Millie's is a great addition to Glen Arbor. The pizza is tasty, the ambiance is hip and modern, and the outside seating looks at the river. All in all, a nice spot for some pizza! We got the Il Porco pizza which had Italian sausage and sweet onion on it. We opted to get the Roman crust and it was very flavorful! The downside was it was a long wait to get our food. Like crazy long. We also did not know if we would be served our pizza or if we would have to pick it up inside- it was a bit confusing. We would definitely eat here again as the taste of the pizza and spot along the river was worth the long wait. read more

Millie's Glen Arbor - I'll Porco Pizza with Roman Crust - Pizza Near Me - Glen Arbor, Michigan

Came here for the gluten-free pizza and the outdoor seating. The GF pizza is 12 inches, which makes it a good average size. It tasted pretty good and the toppings were baked under the cheese. I ordered a water, which was about $3 and in a bottle - not what I expected, but I guess it is very fancy imported water from Italy. They also offered drinks like Olipop and kombucha which might be a little more worth the money. The girl taking our order didn't go out of her way to be friendly but it wasn't a bad experience or anything. I don't believe there was much of a wait before our order, but the pizza was predicted to take 20 minutes to make. The inside is pretty crowded but the picnic tables were cute to sit in. I do think the hours are a little strange, definitely not for early dinner eaters. Overall, it was a cute outdoor dining experience and they did consider gf and vegan pretty well! read more

Millie's Glen Arbor - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Glen Arbor, Michigan

See all

We ordered the thin crust pizza with sausage and mushrooms along with a cheesy bread. The thin crust definitely is made with a whole wheat flour as it was dense and very chewy. I would much prefer a thin crust to be made with "00" flour or something similar as this current thin crust is tough to eat. The cheesy bread which was Roman style was delicious however. So we would probably order again just not thin crust. read more

Food was decent but don't waste your time. They won't answer their phones and we had to wait 45 min for sad fried ravioli that was cold. This place could be good but clearly understaffed and not good if you're actually hungry when you order. read more

Millie's Glen Arbor - View of the river - Pizza Near Me - Glen Arbor, Michigan

Well, this was a pleasant surprise. The Roman-style pizza was crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and perfectly cooked. Make sure you order the hot honey to complete your order. The staff was friendly and personable. We will be ordering again. read more

Millie's Glen Arbor - The classic cheese "Formaggi" pizza and "The Millie" pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Glen Arbor, Michigan

One of the worst pizzas we have ever had unfortunately. My partner and I went on a trip to this area, decided to get a pizza -we ordered the Millie on a thin crust (maybe they specialize in deep dish). It got cold fast, the flavor of the seasoning was overkill -tasted like a pound of pepper, and the crust as a whole was pretty bad from the flavor to the crunch. The service seemed fine, took about 25mins to make the pizza. read more

Our order(big order) was ready on time and the food preparation was really good. Given several people in our group are pizza enthusiasts, I wasn't sure what the reviews would be, but it was nothing but positive feedback. I would definitely order again! read more

The service and ambiance was great! The pizza--not so much. We got the pesto garlic pizza with the homemade crust. The crust definitely tasted homemade, and not in a good way. It was pretty flavorless. There was barely any pesto. The cheese and garlic was good. It kinda just tasted like meh cheesy bread with some garlic and just okay bread. It was also pretty expensive--a little over $20 for 6 square slices with zero meat... read more

Fungi flatbread, pizza - like eating cardboard. Spicy Italian Roman crust - way too much cheese, really chewy. this new establishment took the place of the legendary riverfront pizza, Home of Johnny salami. RIP Johnny, we loved your Really-Inspired- Pizza. read more

Good pizza. Small ice cream selection. Overall, not a bad snack quick bite fix. Wishing for more ice cream options soon!

Doing a mid winter break. Got a Roman pizza. Was excellent! Top notch premium pizza. Can't go wrong with this place if you're looking for your pizza fix. read more

Pizza was pretty good, we got the Roman style and it was a nice change of pace. It was pretty quiet and we were the only people who were inside. They were out of a lot of ice cream flavors so we opted to head somewhere else for dessert. read more

Pizza is excellent. Thin crust is a cracker and the pan style has great crust too. Staff was very pleasant patient and helpful. Returning today for second day in a row. read more

Pizza was solid. Told us 50 min for carry out order - ended up taking 2 hours. Most likely a staffing issue but dont make fake promises

Absolutely do not order from here if you want to plan on receiving your food. Ordered a pizza at 6:20pm for my family and paid in full. The order pick-up time was listed on the receipt as 7:30pm. We arrived at 7:20pm to pick up the food and the business had closed. The hours are 12-8. We then stopped by The Mill (same owners) to ask what happened and the manager informed us they closed early because it was slow. Closed early because is was slow but did not fulfill orders paid for in full, made no attempt to contact the customers, or issue refunds. Head to another establishment that actually considers their customers. read more

Worst service ever! Every time I have gone there they get my order wrong and blame it on me! If could I would give 0 stars!

Thin crust pizza came raw, with an entire package of pepperoni thrown on top of it. Square pepperoni pizza was also underdone and very doughy with little/no sauce. read more

Stopped by Millie's after a weekend of hiking & camping and this was the perfect way to cap iff the weekend! Got a slice of pepperoni & the hot salumi foaccia sandwhich. Pepperoni was great, they cooked it so the little pepperonis started to cup and got crispy at the edges *chef's kiss* Salumi sandwhich was also a banger, focaccia texture was still a bit springy even though it was a pressed sandwhich but my favorite part was the pepperocinis! There is a small indoor eating area, just a standing counter/table near the windows, other than that it's all outdoor seating. I'm definitely coming back next time we're in the area! read more

You could improve the pizza and the service. We called around 6:45 and got an answering machine. Fortunately we live pretty close so my husband drove over there. The women taking the order was not very pleasant to deal with. In fact she mentioned they're just too busy to answer the phone. If the service and pizza remains the same the phone probably won't be ringing at all. My husband ordered at the place and made it clear that he wanted red sauce, which we feel is always part of a pizza even without asking. No red sauce at all and garlic was very heavy. Very disappointing. We were looking forward to a good pizza restaurant in the area but sadly can't recommend Millie's. read more

Millie's Glen Arbor - Where is the red (pizza) sauce?!? - Pizza Near Me - Glen Arbor, Michigan

See all

Pretty solid pizza - great rise on the Roman-style crust, maybe a touch overdone but excellent flavor and crispiness.

We were told the pizza would be ready in an 60 min. However the mushroom pizza may take 10 min longer. We asked that they text us when put into the oven. Sure, no problem we were told. We came in 50 min later and the pizzas were sitting on top of the oven. The mushroom pizza was cold. NOT WARM, Cold! Very disappointed! Three pizzas over $70. Wow! They need to step up their game. read more

Millie's! We attended the grand opening and WOW were we impressed. The entire experience was perfection. The kindness of the owners, the design of the building, and the quality of the food - all 10/10. The pizza is bought by the slice to build a box of 6 slices, all a thin style deep dish with the best crust we've had. We tried all flavors available and were not disappointed! The outside seating along the crystal river and back patio make for the perfect ambiance. For opening day we were served within 20 minutes and all pizza piping hot! This is a staple place to add to this charming town and is now a must to stop for lunch or dinner on your next visit to Glen Arbor! The home made ice cream was the perfect end to the meal! read more

See all

Finally a great place to buy ice cream in town beyond the foul ice cream shop (dirty) down the street.

Absolutely best pizza in town, in the top 2 in the county, in the top 3 within a 60 mile drive. Fresh/real ingredients (as if someone has to call that out...)! read more

I ordered 3 pieces of pizza (which is sold by the slice) cheese, pepperoni and mushroom and garlic. The pizza was ready in less than 10 minutes and smelled wonderful but the only piece that was good was the cheese. The mushroom/garlic was cold and the pepperoni was soggy. I would not recommend read more

We've tried it twice. Just not a fan of the pizza. The dough is too thick and the toppings/sauce could be better. Glen Arbor needs a good pizza place and Millie's misses the mark. In addition, selling pizza by the slice means some pieces come from different pies. This just doesn't make sense because each slice is different. The venue is beautiful and the location is perfect, they just need a better pizza. read more

Great new place in town! Glad we picked up some delicious slices while we were there. Great addition to the area. Next time we'll eat at the picnic tables on the river. read more

Excellent pizza and ice cream with a lovely outdoor seating area! Great service as well!