We had a last minute change of plans and were so happy to get a reservation for brunch after church…read moreon Easter Sunday and to finally check this place out. Thought we were going to be outside on the enclosed patio and knew it was going to be raining so we were thrilled to be seated inside by the fireplace instead. Price fixe was $65 pp so a bit steep but the bottomless drink options definitely helped. We enjoyed everything we ate and the service, restroom cleanliness and atmosphere were all on point. Will def return!

My sister tried this restaurant for the first time we enjoyed it. The restaurant itself is very…read morecozy and homey as it is in an old house and we walked through a variety of rooms to get to the different dining rooms. The two rooms we saw even had fireplace places in them. Everyone on the staff was super nice and service oriented. Our waitress was very good, but we enjoyed the bus boy even more with his upbeat personality, excellent service and great smile. They have a number of dining options, including a prefix menu which we took advantage of. Between the two of us, we had baked clams and a fried artichoke appetizer, Uncle Leo's chicken, Nonna's Sunday sauce with meatball, and ice cream sundaes for dessert. All the food was delicious and the portions were plentiful as we both took home half of our entrée, which will serve as dinner another night. I would definitely come back to this restaurant and look forward to sitting on the patio when the warmer weather arrives.

Great butcher and then some! Antipasto, heros, sausages, ravioli, fresh mozzarella, jarred…read moredelicacies, fresh bread, clean store and nice staff. What are you waiting for? Everything was excellent here.

Amazing place highly recommend!!! The fresh mozzarella is to die for , the chicken cutlet is…read moreamazing the store is immaculate. The guys are the sweetest!

Since the day Southpaw opened, it's been wonderful friendly environment with great food. The menu…read morehas expanded quite a bit since they first opened, it's not your typical bar food. It's freshly made, tastes great, I've never been disappointed. The atmosphere is pretty nice, especially during the warmer months where the patio is opened outside, and the service staff are always friendly. I just wish the prices were a little lower so we could go more often.

Great place. Went on a Monday at 7:45 and still had to wait 10 minutes for table. The service was…read moregreat. Fun atmosphere. Food was amazing. Huge French dip, delicious truffle arugula pizza. Big kid portions. Nice beer selection. I will go back!

I came here for the first time today. My brother and a friend made tge recommendation. I was…read morewondering why we were driving so far away from Montauk Highway. But it turns out the food here is some of the best Ive ever had on Long Islams. We can perhaps go further and say best anywhere. My main course was a Flounder Marinara. It was amazingly tasty and fresh! The garlic bread was crispy and nustmike homemade. And I can't even spell the name of the amazing dessert. I'm more Interested in the food and not the decor - so Id recommend avoiding the advice of anyone who feels that it isn't up to their "fancy" standards. The food was great!

Fantastic food. But hands down the worst service uve had in my entire life. Not sure who was…read moreserving, the owner or what. Sweet lady they call nona. But she fkrgot everything i asked for. Had to ask for the check 4 times. And i woukd watch her leave my table go behind the bar and chit chat with her friends. It took an hour to get my meal. It took an hour to get my check. Only redeeming quality was the food was good. The chicken parm was to die for. The alfreso tortelini was average. Tortelini overcooked and mushy, and the alfredo sauce was clumpy. The tomato soup was great though. And the atmosphere was pleasant. Dim lighting, small bar area seats only 4. But pleasant aesthetics. Very mom and pop feel. Wish the service was better. One table had complained they been there 3 hours and still werent served their meal. They ended up taking it to go. And no it was not packed. There wwas only three tables seated.

Overall, good meals and would go again. Everything was tasty with some items being just a bit off,…read morewhich I'll explain. Service was great! Nice ambiance too, casual but a bit elevated. Grilled octopus appetizer was mostly excellent. Octopus was very fender and tasty along with the mashed potaoes. The pesto added a nice touch. The cornichons were the sweet and sallty ones, really didn't go with the dish. The whole carrot on top was mushy, and should be dropped. The fried calamari was tasty but some pieces were just the littlest bit overcooked. The rice flour made a difference to the crispness in a good way. Their cheese pizza was very good, good tasting crust. The gnocchi with bolognese sauce was also quite good. The gnocchi was definitely homemade and just a bit overcooked. The gnocchi kind of melted away in your mouth, it should have some bite it to be al dente to it. The chocolate mousse dessert was excellent. It was almost a dark chocolate mousse, so if you don't like really sweet desserts it was perfect. Definitely going back to try the salmon and other pizzas.

I have eaten again and perhaps my initial review was too harsh for new management. I understand…read morethat the wrinkles have to be ironed out and they certainly did. The pizza is good, service is good and I will continue to be a patron.

My mom and I, stopped in tonight, for an unexpected dinner. Not only was the food outstanding but…read morethe service was amazing! Our server, Venus, was friendly, courteous and knowledgeable about the menu! I would highly recommend this restaurant!

I'll keep it simple. Tried the regular slice…read more The ingredients didn't seem fresh. This was definitely not "good" pizza. I believe that they offer coupons on each pizza box, so when you get 10 coupons you get a free pie. This could be what keeps people coming back which pays their bills. If you can't make good pizza, is there really a point in trying anything else?

What a top notch restaurant. The owner greets you with a smile and a thank you !…read more Our server was Sam and she was terrific. The food was outstanding as usual. Strong. Consistent Solid food. A mastic favorite !!!!

We had the same disappointing experience as Rob B. and several others. The food arrived cold and…read morewas mediocre at best. The owner apologized, but nothing was done to address it. It's just not the same restaurant it was a few years ago. The quality has slipped, and it feels like they've simply stopped caring.

Hidden gem! Food is great, (& picky eaters) beautiful decor and our waitress, Jackie was wonderful.read more

Staff are always super friendly whether it is takeout or dining in…read more The food is always great. The portion sizes are generous. My favorites are the eggplant rollatini and the spinach white slice. The garlic knots are always great as well. The setup of the place is very cute.