Our server, Maggie, was amazing!! Food was delicious, big portions, and everything came quickly. Highly recommend!

After having to reschedule coming here on my birthday weekend I was glad I finally got to come out and experience Another Broken Egg. I was greeted warmly when I arrived and despite it being a busy Sunday the wait was relatively short. The music selections added to the lively and family friendly ambience of the cafe. Our server was very helpful, timely, and anticipated our needs before we had to ask (which is a huge plus in my book). The menu has a nice balance of savory and sweet as well as traditional breakfast items and new creations while staying true to their southern inspired roots. I opted for the Mardi Gras omelette which was amazing and opted for the breakfast potatoes which were seasoned to perfection! If you are ever in the Nickel Plate District this is a great brunch location for couples and families alike. This is most definitely not "just another brunch spot". read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Mardis Gras Omelette w/ potatoes & english muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

The Manager of Fishers is cool He sat us outside- it was super busy The food was out of this world!!! I had the Lucy Omelette with grits - best grits I've ever had My wife had the Lobster/Brie omelette- delicious!!! read more

We love another broken egg cafe! I only wish it was just a little cheaper. But definitely delicious

We haven't eaten out a lot during the pandemic (takeout warriors) but tried this place last weekend. We sat outside and the food was so good. I like that the kids meals come with scrambled eggs. A little protein with pancakes never hurt a toddler :). The service was fantastic. It was so great last weekend that we went again this morning. Corris was our server and she literally makes you feel like you are in her home. She recommended a few things and she was spot on. The food was so good again! The fruit was super fresh. The coffee is also really great. We also loved that during both trips the owner or manager came out to ask if we needed anything. I guess we will see you next weekend, Corris & co :). read more

Stopped in on a Saturday afternoon with many in the Fishers area, thankfully the wait was quoted around 35 minutes and we likely even less. The host stand will take your phone number and text you when your seat is ready. Which his very convenient to allow you to wander around the area. The staff was very friendly and pleasant. After being seated the friendly waitress took our drinks and reviewed the menu. Unfortunately that didn't help narrow down the food options much as the selection of good food seemed very large. I ended up going with the suggested Lucy Omelet. It was a great omelette, the potatoes were nice and crispy, I added upgraded to an additional pancake for 50 cent. I look forward to coming back and tackling this menu. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Boozy coffee drinks. I just wanted to make sure I got that out there, because that was my favorite part. Captain + Caffeine (before noon)= Great Weekend. They also had different flavored Bloody Marys, which I'm sad I didn't get to try. I went for it when I ordered. "Yolo'd" if you will. Lobster and Brie omelette with champagne butter sauce. My mother would be so proud. Although some bites were delicious, my stomach hurt afterwards. Too much of a good thing I guess? Maybe a little over the top... All in all, it has your classics, and it has some fun choices. I thought it would be pretty basic based off the logo, but it's worth the try! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Lobster + Brie omelette - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

5 stars all the way! The food is outstanding, and far more than one can eat...but we gave it our best as it seemed a shame to leave any food. Even better than the food was the service! Our server was amazing; he is kind, awesome at his job, and just a complete joy! Austin, thank you so much for the fantastic service and being such a blessing to our family! We appreciate & see how hard you work. read more

I love this restaurant for family brunch. And our sevice today was outstanding. Our waitress was Corris, and she was by far the best server we've had in a long time. She was super helpful, mindful of our alergy issues, and handled my large family with ease and finesse. She was very knowledgeable and she made great recommendations. She enhanced the visit with her amazing energy and and speedy service. Oh, and the food was great, too. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Lobster and Brie omelet and Banana Foster pancake - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We had a lovely impromptu Monday breakfast here at ABEC in Fishers. My partner ordered the Louisiana Scramble, which was hearty and well done. I had the power waffle (ask for extra strawberries for a bit of sweetness) with scrambled eggs and chicken sausage. Everything was on point, especially the coffee. And our server, Kyle was fantastic and very attentive. Looking forward to coming back soon! read more

Went to Another Broken Egg for the first time for brunch with my sister and a friend. The atmosphere was relaxing but also upbeat. Our waitress, Elise, was so friendly, hospitable, and really took her time to walk us through the menu. I had the eggs black stone benedict--it was delicious! I'm not a coffee drinker, but my sister said their medium roast coffee was amazing. We will definitely be back! read more

Jumped on the waitlist through yelp which was very helpful. The wait was a little longer than anticipated but they can't help that. They were really great about the wait. The coffee was good. We both had cinnamon roll French toast. The sausage patties were great and tasted homemade. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

The first thing that impressed me with my experience here was how promptly we were greeted as soon as we walked in the door. We were sat super quick & our waitress was at our table within 30 seconds of getting sat down. It wasn't a rushed feeling but more so like we were important to them. It wasn't too busy for a Friday lunch but I'm sure we would've gotten the same service had it been busy too. The manager found out it was our first time & gave us a small signature mason jar & four complimentary beignets (which were amazing by the way!). I love that even though it's just a brunch place they still had a good variety of adult drinks from single drinks to pitchers. I got a single Strawberry St. Germain which has champagne. It was a little too sweet for me but I'll definitely be back to try more! They have champagne drinks with fruit, mimosas, & even a signature Bloody Mary. Definitely worth the try! For my meal I had the Hey Lucy Omelette that has things like avocado, chorizo, sautéed onions, & cheddar jack cheese. It was pretty good and a great size portion! I really do like this place & can't wait to come back to try new food & drinks! read more

See all

Got complimentary beignets because it was our first time dinning in. Delicious!!! That orange marmalade was the perfect combo, it melted in your mouth. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

One of my favorite brunch places in Indianapolis. Love their eggs and fruit juices...

So I've been here a couple of times and I can say each time has been amazing. I remember the first time that I went was with my mom and the restaurant first opened. The wait staff was courteous and very patient. I think since the restaurant had just opened and it was our first time we did get their biscuit beignets for free. Furthermore, each time I go I'm always asked if I have been there before and am thanked that I'm a returning customer. Although, when you see the location parking may seem like a hassle, however with the newly built parking garages and street parking, I've never had an issue with parking. Let's talk about the biscuit beignets, first of all they are AMAZING. Just get an order you won't be sorry. You can order a full or half order. I do appreciate this because they are very high in calories. They always have seasonal selections which are fun because I do love my favorites at restaurants but having some seasonal selections is really great. It can change up my routine and am never disappointed. The service is always impeccable. Additionally if you sit outside you could bring your well behaved doggie with you. Even better, they have a water bowl for the dogs as well. Again it's just the little details that I think set restaurants apart. Lastly, their menu may seem overwhelming however, they always offer a "menu tour". This is great because their wait staff can walk you through different entrees you may like. read more

We dined here for the 2nd time on Sunday. I must say, this is hands down one of the best brunch spots, and this location has such amazing customer service! We were able to be seated right away outside, and our server, Mikali, was top notch. We were blown away when she said it was her 2nd week. She was so caring and attentive, and also let us enjoy ourselves. The food was melt in your mouth delicious. I had the Floridian Omelette which has crab meat and cream cheese. So so good and my fiancé had the broken egg biscuit sandwich and he said it was the best fried chicken breakfast sandwich he has ever had. Mimosas and drinks are always excellent. See you again soon!! read more

See all

Always good service and yummy brunch food! Never much of a wait with indoor and outdoor and bar seating options. I recommend!

We were warmly welcomed by the hostess immediately upon arrival. Holly, our server, was wonderful in every way and made our experience enjoyable (no small feat with a toddler in tow). Food and drinks were outstanding. The restaurant and surrounding area had an unexpected power outage. Sean, part of management, adapted effortlessly and the staff maintained focus. My wife and I previously worked "in the biz." We expected just brunch -- instead, we were legit impressed. We will be back. read more

Very good! Ordered the fried chicken and waffles and a smore hot chocolate. The chicken was boneless but juicy and crispy. The waffle was warm and soft and really complemented the chicken. The beverage was not amazing but it was pretty good, nothing ground breaking that I would buy again. But overall cool vibes, great place for brunch and hanging out with friends and pretty fast and friendly service. read more

I was doing some running around in Fishers. I search for breakfast spots and came upon this place. They had outdoor seating and indoor seating with mask requirement. I was greeted by a nice host who sat me. She recommended the specials. I quickly decided to get the blackberry stuffed French toast. Yum! It was so bomb. I paired it with some green tea and that was the best decision I have made in the longest time.I was please with the food and service. Definitely will re-visit. read more

Really good breakfast/brunch! The drinks are great as well, and I really enjoyed our bartender the last time we were there. I believe her name was Ashley! She was awesome. read more

Don't even waste your money. Ever since the had a change in management this location is poorly managed. Flavorless stale food. Slow service. Overpriced. Went in for a bday brunch and completely ruined our time together read more

A sandwich I didn't know I needed. I don't usually like breakfast sandwiches but the chicken biscuit is so good. I'm already planning my next visit. It really taste homemade reminded me of something my grandma would've made. My husband had an omelette which he devoured. Loved being able to add pancakes for only a few dollars. Coffee is great as well. Can't wait to go again. read more

See all

It was a very pleasant experience once I walked in the door. The staff greeted us right away and showed us to a nice quiet, comfortable booth. I was impressed by the diversity of the menu. The food was great and the potatoes were perfect! I didn't think potatoes could be more delicious until I ate here. They had it seasoned perfectly and not greasy it all. Food was fast as well despite the amount of people that were there. The ambience was relaxing and the music was great. They played a really nice set of songs that day. The wait staff was very corteous and kept checking on us. Best service I had in a while. Everything just went well the moment I ooened the doors. To me it wasn't just breakfast, it was a pleasant memory. I would keep coming back here if only it was close to me. Hopefully the restaurant doesn't change and that continue to give nice memories to their customers read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Two things I love--breakfast foods, quality customer service. This place delivers on both!!  I was blown away by how outstanding the service was here.  A friend and I came in for breakfast one Sunday morning.  We started out with one waitress who walked us through the whole menu since it was my first time there, but then had to go do something else, so we got a second waitress.  There was no difference between the two of them, it was like she had been with us the whole time.  Both of them were incredibly nice, helpful, and patient. Really great service. The food... (faints thinking about it) It was so good!!  They have a big 'gluten friendly' menu and substitute gf pancakes for muffins, toast, etc.  I had with the Bacquezo Omelette with a gf pancake and a side of city grits.  This omelette comes stuffed with warm cream cheese and topped with bacon, chorizo, cheese, and onion.  Best omelette I've ever had.  Cream cheese in an omelette might sound weird, but it's not, it's perfect.  Solid pancake.  And if everyone made their grits like they do, everyone would love grits. They have gouda cheese, bacon, tomatoes, and onion in them.  My friend ordered the Mardi Gras Omelette with a side of potatoes, a lemon, blueberry, goat cheese pancake, and a strawberry mimosa.  She also loved her food.  And because it was my first time there we got a free order of beignets with orange marmalade.  They aren't gf, but they were totally worth eating.  I was expecting them to be like a doughnut--they are not. They're crunchy on the outside, soft and fluffy on the inside, and not overly sweet.  I left with over half my food still, and a new go to breakfast place!! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Ate here the other day for the first time on a whim and eneded up absolutely loving it! Our server Kyle was awesome as well!

They were amazing. I had the shrimp and grits with side of crab cake which I ate with my grits. (AMAZING) .They went together perfectly. The shrimp was nice and sweet. It was just enough shrimp that it balanced out with the cheese grits. The crab cake was good alone but I love it with my grits. The cornbread beignets was AMAZING. I ate them all except one. Hot and fluffy in the middle. This was our first time coming, we will definitely be coming back. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Shrimp and cheese grits and crab cake. Both are good alone but paired together you will thank me later. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

No wait on a busy Saturday morning??!! How's that even possible?! Any other weekend morning I'd dread going somewhere since there's always a wait; however, this morning we used the "Join The Waitlist" option through Yelp. If an establishment has that option, by all means use it. The wait time was 40 minutes but we signed in from home and took our time getting there. Yelp let us know our place in line and accurately stated there was one party before us when we got there. Great feature! Now, moving on to the restaurant. The staff was probably the friendliest I've encountered without that "ChickFilA weirdness" vibe. Everyone seemed to be in good spirits and no one had that "You're not my table, so I can't help". We ended up picking two items off their Fall selection. The Pumpkin Waffles and I had the Lobster Benedict with "City Grits". I'm not a grits guy, but their City Grits has garlic, scallions, tomatoes and chunky chunks of bacon. #ChunkyChunks Speaking of chunky, huge chunks of lobster topped my Eggs Benedict. Delicious and will continue to come back. So many other things I want to try. read more

See all

My 15 year old daughter ate there yesterday with a friend. Their server offered them a refill on their apple juice, which they accepted assuming it was free. Well, they were wrong. It was $3.99 per glass. It feels very wrong to have a server take advantage of 2 teenagers. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Another Broken Egg is my new brunch spot. Brunch with mimosas are my favorite meal. This is a great spot to meet your girlfriends and catch up over a great meal. Caroline was our server and she was really sweet and on top of it. Caroline suggested the strawberry and St. Germain mimosas---we went for the pitcher. We started with beignets and orange marmalade. The guy who brought them out suggested bananas fosters sauce and it was yummy! We ordered chicken and waffles, shrimp and grits, lobster and brie omelette. Everything was great. I ordered the omelette and it came with city grits---- grits, bacon, tomatoes, and green onions. They were very creamy and full of flavor. My omelette was huge---it became Monday's breakfast. I wasn't sure about the omelette being stuffed with cream cheese but all of the flavors came to together and was topped with a brie and champagne butter sauce....yummmm. Grab your friends and head to Another Broken Egg for brunch you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Ordered crab Benedict taste was ok... Food was room temperature at best. English muffin was soggy and crab cake was mushy. Definitely tasted like it was prepared the night before and put in the microwave. It wasn't busy so no excuse for food not being fresh. Server was nice and mimosa (lemon blueberry) was delicious. Not extremely mad but won't come back. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe is almost always packed when I got there, and there's definitely a reason why... this place is great! They have so many food options and whether you want sweet or savory brunch, you'll be able to get it. They also have delicious breakfast cocktails and even make suggestions on the menu of what cocktails go best with certain breakfast items. I try different dishes every time I go in there, but the one constant I have is getting the beignets with the orange marmalade as an appetizer. Not only is the food good, but I also have to mention the staff. They're always so friendly and attentive! They'll also make suggestions if you can't decide what to get since it all sounds so good. read more

Its impossible to make a wrong selection with their menu. The environment is quaint yet bustling. Staff helpful and friendly! We keep coming back read more

Shrimp and grits is a must with city grits! The crab cake Benedict is also super delicious. The breakfast spiked coffees are good but I'm not into sweets so this may be for you if you're one to add cream and sugar to coffee rather than taking it black like me read more

Great brunch place. Service has always been great for our group of 7. Food comes out quick, nice variety of menu that is always well done. The menu rotates so that there is always something new but still has staples. Food can be pretty hearty though, generally not light fair. read more

Each dish here is absolutely delicious! I've been here many times and am NEVER disappointed. It is very popular on weekends so either get here very early or be patient to wait. read more

Finally tried this place and I think it's my new favorite for brunch. I had the shrimp and grits that blew my mind! The flavor of the sauce on top of the grits with shrimp and andouille sausage was amazing. Big thanks to my waiter who recommended I try it. I loved it and it might be hard for me to try other items, but I would love to come back for more menu selections and try the mimosas. I love that all the food is southern inspired. If other meals are as great as the shrimp and grits, I'll be coming back regularly! read more

See all

This place was amazing. Not only was the food one of the best breakfast meals I've bet had these service was beyond what you would get at your average restaurant. From the hostess to the server to the manager on staff they made sure our meal was no less then perfect! I would highly recommend this place for a nice drink and a pancake! We had eggs Benedict (best I've had), brisket cornbread waffle and French toast with the coolest kids milk! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Eggs Benedict with grilled tomatoes and smothered potatoes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Another Broken Egg Cafe is a pretty great way to start your day! Our visit started before we arrived, when I selected the option to be added to the waitlist through the Yelp app. This meant that we got through the 15-25 minute wait that everyone else experienced while we drove! When we arrived, we walked in the door and waited maybe 2-3 minutes before being shown to our table. The gentleman who seated us was very friendly and helpful, identifying us as first time customers and showing us around the menu. As he did, he made a few recommendations which sounded so good that all three of us ordered them! I ordered the Carnitas Benedict which consisted of a Mexican spiced pulled pork over savory jalapeño cornbread and poached eggs with chipotle hollandaise sauce. Omg so good! Both of my brunchmates opted for the second recommendation, which was a Bacquezo Omelet. Cream cheese, bacon and chorizo! They both loved them! If there was anything wrong at all, I would advise the staff to pay closer attention to the toasting of English muffins and to make sure the grits don't sit too long before coming out to the table. Everything else was amazing! Overall our trip was fantastic and I will definitely go back. read more