Amazing simple food. Great scones. Don't drive through town without stopping. Open 10-4.read more

4&1/2..Vibes for days...It's hard to imagine one not being smitten by this picture perfect,…read morebeautifully restored vintage turn of the century set-piece worthy little all-day cafe, smack in the middle of what was a strong contender for the most postcard/storybook perfect little upstate town I visited in my recent treks trough the region this past fall. I've heard this little village has had among the most intense glow-ups of the post covid boom in the region and it sure shows. What was once a typically sleepy and stagnant, though still undeniably charming downtown common to the area when I last came through some 20-plus years ago now has all the hallmarks of an upscale, bespoke Brooklyn-north outpost, and this place is a perfect representation, though thankfully one that accentuates a positive example of such development that can serve and be appreciated by both the recent transplants as well as the longtime locals. This is thanks most crucially to the prices remaining happily reasonable and accessible to median income in the area, as opposed to raising prices to typical Brooklyn levels (like at the previously panned Phoenicia Diner). This is likely due to the fact that this place actually was established in the last decade, when, while the Brooklynification of the Catskills was certainly well under way, it had not yet been turbocharged to its insane post Covid levels. Food quality however was uniformly excellent, to the point that it would be a beloved neighborhood asset most any of us would love to have in our own hood. Everything I sampled on my lunch there, selected with the help of the thoughtful suggestions of my excellent server, tasted exceedingly fresh and clean, no doubt owing to the bounty of wonderful local ingredients from which the kitchen procures from. Each dish displayed some delightfully retro 90s era influences from the thick and creamy corn chowder, tasting brilliantly of peak late summer corn, to a bright and briny orzo salad, and the star of the meal, the unctuous, savory, perfectly seasoned umami bomb of a meatloaf pressed panini with the squishy pillowy meatloaf melding topped with gooey smokey provolone contrasted brilliantly with the crusty craggily pressed bread. It was a contender for best thing I had upstate and rivals any burger I had in 2025. Was a deeply satisfying lunch that left be deliciously satiated for my drive out of town through the glorious rolling Catskill Hills dreaming of a future opportunity for another visit.

Cute spot tucked in among the motley assemblage of colorful Woodstock buildings. Def recommend.read more

Service - Simple. You order at the counter and you grab your order. It's as simple as that!…read more Food: BEC w/ EV Seasoning - Uneven. I love the idea of the bagel being stuffed but the distribution of filling is uneven. There were point where all I had were eggs or all I had was bacon bits. It was still delicious to try. Black and White Cookie - Dry. It was a stale cookie. I would pass on this. I would recommend getting these frozen to go to have at home! On to my next adventure...

Awesome plant based vegan friendly place! Staff was helpful for us being first timers here. The…read morefood was fresh and tasty. My husband is vegan so it was nice to have a place where he could have o many options. I ordered the strawberry banana smoothie which was so refreshing. He had the banditto burrito and the jackfruit bbq. He's thoroughly enjoyed both. We'll definitely be back for more!

I highly recommend enjoying a leisurely coffee break or light bite at this refreshingly hip coffee…read morehouse. The owner takes his beans and brews seriously, carefully selecting them for quality and sustainability, and has elevated coffee brewing to an art. There is more than one way to enjoy the roast you choose, and while you wait, you can peruse the bakery case (which includes locally made treats, some of which are vegan and/or gluten-free) or gifts ranging from gourmet foods to clothing. The breakfast/brunch/lunch items make this delightful place a haven for vegetarians and vegans. The offerings are healthy and delicious, and you can get takeout or eat them at an indoor bistro table or a picnic table outside on the well-maintained patio. It is located conveniently off of Route 88 exit 17 if you head north toward Cooperstown.

Amazing sandwiches, excellent coffee, and outstanding service! We stopped by while in town for the…read moreCooperstown tournaments, and it was one of the highlights of our trip. The sandwiches were fresh and delicious, the coffee was fantastic, and the owner was incredibly friendly and welcoming. If you're visiting Cooperstown for the tournaments, I highly recommend stopping by--you won't be disappointed!

Loved it! Went it for breakfast and ordered the Hunter's…read morespecial. Portion and price was well worth it! You order at the front then seat yourself, they bring the food to you. Potatoes were well seasoned, sausage was amazing and bacon was crisp to perfection (we didn't ask.) Loved that the plate included a bagel and drink. Iced coffee was great, didn't need any cream or sugar! Would love to come back. Staff was friendly.

Always great fresh bagels and a generous bakers dozen ! Go to place for bagels all occasions !read more

I pass through Monticello a few times a year and Monticello Bagel has turned into my little road…read moretrip ritual. I pull off, stretch my legs, and you can smell the toasters working the second you open the door. Last time it was a rainy morning and the whole place had that warm bakery air. I ordered an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and a coffee. The bagel came out still warm in a brown paper bag. Good crust, proper chew, not bready. Seeds actually stick instead of shedding all over the car. Small thing, but it matters. The line can look long from the door, but it moves. I was back in my car in maybe ten minutes. Parking is straightforward. If I am trying to make time, the drive through is there and does what it should. The staff is focused and quick. Not chatty in a forced way. Just normal, which I appreciate before caffeine. This is not a fancy place and it does not try to be. No rainbow bagels, no dessert disguised as breakfast. It is a simple bagel shop that knows its lane. Price felt fair. Coffee was hot and not burnt. Cream cheese ratio was right. I am picky about that. Do I wish the menu had a little more going on. Yeah. A couple extra spreads, maybe a rotating special. If you want wild flavors, this is not that stop. But the classics are done properly, and that is why I keep coming back. If you are passing through town and need a quick breakfast that will not let you down, this is an easy yes. Park, grab a bag, get back on the road. Simple, reliable, and it hits the spot..

Has great options and the coffee is amazing!!! Highly…read moresuggest trying the sandwich's and subs The omelets are so delicious. and the seating is just wonderful. They have really fast orders and the staff are so nice.

The menu is surprisingly extensive for what appears to be a very small café. This place does have a…read morelot of charm. The service was excellent. The coffee, however, was a bit disappointing. I tried both the dark roast and the house blend. To my taste, the coffee seemed to be brewed at too high a temperature (above 90°C), which can extract excessive bitterness and astringency.

Fallsburg bagels and bakery is an exceptional bakery with amazing baked goods for all occasions…read more Great hours as well!

Love this place! It is worth braving the busy parking lot, jammed with Shabbat shoppers to get a…read morebagel, challah or other baked goods! Always a kind "Shabbat shalom" from the proprietress to me , a shiksa through and through!

My friend bought the peanut butter delights( I think that's the name) THEY WERE AMAZING!!! they…read morewere the perfect ratio of chocolate cake, chocolate frosting & peanut butter cream of some kind. All I know is that I will be getting this every time I am in the area! There's plenty of parking ... I highly recommend this bakery. .

Driving through Cobleskill, this place immediately caught our eye. Cute, local bakery + (full menu…read morelooked good). Place our order.....relatively simple ..... grilled cheese, drinks, chicken parm sandwhich. Paid. received a locator. WAITED WAITED WAITED for a FULL HOUR (12:18 pm until 1:30pm). NO service, NO inquiry, NO service check ..........FINALLY inquired. NO order was ever entered. Interior was very interesting & reflective of college town. Would have been neat experience. :( :( :( :( refunded full amount. Just overly disappointed.

Great service and high quality breakfast! Always a pleasure to show up! A positive attitude is…read morealways shown by everyone inside.

It's been closed for months. Currently the window windows have paper over them, saying it will open…read moreas the Pony. Haven't seen any updates for a while, but this town could use a diner.

Let me preface by saying that we did not get to the bakery until late morning, so the remaining…read moreitems to choose from were not as fresh as I can only assume would have been first thing in the morning. That said, it was slim pickings and items we did get were good. The remaining items were very well decorated and appealing to the eye. My suggestion would be get there early for fresh baked goods.

Reply to Emily Having been in this bakery many times over…read morethe last SEVERAL DECADES, and family that has been their even MORE OFTEN we have AKWAYS FOUND 1-Products fresh snd delicious 2-Help friendly, professional and helpful That is why EVERY FAMILY MEMBER LOVES TO GO THEIR We do not return to any sub standard place snd will be back to Schneider's Bakery I seriously question your motives for writing what you did,, I have NEVER heard any other local people give them anything but praise. Carl L