the food was amazing, they have the greatest service! the place was clean Just a perfect place to have a coffee and Beacon egg and cheese sandwich I'll definitely be back there! read more

We were in town for a lacrosse tournament and I had a request from my boss, bages from Long Island. He grew up on the island and said there is nothing like those bagels. I searched and Bagel Boss came highly recommended. We walked in and were immensely greeted by staff behind the counter. I witnessed the amazing offering of cream cheese flavors and wanted to sit and try to them all. I ordered myself one to go along with the bag of bagels for my boss in Ohio. The employees were so friendly and helpful with my order. Oh and that homemade cookie was AMAZING! We will be back next summer for sure! read more

Got taken over by"by bew management" worse than before. The people have no idea what theyre doing. You guys dont even have the air conditioning on when its 90 out. Horrible i hope it gets replaced by something better. read more

A mini bagel boss in planned community just northwest of the LIE at exit 68. Super easy to pull off and drive right into the community - pull around the traffic circle to the front of a few cafes. We split an everything flagel. Noticed rows of thin trays of what loomed like fresh salads. It looks like they keep smaller quantities there but keep them up and fresh which is nice to see. Would recommend for a light bite. read more

Bagel Boss - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Yaphank, New York

Let me just list all the problems with this place: 1. Everyone is extremely rude every time 2. Not ONCE have they actually gotten our order right 3. Don't bother ordering one of their specialty sandwiches because they don't actually know what's on it. 4. Ingredients listed in said sandwiches they don't actually carry The only reason Iv been back multiple times it's just convenience read more

Bagel Boss - This should have ham bacon and cheese on it. None of which are there .. again . - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Yaphank, New York

Bagel Boss is always solid! The staff is quick, the place runs smoothly even during the morning rush and everyone behind the counter actually seems to care about getting your order right, which I appreciate. The place is clean, the line moves quickly, and the food is consistently fresh! It's honestly just good breakfast every time. Lately, been ordering their chorizo burrito and it is phenomenal! The chorizo has that perfect spicy, smoky flavor and the eggs are always great. It's one of those things you try once and then keep coming back for. If you're looking for a reliable breakfast spot with something a little different than the usual bagel and cream cheese routine definitely give the chorizo burrito a shot! read more

Bagel Boss - Chorizo Breakfast Burrito - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Yaphank, New York

Bagels are good. Lots of cream cheese options. The line wasn't too bad. The tip suggestions seem a little much for simple orders. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ read more

Bagel Boss - Tip prompts. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Yaphank, New York

See all

For what can be improved is the cost and service. For one, the people behind the counter are not friendly... the Girl had such an attitude. Now here is why I'm rating them low.. it Cost me over $40.00 for a Dozen Bagels, and for a Buttered Roll it was over $4.00. Mind you they're Bagels and Roll isn't anything Special or better than any other Bagel place. read more

Stopped in to grab sandwiches, coffees and bagels to go. The new manager was fabulous. He was kind, quick, and went the extra mile to provide great customer service. Thank you! read more

absolutely terrible service every single time I get a egg sandwich something is wrong or it does not mean correctly and it happens every single time without failure the store needs people who know how to really work in a deli properly... read more

I've tried this place 3 times. Each has been a disaster. Time 1: The employee at the counter didn't know what roast beef was. Time 2: I saw that it was under new management (less than a year after they opened), so I gave it another go. Only two employees working. The same customer was still at the counter after about ten minutes and there were more customers waiting. I left without ordering. Time 3: Unfortunately someone bought me a gift card, so I went again.. I grabbed a WARM 20oz Gatorade from the fridge and placed my order. None of the employees knew how to scan THEIR OWN GIFT CARD. I ended up having to pay with my credit card because nobody could figure it out. I didn't realize until I left that I was charged almost $5 for the Gatorade... I could have stopped at 7/11 and paid half. I'll never be back. read more

Short wait time, location was clean and well lit. Order a poppy seed bagel with strawberry cream cheese. The bagel was fresh and the strawberry cream cheese was tasty too. The service was good. read more

First time trying this place with my sister and the breakfast was absolutely delicious! The place looks unassuming but the quality is good. It's a nice spot to sit inside roo and take on the scenery. I will definitely return! read more

Bagel Boss - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Yaphank, New York

Although the girl at the register was friendly and the wait time was short, the order was incorrect. Instead of giving us what we asked for, they gave us a cheaper item and charged us for the more expensive one. The people packing the orders seem to be careless. As we were taking the order to go, we didn't know there was an issue until we made it to our destination. read more

The local is clean and inviting. There are a few of indoor and outdoor tables. The chicken cutlet sandwich I ordered was excellent! The decaf coffee was equally as delicious. My wife's bagel was also very good. Takeaways: 1. Excellent menu choice to price ratio. 2. Very good coffee. 3. Bagels are fresh and savory. 4. Service is great and done with a smile. 5. Yes, there are gender neutral restrooms. 6. Ample parking Final thoughts... If I lived in the area this would be my go to bagel store! read more

They need to take classes in customer service. I've been to this location a few times and have really tried to give them the benefit of the doubt. They never understand what you're asking for, orders are consistently wrong or partially missing. Over priced, terribly cooked. Just over all they should've put a regular deli here instead of this place. Hopefully they loose more business and get out of this community. read more

Tasted like Costco bagels not New York bagels. Sad disappointment, as I was flying in from California. I could get better bagels in California. read more

My bagel was a little burnt - but the people working there were great. I had a complicated latte order and they really put effort and care into making sure that they got it right and that I enjoyed it. read more

Trying to order a simple breakfast sandwich to 2 people who don't understand English is crazy. Never again.

Owner is friendly and accommodating. Better faster service this time around. Especially when you're trying to get to work quickly!

Everytime I have an order there's always a chance that I get the wrong item or that it's missing something which I requested & paid for. Overall the employees are very nice but more training seems to be needed. Listen to your reviews instead of asking others to fake good ones sonny. read more

Terrible food. Their bagels legit taste like it was brought in from Kansas or something. Doesn't taste like an authentic NY bagel at all. The service is even worse, their employees have horrible customer service. I'd rather take the extra 2 minute drive to the other bagel spot in the royal shopping center for real food. read more

The bagels are very expensive. I went once and I bought two bagels and two batteries and they charge me over nine dollars any place else you go it's it's about four dollars read more

This place has a ways to go before I'd consider the service and food even tolerable. I ordered a toasted bagel with light cream cheese and it took them 3 times to get it right. The first time they gave me a raw bagel, second time they gave it to me with butter, and the third time it wasn't toasted and came with a massive chunk of cream cheese. The staff is clueless and if you don't repeat your own order back a few times you WILL get the wrong thing. Do yourself a favor and go elsewhere. read more

Bagel Boss - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Yaphank, New York

See all

Chicken Salad is the best! Sammy is a great entrepreneur Great place for breakfast or lunch read more

Service and quality has dramatically improved, I come here often and I'm a huge fan now. Fruit is always fresh, sandwiches are always hot. Def recommend read more

I will start off by saying we have never had a problem with the taste of the food. We have been here a few times and when they get our order right it's good. The issue is the young girl behind the counter with a horrible attitude. It has been this way for months but today she decided to argue with us when she got our order wrong. Another girl did step in and correct our order for us but we will never be back again. read more

I have had not one good experience here. I am not sure why I keep going back. Between the constant mess up of orders, losing my order, the terrible service and the stale bagels. This place needs to get it together. read more

Have been going to bagel boss in merrick and plainview for 30 years . Not sure how bagel boss allowed this establishment to use the same name . . . Bagels were not fresh . Went 10am sunday morning and i asked to get whitefish salad and the girl had to ask 3 people and finally said we dont have that . Never thought i could give a bagel boss a bad review . Definetly woipdnt ho back read more

I got egg everything ba with chicken salad.bagel is not bagel.this is roll.like bread.chicken salad is no good

I have been going to Bagel Boy since I'm a kid in Merrick. Always the best! They opened in Yaphank and I could not wait to try them! This was the biggest disappointment ever. Wasted $34 on one dozen bagels, one egg sandwich and two chocolate milks. It seemed like the bagels were brought there, not made there. I will keep on going to my normal spot which is Best Bagels on route 101 Sills Rd. in the IHOP shopping center. No more Bagel boss for me. they made a big mistake cheaping out, and the Spanish staff has a language barrier. read more

Horrible customer service. Food made wrong, argumentative. Stay away from this terrible establishment

Excellent bagels and service. The bagels were fresh and seeded on both sides. Glad Bagel Boss opened close by

Every single time I go to this place the order is wrong. Whether you order in store or today after ordering online the order is still wrong. I can't even comprehend how awful this Bagel Boss location is and how it is ever going to stay in business. 3 separate times I have given them another chance and I will not make that mistake again. read more