Cancel

Open app

Search

Bagel Pantry

4.0 (11 reviews)
Open • 5:00 am - 3:00 pm

Order Bagel Pantry Takeout or Delivery

Bagel Pantry Photos

You might also consider

More like Bagel Pantry

Recommended Reviews - Bagel Pantry

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Z T.
0
79
0

3 years ago

Delicious bagels. Friendly hospitality. Clean with lots of parking. Highly recommend

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jon D.
53
3
0

4 years ago

I had just a cinnamon bagel with cream cheese. Reminded me how much pleasure a great bagel brings. Makes life worth living!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Super quick, friendly service. Very reasonably priced, and delicious! My new go to bagel place.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Bagel Pantry

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bagels 5,012 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Order - The dumbledore

The Order

4.6(182 reviews)
3.6 mi
•$$

Met up with my college roomie at The Order and it was lovely!! The food was AMAZING!! I ordered the…read moreDumbledore while my roomie ordered the Harry in a pressed wrap. The food is plentiful. The server was super kind. The owner was very friendly and speaking with guests. This is such a cute little cafe with about 10 tables. They sell clothing from local vendors which was pretty cool. Theres ample parking in the area. There was no wait. The food came out in a timely manner. Food is plentiful.

I've been meaning to check out The Order in South Orange after seeing the long lines for brunch in…read morethe past. Unfortunately, my visit left me with mixed feelings. The entrance was confusing--it feels like you're walking into a clothing store, with a kitchen right next to it. Personally, I'd hesitate to buy clothes so close to cooking smells and fumes. The setup felt odd to me. Our server, Kayden, was a gem: attentive, polite, and welcoming. They were definitely the highlight of our visit. We started with the onion ring chutney, which I'd rate 2 out of 5. The onions were fried so hard that they were difficult to enjoy, but we were hungry and don't like wasting food. The tandoori chicken was underwhelming. The Foreigner burger had good flavor and was very juicy, but the fries were also overly fried and hard. I didn't understand the approach to fried hard. The Pom Pom juice tasted good, but it had too much ice and felt overpriced for what we received. I'm glad I finally tried it, and I appreciated Kayden's service, but the food and overall value left me unsure whether I'd return.

Photos
The Order - New Menu

New Menu

The Order - The Royal. Very savory good!

The Royal. Very savory good!

The Order - Dinning Room

See all

Dinning Room

Liv Breads Artisan Bakery and Coffee Bar - Blueberry Financier - unfortunately not a fan

Liv Breads Artisan Bakery and Coffee Bar

4.5(307 reviews)
0.8 mi
•$$

I had been wanting to try Liv Breads for so long, especially after all of the amazing reviews I had…read moreread and the positive feedback I had heard from family. I finally made it there the other day and was shocked at how substantial the place was. It was no small bakery, but was a full cafe and gourmet shop as well. Though I did not try their savory sandwiches, breads, salads, or spreads at that time, I did purchase some of their sweets. First, the Chocolate Rugelach were some of the best I have had. The delicate, flaky cookies were like little croissants and were ribboned with a rich chocolate spread. Their version also had hints of vanilla, which I really enjoyed. I also got one of their large Chocolate Chip Cookies, which was thin, but packed with gooey bittersweet and semi-sweet chocolate. It also had a light sprinkling of Maldon sea salt on the top. It was super decadent! Liv Breads exceeded my expectations, and I look forward to revisiting to try many more of their items.

I have never written a negative review before, which probably says something about how upsetting…read morethis experience was for me. My family and I have been regular customers at Liv Breads in Millburn for the past five or six years. I come here almost every day, often morning and evening, for coffee and breakfast, and my husband gets his coffee here literally every single day. We have always enjoyed the food and coffee and have spent a considerable amount of money supporting this bakery over the years. Even a regular black coffee here costs around $5 plus and when you are buying coffee and breakfast this frequently for years, you are clearly a loyal, paying customer. But what happened today genuinely hurt me. After finishing my coffee, I asked for the usual refill. The person serving me insisted that I bring back my used coffee cup before she would give me the refill. She then specifically told me that "a lot of people like you" have been asking for refills, and therefore she needed to see my cup before giving me one. If there is a new policy requiring customers to show their original cup, I have absolutely no problem with the policy. What upset me was the way it was communicated, particularly the phrase "people like you." As a brown-skinned Indian woman, I could not help but wonder what exactly "people like you" meant and whether I would have been spoken to the same way if I looked different. I am not claiming to know what was in anyone's mind, but I can say how the interaction made me feel: singled out, embarrassed and unwelcome. I have lived in the U.S. for years and cannot remember another interaction that made me feel this way. What makes it especially disappointing is that this wasn't an interaction between a business and someone who walked in for the first time. They know us. We have been coming here almost daily for years. Customer loyalty should mean something--not free coffee and not an exemption from reasonable policies, but simply being treated with familiarity, dignity and respect. The food and coffee have always been good, and that is exactly why we kept coming back for so many years. Unfortunately, after today's interaction, I walked away feeling deeply uncomfortable and no longer welcome. After five or six years of supporting this bakery, it genuinely makes me sad to say that I don't plan to return.

Photos
Liv Breads Artisan Bakery and Coffee Bar - Outside

Outside

Liv Breads Artisan Bakery and Coffee Bar
Liv Breads Artisan Bakery and Coffee Bar - Pardon my lipstick

See all

Pardon my lipstick

Summit Diner - Taylor, egg and cheese

Summit Diner

4.0(308 reviews)
1.9 mi
•$

I'm already a generation behind America's true greatness. But one day, when my children and I sit…read morein the devastation of the whole world, after the wars, they'll ask me--"Dad, was America a good place?" And I'll tell them it wasn't but-- But once, there was the Diner, and it was a small room giving off warm light and smells of satisfaction. And anyone could come, and everyone would be welcome, and you'd sit in the chairs (which were just comfortable enough to keep you there for lunch), and get an earful of everybody else's business, and smile at the waitress, and complain to the waitstaff about what fools everybody's becoming, and gulp down two and a half cups of piping hot coffee from a piping hot mug, and eat a bowl of soup and half of an egg salad sandwich, and finish it off with a slice of pie, and in these small, often dirty, slices of time and place-- just for a little while-- America truly was good. It was great, even.

I've known about some at diner for the longest time, but finally had the chance to swing by for…read morebrunch! The diner is inside a classic boxcar and not much has changed since opening - which is the way it should stay. The service was great and everyone was friendly and accommodating. We arrived around 12 PM on a Sunday and waited about 10 minutes for a table. They don't have high pairs but they have booster seats that worked just as well. We ordered Taylor, ham, egg, and cheese on a roll, two pancakes with scrambled eggs, and the front toast plate that came with eggs and sausage. Taylor ham, egg and cheese on a roll was standard and good. The French toast was tasty. The pancakes were very, very good. Definitely order these! The diner is no-frills. It's classic food served the original way. It really feels like an authentic New Jersey establishment and I love that it hasn't changed.

Photos
Summit Diner - Inside

Inside

Summit Diner - Grilled chicken with added cheese and onions

Grilled chicken with added cheese and onions

Summit Diner - Outside

See all

Outside

The Committed Pig - Mr. Beautiful

The Committed Pig

3.8(515 reviews)
1.9 mi
•$$

It looks like a nice brunch spot inside. Foods were very breakfast focused, and they serve…read morebreakfast all day. - Chicken Milanese, (4/5): salad was acidic and refreshing, especially with the cherry tomatoes. they gave plenty of nicely fried chicken - the other thing was it was on the drier side. They did give 3 flattened chunks of chicken, and it was filling - Crispy Eggplant: friend got this dish and she was perfectly pleased by the tiny pasta. A good veggie option! Just a heads up, I was charged extra for my chicken Milanese on accident, so double check your receipt!

It had been a while since I last ate here and when I say a while, it was like 8 or 9 years. During…read morebreakfast yesterday I was reminded why. To their credit the food is quite good and the service is attentive and friendly without being overbearing. So why the 3 Stars? Simple. There are no healthy options on the breakfast menu. Sure there are things that can be construed as healthy like egg white omelets, etc but there's no oatmeal, no overnight oats, no yogurt, no granola... Well, I think you see the point. To 90% of the egg, potato, pancake eating public this probably isn't an issue but to me it is. Ordered lemon ricotta pancakes which were quite good with a massive portion sure to delight most people but again, no short stack options and I barely made it through 1/2 of it. All in all, if the aforementioned issues are unimportant to you, I'd give them a try. If, on the other hand, you're like me, I'd look elsewhere to start my day.

Photos
The Committed Pig - Inside

Inside

The Committed Pig - Cheeseburger & chipotle burger

Cheeseburger & chipotle burger

The Committed Pig

See all

Bagel Pantry - bagels - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...