This place is doing it right. The ambiance is just what you should expect from a busy Long Island deli. A huge showcase filled with salads, bagels, specialty cream cheeses, pastries, cookies, etc, a small dining area, the exterior walls lined with stocked refrigerators, and of course, a line literally out the door and onto the sidewalk. The lined moved pretty quickly, and it's obvious that these people know what they're doing. I could not even count the amount of staff they had running around in the back, but everyone was moving swiftly, and with a purpose. We ordered 10... yes 10... bacon, egg (over medium, for just the right amount of yolkiness) American cheese, S&P on a poppy seed roll. While I was waiting, I got a chance to chat with the owner, who was running the register. What a great dude! Anyway, the BEC's were fantastic! Just as they should be! They also make the poppy seed rolls in house, as I was informed. Whenever I'm in the area, I will return for the perfect combination of great food and hustle and bustle! read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - BEC - Bagels Near Me - Medford, New York

Used to think this spot was pretty decent, but I've recently moved back to Long Island and got a delivery from them.... Nah, no thanks, ordered a BLT with avocado and onion, got about three pieces of bacon and a few slivers of onion for around $20 or some crazy *ish. trash on a decent roll. Place should burn in heck. read more

See all

I bought cream cheese from here, upon getting home both my husband and I had the same individual experience the cream cheese tasted sour, they had the wrong packaging date on it so that leads me to believe they didn't even realize it was.. that's not the point, upon letting them know they accused us of lying that it was rotten. Then the short older Caucasian bald gentlemen with a nub on the index finger proceeded to make a very inappropriate comment that we had put coke in the cc ? It was very insulting and a micro aggression considering my husband is a person of color. Needless to say I think we minorities need to be especially careful in what businesses we choose to patronize, not ones in which have a racial bias with no basis nor treat their customers with respect or dignity ! Will never come here again and let others know what a horrible business this is. Oh and p.s my cousin said she's seen roaches in here ( trust me no reason to lie as I gain nothing from it ) so buyer beware. They need the FDA called on them. Yuck ! read more

This bagel store beats most of the others around. Their prices are competitive and the food is worth every penny. They give u what u ask for and ur order is always accurate. Amazing amount of choices as well. Such a great variety. No other bagel store compares. read more

i have been going here for a decade, but this just made me mad! I ordered 1 (BEC) Bacon Egg & Cheese on a roll $8.45 pls tx, 1 Bacon and egg on a roll $8.45 pls tx, 1 Turkey Club @ $10.99 , 1 bottle of coke $3.25 (12-16oz not sure) and 2 bags of chips @ $2.69. @$46.13!!! now i got charged $1.30 for the cheese on 1st egg sandwich ok fine....i got charged$10.99 for the turkey club but then they charged me for the cheese the lettuce the tomato and the bacon on my turkey club??? What the heckkk....I reached out to the owner and after TALKING OVER ME and being combative and he even hung up on me said"" i owe you $1.55, i charged you for tomatoes when they came with the sandwich" funny part is if you owe me $1.55 what charge was that? cause the cheese was $1.30 and the lettuce and tomato was $1.99 and the bacon was $2.35? so where does $1.55 even equate from? Secondly you just charged me $10.99+1.30+1.99+2.35 for a Turkey Club on a ROLL!!!! bad service can be fixed and so can mistakes but trying to justify an almost 20 dollar turkey club is just next level disrespect and robbery!!!! read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - the proof - Bagels Near Me - Medford, New York

They forgot something in my Uber Eats order, I couldn't get ahold of Uber Eats so I called the restaurant and whoever I talk to on the phone was beyond accommodating and professional! read more

Food was great, an amazing selection & fresh. The staff were very attentive and helpful and also very pleasant! As far as ambiance, it's a bagel cafe, so clean, comfortable and well organized. read more

Don't order on uber eats from here, spent 22$ for a wrap. Had to pay extra for "3" egg whites extra for turkey and waited an hour for this to show up. Kind of insane that you set a base price for an egg sandwich but then have to pay extra to put anything in it. Wouldn't mind paying the extra if you actually filled the wrap. Instead I ate a stale tortilla. I'm hungover at work and just wanted a sandwich. Do better read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Medford, New York

If I could give this place no stars I would....when good bagel stores are everywhere why settle for this place Sunday I called in an order waited on line to pick it up watched staff sneez in their hand....hang out talk ok ....its my turn the girl tells me next time I dont need to wait on line and my order isnt ready yet to stand to the side...Im waiting and 2 more times asked my name I tell them and was told my order isn't ready yet now I see people coming and ordering and their food is ready ok. As Im waiting on line I see the cashier get nasty to someone who was paying for a sandwich with a debit card dont you have cash the man's response was no! The owner comes over just as rude. No i go up to the same woman who tells me my order wasn't ready and said can you tell me how much longer its been over 30 min...she asks my name and tells me its not ready yet I said ok can I please cancel my order she gets nasty and asks what number I called to order turns out I was in the wrong bagel place mine was across the street I said I am sorry the cashier instead of saying ok gets nasty and here comes the owner and they are talking about me so now I say to him I guess you are the manger he said no the owner that's how I knew ...I said your cashier was very nasty to myself and others well he starts yelling and cursing and telling me to leave the store mind you I am walking out! Not a place I will ever be caught dead in again as is the bagels aren't good I was there for my job. Went across the street got my bagels wonderful staff over at bagel lovers and good food! read more

One of the more decent bagel spots in the area. This might be an unpopular opinion, but Suffolk County has a tough time when it comes to good bagels. The bagels here are comparable to Nassau and one of two spot we grab bagels from when in the area. This time we were in the need of lunch so we grabbed sandwiches. The Dagwood wad one of the most really well done sandwich that I've had in a while. Think of an American hero, add salami and Swiss cheese and throw it on a hero (I like mine with mayo, lettuce, tomatoes and onions). What really would have knocked this sandwich out of the park is if the bread was a tad better. Ordered with our sandwiches were deli iced teas, and two cookies stuffed with a Reese's Peanut Butter cup (genius). The iced teas were a little too sweet. Sometimes when we come here the service is a little meh. This time, however, I was quickly in and out of there and the guy that help me was actually quite pleasant and made everything really good. I didn't realize that our sandwiches came with a pickle and a side salad but those were packed with our sandwiches which was a nice surprise. Cafe is in the title of the name of this spot, so it's no surprise there is a decent amount of tables for dining in. Not a bad pit stop if needed right of the expressway. read more

I'll keep this one short. My sandwich was fine, but the water quality used for the iced tea had a nasty aftertaste and had to be ditched. read more

Most overpriced deli/ bagel place on Long Island. $13.14 for an egg sandwich on a bagel and they put it on a roll forgot the meat and look at the COMICAL JOKE of a sandwich in the photos.... I've also attached a picture of the price so you know I'm not lying supposed to be two eggs on a sunflower seed bagel with ham and cheese salt pepper, ketchup. Clearly a roll, barely any cheese no ham but at least there's ketchup in the eggs. Don't even fill the roll. Yelp asks "oh no what could improve" literally everything read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

I'm a regular customer. Bagels are of good quality. Food is pretty good. Lots of options. Overpriced. Very long wait times! Older staff has a problem with adjusting their attitude! Need to be more friendly toward their customers! read more

Good food. Very friendly staff. Line goes very quickly. The girl took the time to wrap each bagel individually! Because I told her I was traveling with them. So nice. read more

I got two chicken cutlet sandwiches. It cost almost $30 and it literally came with nothing but chicken cutlet and bread. If I wanted anything more, it would've been $1 extra per add on, per sandwich. So if one sandwich was $13 after tax, then 2 sandwiches for $26 and that is not including anything but bread and chicken that tastes like it was bought at the frozen aisle of a supermarket That means that if I wanted tomatoes, onions, mushrooms and lettuce, that would've been an extra $4 per sandwich So if I wanted 2 sandwiches that were actually delicious, and if I wanted this restaurant to actually bless me, I would've had to have paid $34 for 2 sandwiches. Mind you, these aren't big sandwiches at all. They are on a roll. Honestly, I had to FORCE myself to eat it because I already paid almost $30 for it Worst food I've had in a long time, by far. I could've, and should've, just spend $15 for frozen breaded chicken and bread rolls at the supermarket, and I would've been able to make 4 of these sandwiches , with all the toppings I wanted I can't stress enough how bad this tasted read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Medford, New York

A horrendous experience called the store because when I got my food I looked into my bagel it wasn't toasted or buttered as requested asked for medium runny eggs they weren't runny even a little bit they didn't add salt pepper ketchup I paid 24 dollars for this and on top of that they gave me the wrong Celsius so when I was on the phone this stupid condescending worker or owner named joey lol was telling me well I'll tell uber that you want compensation because ur eggs weren't runny enough lucky I don't pu there some bagel place will never get my money again. read more

Exactly what we were looking for: amazing bagels and wonderful service. I had an everything bagel with cream cheese and cucumbers and my son had a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel. It was delicious. We highly recommend. We ordered a blueberry muffin to go and can't wait to try it!! read more

Wouldn't recommend. This is the 2nd time we've been there. 1st time the food wasn't all that for the price for an egg sandwich. This time around. Waited behind a couple who was having a conversation with the women at the counter for 5 mins. Wasn't asked if we would like to order or told someone will be with us "shortly" when I asked her if they ordered she said yes. I asked if we can order she states she's on the register & just continued on her conversation. It wasn't busy at all. I don't understand why she couldn't write our order down for the cook & ring us up. Walked right out. I'll never go back. read more

Two egg sandwiches two large deli Ice teas, $50 you do the math! WTF . Snappy service which seems to be usual. I think I'm crazy coming back here for a 2nd try. read more

You can't even call in an order, when you do call, it prompts you to a website to place your order when they can pick up the phone and take your order like all normal deli's. Very inconvenient. No one wants to press buttons and give all the personal info just to order a sandwich or bagel. Your ordering a sandwich not a big party order. I mean really... Inconvenient especially when your working. So overpriced and they charge you for everything you put on your sandwich. They are robbing you, better to find another deli that's more personal, more convenient, and more affordable. read more

Absolutely horrible service ! Women was nothing but aggressive, abrasive and rude ... plus the man who took the orders before her was slow rude and dismissive. If you want to be charged 8 dollars more than what the listed menu price is sure go eat there . But if you actually want to enjoy your morning without a bad taste in your mouth literally and metaphorically , SKIPPPP! read more

The Service was nice, but I got two chicken cutlets two small chips and 2 small drinks and the total was almost 40$ I didn't mind I paid and left. WHYY did my sandwich have one piece of lettuce one tomato one slab of cheese and the smallest piece of chicken ever?? Like I understand prices have gone up so food establishments must charge more but if they feel that's necessary then at least make the food quality and worth it also. Most people don't mind paying more if the food is quality and is worth the price. read more

See all

First time here. Fairly crowded. Difficulty trying to read all the menu items posted on the wall. Settled on onion bagel with roast beef. Counterperson asked me if I wanted it toasted which I thought was nice of him. Also got salad. Bagel was delicious. The potato salad suspiciously tasted like outsourced stuff. Had that preservative ingredient taste which automatically drops a review down to three stars. read more

See all

Never here before, saw 2 1/2 stars which made me look elsewhere, but this was the closest....so we went. Good decision! Bagels were good coffee was good, large line (which means a lot of people like this place) and 10 people behind the counter = the line moved quick. Two bagels and two coffees was about $10, very reasonable. Sign said 14 bagel "bakers dozen" for $15. I think 2 1/2 stars is because some New Yorkers are brutally demanding babies. (Smile) read more

I usually get a good breakfast from here. Usually five stars, but the last time I went there I bought two sandwiches on rolls. Both rolls were stale, and the sandwiches weren't assembled correctly. I'll garage my report on the next time I order from here. read more

Our favorite place for deli breakfast and bagels in the area. The breakfast potatoes, bagels and egg sandwiches are so good. All of the fountain drinks and bakery items are awesome too. I also love that when you order on an app they have all of the customization options available. read more

Egg sandwiches are fine but $8 for a bacon and egg on a roll is ridiculous. They must get there from the golden goose. Last time for me as there are so many other options within 2 miles. Greedy people. read more

I am extremely disappointed in this place. They used to be very good but something has happened to the quality. The food I was served this morning was not edible at all. I had to throw it away. It was absolutely disgusting. The bacon was hard as a rock, cold, thick and reminded me of the bacon treats you would feed to a dog. The toast had egg stuck to it and was also disgusting. I also cannot eat eggs. Money right out the window. read more

The worst place I was ever in, I'm in the food business as well. I stood on line for 10 mins counted 8 people back there working, not even an acknowledged person behind the v counter. There all talking to each other slapping each other's asses. Stood there and left. Never will I be back at this place again, really not a way to treat customers, at least say hello, Absolutely absurd...... read more

If I could give them no stars I would, the people at the front (besides Chris and the lady behind register) are nasty people with terrible customer service. This hasn't been the first time I've had bad experience with this place. For starters they never answer the phone, my food was incorrect they wanted to blame it on being busy but there were only about 5 customers inside at the time of placing my order and they can check the camera and see. Not only did they not want to take accountability for THEIR mistake they had the audacity to blame it on me saying I took the wrong order as if the lady didn't hand me my food again watch it on the camera. And the manager Joey is a piece of work. Claims to be "understanding" of the situation but constantly said "most people wouldn't make a big deal over a sandwich." As if my time wasn't wasted either or my gas. I grabbed the sandwich on my way to work. If they picked up the phone the many times I've called it would have saved me the trip from work to get my order fixed. Claimed wanted to "make it right" but spoke to me in a condescending tone, justified his untrained teams nasty remarks to me. I will no longer support this business if this is how they treat their customers who made it possible for them. Disgusting. And to top it all off those people still made my order incorrectly. Unbelievable. read more

Welcome 2 my $9.00 + chicken salad wrap, losely rolled with empty ends. Also my mac salad that is half liquid. read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - a wrap of chicken and lettuce - Bagels Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

Lately they are going downhill, not sure if it's the new people who don't know what they are doing but we went yesterday and asked for two different items, one a bagel with cream cheese and another was a chicken cutlet sandwich, they combined the two and put cream cheese with the cutlets. Today I ordered on Uber eats, asked for no pepper because I'm allergic yet there it was, had to throw out. The second sandwich was Turkey and Swiss, there was no Swiss. I'll be going elsewhere from now on. They used to be a lot better. read more

The last 3 times I've purchased a bagel worh cream cheese I ended up with a virus. The place is not clean. The bagels are amazing. But they need to know that cleanliness is important in the restaurant industry! And it's rude to ask for credit card over the phone. The man at the register is rude. I understand places get busy but if you're rude and the establishment is not clean then customers go elsewhere read more

They lost a customer today. I work in Medford every Thursday and go there religiously for lunch. Food is good but what stands out is the amazing staff. Always courteous, always friendly. The food isn't cheap however. I bought a sandwich and a Kevita kombucha drink today. The drink was $4.99 +tx. Same drink is $3.19 at Target mind you, already marked up for retail. I've had kombucha tea beverages before but this was disgusting. No 'raspberry lemon' was taste able, was like carbonated vinegar so I took it back. Not only was the manager (owner?) aggravated but he also felt the need to keep talking about me as I was leaving the store. Very unprofessional. There's a Chinese, pizza, and Spanish food place in same complex. I'll go to one of them from now on. I will not patronize this business again. read more

what a dump!!!!! the interior of this place never looks clean. old benches. nasty tables. omg sooooo nasty!!! bagels are small. coffee is well....dont even try it!!! this place is garbage and they treat people like we need them. the owner and his adult son could care less about a business being run the right way. people all over the community have nothing good to say about them. everyone uses the bagel store on north ocean ave. much much better. for the owner and son.....i hope you change your attitude. this is not how you treat people paying your bills. how you keep people waiting for their food because some boy/girl who works there is crying because you treat them like garbge is horrible. go to north ocean bagel place and save yourself issues. read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - Store slogan - Bagels Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

Almost 2 years later and absolutely nothing has changed at this place. Thought i would give them a second chance. Called in an order for Western Omelette with cheese extra bacon and sausage. Also a Bacon egg and Swiss cheese sandwich on a toasted Onion roll. Simple huh well that's what i thought. Order picked up paid a ransom of $20.78 cents. Opened up the food and in the bag was a Western Omelette ( no cheese ) 2 slices of bacon and (1) sausage patty. The sandwich consisted of 2 slices of bacon , eggs , (1) slice of Swiss on a old Everything roll. Called up and after telling my story to 4 incompetent people i guess i ended up with the decision maker. I was told that i was given an Everything roll because they didn't have any more onion bagels ( i guees they reserve the right to decide what they want to give me). I was told there standard bacon order is 2 slices ( seriously the entire world know the unwritten rule is 3 slices ) Then i get charged $1.77 3 times so for 2 slices of bacon and a frozen fake sausage patty and the mysteriously missing 2 slices of bacon oh and lets no forget the missing cheese .88 cents. That's a grand total of $6.99 cents. Any way the morale of the story is they agreed to give me the $1.77 for the missing bacon the next time i come in. THE NEXT TIME I COME IN WILL BE NEVER. So i guess i just lost my $1.77. I come from Williamsburg Brooklyn where you could get a real Bagel on either side of the Bridge. Not this watered down faded out imitation Bagel spot. On top of it they have absolutely no customer skills. Zero personality. The bald head guy at the register acts ass if he is doing you a favor. Seriously thinking of filing a complaint with Consumer affairs as well as the Health Department. Note* To the older guy with the Mustache. NO you cannot have gloves on give work the register handle money and then go right back to handling the food. YOU NEED TO CHANGE THE GLOVES IN ORDER FOR THEM TO BE EFFECTIVE. Also how about a hair net your dandruff is out of control. So done with this place. Sorry about the long rant. read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - Maybe if you properly wrote orders people called in you would get them right - Bagels Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

Literally waited 15 min for my order for it to be wrong the coffee tasted horrible.

They're so rude at this spot! Forget how they spoke to me with their sarcastic bs (they tried so hard) but the way they speak to their employees was good enough for me to never ever go back. The food is mediocre. Nothing special. The location is convenient & inside the deli it looked clean. read more

This past Sunday was my first time here, and I went for bagels (my way, right?) on the go. This was a toughie as I'm pretty torn between three and four stars, so 3.5 does the trick pretty well, so consider it boosted due to location. Let me explain. There was a lot to like about Bagels Your Way Cafe. For a storefront in the middle of a strip mall, it has a pretty casually quaint, personality to it. The seating area is a nice touch if you'd like to grab your grub and sit for a bit. I came in to order bagels for myself, my girlfriend, and her sisters. Though once inside, I had that egg-sandwich-itch and after ordering theirs, I went for an everything bagel with bacon and egg. The friendly (and funny) staff member then asked the quintessential LI deli question I love to hear: "Salt, pepper, ketchup?" It just works so well on a sandwich most mornings. A few minutes later, the bagels and my sammy were ready. Once back at my girlfriend's house, I dove into the sandwich, which honestly looked and felt a little small (and didn't entirely match up to price). As a born and raised Long Islander, I was a little surprised at that, but then again it's still about the taste. Though, once I began to sink my teeth into the bagel, egg, and bacon, I found the bagel to definitely taste like a good ol' Long Island bagel, but nothing that stood out to many others I've tried in my lifetime. The egg was decent in taste and bacon sufficient in flavor to create a sandwich that did well in curbing that egg sandwich bug, but fell a little short to LI expectations. Remember though as I mentioned location earlier on as this spot is quite close to my girlfriend's abode, making it a reasonable morning meal in close proximity to her. Overall, though it falls short to many other bagel and breakfast places on the isle via taste, it puts together good ambiance and friendly service. Unfortunately you can't eat those things, but I still may return here for a decent sandwich located not too far from an area I frequent. read more

See all

If I could choose no Star I would would have !!!!Made a big mistake going back to this place. The douchebag who takes your money at the register is the rudest person I have ever dealt at a good establishment. Place wasn't even that busy and I was here to pick up an order I called in and he was just a complete rude ass"@& !!! $45 dollars for 4 sandwiches and a stale bialy that was from yesterday!! Hardly any cream cheese on a bagel that was supposed to have extra cream cheese( I'm sure I was charged for it )and uncooked bacon on every sandwich we bought. Had not gone here in a while and I can say I will never go here again. Terrible service and the food was terrible !!! Bye Bye Bagels your way !! read more

See all