My son and his friend wanted to go for ice cream and we usually go to Old Fashioned Ice Cream Shop…read moreon Straight Path. But they don't have indoor seating and I just got a new car 2 days ago. No way was I letting 3 teens in my car with ice cream. His friend recommended Coyle's off Sunrise Highway. I can't believe we've never stopped here before! It was all decorated for Christmas and had friendly old ice cream shop / diner vibes with plenty of booths and counter seats. It was empty because it was 5 pm on one of the coldest days of the year. They have a wide selection of homemade ice cream flavors, plus soft serve, waffle cones, waffle bowls, their own sundae creations, and ice cream cakes and other treats to take home. I got a cannoli and Irish cream cup, my son got pistachio, and his friend got mint chip and Nutella. My daughter got a hot chocolate that she also enjoyed. I'd say it's easily comparable to OFICS, but the seating and atmosphere takes it to the next level. We will definitely be back -- ideally when the weather warms up!

Coyles is a lovely old-fashioned ice cream shop that my kids and I love coming to! It's clean, tons…read moreof flavors, great friendly employees!

I ordered the Berry Wild Crêpe--strawberries, blackberries, blueberries & Nutella. The crêpe maker…read moretold me that the recipe calls for only two tablespoons of each fruit and lots of Nutella. Because I am watching my weight, I asked for more fruit and less Nutella. The crêpe was pale, thick, and doughy, but the filling was tasty. I am a crêpe lover, having eaten my first one in its place of origin--Brittany, France--as a 17- year-old exchange student. No crêpe will ever beat my first! That one was a thin brownish pancake made from buckwheat flour and garnished with fresh-squeezed lemon juice, lemon zest, powdered- and granulated sugar. I have never eaten one as good since then, and I have dined in fine French restaurants in NYC and abroad. Yo Go Wild has several small tables inside to sit down and eat, and the place is relatively clean. The service was quick and friendly, but I will not be back for their crêpes. I usually come here to buy their frozen yogurt. They taste fresh and come in a variety of flavors.

Enjoyed the froyo as a dessert after a hot spicy Sichuan meal on New Year's Day 2026. I wish there…read morewas more variety of flavors. I got the mix of dulce de leche and vanilla. There was too much varieties of vanilla and chocolate. I wish they had an original tart flavor as well. Really enjoyed the nuts in syrup and blueberry Oreo. Prices were fair. Will be back if in the area.

been going here almost 30 years to this location. all I can say is. Thank You. Great People. Great…read moreFamily. Great Location. miss you Paul. Truely a great guy whom loved his customers. Ill be back to order the same sundae Ive been ordering since the beginning. ;)

Twice I visited the Carvel at Bay Shore and twice I had a problem…read morebecause of buy one get one free Wednesday. I asked for a buy one get one sundae and i was told it didn't apply to sundaes. The next time I ordered a small cone with a small cup. I was told I couldn't get a cone and get anything free. I walked out and went a few miles on Bay Shore Rd and got 2 Sundaes for one price. They even say it on the door. Do yourself a favor and go straight to the one on Bay Shore Rd especially on Wednesday.

Great selection friendly .been there many times and will continue to go back for there great…read moreice-cream.

Beware! Check your bill! They are ripping off customers…read more Every year for the last ten years, I order a birthday cake from Hershey's in West Islip. Went in on Friday. Ordered the cake. Was told it was $20.99 for the small. Today is Tuesday and I just returned from picking up the cake. After ringing it up, it came up $21.83. I told the cashier who kept repeating, "I just work here. I just work here," that the price was wrong. I was told the price was $20.99. The TICKET says $20.99. She called her manager and told me the prices went up. The price didn't go up. They are just ripping off customers, hoping they won't notice. I was given a price of $20.99. after calculating the tax, I left the actual cost of the cake, not the ripped off fake amount scam they tried to pull off on me. What an utter disgrace. NEVER AGAIN! After response from owner: Christine, I paid with cash. I always pay with cash. Your cashier saw the cash. So when she was on the phone with the "manager," the manager should've asked her was the customer paying cash or credit card. And your "manager" stated the prices had gone up. So your "manager" lied. So yes. You are ripping customers off if you don't explain cash vs credit or train your employees to select the button that states the customer is paying cash. And if you had read the above review carefully, you would see that I paid in cash.

We are never disappointed with Ralph's treats. We have tried the soft serve, the cream iced and…read morewater ice. All are delicious. The service is always fast and courteous. One star taken away for the prices. We easily spend $15 on a treat for two teen.

Not sure why there aren't more reviews for this place b/c it's super yum! I came a few weeks ago…read moreand they still had a TON of flavors. Ordered 8 tubs for my work staff a few days in advance and they were ready for pickup in the evening. Staff were super helpful in helping me choose a variety of flavors. Favorites were passionfruit and pumpkin pie.Can't wait to try more flavors!!

We were stopping in for ice cream and my toddler and I needed to use the bathroom. We were told…read morethe "bathroom is closed." How could you close a bathroom at an establishment that sells food?! Disgusted beyond belief that I was pregnant and was told I couldn't use the bathroom nor could my daughter. The woman was nasty and walked away too. They lost our business!

I love cold stone. When my husband and I first moved here in 2016, back when we were dating, I was…read morewondering if there was a location in Suffolk. My husband's friend said that there was one in Babylon. I was so excited! The service is always great. They always ask if I need any help. There used to be seats back when I first started going. They changed it to having about 3 fridges for their cakes and ice cream sandwiches as well. They have different sized cakes as well, so it was nice seeing that.

I called in 5 days ahead for a Fudgy the Whale cake. My husband went to pick up at the appointed…read moretime of 11:00 am. The owner strolls in at 11:15 and decorated the cake then. Don't get me wrong, th4 cake was delicious and typical Carvel crunchies fashion but the wait and the size was underwhelming. No need to call in ahead, maybe just 1 day in advance if it's a specialty cake.

The best Carvel store anywhere. Secret, Soft serve large is BOGO everyday of the week, just ask for…read moreit. On most days there are SIX different dift serve flavors. The same Family operated business for years. The young employees working at the counter are always courteous and polite. This place gets packed certain times of the night but the lines move fast. They'll also accommodate your special ice cream cake orders. Hard scoop ice cream is available. Freezer cases always has an assortment of ice cream novelties.

2 birthdays in a row they said I couldn't use my birthday coupon. The manager said their system was…read moredown, so how are you able to take payments or process transactions if the system is down Yo Go Wild is better

Sooooo very happy that they have the lactose free coconut and the all fruit ice creams!!!! Their…read morecompany site says that they don't have it but they actually do!!! Get the coconut with the Oreos and the dark chocolate chips!!!