They don't take reservation and they prefer cash. Once you know this, you don't need to complain about it. The service was the best. The waiters were professional yet they had fun with you which of course, I liked. The food was traditionally Tuscan Italian. The meal began with some fresh Italian bread and olive oil. So good start there! Our starters were an Antipasto Toscano, a generous platter of cured meats, cheeses, crostini full of Tuscan flavors and great for sharing! We also shared the Fried Mushrooms but we both felt that it was fried too much. For our mains we had the Ossobuco which went down very nicely as it was the first time she had it. And I had the Pappardelle al Cinghiale (Wild Boar Ragu) which I loved as well. The place is not that big and the tables are close to each other plus it was full but it was buzzing with a young crowd which made the ambience jolly.and lively! Food: 4.5/5 Service: 5/5 Ambiance: 5/5 read more

See all

While walking by, I noticed several boxes of meat sitting out on the sidewalk, one of which was damaged and partially open with raw ground meat visibly exposed. It appeared to be stored directly on the ground next to a hand truck. Seeing raw meat like that outside uncovered and clearly not being kept at a proper temperature was honestly shocking. Food safety should be a basic standard for any restaurant, especially one that has the reputation and prices this place does. Watching staff move around these boxes without much concern made it even worse. It is hard to feel comfortable eating somewhere after seeing how ingredients might be handled before they even reach the kitchen. I understand deliveries happen, but raw meat sitting exposed on a city sidewalk is not something customers should ever see. Hopefully management takes food handling and storage more seriously in the future. Unfortunately after seeing that I decided not to dine there. read more

Bar Pitti - Inform NYC FOOD SAFTEY - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Bar Pitti is exactly what you expect from a beloved New York hotspot -- lively, crowded, energetic, and full of personality. The service was fun and friendly, though admittedly a bit slow at times. Definitely arrive early if you want to avoid a wait. The atmosphere is classic NYC: tables close, conversations overlapping, and you'll probably "get to know your neighbor," which is part of the charm and totally expected for this style of dining. I ordered the Taglierini al Tartufo Nero, which was good but not great. The pasta itself didn't taste fresh -- almost as if it had been made days prior and dried out too long. The truffle sauce was also noticeably under-seasoned and a bit bland. Fortunately, a generous snowfall of fresh Parmesan brought the dish back to life. The pairing of high-quality Parmesan and aromatic truffle worked beautifully together, even if the noodles themselves were underwhelming. Despite the pasta misstep, the vibe, friendly service, great company, and a surprise celebrity sighting made the evening genuinely memorable. Bar Pitti has an undeniable charm, and I'll absolutely be returning to try more dishes. It remains a classic New York local favorite -- imperfect at times, but still well worth the visit. read more

See all

Cash only spot which is slightly inconvenient but really tasty and classic spot in the heart of Soho/WV

The best and authentic Italian experience I have had. It is a small and busy casual restaurant. Everything is made like a home Cooked meal with real cream, cheese and fresh vegetables. This is the most comforting food you can get in the city. The staff is super nice and talkative. They were really friendly and all introduced themselves to me and joked around. Service is fast. One of the best places I have eaten in NYC. Get the mushrooms!!' Cash only! read more

See all

this place is iconic. something about a restaurant that's casual but the food is top tier that does it for me. i walked in here on a thursday night at 6pm and sat outside in workout clothes. you can dress up or down and the vibe is still immaculate. service is quick! waiters are italian so it feels very authentic. can't go wrong with this place. only downside is it's cash only and there's sometimes a wait. read more

Bar Pitti - eggplant parm - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I loveeee the pasta here. Service can be iffy but the food comes out pretty quickly. Also cash only. I prefer to sit outside but the inside can also be a vibe. Pretty sure celebrities come here like Taylor Swift which is why it's always busy. read more

See all

Bar Pitti absolutely lived up to the hype. From start to finish, everything we ordered was spot-on, delivering that rustic Italian comfort with just the right amount of New York energy. The Burrata was a standout -- impossibly creamy, perfectly paired with fresh bread. The Rigatoni (Riggies) were rich and flavorful, with sauce that clung to every bite just the way it should. The Gnocchi were pillowy and light, a true testament to well-crafted handmade pasta. And the Pappardelle? Silky ribbons tossed in a hearty creamy sauce. The vibe is casual. Service was amazing! Our waiter had the Italian accent and we loved him. The experience felt authentically Italian without trying too hard. Can't wait to go back. read more

See all

Ouch... I've heard so many good reviews about Bar Pitti but I hate to be the one that begs to differ Our tab came about $700 worth of food and drinks, I even tried my homies' order & nothing moved me + the restaurant lacks space, the only thing that was moving was my seat that kept being kicked by servers and people passing by behind me. Appetite low, Overstimulation high My Linguini Alle Vongole was slightly the best pick on the table read more

Bar Pitti - Linguini Alle Vongole - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I was unfortunately underwhelmed by Bar Pitti. I was super excited to try the famous pappardelle but was unfortunately let down a bit. Don't get me wrong, it was by no means bad. It was good, however for the amount of hype around this restaurant and this dish, in particular, I wasn't overly impressed.The wine was great and the appetizers we got were very good as well. I tried one person in our parties Milanese and it was very good. Service was a bit slow, but we were a larger group so that's understandable, but unfortunately, our waiter was not the friendliest. I must say the ambience is great as it definitely feels like a typical old school Italian restaurant. I would definitely try Bar Pitti again, but I think there are much better Italian establishments in the city. read more

Bar Pitti - Pappardelle Alla Fiesolana - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

celebrated my friends birthday at this old school italian restaurant which was the perfect choice for 5 hungry girls we all got the Pappardelle Alla Fiesolana and split the burrata to start. this entire meal was so delicious i was constantly licking the plate. definitely not the best italian ive had in the city but its definitely a solid spot and super consistent! they brought out our food in what felt like seconds and it always came out so warm! this place is cash only fyi, but def recommend and would return read more

Bar Pitti - Pappardelle Alla Fiesolana - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Bizarre experience all around. Hectic service, outrageously tight seating, shortcuts being taken on the food prep. Crowd is a blend of vintage "South Village" (a la Villa Mosconi) and younger people who visit the neighborhood only on weekends. Bread is chilled (but, indeed "fluffy") and served on slightly warmed plates. Olive oil pre-portioned with no balsamic in sight. Water glasses are so beat up they look like they were used as instruments in a chamber orchestra. Large blackboard somewhat charming but I was asked if I was ready twice before I had to ask for someone to introduce the menu / translate Italian. Two lamb dishes, rack and shank, were priced at $39.50 and $69.50, respectively. The waitress then told me that they were "mixed up," while smudging up the chalk board, but I didn't fully grasp what she was saying. Obviously the rack is the more expensive cut, but 1. nobody ever serves the full rack and 2. Brisciola (like two blocks away) serves a few chops for like $20. Anyway, I ordered the Pappardelle Alla Fiesolana (which was $26.50) and the rack of lamb (which ended up being $69.50). Pappardelle was sloppily plated but was really good. Using bacon in place of a traditional cured meat, with no semblance of actual fresh tomatoes, is a cop out--really a $19.50 dish at most. The rack of lamb, which, of course, wasn't a rack of lamb, but was a half a rack of lamb, was probably the most amateurishly prepared premium protein I've had so far in 2025. Basic seasoning, nothing resembling a crust, rare+ for the center cuts--exactly how this dish turns out the first time a home chef cooks it. Not having been able to cover my bill with a single hundred dollar bill encapsulates my disappointment. read more

Really enjoyed the outdoor seating and the fresh pasta! The pappardelle alla fiesolana was such a great dish (quite heavy) but phenomenal! The rigatoni pitti was also delightful! The veal meatballs were a little chewy, but still a great appetizer! Cheers! read more

See all

Definitely one of the best pastas I've had in this city for a long time. Authentic Italian touch. Servers were so sweet and had the right amount of euro style care I look for in my experiences. The restaurant isn't huge which also adds to its charm. People are flowing in and out of there creating a sense of lure! You have to be there and if you're not...what are you waiting for?? read more

See all

Really great local spot ! I love the pappardelle pasta ! Here's photos of the most recent menu read more

Bar Pitti - Menu may 29, 2024 - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Wow! Such a gem in West Village. I absolutely loved the experience from beginning to end. The service was fast, attentive, and very friendly. Ambiance is loud and great for groups. I am looking forward to returning. read more

See all

Myself and my boyfriend have been to practically every Italian in the city and this one is a restaurant that we come back to over and over and over again! You could never go wrong with their veal meatballs, or their eggplant Parm as appetizers their pastas are homemade and to die for. Tight cramped quarters, but always worth it for some of the best authentic Italian in the city! It really is some of the best food you can ever enjoy! The homemade desserts - especially the tiramisu, are just the icing on the cake! All the staff are great, but we always love to have Rudy as a waiter who takes such good care of us!! Whoever rated this restaurant three stars needs to go get a life. This is definitely four stars all the way! Come enjoy dinner here you will be happy you did!! read more

Micheal was our server he was great!! Great recommendations, great attitude, def made us feel welcomed. Food was great, had veil, gnocchi, pesto pasta, rabbit pasta, wine and a great time. My girlfriend was already at a table when we got there so I don't really know what the wait time is but from the looks of the crowd, it probably gets pretty hectic and also luckily we had gotten there at 5:15 530 or so, that worked in our favor. Ambience is super cute casual. It could be a date night for sure. Definitely a Sunday fun day.! read more

I am not understanding the low ratings to Bar Pitti. I stumbled upon the restaurant over a specific pasta which I will go over later into my review. I saw a picture, asked a friend if she knew where the restaurant was, I ate the pasta, and the rest was history. Hubs and I walked on over at noon for lunch. I felt like I walked into an episode of The Bear; where the restaurant staff eats together prior to opening the restaurant. I appreciated this site prior to being seated. We were given menus and I knew what I wanted immediately. We passed on appetizers because I didn't want to be full prior to recieving the main course. The Pappardelle Alla Fiesolana. It was a wide pasta noodle with a pink creamy sauce. It had the taste of a Carbonara due to the bacon but so much better. It was love at first bite. I already told the hubs that I plan to go once more while we are in New York. We also ordered the Tiramisu which was raved about and they weren't lying. It makes it to my "Top 3 Misus" list... if I had a list. It was so light and airy. Not overly sweet. And after a carb-heavy lunch, this was perfect. The staff was as friendly as a staff should be. Their Italian accents were music to my ears and the cost wasn't too bad. It gave me Carbone-esque pricing, but better. The only thing is that the restaurant is cash-only. No biggie. read more

See all

The food is really delicious and the wait staff is very good. They have heated seating outside now that the weather is chilly. But Yelp needs to update the prices. The pastas are at least $10 more. read more

Soooo delicious. Had to eat the rest of the sauce with the bread because it was so good!! One of the best pasta I've had read more

Bar Pitti - Pappardelle Alla Fiesolana - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

prices are fair for the portions! came before the rush so it was pretty empty and service was fast. pretty basic restaurant focused on pasta. no flavors stood out but everything tasted good nonetheless. read more

Bar Pitti - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Whouuuuu,still one of the best Italian restaurants in New York.Owner and chef Giovanni is still putting his heart and soul into the fresh pastas and great meats.You gone start you dinner with excellent bread and extra virgin olive oil.i always order penne arabiatta follow by huge chicken Milanese made to perfection.BRAVO, BRAVO, BRAVO read more

Food was great service was good. Only drawback is it's only cash, but not a big deal for me. read more

Bar Pitti - The chocolate mousse was fantastic - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Solid 3-star pasta place. The pappardelle was underwhelming and overly creamy in my opinion. Didn't do it for me. But the truffle pasta was amazing. Went on a Friday night and to my surprise, several tables were wide open outside, and the inside was pretty empty. Yet still service was a bit slow. Had to flag servers down for water refills and some of them just hover around the dining area, looking more like security than anything. The vibe just felt off inside and the pay by cash thing is annoying. But, it's worth a try. read more

See all

Wow, wow, wow. Extremely great experience over at Bar Pitti, we got lucky getting a table here. Place is packed to the brim most night, especially on the weekends. You'd expect this place to charge an arm and a leg for what they put out but it's price reasonably. The staff seems to be very knowledgeable on the menu so we took their advise on what to get. Can't go wrong with anything on the menu. read more

Bar Pitti - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great place for outdoor dining and take in the views. It gets packed in here especially weekends. Our pastas were delicious and creamy. The bread was also very soft and yummy. Staff is friendly and accommodating. read more

See all

I like this spot and those who work there, but I ordered a side of chicken and got charged $38.00. It was more expensive than any of our entrees. I asked the server about it and he made it sound like it was the normal up charge, so I rolled with it -- but 24 hours later, I'm a little mind blown. Lol read more

I was surprised when I saw the overall Yelp rating for Bar Pitti; I thought it would be a lot higher! I went here last night with my two friends and we had a great time. I got penne with tomato sauce and it was delicious- quite spicy, but delicious. My friends got the pasta with meat sauce and enjoyed it as well. The waiters were fine, nothing special, but they did make it feel like an authentically Italian spot which was nice. The place is cash only which can be annoying but they have an accessible ATM. This place is a bit pricey but overall I think it was worth it, but it's not like I'll be coming back super frequently. Maybe if I lived near it I would and the prices were a tiny bit lower lol. The portion sizes were great and my friends finished their plates but it was almost too much for me! The bread that they brought out for free was fine, nothing special. They don't take reservations but I went at 6:30 pm on a Wednesday so we didn't have a wait, but some ppl who came after us had to wait a while. Just something to keep in mind! I can't really speak much on the ambiance because we ate outside but I had a lovely time and loved the outside seating. I also am biased though bc I love sitting outside in the summer lol! read more

Bar Pitti - Penne All Arrabbiata - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Excellent food, great service. Very attentive, meatballs were incredible. Love the atmosphere.

The "Bill & Tony's" of New York - no frills, cash only, mismatched glassware, no fuss. There's an ATM downstairs (good to know). Sit outside with a spritz and order a pasta and salad - heaven' read more

The people watching - other folks in the restaurants or pedestrians - is my favorite part about this restaurant. Great location, great neighborhood. Everything I've ever eaten here has been wonderful. Slower service, but feels authentic to European style dining. Cash only! I find the prices reasonable, the specials to die for, and the vibes immaculate. read more

The pasta is delicious, the service has always been fast and kind when I've visited, and it's honestly such a classic, wonderful experience to sit in their sidewalk area, enjoy the open air, and just people watch as you eat your dinner. Unfortunately taking off a star because my olive oil plate was dirty with dried food on it ... read more

Bar Pitti - Free bread - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

So, here's the thing. I do think the quality of food is closer to a 3 for me HOWEVER the service was SO incredible and stand out, I have to bump them up to a 4. The olive oil was quite bland and I needed to add salt to enjoy it. The table bread was fluffy and yummy. I went a bit out of my comfort zone to try the chicken liver pate. Again, I felt it was quite bland. I've had liver a few times and sometimes it just doesn't suit my palette. This was definitely one of those times. I wasn't able to eat more than a bite. My server noticed this and decided to remove it from my bill without me even mentioning anything, which to me is stand out service. I decided to try their famous blush pasta. It was slightly bland but I loved the flat noodles paired with the sauce. I still ate almost the entire dish and used some of the table bread to help soak up the sauce. I smelled someone else's truffle pasta and it smelled divine. I wish I had also ordered this to try. The pana cotta was decent, but didn't wow me. This spot is cash only and walk in. Oddly a quite casual experience for Italian food which I appreciate. 3.9/5 read more

See all

Pastas are so mid, small portions, horrible customer service, only accepts cash and that's how they get you to use their ATM to collect their fee. Don't waste your time here. read more

Saw a TikTok about this place saying that they have great Italian food. So bad that I had to leave a review! 1. The waiters who are older men had the nastiest attitude for absolutely no reason. Everything we asked seemed like a big inconvenience for him. We were asking about the menu but he made us feel like idiots for not knowing what a certain dish has in it. The menu board that he showed us had horrible handwriting we couldn't even read it. It doesn't help that he goes over the menu board in 3x speed playback. We didn't even bother asking about a certain dish because we were scared of pissing him off. 2. Food was OVERPRICED ASF and the protein content were very limited. The pasta was very mediocre. Do not get the truffle pasta please. For $50, you get a good amount of truffle but the cream sauce was literally water by the way it had no flavor. And the noodles had a weird chewy texture in a watery cream sauce. Wine was served in an old short glass, not very classy, not very demure. Water glass smelled fishy like it wasn't washed well. We ate as fast as we could so we could get the hell out of here. Ambiance was not great if you want to enjoy your night. 3. Cash only, which is fine. But if you're gonna charge only cash, at least lower the price a little on your mediocre food!! Receipt was very sketchy. It was written out sloppily in hope that you don't bother asking about them charging you more than they should. I could not read the handwriting and he gave us an attitude when we asked for him to clarify the total and gratuity. Don't support restaurants that could care less about their customers and the quality of their food. If this is considered "authentic Italian food"... I'm not sure if I want to go to Italy. They're doing Italian cuisine a disgrace. read more

Bar Pitti - Penne Strascicate Pappardelle Alla Fiesolana - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Great food, ambience and service. We had Mauricio as our server and he was amazing. Will definitely be coming back when we're in New York. read more

Bar Pitti - Friends and family and Mauricio our server!!! - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Fast service excellent food did not rush us. Cash only. But they have a ATM downstairs Fun casual atmosphere read more

We've been told that this is a great restaurant by more than two people and we're excited to try it out on our Ny trip! It was an early dinner time and we walked in, as soon as we walked in, the spot got packed, so we felt lucky, it was perfect timing! It has European vibes with Italian staff, looks authentic. My friends ordered2 Truffle Linguine and I ordered Pappardelle Alla Fiesolana, fiesolana was great! I love the sauce, everything in it make the pasta tastes beyond! The truffle linguines were missing salt though, so the taste wasn't quite there until you add the salt. The tiramisu was alright, but nothing special. I really love how they change and add daily items on the menu, I think it's innovative and fun! The things we didn't quite like; the service was a bit weird; the 2 Italian servers were fighting over our table while serving food, and the temper wasn't really appealing. He was shaving cheese on my pasta and we got cheese all over the table, including my wine.. I know they're Italian but no one wants to bring it in front of customers.. read more

Bar Pitti - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Seen and be seen. Great food. Don't forget to have cash on hand. Been coming here for over 30 years