Another Broken Egg Cafe

It's pretty crowded and I was bummed because the kitchen was closed when I got there, but at least…read morethe bartender Molly was freaking awesome. Attentive knowledgeable and friendly.

The place is super cute, we ordered bbq chicken, wings and spicy crab legs. Everything was…read moredelicious and our service was outstanding. We are definitely coming back

Buffalo Chicken wrap

See all

Pulled pork dinner

Moondoggy's Saloon

4.3(12 reviews)

3.2 mi

This is my favorite bar! The atmosphere is always fun, the service is great, and they have a huge…read moreselection of bottled and canned beers, plus a solid variety on tap. One thing I really like is that customers can pay to choose the music, so there's always something different playing. We've also been there on nights with a DJ, which makes for an even better time. There's a small dance floor with a stripper pole if that's your thing! They also allow smoking, and you can even buy cigarettes there. They also have a vape and Pokémon card vending machine, again if that's your thing. They have a separate pool room, along with plenty of seating options, including bar seating, high-top tables, and tables facing outside. Overall, it's a great place to hang out with friends, grab a drink, play some pool, and enjoy the atmosphere. I always have a good time here and definitely recommend checking it out!

Best place in Gulf Gate, Sarasota If you want a fun place to go this is it. Saturday's they have…read moreFree Hotdogs and if you buy a sandwich at A's Giant Sandwich next door you get a $1 10 oz bud draft beer.

New name... same owners?

See all

Gilligan's Island Bar & Grill

3.2(490 reviews)

Great place for food and fun! But horrible mens bathroom it needs updating no privacy. And these…read moredays that's a concern.

After a long day at the beach, we were hangry and stumbled on the tiki hut vibe of Gilligan's…read more Cute, cute, cute! We were seated outside immediately but because it's love bug season, we switched to an indoor table. Marley was our server, so nice and friendly, she did a great job.the menu is nice sized, something for everyone. The window where the food comes out looks like a converted VW van and adorable for the location. I ordered a pineapple lemon drop and it was really so good! Meaning, it didn't taste like I was drinking rubbing alcohol. Garnished with a cute pineapple wedge, I could drink 100 of them! As for food, I would strongly suggest The Native sandwich. Weird that the fish is served on toasted raisin bread but such a great concoction. Come and eat here!

Bar

Nachos with black beans

See all

Pineapple lemon drop

The Big Tiki Lounge

4.0(55 reviews)

0.2 mi

Going by the 3.5 star rating, I really wasn't expecting anything too amazing. SURPRISE!! Best…read moregrouper of the trip. I guess the owner is a fisherman and provides some of the catch. Anyways, the grouper was super fresh and nicely cooked (not overcooked like the last one we had in Clearwater). We also tried their smash burger- totally legit! The yucca fries were a nice surprise as well. Great food, great service (thanks Lexi!), and a cool location with a good vibe. we'll definitely return the next time we're in the area.

We came here for lunch and a drink and it was good! I didn't realize it was a restaurant located in…read morethe middle of a hotel but you can't even tell! I got the Shark Bite Punch and it was delicious! I also got the chicken wrap with fries and it was also delicious! Our waitress was friendly and helpful! I love the decor all around and it feels like a beach bar!

Inside

See all

Siesta Key Oyster Bar

4.0(1.9k reviews)

Menu had something for everyone. Food was great. Drinks were great. Service was great. Ambiance was…read moregreat. Definitely a place worth visiting. Great beach feel.

The atmosphere underneath the tiki roof was cool and inviting. A gentleman was playing and singing…read moregreat music- tv's all around if you want to watch (but not obnoxious or loud) very much a Beachy vibe! Great service (had our dog with us and ordered her a grilled chicken breast- so dog friendly) AND the Food! Delicious! Hubby had breakfast sandwich and I had shrimp and grits. SO Good

More inside

Salmon Tacos

See all

Seafood Tower

Lido Key Tiki Bar

3.9(31 reviews)

2.1 mi

•$

This was our first stay at this resort. We went to the Tiki Bar for lunch…read more The service was outstanding, as was the food. I had the Fish Tacos, blackened, which were delicious. I can't wait to return.

Food was good nothing extraordinary. Staff were mediocre. Prices were fair and the atmosphere was…read moregood.

See all

Island House Tap & Grill

4.4(668 reviews)

I'm slightly ashamed to admit that I've lived here for over a year and somehow completely slept on…read morethis place. Thanks to the recommendation of a total stranger, my husband and I finally checked it out earlier this week. Naturally, I had already done my due diligence by reading approximately 22 million Yelp reviews and looking at pics before walking in. I'd narrowed down my choices, but after chatting with our server, I went with the lobster burger. First of all- who decided to put the words lobster and burger together? It sounded confusing. And possibly unappetizing. Turns out, I owe whoever invented it an apology. The sweet server swiftly delivered a buttery brioche bun stuffed with big chunks of lobster, crisp lettuce, and a juicy tomato. I also requested a side of melted butter because...obviously. I feel like if there's lobster involved, melted butter is non-negotiable. Crispy fries rounded out the meal, and it was so ridiculously good that I pretty much unintentionally halted all dinner conversation to enjoy the party in my mouth. My husband ordered the ahi tacos with a side of duck fat fries. He inhaled every last bite of the tacos. They were piled high with fresh ahi and all the fixings, and the duck fat fries were rich and savory perfection- crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside, exactly as fries should be. The restaurant itself is pretty small, with just a handful of tables inside plus some outdoor seating. I can definitely see this place being packed during peak hours and high season, so plan accordingly. We'll absolutely be back sooner than later.

Service was wonderful and attentive Great draft list (12…read morebeers on tap) I had a Michelob Amber Bock and a Czech Pilsner (both tasty) The food was very good. The duck fries were amazing and the Steakhouse burger was tasty. My lady had one of their island bowls with shrimp and she enjoyed it. I can't say anything negative about this place. If I want to nitpick the establishment is located inside a strip mall and wedged in the corner between Birkenstock and a cafe. It is very small with inside seating for approximately 20 people and has some outdoor space as well. All in all a great place and worth going to.

On the road working a video project. Stopped in for lunch today.

Chicken Wings

See all

Irish red ale

3.14 Pi Craft Beer & Spirit

4.0(277 reviews)

Date of Visit: June 13, 2026…read more The wife and I were doing another one of our local road trips to Siesta Key. We stay at the same place. We like doing a Friday-Sunday get a way. The place we stay is across the street from 3.14 Pi. We have stayed here so many times and not one time did we try the pizza. We have had drinks and watched the bands before, just not eat. This time we were wanting a couple slice and decided to go the place we went to last trip. I reviewed it. As we walked in it was not the same place, we walked out. What happened. Heading back to the room we looked over at 3.14 and both said "lets try there" and glad we did. Still not sure even after when we sat. We ordered a couple BLs and a small Margarita Pizza. Looking around and you can tell this is a locals beach joint. Didn't take long and our pie arrived. I'll be honest, I was expecting some Restaurant Depot crust and weak sauce...when it was put in front of us we were both like "Wow, this ain't no pre-made crust". Then we bit into it. The crust had a perfect crisp and the ingredients were all fresh. My wife had two slices it was so good, and she almost never has two in one sitting. This has been the best Margarita pie we have had in a long time. We didn't finish it and what was left was brought home and re-heated in the oven...just as good the next day. Need to give this place a try. Peace.

This is our favorite late night stop while on vacation in Siesta Key and, after over 10 years of…read morevisiting, feels like family every time. The servers are always super friendly and the vacation vibe can't be beat. We enjoy coming here after sunset with our kiddos and getting a table outside...while they read or play (or convince us to get them an ice cream treat from the fudge factory next door), mom and dad get a chance chill. The wings are perfectly crispy and the pizza is always spot on. But the best thing is ordering a late night fresh hot slice...it will be as big as your head! Seriously, this little corner nook holds some of the best memories. Stop by and you'll see why!

Wings

See all

My Village Pub

4.0(251 reviews)

0.0 mi

So many nice eateries in downtown Siesta Key and this is one of them. Great sports bar but with a…read morenice porch too. Excellent bartender and great drink of the month: pineapple margaritas. Cheesesteak reimagined as Chinese fried wontons or egg rolls...yum with a spicy sauce. Good place. Now can someone gift me $2000 so I can do some proper shopping at the nearby Lily Pulitzer and Tommy Bahamas boutiques?

Lucy is awesome Love the pretzel , smash burger, wings and…read moreice cold beer!! Will be back very soon... like tonight

Cheesesteak reimagined

See all

Outside seating

Siesta Key Wine Bar

4.7(61 reviews)

0.0 mi

This is a must go to if you like wine!!! Great service, fun atmosphere and delicious wine!read more

Always enjoy our visits, Tom & Mel are great owner operators, always make guests feel welcome!…read moreChristmas decorations are fantastic! Merry Christmas and thank you for getting us in the spirit of the season! We will come back with friends!

See more unrecommended reviews

See all

This was an absolute savior on the hot beach days!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

26 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Carlie R.

Elite 26

185

239

717

3 years ago

Another Broken Egg is an absolute gem of a spot! My boyfriend and I decided to make a day trip from St. Pete and stumbled upon this charming breakfast place. From the moment we walked in, we knew it was going to be good--the bustling crowd was a sure sign! Our server was a delight, offering us numerous recommendations and making us feel right at home. Although I missed out on the cinnamon French toast (apparently a must-try!), my lobster and brie omelette was a delightful surprise, packed with flavor and uniqueness. My boyfriend enjoyed his power bowl as well. To complement our meal, we indulged in a pitcher of mimosas that were absolutely divine. Overall, Another Broken Egg exceeded our expectations with its fun and cute ambiance, friendly service, and delicious breakfast offerings. It's definitely a spot we'll be returning to on future trips! read more

Kelly M.

5 years ago

Today, 2/4/22 was my last day in Sarasota until next February, my family left the breakfast decision up to me and without hesitation I said Another Broken Egg Cafe. All the staff is amazing, very attentive to your needs and truly care about you having a great experience. Today I had the Lobster and Brie omelette, City grits and a Screwdriver. My mom had the Floridian omelette, we split them in half and shared. Both were amazing. No pictures to share, but the portions are very generous, and you will not leave hungry. IMO, you are wasting your time eating anywhere else. Use the call ahead feature on Yelp , very easy to use and you get right in. read more

John T.

6 years ago

Another Broken Egg is worth the time and money for exceptional food and service. We have been going there for years and the food and service is consistently good. We usually order an egg scrambler with spinach and roasted red peppers. It comes with potatoes and muffin. For dessert, a waffle with strawberries. Waffle is the best tasting in town -- crispy and light. They,also, make a great blood Mary. I prefer coffee and a mango ice tea. Price is very reasonable for what you get. My wife and I love sitting outside under the patio. Give it a try. You will love it, Management and servers are pitiless and helpful. read more

Carter D.

6 years ago

terrible service. they were out of 2 menu items that i tried to order and the server had no idea each time she had to come back and tell me instead of knowing. Not only were they out of 2 items i wanted they continued to rush me to order my food after they told me. food was subpar i could make a better omelette at my house. drinks were watered down. only got 1 napkin and it was soaking wet because they cleaned the table right before we sat down and didn't bother to dry it off. I WOULD GIVE IT 0 STARS IF I COULD. read more

Nicholas R.

11 years ago

Fortunately for visitors this another excellent option for breakfast or a snack in Siesta Key. The staff are pleasant and the service is swift. My wife and I both enjoyed our meals and were in and out of there quite quickly. I like to eat good food but don't like to take too much time away from outdoor activities and this place is perfect for that. Of course, it would do equally as well for someone with more time on their hands. read more

Tina S.

5 years ago

Best breakfast place in the village. Prices are comparable.food is delicious lemon berry mimosas amazing and staff friendly.John the bartender did an awesome job of checking in on customer to ensure they were doing ok. Overall this place is busy but they do a great job of getting people in and out without you feeling like you are being rushed. This is definitely a must try for breakfast.Scrambled EggsBaked Bacon and English muffin read more

Jenika W.

5 years ago

My friend, baby, and I came in and sat with Denise. She was super attentive, sweet, and knowledgeable about the food. I have a wild child and she was able to help calm her by getting her food out quickly and efficient. I would definitely request her over and over again! read more

Lexi B.

177

11 years ago

This is our favorite restaurant for breakfast here in siesta! Our server Sheila was so great and explained almost everything on the menu, she was so helpful!! Can't wait to come back next year!! read more

Madeline D.

4 years ago

I've been going to Siesta and have always wanted to try this place. It did not disappoint! Calling ahead was a good idea. Food was delicious and our server was very friendly and accommodating:) read more

Lily G.

5 years ago

Amazing breakfast! Bit of a wait so I suggest adding 20 mins to whatever they say your wait time will be. Food was so good though and service was amazing too. Worth the wait for sure. read more

Lisa P.

5 years ago

We love our stops at Another Broken Egg in Siesta Key! James and Anna O. are the best! Great service and great suggestions! Can't wait to be back. Great job team Siesta! read more

Predator X.

5 years ago

Stacy was out waitress and was also amazing, had our order taken very quickly and made sure everything was how we wanted. Definitely coming back! read more

Isabel L.

1 year ago

We go every year with our special needs nephew who is in a wheelchair. The staff are very helpful and kind with him. Food is always wonderful! read more

Chris W.

5 years ago

Breakfast was great - as usual! Staci was our waitress - very ver nice and friendly. Again, food is fantastic - lots of great options.

Denise P.

5 years ago

I absolutely love the food and atmosphere of this place. Service is amazing and our server John was fabulous. Highly recommend

Brittany S.

11 years ago

Best breakfast ever! We've been here for three days and eaten here every day so far. Miles is also our favorite server!

Scott R.

12 years ago

Great breakfast spot on the key. Other choices available but if you're down for a week, make sure to stop and try.

Bradley B.

5 years ago

Stacy was an incredible server. Her smile and hospitality was a delight!! Always an enjoyable time.

Jeff C.

5 years ago

The food is great, and they are always faster to seat you than they predict. Always worth the wait.

Greg H.

5 years ago

James was great... and the food even better! Thank you for a great experience. We'll be back!

Another Broken Egg Cafe - breakfast_brunch - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Another Broken Egg Cafe also viewed

Allswell

4.2

(50 reviews)

We decided to stop in Sarasota for a quick lunch halfway through our recent road trip and…read morediscovered the beautiful Waterside Place neighborhood. There are quite a few restaurants to choose from in this little area, and Allswell caught our eye. It is a elevated gastrobar and Irish pub serving up comfort food favorites. The interior has a vintage art deco feel and it was pretty chill on a late Sunday afternoon. We got a table inside -- they also have a large outdoor patio, but it's too hot right now. The service was quick which we appreciated. I started with the zero-proof "Spritz Me Softly" (lyres italian aperitif, sparkling lemonade, fever tree elderflower tonic, & citrus) which was light and refreshing. For food, we ordered the French onion soup and the classic fish & chips. Both were delicious and their fries are perfection. They have really mastered the French onion soup. My reason for giving 4 stars is that they seem to have a fly problem inside, which made the experience much less enjoyable. We were being swarmed by tons of flies throughout our entire meal, constantly swatting them away. They kept landing on my husband & son's heads. We were seated at the table nearest to the kitchen. All the doors & windows were closed, so it was a bit concerning that there were so many. Hopefully they get that issue sorted out.

AGAIN, another awesome experience at Allswell! Went yesterday for Mother's Day and enjoyed another…read moregreat meal! Had no problem getting reservations a few dates before, had a great outdoor table that was definitely better than being inside. Our server-Makayla, arrived immediately, helped us through their brunch menu and returned shortly with our drinks. I have to tell ya that their "limitless" Bloody Marys and Mimosas for only $25 is a great deal!! Of course we had to order their FAMOUS Banana Old Fashioned, a Bloody Mary and a Hugo Spritz. We ordered the following brunch entrees: -Truffle Mushroom Omelette -Signature Allswell Burger -Full Monty Sandwich -Chicken & Waffle Stack EVERYTHING WAS ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS, HOT AND VERY TASTY! Job WELL DONE the Vicky and her ENTIRE team! This place is definitely my new go to place to eat. Can't wait to see their new restaurant concept that's going into the old McGrath's location on Main Street in LWR. If they do as good of a job there as they do in Waterside, I'll definitely have another place to add to my 'regular' places to go!

EVOQ Sarasota

3.6

(43 reviews)

EVOQ was such a great experience from the moment we walked in. We received a really friendly…read morewelcome, and the staff was warm, attentive and genuinely great throughout the meal. I also loved the convenience of having such a good restaurant right in the hotel, especially when you're traveling. The Sugarcane Shrimp was absolutely the star of the show and definitely something I'd order again. Great food, great staff and such an easy, enjoyable experience!

This is the restaurant in the lobby of our Westin hotel. It was a modern bright, beautiful room…read morewith walls of floor to ceiling windows, and a view of the marina. Our complementary breakfast is served here, each morning. We had a waitress serving us our coffee and drinks, we went up to the buffet. At the buffet we enjoyed hot & cold cereals, yogurts, pastries, breads, fruits, eggs, potatoes, and meats. Everything was perfect, a nice way to start the day. Breakfast options were fresh, delicious and beautifully presented.

Boca

4.0

(943 reviews)

We came here with a large group for dinner and the food and service were both excellent! Our waiter…read morewas kind and attentive! We ordered a lot of appetizers and drinks and everything came out in a timely manner! I love the ambiance of the place and the bathrooms were clean! I feel like this could be a perfect date night spot!

Very disappointed by the false advertising. Boca promotes that they serve lunch, but if you visit…read moreon the weekend, you'll quickly find out that they only offer a brunch menu with very limited lunch options. We specifically came expecting a lunch experience based on their advertising and were frustrated to discover that wasn't the case. There's a big difference between serving lunch and serving brunch with a few lunch items sprinkled in. Restaurants should be transparent about what they actually offer so customers can make informed decisions before visiting. If you're looking for a true lunch menu on the weekend, this may not be the place for you.

Lo’ Key Island Grille

4.3

(82 reviews)

Food and service were awesome! Very different environment from other options on LBK…read more The daily specials are a nice touch for variety. Pricing is also competitive!

This is where the locals go. Why? Because we know the great places on LBK. There's something tasty…read morefor everyone on the menu, the servers serve with pride to be serving such delicious food, and the ambiance is a laid-back beachy feel that will keep you coming back.

Yard House

4.2

(352 reviews)

Definitely a disappointment this time! We went at 6:30pm tonight (Friday). The place was very…read morebusy but we were able to make an online reservation as we were pulling into the mall. We were greeted immediately upon arriving and sat right away. Our server, Justin, arrived at our table immediately. He was very friendly, professional and sincere. And with OUT being annoying, was vigilant in getting our drink orders and then our food decisions. We chose the chicken fingers & fries app, 2 burgers and a Cobb salad. Justin then asked if we wanted all the food together or he'll wait 3 minutes after our chicken finger app. We chose for him to order our entrees after the app was delivered. LITERALLY, LITERALLY 30 seconds after he walked away from our table, our chicken finger appetizer was delivered. WAYYYYYY to quickly we all thought, and we were right. Both the chicken fingers and fries were BARELY warm! They basically just sent us out an order that was very obviously sitting under the warmer TOO LONG! Shame on them for 'selling' dead food. Justin came by and apologized and took the plate. After a few minutes, the plate came out again, NOT hot but warmer/hotter than the first one. Our entrees were delivered about 5 minutes later. The burgers were cooked perfectly to what we asked for and the salad was cold. Now the sides we ordered with our burgers: Sweet potato fries, NOT hot and crunchy and served with pieces of their fried Brussel sprouts on the bottom. The other burger had Onion Ring as a side. WARM, NOT HOT, soft not crunchy, and just overall nasty. We were hungry and I did not complain when Justin checked back with us. Overall, the problem was anything fried. So whoever worked the 'inside' and 'outside' kitchen windows obviously were just grabbing anything that they needed to 'sell'. Bathrooms were clean but this was the first time that I had bad food. I personally feel that this was a completely avoidable situation...and I blame kitchen staff for not taking the time to serve their normally very good food. There are soooooo many other restaurants now in the area, they can't afford to take short cuts with their food!

Walking in, they already had a table ready for us since we were with a large group working with…read moreMote. The service started off great right away--getting drinks going and giving us time to look over the appetizers. Since we were on a work lunch, everyone ordered appetizers, which meant we got to share a lot of delicious food. I ordered the Spicy Tuna Stack, and it was DELICIOUS. The tuna was fresh, and the edamame, cucumber, and avocado complemented it really well. Overall, I would order that again and again. I was also able to try the Brussels sprouts, which were vegetarian-friendly and absolutely delicious. They were seasoned really well. The last appetizer I tried was the Firecracker Shrimp. They were AMAZING! We couldn't get enough of them, so we ended up ordering a second round. For my lunch entrée, I ordered the Lobster Garlic Noodles. These are the only reason this wasn't a perfect 5/5 experience. They were good, but unfortunately all of the seafood mixed into the dish made it a little too salty. Also, another person at the table ordered the same dish and had two or three more shrimp than I did, so that was a bit of a bummer. Still, this was a great experience overall. I believe our server's name was Julian, or something that started with a J, and he did an amazing job. If I'm ever back in the area, I'll definitely make sure to visit again.

H2O Bistro

4.0

(21 reviews)