Ordered a $200 custom cake through Instragram for my daughter's 2nd birthday party 2 and a half…read moreyears ago. I messaged the company and I believe SJ took the order. She was highly recommended from an acquaintence. The theme was "2 sweet" I had sent her 2 photos for inspiration for an idea of what I wanted. I felt like I was an easy customer. I picked up the cake and I remember her finger nails looked dirty but I just thought it was from the cakes. At my initial first look of the cake, I liked it. I left it out in the shade, it was an outside party. When I looked at the cake, my daughter's name looked like it was slapped on by a child and the top fondant swirl on top was uneven. No big deal... When I finally cut into the cake, it was very hard and seemed very dry right away. Not a typical moist cake. I honestly had no desire to even taste it and felt bad distributing it out. I had asked a few people how they liked it and they even said it was dry but the icing and everything else was good. I think they tried to be nice. I messaged SJ telling her I was not happy with it and even my guests felt the same. She was speechless and her feelings were hurt that I didn't like the cake. When she asked what she can do, I told her I wanted 50% off. Since most of it went in the garbage too. She eventually became very defensive and blamed me and saying something about the butter and how it didn't melt in the shade or how I should've left it out longer..? Which I never heard of and also saying she uses fresh ingredients and all her cakes are fresh and she puts in a lot of time into each of her cakes. I do believe her so I don't understand why I felt my cake was so hard and dry. Her husband even messaged me too. I even showed her screen shots of what my guests said and how they agreed that the cake was very dry. She didn't like that I sent her what my guests said. Eventually I got my $100, this was 2 years ago so I will never order from here again.

Very accommodating for someone like me who had no idea what kind of cake I was looking for my…read moresoccer playing teen. Excellent suggestions were provided for the look and the ingredients from the very patient owner. I didn't have to go to the storefront to make the order and payment was made online so that was very convenient. The cake was ready on time and it came out great. We added some deco from Amazon to complete the theme and he loved it. The cake was delicious!

Amy was so easy to work with! I sent her a photo of the cake I wanted for a gender reveal, and to…read morebe honest, I didn't expect it to be just like the picture because it's something off pinterest. You know. But when I saw the cake in person, I was sooo happy! It looked very well put together. And I kept on telling everyone how excited I was about the cake! We ended up taking some of the cake home and though was in the fridge for a couple of days it was still moist and still tastes great. She doesn't charge a fortune either, I would definitely order from her again for my next party.

I've ordered several cakes from Sweet Chaos and I've had nothing but great reviews. One of my…read morefavorite fillings that they've managed to perfect is the Red Velvet filling with vanilla cream cheese layers (I am salivating as I write this by the way). Her pricing is absolutely under par.. I've purchased a designed cake from a bakery in Verona and paid three times what Sweet Chaos charged me for a custom made cake. I really recommend asking for some ideas on designing the cake or cupcakes - the vision that Amy has is beyond a few tiers of cake with different colored fondant.. it's a masterpiece the describes the event or the person. I have to emphasize how talented and professional Amy is and her ability to tailor a pastry to my liking.

I came in from out of town, but found "For Goodness Cakes" online. I had my brother go check it…read moreout for me. The day of my niece's baby shower, I couldn't believe my eyes. The cake design was amazing! So dynamically colorful and full of life. Our guests raved about it, and it was so beautiful, my niece didn't want to cut it. It not only looked good but it tasted great as well! I would MOST DEFINITELY use this bakery again!!! The price was right and the customer service was fantastic!

We needed a cake for my nieces 6th birthday party and Frozen was the theme. I had been Yelping…read morelocal cake businesses and came across For Goodness Cakes. The reviews do not lie! Aimee did am amazing job and communicating along every step of the way with my mom. She not only made the cake look perfect but the cake was so fresh and moist and the frosting was so good! If you need a cake for a special occasion Aimee is your girl!! We're looking for another excuse to get another cake and thinking about a Christmas cake lol. Definitely cannot wait to try another creation!! Thank you for making my nieces birthday so special!

Great place for cupcakes. Friendly service. also have the ability to do birthday cakes and wedding…read morecakes.

I've tried the cookies, brownies, cupcakes, cakes, and everything was delicious . My favorite were…read morethe pumpkin cupcakes. The service was ​prompt and friendly. I will definitely be ordering again soon! ​

Had the pleasure of working with Pilar on a birthday cake for a friend. Pilar is extremely…read moreprofessional, thorough & a true joy to deal with. I emailed her regarding the order along with a picture for reference. Her replies were always swift with all questions and concerns being addressed. The outcome was a beautiful cake which looked better than the reference picture. The taste was amazing!!! Which I believe is due to the fact that she only works with ganache and not fondant. She even sent an email with storage & cutting instructions. I look forward to placing another order with her!!

I contacted Pilar last minute to make cupcakes for a friend's babyshower. Not only did she squeeze…read moreme in last minute, but she was attentive, and responsive to all my emails and questions. The baby shower was a safari theme and I really had no idea what I wanted. She let her creative juices flow and produced beautiful, blueberry lemon cupcakes that tasted amazing, and animal shaped sugar cookies that also tasted great! Pilar was a pleasure to work with and I look forward to using her services in the future.

This is the best eggless cakes ever. We have ordered about 10-12 cakes from here. Nikita puts a lot…read moreof effort in making the cakes, suggesting designs and executing on design suggested by us :) She has done a variety of designs for us & flavors including pistachio, tiramisu, strawberry, chocolate etc. Attaching some samples.

I found this place on yelp, searching for eggless cake options. The only other we have is hotbreads…read moreand we are quite bored of it. Unfortunately, Nikita bakes to order and I had no way of tasting it before hand, but anyhow went for it. It was a fresh cream and chocolate cake, which was right amount of sweetness and quite soft. I drove from Secaucus to Edison and the cake stayed well. We ordered 2 days ago, which was more than enough time. So chocolate cake here definitely gets my thumbs up! Hope to try more varieties here

Delicious fresh baked cake that was the hilight of my daughters birthday. The Bavarian creme…read more and fresh strawberry filling was divine. It was our first time trying Rudy's but we will certainly be returning. Delicious

To quote Stanley Tucci: "oh my God---this is sooo good" And…read moreit was. My wife is a German teacher and has used Rudy's for class celebrations....and Germania Park In Rockaway NJ can't be wrong either!!