This place is awesome. Haven't been disappointed once with all the different subs they have. Staff is friendly as well

My husband and I have ordered from here twice so far. The first time, I had the blue balls, which was fantastic. The meatballs are seasoned well and the sandwich was delicious. Recently I wasn't feeling well and wanted something comforting so I tried the meatballs in tomato soup in a bread bowl. It was packed with meatballs and the soup was good, and the entire thing was covered in melted cheese. I wanted to hop inside the bread bowl! I can't wait to order that on a cold winter day. The food is well prepared and well priced, and of course, delicious. Just make sure to order enough in advance since it takes a little while to cook and prepare the orders. read more

B-Balls Meatballs - Meatballs in a bread bowl, my favorite. - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

I just moved in the area. Saw the reviews and thought I would give it a try. I placed my order from app and picked it up. This place is basically a house with a restaurant inside. Small, but quaint. I ordered the disco balls, and chicken Parm hero. The combination of mozzarella cheese, onion, brown gravy, and the meatballs on the disco balls was incredible. The meatballs are very flavorful. The brown gravy excellent. The sub can feed two. The chicken Parm was also excellent. I will definitely order again. read more

This is a hidden gem. The sandwiches are great and big portions. The pizza is also good and they also sell delicious ices. The prices are good too. read more

We found this awesome place from Yelp! We absolutely love the names for the food on the menu :) This is a very friendly and super clean place to eat the food is mouth watering. I wanted to try everything on the menu!! Everyone was very happy with what they ordered and not a single bite was left ... And no one shared a bite either!! It was that good!! Definitely Will be back!! read more

See all

Excellent Neighborhood pizzeria ! The pizza reminds me of how it was made growing up, nothing fancy just a straight forward great tasting pizza. Try the selection of meatballs in a bread bowl or hero, they are awesome also. Nice ppl too. read more

I feel like this was a hidden secret while I was a Ramapo College student. I always loved grabbing a sub here when I was in the mood for meatballs. The concept and variety of Meatball Subs alone are worth the hike from campus. Why should I even say it's a hike, it's a block away from Bagel Train and we all know that's the bagel spot for the college lol. Check this place out for lunch!!! read more

I am a frequent customer at B-Balls. The staff at B-Balls are very friendly and attentive to all of my questions and quirky needs. In addition the food is excellent. I will continue to be a customer for a very long time! read more

The place is located in the middle of a residential neighborhood, It used to be our corner deli/penny candy store (McClintocks), The pizza is very good, the meatballs are excellent, but I absolutely love their Stromboli! I always order extra, because it is just as good at room temperature. For meatballs fans, they have very unique meatball hero combinations. Very imaginative! read more

i never thought i'd be so in love with a pair of shweaty balls. if u don't know what i mean, look at their menu. very creative and filling meals for great prices in the area. perfect for any time of the day read more

Excellent meatball sandwiches and pizza too! Great menu option and creative choices. Highly recommended A+++++++

Traditional Italian eatery tucked away in a cute neighborhood. Pizza that definitely has the flavor & "droop" that you expect from NY Pizza. Also has a very large selection of types of meatball sandwiches. So glad I stopped in for a quick bite. read more

B-Balls Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

It's always great ordering a lunch time Alfredo Sandwich from this shop. I prefer dining in quickly so that way the bread stays crunchy and toasted while i enjoy my meal. Pair the sandwich with some chips and a Joes Ice Tea and you have yourself the reason why this place earns 5 stars. They not only have subs, but also pizzas and other items as well so be sure to check the entire menu! read more

Love this place. Random location in the middle of a residential neighborhood, but really yummy goodies. Their subs are not for the weak - these bad boys hit you hard. With that said, they are delicious. My favorite is the Alfredo which is just so decadent , but that's just how I does it. My girlfriend usually gets the bocci balls and has a fit (in a good way) every time. May not be gourmet, doesn't offer anything as far as an actual location - this place simply has some really tasty, stick to your ribs sandwiches read more

Really great food here! We came in yesterday and ordered one deli sandwich, and three meatball subs. We all loved the sandwiches. I got the Alfredo meatball sub in garlic bread and it was so good. So glad I looked places up around suffern and settled on coming here. The only thing I would suggest is calling ahead of time and ordering if you need to get in and out quickly. We did not and had to wait about 10-15 minutes for the meatball subs to be done. We didn't mind though, because we figure that must mean they're all made fresh! Just something to note if you can't wait around that long. Overall, a must try. Everything was great. read more

Ordered from B-Balls today for the first time. So glad I did! My coworker had the Shweaty Balls (lol) and I had a chicken parm hero. My coworker said it was delicious and she is usually very picky. Chicken parm was also really tasty. Both subs were about 8 inches so they were great portions. We couldn't finish them. We ordered around 11 for delivery at 12. They don't start delivering until 12 so if you want to order before then, you should call. They delivered right at 12 and the food was still very hot. Subs don't come with any chips or anything like that so if you want anything additional be sure to ask for it. With delivery, two subs came out to $20 plus tip so prices are pretty decent considering the quality of food. All in all, we will definitely order again and try some other items. read more

Eat here twice a month and never had a bad meal...Service is excellent too!!!

My husband and I stopped in yesterday on the way to Newark Airport. Thanks to Yelpers I got a last slice of good pizza. We had pizza-by-the-slice - plain and pepperoni - and it was delicious. Also ordered 2 subs to go for the place - the American and Italian. Very large sub for one person. It was 2 full meals for me, 1 for Tim. The bread was fresh and they are generous with the cold cuts and toppings. I wish we could have tried the meatballs - the sandwiches sounded amazing but we didn't have time to stay and figured they wouldn't work in our airplane seats. The woman who helped us was friendly and quick and there are a few tables to sit down and eat. It was clean and all-around a good lunch stop. read more

The best meatball shop in Rockland county HANDS DOWN! I can walk from my house (less than a block) and get a fresh meatball sandwich with extremely creative titles like "Buckwild Balls." Trust me...it is ridiculous in the best way possible. The #1 thing about throw restaurant...the owners are local, dedicated, and extremely friendly. SUPPORT THIS BUSINESS! read more

I first tried this deli upon a recommendation from a friend. It was a little hard to find it at first as it's not on the main street in Suffern but down in a residential area. The actual deli has been there for well over 50 years. But it has been a meatball shop only for the past couple years. In addition to meatballs they serve pizza both the regular size and personal. Along with regular deli sandwiches. But their specialty are scrumptious meatball subs. They have over a dozen different types. Cutely named with double entendre. Like blue balls or the whole package sweaty balls. I tried the traditional meatball Parmesan sub. It came out in about 12 minutes. Smelled and looked delicious. I noticed the hoagie roll was very nicely toasted so it added A crunch to the sandwich when eating it. The meatballs were flavorful and The sauce and Parmesan cheese were spot on. A very good tasting sauce with just the amount of sweetness and tanginess. The meatballs weren't too spicy but not bland they had their own special flavor and secret ingredient. Definitely one of the best meatball subs I have had in a long time. I have also tried their personal pizza with a single topping and it's a real bargain at seven dollars. They also have a great special of two regular slices and a soft drink for four dollars. Make sure you come by here and try anyone of their delicious meatball subs. Get daring and try some of the creative creations they offer in a meatball sub. read more

We ordered from here tonight. It's usually some of the best food delivery in our area, so it's our go-to. I had been craving a tuna salad sandwich so I was dismayed to find that I received chicken salad. I called and the owner, Kelly- I think, apologized and sent a new sandwich, explaining that the employee who made the mistake was new. After getting a replacement tuna, I was happy to find it as delicious as always. Kelly even called to make sure it was correct. Great customer service, as usual. Their crazy meatball sandwiches are unusual and fun. I like the Big Mac type one the best. Our kids love it and my bf regularly craves the one with gravy. Go to BBalls! They're independently owned, delicious and you'll have leftovers because the sandwiches are generous. One of the best in the area, without a doubt. read more

Dropped by on my way back to Manhattan from a day hike- and this place lived up to its description! Great customer service, amazing meatballs and sauces- we tried the rice balls and the real deal, and both tasted unique and flavorful- and hands down the best bread bowls any of us have tried. And if you aren't in the mood for meatballs, they offer a full range of other deli sandwiches and side salads/sodas/cookies. read more

We happened across B-Balls on our road trip from NYC to Albany. So glad we did! The meatballs are amazing and you can get just about any variety of meatball sandwich imaginable. Everyone in the shop is friendly and we felt like part of the family! We will be stopping back through & recommending to everyone we know. Great job!!! read more

B-Balls Meatballs - Amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

Went there for the first time today after hearing about it for a long time. I must say it was one delicious meatball Parm hero! Very old-school, reminds me of my mothers. I will definitely be back again, it's worth turning off the Thruway for! read more

The best Italian Ice in the entire world! It brings me right back to my childhood! Could not ask for better food and nicer owners! If you are in the area, this is a "MUST" location! read more

Such a great local eatery. Owners are so welcoming and make you feel like family. My go to place!!!

This is my place!! The meatball are amazing with combinations you can't even imagine !!! It comes right out of the owner's imagination ha!! Other than that everything else is also great! I am a pizza snob and this place is the ONLY place I buy pizza .. they also have great garlic knots ( better than most Italian I've tried )The owners as well as the chefs are all great and if you want something sweet .. this is a double review because they are also the proprietors of the ice factory ( downtown Suffern) I highly recommended both !!! read more

Off the charts amazing choices never seen nothing like this love the idea #goodfoods I'll eat here again any time

I just went to B-Balls Meatballs for lunch with a few co-workers. This place was recommended to me by my husband's coworker. We first pulled up to B-Balls, at first we weren't sure if we at the right place since we were in a residential neighborhood. It's located on a street corner of a residential street, the store front reminded me of the corner stores in Philadelphia. We walk in and there was a small seating area, drink coolers and the counter. The woman behind the counter was very friendly and answered our questions. I ordered the Alfredo Balls and my two other coworkers ordered the Gyro Balls and a ham sub. My sub was amazing! The meatballs were fresh and homemade, the Alfredo sauce was just the right consistency, had good flavor and seasoning. We all agreed that this place had great food and we'll definitely be back again! read more

I will tell you...The bread is FANTASTIC! It is likely my fault for ordering chicken parm at a meatball place but I wasn't crazy about the actual chicken. It tasted like it was frozen rather than fresh. The sauce didn't have enough flavor. Frank's Pizza or King's has a MUCH better sauce. But I will tell you, that they were on time, VERY friendly and I will absolutely order again. The pizza is FANTASTIC! read more

Best place in town! All of their sandwiches are great, pizza is amazing, I have not had a meal here that I did not like.

My fiancé and I flew into NYC from Arizona, and we were traveling upstate to Syracuse for a wedding. We really wanted to have a classic Italian sandwich while we were here, and didn't have a chance to grab something in the city (too many delicious choices!!). We quickly yelped sandwiches on our way, and saw the awesome reviews for B-Balls. So glad we chose this place! Food was great, folks were very friendly, and if we lived in the area it would be our go-to deli. Thanks for gettin the door on the way out y'all! read more

What a fantastic place. The owners are awesome and the food is fantastic. I got the gyro balls and it was awesome. My kiddo got spaghetti and meatballs and he loved it. What a great experience and friendly, family oriented place. read more

B-Balls Meatballs - Lol ian enjoyed the balls - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

I had the "Blue Balls" best sandwich ever!!!! Owner was really friendly. You can eat, do takeout, and they do deliver. The bread in sandwich was perfectly toasted the meatballs were seasoned pretty well. Definitely the perfect cheat meal! It's a small location in a residential neighborhood, not hard to miss, you just have to park on the street. read more

B-Balls Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

We were in the area for a gymnastics meet and found this gem through yelp. Glad we did because the food was amazing. It is a small deli style place with a couple of tables and a bunch of bar stools, but the owners were very accommodating for our group of ten and pulled out extra chairs for us. Extremely friendly owners and again, all the food was outstanding. We sampled a bunch of sandwiches and some of the favorites were the classic schweaty and the baci balls. Also got a pizza for the kids that we all tried and loved. Don't miss the Italian ices when done either, nice finishing touch. read more

B-Balls Meatballs - Kids picking out their Italian ice flavors. Awesome place and great owners. - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

The food is delicious. The staff is very friendly. I love places like this. They definitely don't play it safe with their sauces and styles. Bold, creative, and sure to please every palate. I hope to go again soon. Thanks Lance! read more

I was here a few days ago, happened to be in the area, followed the good reviews and didn't regret it. On a whim I ordered their "Great Balls of Fire" because I love hot peppers and hot sauce. They offer this for free if you can eat it there in under 10 minutes without a drink, but I wasn't up to be competitive. The sandwich is indeed hot as hell and I ended up finishing it in four separate sittings. It cleared out my sinuses and was delicious in portions I could handle. Staff was very courteous. I'll be back when I'm in the area. read more

This restaurant is a prime example of a reason why to travel off the beaten path! The menu has character and enough choices to make you think about your selection. I had the #20 "Really Shweaty Cheesy Balls" in a bread bowl. The meatballs were flavorful and there was a perfect balance of sauce and cheese; this choice added creamy ricotta cheese to the dish which was an awesome touch. The staff was super-friendly. You should stop in! read more

B-Balls Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

located amongst private homes. ordered the reuben with mustard. quite dry, barely any cheese or saurkraut. small meatballs, invisible pastrami that I had to pull out to find. I know they usually give ample portions but mine was tiny. the inside is nice and the hero does taste good. need to work on their consistency of filling up the insides of the bread with product. read more

B-Balls Meatballs - located in a suburb street full of houses. - Pizza Near Me - Suffern, New York

See all

Yum, on a street corner, not much seating, but good variety of meatball subs. It's a family run business and they were really nice and welcoming when we took a road trip out of the city and came by for some quick food. read more