although there was some construction going on when we visited, so we decided to stay inside. They also have a Northwoods soda machine, which is a lot more fun than plain Coke or Pepsi for a northern Michigan adventure like a trip up to Suttons Bay. The guy behind the counter was perfectly friendly and didn't have an issue with us trying all of the different sodas. This will be a place we make into a destination next time we visit northern Michigan!

    Had a couple local friends recommend Roman Wheel while I was staying up in Suttons Bay. Very chill…read moreand homie inside. The guys working were helpful with what I should order. I was stuck between pizza and the broasted chicken. I ended up with the deluxe pizza. The ingredients were so fresh and each bite was crispy and full of flavor. Picture doesn't do justice. Next time, I am going to try the broasted chicken!

    Photos
    Roman Wheel Pizzeria - Inside

    Inside

    Roman Wheel Pizzeria - Deluxe Pizza

    Deluxe Pizza

    Roman Wheel Pizzeria - Inside

    See all

    Inside

    Nittolo’s Seafood & Pizza

    Nittolo’s Seafood & Pizza

    3.9(129 reviews)
    3.1 mi

    My girlfriend and I came here once before on our first date over a year ago, and it was a great…read moretime. So much so that when her parents came to visit, I wanted to take them here, and I'm glad I did. We made reservations for 4 people ahead of time, which is recommended, and we got a nice table inside. Rachel was our server and what a complete gem of a human. Rachel is funny, attentive, and just plain awesome. Three out of four of us got drinks and my Old Fashioned was made VERY well, I know it's a simple drink, but you'd be surprised. My girls aperol spritz was also made well. Nobody ordered appetizers but I chose a bowl of Morel Forest Mushroom Bisque and HOLY SH*T was it good. Once I tried it I had to make everyone at the table try it and we all had the same reaction. Rachel came to check in on us about the drinks n soup and I expressed how great it was. The pizzas came out a little too soon but it was fine since nobody got appetizers. My girl got the Spanish pizza and her dad ordered the Smoked Brisket BBQ, and they loved their food. The Spanish was a perfect balance of sweet n savory and had a crunch with the nuts and was absolutely awesome. I didn't try the bbq pizza because it was gone quickly haha. I ordered the Chicken Parm, which is going to be hard not to get next time. The pasta seems made fresh, the sauce was bright and flavorful for 'just a red sauce' and the chicken was unreal, just perfect. Outside was crunchy and inside was juicy and perfectly cooked. Now, despite being absolutely one of the best Chicken Parms I've ever had, I was only able to eat about 1/3 of this plate. It was SO much food l but I was excited to take it home. My girls mom didn't get Chicken Marsala til a bit after we all started eating, and when it finally came out it looked smelled awesome. After a little allergy scare ( totally cleared up and no issues on either end) we decided to grab desserts to go (which ended up being incredible as well much later) Rachel and the chef that we met were absolute legends and despite a couple little oversights (early pizzas and late entree) I couldn't have asked for a better experience. I'm sad I didn't get any photos but everything was too great to waste time on a phone. Thanks Nittolos, we'll be back soon!

    We were seated in their outdoor garden area on a pleasant summer night. Beautiful flowers, pergola…read moreand overhead twinkle lights lend a relaxing atmosphere. We started with a limoncello martini and a bottle of Fuga red wine - both excellent. There were 7 of us and we ordered for the table to share Caesar Salad and Pasta Rigatoni. Also, Crab Cakes and Shrimp Alla Vodka. All were delicious. Service was good and we had a wonderful, friendly waitress. Would recommend!

    Photos
    Nittolo’s Seafood & Pizza
    Nittolo’s Seafood & Pizza - Halibut

    Halibut

    Nittolo’s Seafood & Pizza

    See all

    VI Grill - 1/2 Sandwich & salad- chicken salad with grapes and walnuts on 9 Grain bread, side garden salad no tomato

    VI Grill

    4.1(226 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    •$$

    Stopped by late Friday afternoon for some drinks and appetizers on the patio…read more Great shaded place with a nice breeze and very friendly staff. They had a great selection of drinks, craft beers and appetizers. We enjoyed chicken nachos, pesto pita pizza....they were both great. Would love to come back for dinner!

    Food - 3/5 Service - 1/5…read moreAmbiance - 4/5 My group of friends and I were visiting Michigan for a wedding and while stopping in Sutton's Bay, decided to get lunch at V.I. Grill! Three of us had the lunch special of a half sandwich of chicken salad with corn chowder and one got the perch basket. We decided to sit outside because it was a nice enough day so the ambiance was pretty good. The chicken salad sandwiches and perch were decent but the soup was underwhelming, thick and lacking seasoning. We decided against saying anything because there was salt and pepper at the table and that helped a little. I also added at least two tbsp of hot sauce. When we got the bill, I paid quickly after skimming it on their little handheld payment device. It wasn't until I was reviewing the bill later than I realized they added on a whole additional sandwich charge. I know servers are busy and it was probably an honest mistake but still frustrating for the bill to be wrong. I called the restaurant and they were nice about it but I had to call multiple times for them to look into it and their voicemail is completely full. I had returned home so it was not possible for me to go in person to resolve the situation. The restaurant is still in progress of resolving the situation so if they do, I will update my review and add a star for service.

    Photos
    VI Grill - Planters lining the patio

    Planters lining the patio

    VI Grill - Ribs and walley

    Ribs and walley

    VI Grill - A lemonade vodka cocktail of some sort.

    See all

    A lemonade vodka cocktail of some sort.

    Vineyard Inn On Suttons Bay - The sunlit view of a Vineyard Inn room

    Vineyard Inn On Suttons Bay

    2.4(27 reviews)
    2.1 mi
    •$$$

    So my wife and I stayed at the Vineyard Inn for the last 3 nights for our first anniversary. The…read moreInn was nice, but is capable of so much more! First off, the exterior is in need of some tree and bush trimming. They have a couple of light posts out front, both of which are completely covered with vines and one of them even has the vines growing inside of the light itself. The tree right in front that hangs over the circle drive has branches hanging so low, you have to walk all the way around it and they have a fountain in the center of the circle drive that has been re-purposed as a flower bed, but there were no flowers in it, just dirt so it looked very tacky and unmanaged. In fact there are many planters around the front of the inn that had no plants in them and were just dirt. We had a Lakeview Suite which was nice, it was clean, but as other reviewers had mentioned there are areas where you can tell corners were cut during the remodel or that they just need more attention and there isn't a handyman onsite. The tops of the tub enclosures need to be caulked, the window blind in our room was broken, the sliding screen door is hard to open and close and doesn't roll smoothly, the mini fridge with freezer needs to be defrosted to get rid of the 2" of ice buildup inside, and the shower head is in dire need of either replacement or a deep cleaning with CLR. The beds were kind of uncomfortable. I think they advertize them as being a pillow top mattress and if they are, the pillow top has been heavy worn out. The beds sounded too like that had a plastic sheet over them (you know the type you use on beds when kids can't hold it through the night) although I never pulled the fitted sheet off to check. It was nice that every room has either a patio or balcony attached with chairs and the views of the bay from the rooms are great! Many spots outside on the lawn and beach to sit and having the bonfire pits lit at night was really nice. They had bean bag toss set up in the back for guests to use as well. They have a restaurant attached too, Corky's. We were going to have dinner there Thursday night when we arrived after being on the road for that last 8 hours, but they were closed and are only open on the weekends even though their website states "Open Daily for Dinner at 5:00", so we had to go somewhere else. After that night, we read the reviews for Corky's and opted to continue going elsewhere for dinner. By the way, the plants are so overgrown in the front around Corky's sign that all you can read is "orky's". We thought it odd as well on how not busy Corky's was. They have a great looking space, right on the water, with a great outdoor bar and yet on a busy Friday and Saturday night, they had maybe 5 or 6 tables with guests, the bar was closed, and just barely had any business, and yet almost every restaurant in downtown Suttons Bay, only 2 miles away, has a wait to get in the door. So, all in all, not a bad experience, just not exactly what I thought I was getting for how much I paid a night to stay there. I think I'll watch for some more positive reviews from Yelpers though before we decide to go back.

    We have enjoyed the food and atmosphere here in the past but unfortunately we had an extremely…read moreunfortunate experience! I had planned a very special dinner celebration for my sister and her husband's 50th wedding anniversary. We had a reservation for 10 which was confirmed 2 weeks prior via the owner. Our guests travelled a long way for this event (as far as Atlanta). When we arrived we found the restaurant closed, ruining our celebration. I contacted the owner and she said she was sorry , but they did not have a chef or any staff! SO UNPROFESSIONAL AND SO DISAPPOINTING!

    Photos
    Vineyard Inn On Suttons Bay - Beach Bistro  " The most popular waterfront restaurant in Leelanau County" Great food, libations and FUN!"

    Beach Bistro " The most popular waterfront restaurant in Leelanau County" Great food, libations and FUN!"

    Vineyard Inn On Suttons Bay - Corky's waterfront bistro and outdoor seating at the Vineyard Inn on Sutton's Bay

    Corky's waterfront bistro and outdoor seating at the Vineyard Inn on Sutton's Bay

    Vineyard Inn On Suttons Bay - Great view during lunch

    See all

    Great view during lunch

    Two Sons Pizza - This is why you never tip carry out

    Two Sons Pizza

    4.2(52 reviews)
    14.9 mi

    We ordered takeout from Two Sons Pizza. It was ready by the estimated time and our order was…read morecorrect. We felt the pizza had too much pepperoni for our liking. We enjoyed the garlic knots!

    This New York style pizzeria is located inside Silver Spruce Brewing, which is a fun,…read moreindoor-outdoor venue. Frontage on Eighth Street, but it feels like a neighborhood joint once you are in there. I apologize to Two Sons Pizza, for not writing a five star review, when the pizza was five stars. I mean, we've got The Filling Station for the real thin but still chewy crust. Excellent. Charles and Reid for Detroit style, which is life altering delicious (and I generally hate thick pizza). And Two Sons completed the power triangle with big New York style slices and pies. But what the F happened? They've always had a little bit of that dismissive hipster kind of vibe, where they try to make you feel like you're not important, or possibly not cool enough to enjoy how amazing their pizza is, or was. But now it's like the one or two employees who are there at a time, don't want to be there at all. And that's what the pizza tastes like now The slices used to be massive, like cutting an extra large pizza into six slices. They were priced accordingly, $7-8+, but well worth it. Delicious. Now the pies are old sitting around for hours, and they don't perk up when reheated like they used to. I don't have a problem with proper New York style slices, being reheated, that's part of the tradition. But the attitude I get is, if they aren't slammed busy, they don't care about having fresh food, and you just get what you get. It seems the employees don't care, they are like robots now, and unhappy robots at that. They've got the NY magic and the special sauce, they just aren't using it anymore. Maybe the chef quit, maybe it got sold, I have no idea. The last slice I had, I threw it in the garbage, and went to Toby's dog house, the hot dog trailer outside. But it was closed on a day it was supposed to be open. The guy behind the bar at Silver Spruce brewing has the same dismissive/dumb attitude. I wouldn't be surprised if all three places closed after summer 2026 ** since they are capable of making a good New York style pie, at least in theory now, just order a whole pizza. That way, it will be fresh. The slice game is dead there. **

    Photos
    Two Sons Pizza - All three pizzas mentioned in the review

    All three pizzas mentioned in the review

    Two Sons Pizza - Shame on you, fire this guy

    Shame on you, fire this guy

    Two Sons Pizza - Outside Patio

    See all

    Outside Patio

    Bay Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...