The food was served beautiful And it was so fresh. I especially enjoyed the squash soup seasoned perfectly. The service was top. They didn't rush us and was willing to answer any questions we had about the menu. read more

A bit of an attitude was felt not by the waitress but by staff Overpriced and under portioned Just ok Not like it was in the past Disappointing experience read more

Made a reservation on 4-21-26 for 5-11-26 to have a family celebration after our kid graduated from NYU. Received a call on 5-10 that the restaurant isn't even open on 5-11 and they blamed it on a problem with "the system". Restaurant waited over 2 weeks to tell me that they issued me a reservation confirmation (3VRLMC43RHMY) for a Monday evening AND THEY AREN'T OPEN MONDAYS. read more

We went for the pre-theatre menu, which was a little disappointing. The soup wasn't hot, but it did have nice flavors. The salmon was nice, but overall a bit underwhelming. Staff were lovely and attentive and it's nice inside. For the price, I would be unlikely to return. read more

See all

What a wonderful experience. The decor is lovely and elegant. Our server Martin was very attentive and plated our branzino beautifully. The entire staff was efficient. We ordered the calamari which was nicely battered. The firecracker roll is topped with salmon, I would swap the salmon for scallop or shrimp, however it was still good. The pasta and branzino were really delicious. The bread basket and butter was also a highlight for me happy dining! read more

See all

Food was delicious & right near Lincoln Center! Service was also immaculate - very attentive & Jessica, our service, was EXCELLENT - personable, funny, kind & checked back in consistently. Would recommend! read more

Delicious food wonderful ambiance. The waiters were attentive and courteous. The menu provided ample choices and everything I ordered was prepared carefully and surpassed my expectations. I will definitely frequent this restaurant. read more

Everyone knows the Atlantic Grill has outstanding 5 star food, and they are not wrong! We have a magnificent meal and the restaurant had lots of gluten free options to meet my dietary requirements. The food was outstanding. But I left this review bc I want to rave about the service! Jessie was our server and she was just THE BEST. I mentioned that I wished I could get the spicy margarita but I don't drink alcohol anymore and next thing I knew there was a zero proof spicy margarita at the table that the bartender made just for me (it's not on the menu)! Wow! And it was probably the best cocktail (alcoholic or not) that I've ever had. Thank you to all the staff for your attention to every detail and for the wonderful hospitality! read more

A cozy place with beautiful decor. The food, however, was just okay - nothing special and could have been more seasoned. We shared octopus carpaccio and shishito peppers as appetizers. The octopus was fresh, a light mix of lemon, celery, tomatoes, olives, capers and pistachios. For mains, I ordered the grilled salmon and my friend ordered the mushroom risotto - just fine. The dessert was delicious though. The service was great, but overall the food seemed way overpriced for what it was. For the price, I've had better and more memorable meals elsewhere. read more

See all

Excellent food, great ambiance, comfortable seating, and the best service ever. Perfect cocktails and great sushi. Shout out to our server, Nour - handsome, personable, attention to detail, and our order came out perfectly. Don't forget their great desserts. read more

We had the pre-theater menu and were not impressed. For our first course one of us had salad and the other had sushi; our main courses were both salmon. Nothing was particularly tasty. The desserts were especially disappointing - yoghurt ice cream and brownie sundae were both "meh." With the pre-theater menu, you can pay another $11 to have a cocktail (but limited to only two choices of the many listed). Wine is not offered for the additional fee, which seemed really odd. Our server was pleasant but seemed very inexperienced and nervous. We had to repeat our orders several times and were given a different wine than what we ordered. We won't be back. read more

Such an elegant and classy addition to UWS. I have walked by this restaurant several times and never thought to stop in. Wish I did sooner! Atlantic Grill is a place you would find yourself before a show, date night or take the parents to a place where you want them to be impressed. I personally love to sit at the bar here. The warm vibes and positive energy from the staff and the customers make an amazing scene for a happy hour cocktail. I would recommend the spicy margarita to start. Perfectly made! I love seafood but I have to say, while I've had main dishes (seafood paella is amazing) - every time I come I go straight for the sushi. My favorites are the yuzu yellowtail roll and the fire cracker roll. Fire cracker has a bit of a smoky/ spice that makes it hard to not finish the entire thing (even when you are stuffed!). Service is also fantastic. Bartenders are all attentive and constantly checking in. Very highly recommended for this hidden gem of a classy restaurant in the neighborhood! read more

Atlantic Grill - Spicy margarita - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Excellent, high class ambiance. The bartender Kayla was very skilled and made an excellent Cosmo, great service - the food was fresh and delicious. I got the california roll and it had real crab +wasabi and was well seasoned. Definite recommend! read more

Atlantic Grill - New American Near Me - New York, New York

I've been going to this place since the Gingerman days. When it became the Atlantic Grill it remained excellent ... until this new management took over. The space is lovely, cozy, and comfortable ... But, the food is literally sometimes inedible, barely recognizable and the menu is all over the place. it's pretentious and the staff appear to be terrified of the surly management. I've given it every possible try, hoping it will improve, but it only gets worse. There's a reason it's the only restaurant in the area not open for lunch on weekdays. please fix it! read more

The food was okay. the ambience was okay. The service left MUCH to be desired and managed to spoil what was booked as a celebratory event. The waitstaff could not be counted on to keep my water glass full. We waited and waited and waited on our main courses and again on our dessert. A dinner that should have taken maybe an hour, maybe an hour and a quarter, stretched to a full 2 hours as we repeatedly tried to summon waiters to pay attention to us. Also, it was raining. We were directed to leave our umbrellas in an already full receptacle at the entrance and left them as nearby as possible. On leaving, our umbrellas had disappeared. Only one was recovered -- in a closet somewhere. very disappointing experience. read more

This was our first visit back to the Atlantic Grill since the pandemic. The room is beautiful. It's dark and clubby, with adequate room between tables. The staff were lovely and attentive. Cocktails were very good. The bread service was good. The food was uneven. I started off with a very good dragon roll. My wife had the shrimp cocktail, which turned out to be served over salad. The presentation was beautiful, but my wife didn't love the shrimp. Our friends enjoyed their Mediterranean salads. The entrees were a similar story. The grilled salmon was fine. My wife didn't love her branzino. The only real outlier in the meal was the cauliflower gratinee, which I can only describe as heinous. It was served in a gloppy cream sauce and was overwhelmed with a spice that may have been cumin, but didn't work to good effect. Coffee was very good. Prices are typical for a seafood restaurant. This is a beautiful restaurant with great service. The food didn't quite match the rest of the experience. Still, it's a solid place for a pre-theater eat. read more

See all

Best restaurant for seafood and sushi in lincoln center area, and maybe the whole city. Excellent service and food. The ambiance was amazing as well. Will return. read more

Forget about it. I shall try to forget it. The service, seemingly nice, was ineffectual. (A glass of wine was not brought before food orders were given; a shared salad came without serving utensils. Shellfish in shells was served without small forks.) The food demonstrated problems with the chef as well. Although the salad was supposed to have cheese on the side, the cheese was placed across the top. Scallops, said to be bay scallops, were clearly large sea scallops. The scallops were supposed to be broiled or grilled without butter; they came pale (no browning), seemingly poached. No seasoning was placed on the scallops. We would have been better fed and served at a local diner. read more

Service not good. Food great. Ordered coffee never received.... LONG WAIT Received bill with no pen .... read more

Not attentive at all. Just walked in and out. We dined at Atlantic Grill 3 years ago, much better experience. read more

So sad! This used to be such a good restaurant! Salad with chicken $42 plus tax and tip = $57 and it was totally EH. worst chicken in a long time and the salad was almost all arugula. Plus, near empty Saturday evening. I guess the word is out read more

Originally came for restaurant week. We happened to come on what was supposed to be the last day of restaurant week which they didn't honor. They had claimed it ended for them the previous Friday, although they were listed for Sunday participation. That was a downer but we were already there so we continued. The food items ordered were the sushi, Lobster Bisque and Escalope de Foie Gras, Salmon Béarnaise: Grilled Salmon, green beans, cherry tomatoes, dill, Béarnaise sauce, and Ravioli Atlantic Grill: House made ravioli, Maine crab, brandy cream sauce. The Lobster Bisque was really good. I'd honestly only come back for the that. The sushi came out fresh. The salmon entree didn't feel cohesive I didn't love it. I felt like the entire dish needed more love. The ravioli was okay just missing that extra oomph. I'm not sure if this place would get a second visit from me. I am pescatarian and I just wasn't loving the food as I'd hoped for. The aesthetic is nice, intimate and quiet. suitable for a date night. read more

See all

Excellent service continues to thrive. The ambiance, staff, service, cuisine, and cocktails were all outstanding. We appreciated the coat service upon arrival, well-timed table service, and prompt clearing after each course. Our octopus appetizer and sushi were both superb; the thinly sliced octopus was incredibly tender, and the sushi was among the best we've had. For our main courses, we enjoyed the lobster roll and the catch of the day, which was the Grilled octopus. A perfect martini was created (although blue cheese olives would have made it out of this world). The atmosphere was sophisticated and evocative. We definitely plan to return. read more

See all

This restaurant is such a disappointment. I have gone here a few times when everything else in the area is booked, but it is consistently fair to poor. I just don't understand how a restaurant in such a prime location can be so mediocre and survive. The menu is varied, but so many of the dishes are unappealing. I have resolved not to return unless there are major changes. read more

I went for pre theatre and it's absolutely amazing, quit and comfortable place, it's a hidden gem.

I've been dining in NYC for 10 years and this place should be avoided at all costs. The service is terrible, slow and inattentive. They don't know the menu and struggle to explain the dishes. The food is bad, overpriced and outdated. The restaurant was nearly empty on a Friday night (this biggest red flag) and everything from that point onward was a disappointment. Go to the Smith around the corner you will thank me later. read more

Great service Kayleigh and Ann!! Sushi hit the spot. A perfect Friday night outing. Thanks AG! read more

Atlantic Grill - The perfect end of the night - New American Near Me - New York, New York

I had my daughter birthday dinner and it was a success. Service was on point attentive yet not intrusive. Everything tasted great my daughter is picky but she did enjoy every single bite. The ambience was great for conversation and the candles gave it a cool touch. I am glad we chose this restaurant for her special day. She can't wait to comeback! read more

See all

Beautiful decor, exceptional service, great food. I was really impressed by the service especially: very attentive, and helpful suggestions. The fish tacos and asparagus exceeded expectations. It can be a bit pricey but it was a great experience and it was nice to not have to chase a waiter down to request the bill. read more

See all

Kayla and team are efficient and get you ready for theatre or whatever you've got next! Don't miss the sushi rolls and fresh fish. Super easy location to Lincoln Center. read more

Service was great, we had sushi appetizers which were wonderful. Cocktails were also very nice and split the paella for main course which was delicious! We will be back for pre-theater again soon. read more

Came here with friends for dinner for Winter Restaurant Week. Wow, this place is spacious! After you pass the front section, there is a back section and another bar! Very impressed. Had a nice booth for dinner. Food and service were good here. This was one of the restaurants we wanted to try on the upper west side by Lincoln Center. Complimentary bread... Appetizers: New England Clam Chowder - they didn't serve it with oyster crackers as per the menu stated, rather 2 pieces of crackers already in the soup. Salmon poke bowl - was good too. Entrees: Grilled jumbo shrimp - very good shrimp though not a fan of chickpeas. Seafood rigatoni was good - small dish but filling Salmon was good as well. Dessert: Spiced carrot cake panna cotta w/ fruite compote and walnuts - delicious! Sorbet trio - grape, mango, raspberry (raspberry was tart) LSC members - don't forget to get points for dining here...though nothing special for your birthday except a candle on dessert. Would be nice to a complimentary dessert like some other LSC restaurants... but still good overall. read more

See all

I came back for a 2nd meal this time opting for Orata and rapini. Unfortunately this time the dishes didn't match expectations. The Rapini was salty and they only serve Orata deboned and as luck would have it overcooked. I would go back but not repeat this meal. I love Orata and Rapini so this pained me. I should have stuck with the languostines read more

See all

Best Negroni in town! I stopped for a quick drink, and had a Negroni from the bartender Gustavo. It made me feel like I was back in Italy. And the pizza was great too! read more

The decor is your standard old school seafood restaurant, picture the place your grandparents would want to take you for a fancy dinner. The wait staff was accommodating for our group so that part was fine, although also was a relatively quiet night. As far as the food, the appetizers, while nothing was bad, were underwhelming and for the $15-20 price point, there could've been a little bit more food. Also, the presentation was mediocre. Come to the main course though and there's a major difference. The presentation was great and the food itself, delicious. Overall a good experience, but wish they'd have put a bit more effort into the apps. read more

See all

The post-pandemic Atlantic Grill seems much smaller and more upscale than I remember, less of a boisterous good time and more of an elegant evening. Not as kid-friendly as before - especially not the prices - but it's a beautifully appointed and proportioned space, top-notch service. If Cafe Fiorello is Times Square, this is like turning the corner and finding yourself in Bryant Park. read more

I was indifferent to the Atlantic Grill's pre-COVID iteration and when I found out about it being taken over by the same group as Fiorello (gag), I put off trying it. We popped in one Thursday evening and no one was there and they took one look at us and said they were completely booked. It was a scene right out of Ferris Bueller. Not sure the Maitre 'D could have had his nose higher. So I wrote them a bad review about that and we've not darkened their door, until we were really hungry a couple of weeks ago and desperate and did not want to walk more than a half block. So we risked it. To make it worse, it was a Saturday night and we were not dressed for it. I had a sweater on and my wife had pants. We were way under-dressed for the pre-theatre crowd, as there were quite a few elegantly dressed couples. They looked us over and relented, giving us one of two tables left and we were ok with the seating. Then the menu, which was really quite amazing. The service, by about three different people, was great. When the food came, the tastes were spectacular. Salads, sushi (the wasabi had a lemony something to it), and the fish entrees were exceptional. They had so many choices on fish I could not believe it would be fresh. I picked the swordfish. Very fresh, and buttery. We saved room for dessert and were not disappointed. Delicious. Choc sauce and raspberry compote on whatever. Just the kinds of tastes you would want. It was not cheap, but we had ordered a lot of food. No wine, so if you're drinking, hold on to your horses. But it could have been much worse at some Columbus Circle food/steak factory. I was so very delighted the whole time. I promptly removed the first review and am taking the time to replace it now with this one. I understand their desire to keep things upscale. The crowd changed a lot over the evening, to a much more casual diner, after the first rush for theatre left. Bravo, and we'll be seeing you again soon. read more

Civilized atmosphere. Great for single mature women dining alone. Food was good enough. Nice bar area. read more

I am so happy to see this place re-opened, although I'm not convinced I love the reinvention. The new owners: Monte Carlo Hospitality Group (MCHG), have cut the restaurant in half. Now, Atlantic Grill is a much smaller intimate space. The prices are even higher than they used to be. For example, the fresh fish is priced per pound and comes a la carte. We were told that the half of the restaurant that used to be on W64th St will reopen next year as a French restaurant. We ate at the bar. The bartender doesn't have a big repertoire, but what he does make is excellent and priced right for the size. These are not skimpy cocktails, but they're at least $19! Everyone at the bar agreed with us that the food was excellent. I loved their bread basket too, especially their white bread. It reminded me of scones. The butter comes with seaweed mixed in and they have plain butter upon request. They no longer have the salmon burger (my lunchtime fav); they do have a fish burger which I'm looking forward to trying in the near future.The manager, was very friendly and helped out with the service. Note: There is no outdoor dining. They did check for COVID-19 vaccinations. read more

We arrived a bit early for our 5pm reservation after a matinee show at Lincoln Center. The host welcomes us and asks if we'd like to check our coats, we do. We are taken across the restaurant (This place is huge - entrances on 64/65th St) and given an awesome rounded booth meant for 3. Really an excellent table to check out the smaller bar and people watch. We order a mule and negroni and given an uninspiring bread loaf (better to save room for the menu). Didn't try the mule and negroni wasn't the best one I ever had. There are many things I wanted to try on the varied menu so we ordered some plates to share: 3 east & 3 west oysters: Quality oysters, but our server didn't bother to point out which were which. I liked the horseradish sitting separate in with cocktail sauce and a choice of mignonette as well. Charred Octopus: A loved how tender and flavorful the octopus was, but the portion was rather small. Nicely plated. Truffle Rainbow Roll: If you plan on getting any sushi rolls, let this be the one! A common RR is elevated with a citrus truffle sauce, which is probably the best sauce I ever had on a sushi roll ever! We shamelessly ordered another. This pairs excellent with the house Riesling. Hunts Point Fish Market Scallops: Everything you want in a scallop - plump, juicy, perfectly cooked on a bed of roasted corn, mushroom and tofu. The thai coconut-curry was very light and did not overpower the scallops at all. We had the kitchen split this entree. Brussel Sprouts: Maple Sherry was a bit too much sweet for me and I would have prefered large bacon pieces. I had better. For Dessert we went with a new item - Banana Ice Cream Tower which is served inside a cylinder of hazelnut, almost brittle candy like, with chunks of banana and ice cream inside. Beautifully presented and a good finish. They serve a great cup of coffee. This place gets packed so make a reservation! Our server was decent, but we heard others giving diners more recommendations and going over the market fish of the day. Got the sense that they know they are a long time, popular classic so didn't try as hard. read more

See all