Excellent bagels! (As mentioned by other folks, consider on-street parking to avoid the crowded…read moreparking lot)

I saw it on a side of the road, unassuming looking, but kids were hungry, and me too. So went for…read moreit. The crowd inside made me suspect its gonna be good. Bagels looked giant and had larger variety than any other place outside nyc. I got Philly cheese steak, and kids got chicken cutlet deluxe. My sandwich is good, lacking seasoning as in salt n pepper but I ve notice lately all places stopped seasoning unless you specifically ask for it. Maybe if you're over 40 they automatically withheld salt? French fries are bit on a soft side and greasy. Overall great place, if I ever pass by here again I d try their bagels for sure. P.s. Just tried jids chicken cutlet, its to die for. So good. Soggy salad is forgiven for how tender n moist it is.

My everyday stop Big portions of Filling delicious bagels ,…read moregreat staff , fast service and very clean and organized spot Highly recommended Everything bagel is Fire

First time trying bagel shack and despite reviews I still stopped in to give it a try. Ordered an…read moreeverything bagel with Taylor ham, egg, and cheese. The bagels are extremely fluffy and dense so not ideal for a breakfast sandwich as there is a lot of filler from the bagel and you definitely need to unhinge your jaw with each bite. The TEC on a bagel came to $7.50 which is relatively cheaper than most breakfast sandwiches in the Mahwah area by about $3-4. The bagel itself needed more everything seasoning and salt altogether. It was an okay option based on the location and not having time to go to a different bagel shop. Service was helpful and quick.

My name is Peter I am working in town doing Epoxy flooring I walked immediately was offered some of…read morethe best service. I was welcomed and given some of the best experience I ever had the food is amazing the staff is great. I had a chance to talk to the employees and owner very nice people. I recommend this place to anyone who loves good food.Im a customer for life

I came here 4 times before... 1st they didn't have the…read moreturkey sausage 2nd they forgot to put the turkey sausage (had to go back) 3rd order was good bagel with cream cheese 4th order was a brick with cream cheese ‍ The lady in there was super nice she forgot to toast my bagel the 4th time and I went back she made my order over but then it was a brick. so yeah I will never be returning but the lady very nice..

I have to say, the food here is amazing. I love reading the reviews about the owner, Fred. I have…read moreeaten here over a dozen times and he does have that death stare. He reminds me of the soup nazi from Seinfeld. He's not very nice to me when I go in, he does smile either. He just wants to know what do you want, and off with you. All that being said, the food is A+. My favorite is Taylor Ham egg and cheese on hard roll. The eggs are always fluffy. Taylor Ham is the right amount. The roll is soft. One of my top two in north jersey. The bagels are also really good. Soft and chewy on inside and crispy on the outside. The food comes out fresh and really fast. If you need good customer care and get insulted if you don't get a smile as you come in, this place is not good for you. If you want really good food, this is the place

Bagel is ALWAYS on point! Fresh, well constructed, baked to perfection, flavors will never let you…read moredown. Not easy to find the right shop. Service is well organized, respectful. Place is clean and bright. Highly recommend.

ALWAYS worth it! Hurry in before they sell out of sesame! Awesome bagels and excellent sammies tho…read moreI come in for the kosher pickles. Gotta grab a big container every time I'm in the area. Pastry rocks too. Tables to sit tho I always pick up. Tiny parking lot fills fast and you may have to park in the next lot over. Figuring out the lines to order AND the lines to pay catch everyone the first time. Know your order when you get to the counter- you've had time to check the large menu boards

Bagel Boys is the place to go to experience lines, crowds, rude service and high prices without…read morehaving to travel into Manhattan. The Power Bagel was excellent! But the Bacon, Egg and Cheese in it--it was okay--nothing I would run back for. With a cup of Tropicana--the total came to a whopping $10+ They made me feel like I was back in LA. The woman at the order counter was as edgy as can be. There was a couple in back of me anxious to order and I did not know which bagel I wanted so I told them to go ahead I am still looking. They cut in front and go up to order and the order clerk yells at me: "You are next!..you two (referring to the couple I told to go ahead)--step back!" Hey, it's NY--it would not be the same without the attitude. Capeesh? You should have seen her expression when I asked her how much is a bottle of water? Free easy parking in front, table seating inside if you can find one available. I sat at the long counter on a stool looking outside.

Not a bad spot, but I'd like to make a few suggestions in case the management / owners read these…read morereviews: - There should be prices on the wall menus - Drink fridges are not cold enough! They make a lot of noise, but sodas should be colder. - Please, PLEASE turn off the TV! Nobody wants CNN or Fox news blaring at them while they eat a bagel. It's not an airport, we don't need TVs everywhere. How about some music instead?

Stopped by for the first time today. Good bagels are sorely lacking in this area but Buono Bagels…read morewas a better option. Having lived in NY most of my life, I admit that I'm a bagel snob so the bagel I had here wasn't special by any means but the owner was kind and had a warmth about him that makes me want to visit again. I got an everything bagel with cream cheese. Bagel wasn't as pillowy on the inside as I would've liked but the taste was decent with enough everything seasoning to make it an actual everything bagel. It had a fair amount of cream cheese, although my spoiled NY taste buds would've prefered a tad bit more. Overall, it was better than Bagel Shack. And since there are no good bagel places around, I'll probably be back.

Great bagels and egg wraps still nice and warm upon delivery…read more Excellent customer service and timely arrival of order. Will definitely be ordering again!

not sure about the bad reviews. my manager ordered a bunch of bagels for st patricks day. they were…read moregreen. they gave us a couple of cream cheese options. one of the whipped cream cheese was dyed green. the bagels tasted good. was not disappointed. and it was a fun green treat for the holiday.

Decently priced considering everything in Ramsey is expensive. $15 for a salad surprisingly I guess…read moreit was okay.

stay away, anyone from Bergen county can tell this is a store bought bagel made in a factory…read more Highly disappointed you'd charge 4 dollars for a bagel you took out of a bag this morning. I'll never patronize this store again, please go to one of the legit bagel places within walking distance. If I could go negative would, would never return.

Surprisingly bland everything bagel…read more Upon unwrapping this bagel, I thought it held some promise. The crust was shiny and marked with tiny bubbles, and was decently browned. Unfortunately, it was pretty flavorless. The crumb, which appeared to be relatively open, was also very bland. Neither had much chew. The cream cheese was pretty standard. The everything topping itself needed more garlic, onion, and salt. Service was fine, place was empty. Price was typical of an everything bagel with cream cheese. Would not eat again.

Silly me, I figured because Airmont is a pretty Jewish area that the bagels will be good, so I…read morechose to stop here......SMACK! Reality punched me in the face. this place was worse then mediocre. Granted, I arrived at 10:05 a.m., after the morning Rush, but the coffee was so thick it was more like sludge than it was Java. Hard to believe it could get that sledging in the short time between the rush hour and when I got there. I was excited when I saw Green Mountain Coffee, and very soon let down by the sludge that poured into my cup. By 10:05 a.m. they were out of about 85% of the types of bagels that had places in their case, leaving me far fewer choices. I got the last everything bagel (they had empty bins for whole-wheat-everything as well as egg-everything - but both were empty) - leading me to believe of the sellout might have been a sign of greatness. Instead the disgusting thing that I was served was yet another punch to the face. The inside was doey and undercooked and the outside had color but no crust. I ordered cream cheese and barely got enough of a schmear to even show a ripple of white between the sliced halves. My friend who was dining with me ordered a cinnamon raisin toasted with cream cheese. He said his Bagel was okay but asked where the cream cheese was. He also purchased a container of juice thereby avoiding the coffee. Long story short I won't be back. Especially because the Dunkin Donuts down the road at least puts cream cheese on their crappy bagel and makes the coffee fresh. I will leave off on a positive note though and note that the place was very clean including and especially the bathroom - it was immaculate. Good if you got to go, bad if you need a coffee or to get a bagel.

Clean and well organized!…read more Friendly staff. I had tuna on a roll. It was so-so, but I'll be back to try other dishes.

We've been loyal customers for years, so finding three hairs embedded in our cake was especially…read moredisappointing. We contacted the bakery and followed their instructions to bring the cake back, but they refused to even look at it or offer any solution. The hairs were unacceptable, but the bakery's lack of concern and customer service was equally disappointing. This experience has seriously damaged our trust in the business.