Amazing sandwiches, excellent coffee, and outstanding service! We stopped by while in town for the Cooperstown tournaments, and it was one of the highlights of our trip. The sandwiches were fresh and delicious, the coffee was fantastic, and the owner was incredibly friendly and welcoming. If you're visiting Cooperstown for the tournaments, I highly recommend stopping by--you won't be disappointed! read more

Loved it! Went it for breakfast and ordered the Hunter's special. Portion and price was well worth it! You order at the front then seat yourself, they bring the food to you. Potatoes were well seasoned, sausage was amazing and bacon was crisp to perfection (we didn't ask.) Loved that the plate included a bagel and drink. Iced coffee was great, didn't need any cream or sugar! Would love to come back. Staff was friendly. read more

Oneonta Bagel Co - Breakfast plate with 2 meat options of choice. (Bacon&Sausage) - Bagels Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Staff was very accommodating and went above and beyond to provide great service. Smoothie was delicious.

Order a simple bagel with cream cheese and coffee if you can deliver that simple flavor you need to check your quality of ingredients the bagel was chewy not what is expected out of a "bagel company" the name is BAGEL! Coffee came in with cheap creamers and sugar on the side the creamers were curled as soon as put on the coffee for $4 a pop the least you can do is make the coffee in premises and not use regular scotch tape to seal the cup ewww unsanitary, there is something about small business from the good old block that just simply can't find in this staple of the main on Oneonta ....sad and hungry I will try the next coffee place for my breakfast cause this $12 went to the garbage... try again whoever reopen this place you need to pay attention to the main item in your menu, cause if you can find a good bagel in a bagel company then where? I could just go down to the store and buy a whole pack of mediocre bagel for the price you charge for yours... never again. Service its rush and place its average if any... maybe a good glass of water will be the choice... read more

Oneonta Bagel Co - Cheap coffee over price and an old chewy bagel... disappointing! - Bagels Near Me - Oneonta, New York

I came to oneonta for Cooperstown all star village tournament. This bagel place was great! I come from southern California and the texture and flavor of these bagels was superb. I recommend blueberry bagel with cream cheese. Coffee is good too. Friendly owner. Nice inside too. read more

Just as bad as the bagels in the grocery store. So still have to travel at least 3 1/2 hours for a good bagel. doesn't even deserve one star. read more

A sub-par bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich. Relatively cheap and the staff is nice. Service is slow, seems like there could be a more efficient way... then again I compare every shop to Bruegger's. I guess the Long Islanders can claim the bagels because upstate definitely lacks in this area. read more

The oneonta bagel company is really affordable good food and quick service! They have at least 7 different brews of coffee all fresh brewed. Love there egg and cheese bagels and french toast. They also have really good lunch sandwiches and wraps! Although my favorite is there egg and cheese bagels. There are no waitress or waiters it is quick service. So of course it is no frills. The employess are always very nice and willing to help you in any way. They also almost always have really good cheap specials. So if you are ever in Ononta, NY. Stop by the Oneonta Bagel Co. Close to NYC bagels but half the cost. I see no draw backs! Actually headed to grab an egg and cheese on everything before I leave for the airport and head out. So I can get a dose of the salty crispy savory yummyness!! read more

Oneonta Bagel Co - Turkey spinach wrap!! - Bagels Near Me - Oneonta, New York

This was always my go-to bagel place in oneonta. The bagels are fresh but also cheap.$2.00 for a perfectly toasted everything bagel with regular cream cheese. I would always go here instead of getting Panera bagels cause I felt like the bagels here are softer and tastier! Location is also more convenient Very friendly staff. The cashier works quickly. The place has weird art pieces hanging on the wall by local artists that I think you can purchase if you're into it. The only complaint that I have is that I sat by the the window display one day and it seemed to be untouched for a while because it had a bunch of flies flying around the potato sack. It was pretty gross... read more

Good food and good specials bring me back to the Bagel Company a few times a semester when I have free time in the morning. The hash and eggs are particularly good, but everything is decent traditional breakfast fare. For somewhere called the Bagel Company, though, I would expect them to focus more on their bagels and less on breakfast specials. The one complaint I have about this place is the fact that it's closed on Sundays. Forces me to go to someplace else where the line is out the door and all I can get is an egg sandwich. read more

First off, let me say I'm from New York City, and my dad owned a bagel shop when I was little. I know a thing or two about bagels. The bagels here are very ok. They aren't made in house and are merely frozen bake-offs. This isn't the end of the world, considering really good bagels are becoming harder and harder to find even in NYC these days. What really kills me about this place is the service. Between the crappy attitudes (save a few employees), and the consistently inconsistent wait times and order accuracy, I really don't know why I keep going back.... If you have some time and don't mind having to send your order back a few times, give it a try. They have a pretty good coffee selection and fresh squeezed OJ. read more

Pretty respectable bagels and spreads. They'll make any kind of bagel combination sandwich you want and the price is right. Good spot for breakfast too. read more

Decent (for not NYC) bagels... Check. Free wifi... Check. That's really all there is to it... with no additional frills. I drove up from my no-internet-havin' Catskills cabin to get some work done and it did the job. read more

1) great food. Very tasty and cheap. 2) the place is fun looking but it could be cleaned up from the outside. 3) the flavors are creative but both the bagels and cream cheeses arent string in whatever flavor you choose. 4) get a SEC on an asiago bagel. read more

This is one of my favorite places to go for breakfast! The food and breakfast sandwiches are really food and are made to order just the way you want. They also have a variety of coffee to choose from which is a plus! read more

We use to love coming in here all the time for the quality bagels. We would go while we went to school at SUCO for a great sandwich in the morning. The past year has been an absolute headache and disappointment. Every time we order, something is wrong. Cheese is burnt on the sandwich, they don't put cheese or bacon on a bacon/egg/cheese sandwich, and that's only some of the issues we came across. We still wanted to go though cause we knew like every once in a while they did make a great egg sandwich. Recently I went to pick up my usual order of 2 bacon/egg/and cheese sandwich. 1)was charged for an egg because apparently now they only do one egg in the sandwich 2)took it to go and found out they put no bacon in it 3) had to come back 3 days later because they were closed all weekend with the egg sandwiches to get a refund. When my fiancé went to return the bagels with receipt they tried to only give him money back for the bacon even though we brought the sandwiches back "apparently at first he didn't realize we had the sandwiches there" but was fighting with my fiancé even though we were already told we could get the refund. Save yourself the trouble. Not what it use to be. read more

Yep, its good and cheap. 8 bucks for 2 bagels cream cheese and 2 jumbo java + refills. Best bagel I have had, but I understnad NY bagels are the best. read more

Great Bagels. Cashier, very pleasant. They just open back up after a vacation, and were not fully stocked with all things on the menu. But give them a try. read more

This place sucks! I'm from Rochester and Rochester doesn't have great bagels, but at least I can eat it. Boy would I love a NYC bagel now. These bagels seem like they were store bought. I'm like 99% positive they got them from the Tops. They didn't even taste that good. Will not be back as the place is also dirty. read more

Doesn't look like much as you approach and enter, but one should never judge a book by its cover. The girl working the register was friendly and welcoming - extremely pleasant and efficient. There is such a range of bagels, spreads, and cream cheeses I guarantee there is a combo for everyone. I was pleased with my French toast bagel - not overly sweet, the maple cream cheese was a good accompaniment- though it does have nuts in it which wasn't clear from signage - so allergy alert there. The iced coffee was good as well. read more

Friendly staff but bagels aren't fresh & not very clean, other great options in the area.

I went in on a slow weekday morning and left with one of the best breakfast sandwiches I've ever tried. I know I might sound like I am exaggerating, but after having hundreds in my lifetime this one really stood out. The quality of the ingredients and care that went into making it could really be tasted. Friendly cashier, wide drink selection, and lots of room to sit down if dining in. I will definitely be back next time I am in town. read more

Excellent breakfast place (huge variety of bagels & cream cheeses, plus breakfast sandwiches), wide range of fair trade organic coffee & composting to-go cups, plastic ware & to-go boxes. Best part is that they're a transitional workplace, they help people in the community learn the skills they need to find permanent jobs, nice to see a place that cares about their staff & community. read more

Walked in for a bagel with my family today at around 10 o'clock this morning. We walked to the counter and the staff member working there didn't even look up to greet us or ask us to wait a moment while she finished what she was doing. Incompetence is every companies downfall. We walked out extremely disappointed. Staff should be attentive and friendly, but she looked like she just woke up read more

Great bagels, great cream cheese and friendly staff. The only problem is that they advertise their fresh squeezed orange juice and they haven't had it in a year. It is written on a chalk board, if you're not going to make it erase it. read more

Best bagel in the area but no Long Island bagel and that's okay because the freshly squeezed orange juice is AMAZING and consistently amazing every time. Staff is friendly, wait is never too long, and the outside seating is great in the spring time. read more

service is garbage, food is not bad. Not NY bagels but closest you're gonna get, SERVICE IS HORRIBLE. Their system is horrible, had to go back due to order mistakes numerous times. Theyre toaster is too high and they burn the bagels, plus they dont even spread the cream cheese. their mondo breakfast special is good though, decent place that could be so much better. read more

My husband and I loved the bagel sandwiches here! Best bagel sandwiches we have had since living in NYC!! Must stop next time you are visiting Cooperstown. read more

my only complaint is that there not opened longer they have great food friendly staff and best coffee in town