There's a lot of social media hype about Andrew's having one of the best pastrami sandwiches in Staten so of course I had to try it. All pastrami I eat is judged by Katz ' which sets the bar. This was thinner but amazing tasting never the less, soft and melted in your mouth. The sandwich comes in under $20 which is amazing compared to Katz' $32. Another amazing pastrami sandwich is Sandwich and pickle in Staten. Besides the sandwich their onion rings were crunchy and a nice size portion. I highly recommend them both read more

Andrew's Diner - Onion rings - Diners Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Amazing service, food, and clean family style restaurant. Portions are incredible including the specials of the day! George and Gus take their time to welcome everyone and are well known in the community. It's a pleasure to interact with the owners and staff and we must not forget to have a fresh dessert after our meal! I enjoy their rice pudding... a must for me after every visit! read more

Andrew's Diner in Staten Island on Hylan Blvd has the WORST service EVER! I arrived 10 minutes before opening. I sat down and the waitress brought me coffee. I had asked for milk and she brought me half & half. So i got up to ask for milk and she tells me with an attitude that they open at 8am. I apologized and said i wasn't aware. I sat back down and waited patiently for the waitress. Well! She had the nerve to take someone else's order when i arrived first! Since she had already served me coffee, i left $3 for THE COFFEE, NOT HER TIP, and I left! NOT ONLY IS THE SERVICE TERRIBLE BUT SO WAS THE ATTITUDE! I'll NEVER go back there again! read more

On my few trips to Staten Island I've enjoyed getting the good old fashioned diner experience at Andrew's diner. Even though both times were very packed and busy we had 0 wait on walking in. Food is standard diner sized proportions.. which to me is I can't finish it all in one sitting. The first time I got waffles with a side of turkey sausage and scrambled eggs. Waffles were crispy on the outside and perfectly fluffy and soft inside. I got a side of sugar free syrup on request, which was nice that they were able to accommodate that. One of the other times I got a pastrami omelette which was gargantuan. Easily could have fed 3 people, if you consider the side of home fries it came with. Whenever I'm back in SI will definitely try to make it in for a breakfast sitting at Andrew's Diner. read more

Andrew's Diner - Diners Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Food is consistently good. Service is great. Place is dated but it has an old school diner charm. I would recommend going. The pastrami is pretty good. read more

See all

Nice diner . Enjoyed my meatloaf platter that was a luncheon special with soup and potato and vegetable. Great service. Friendly staff and owner kept checking ig all was good. Limited parking in front so may have to walk to side street. read more

We sat down at 1. It's 1:14 and the server came. Not terrible. She knew the menu when we asked her questions. I ordered the onion soup and the gyro platter and my guest had the tuna. The soup was very good 9 out of 10 and the gyro platter was plenty good. My guest said the tuna salad was awesome and only had half, it was so big. I took a cannoli home and it was good. I'm glad we found this diner. The owner came over with a bit of olive oil and suggested some for my side Greek salad. Friendly service and staff. All in all pretty reasonable 60 with tip. read more

See all

I love everything about Andrew's diner. The food, waitresses, bus boys and the warm welcome always. My favorite is the pastrami. Wish it was closer to home. Maybe once or twice a month I go. There prices are affordable to me, I been to many diners. Andrew's my favorite. read more

This is a quiet and sleepy diner. That isn't an insult... love places like this but they need a little background music or something. Food was your typical diner fare. Loved the muffin and omelette. Can't go wrong with the comfort food here. Food comes out hot and fast. read more

This is the perfect Greek diner. Spanakopita and souvlaki are spot on. Don't miss the cod filet. Get extra lemon wedges with everything and wash it down with a Metaxa at the end. Service was friendly and accurate. read more

great service -and pleasant hosts & servers, delicious food too. George always greets his customers like family which makes people want to go back " home" fir a meal. read more

Owned by A Gent Always nice to the fam and kids Good food Best diner spot on the island read more

I've been here several times already and I have to say excellent service. Amazing food and George is amazing. He's the owner of the restaurant. read more

I went to have lunch with a friend. We ask for hamburgers , soup , and a salad that was absolutely delicious. The owner came to our table, he was kind and we knew that he is a very successful chef. The restaurant's decoration was with many natural plants and flowers . It is a very warm and nice place to share lunch or dinner . There is not doubt that we come back again !! read more

The staff for this diner is so friendly and accommodating! I have to say this is the best diner experience I ever have for Staten Island. They make the best eggs and potatoes for a diner style breakfast. read more

I love Andrew's diner. All of the waitor and waitresses are phenomenal and very attentive to customers. The food here is amazing. Just had a breakfast date yesterday I highly recommend the pancakes & omelettes. So yummy & great staff read more

Tonight was my 2nd time at Andrew's Diner, my 4 year old has been asking to go back for the "super nice lady" waitress named Tara! We honestly couldn't ask for better service, and someone who really knew everything to do to make dining out with two young children (ages 3&4) easier! Wish you encountered more people like her! The food is delicious, we had a Greek wrap with amazing Tzatziki sauce, Italian wrap and the kids loved their chicken tenders and fries. We will be back and requesting to sit at Tara's table read more

Andrew's Diner - Diners Near Me - Staten Island, New York

My family and I have been going to Andrew's and ordering for years. The last few orders, have been totally wrong. Tonight, we ordered and got something completely different. We didn't want the food they sent and just wanted a refund. The manager/owner came on the phone and was SOOOOO RUDE!!! They are actually coming back to pick up panini that we didn't order so please be careful ordering, you never know where your food is actually coming from!! They just lost great customers. The owner should be ashamed of himself!!! Also, there wasn't an option for 0 stars! read more

Over due for this review; my family & I have been loyal customers since Andrews opened... my dad Artie aka "the Gip" & Artie Junior love this family owned business .... We don't care want you order over here they never disappoint !!! My personal favorite is their mixed grill when it's on the menu..... Tonight me & the wife went with the seafood & chicken paella served in your own personal Lil pot !!! Very tasty, clams, mussels, shrimp & lobster & Scallops cooked to perfection!!! My brother went with their unbelievable looking boneless ribeye steak !! I tried it it was delicious!!! My sister went with their mussels fra diavolo over linguine which was delicious also tasted that !!! My other brother went with the meatloaf which he enjoyed very much ... also looked awesome !! My daughter went with the philly cheese steak & onion hero .... my kid loved it as well !!! Went with the Saturday night complete dinner's served with soup ( cream of turkey was off the chain delicious ) and a nice garden salad your choice of dressing... I love their blue cheese !!!!! Deserts; Carrot cakes, Coconut lemon cake, Apple cheese puff !!!! Very good coffee as well ... Always greeted with a smile & friendly service !!!! Thanks to the entire team from the back of the house to the front of the house for always giving my family a great food experience !! Can't wait to come back !!! Greg D & family read more

See all

they forgot my pickle in my chicken finger deluxe even though it said on the menu it came with it. i'm greatly disappointed, not to mention the diner was full of old trump supporters and whining ass babies. don't go here. they also shot a load in my burger. read more

Used to go alot and get the pastrami and it was good but a bit expensive. Last time I went for lunch with a friend of mine and we both had the pastrami and 1 onion rings and 2 sodas and an order of cole slaw. They charged us for refills and $ 10 dollars for an order of cole slaw!! Ridiculous!!! The bill was $65 with the tip!!! I asked why do they charge for refills and the waitress said all the places are doing that after covid. I go to Mike's on hylan and arden and they never charge me for a refill!!! From now on if I want pastrami ill go to harrolds in Edison!!! Get 3 times the amount of food for what I spent and Andrews!! read more

My daughter and Son in law took me here on a. Sunday Morning. We were greeted nicely and didn't even have to wait even though it was almost packed. I ordere silver dollar pancakes with a side of bacon. Food is delicious. Good amount . Coffee was great. Highly recommend read more

This is a neighborhood diner that is a great place for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The service was very good.

Great Food friendly staff food was brought out on time nice atmosphere. The staff makes sure everything is good can eat outdoors or inside. I have gone back few times with my friend, read more

Andrew's Diner - Home fries eggs over easy and bacon - Diners Near Me - Staten Island, New York

My wife was here with her friend so I asked her to pick me up a pastrami and Swiss cheese panini.. omg it was the best thing I ever tasted!! Huge and absolutely delicious!! I'll definitely be going back for more!! read more

We were in the mood for diner food and happened to drive by this place on the way home. I just recently moved to Staten Island so wasn't sure where to go. We ordered a few appetizers and some entrees and absolutely everything was delicious and great portions! The place was clean and so so friendly. Service was quick and efficient. I definitely will be going back. read more

Ordered the Pastrami on Rye and it was lean, a decent sized portion and reasonably priced compared to NYC and NJ. Waitress was pleasant, owner stoped at the table and asked how was our order. Place was clean including the restroom. Ordered French fries and Onion rings. Complimentary pickles and coleslaw included. Small parking lot, but more than enough street parking on both side streets. read more

Andrew's Diner - Pastrami on Rye - Diners Near Me - Staten Island, New York

As far as Diners go, this is right up there. From food to service (Thank you Tara) it's all quite good. read more

Had a phenomenal experience here the other night - Ordered fish dinner- everything was superior quality , large portions, non buttery- perfection Kids chix and fries good yummy chix Service was excellent It was clean The lady even went above and beyond and brought cookies for the kids Will definitely be back here Great diner!!!! read more

My mother's grave is on Staten Island and the last time I visited her grave this past Christmas, I stopped at Andrew's diner because I was hungry. I'll admit that I am not a diner lover because the food tends to be okay not great. I ordered a roast beef plate and strawberry shortcake. The portions are large however the roast beef had a lot of fat and the strawberry shortcake had strawberry filling and no strawberries. I was a bit surprised but understand that when you eat out at a new place it can be hit or miss. If you like diner food and the portions, then this will be the place for you. read more

Just like moms cooking. Hubby had corn beef & cabbage; he loved this very proportioned this dish. I had a small bread filled with pea soup! It was scrumptious. It's always a treat to eat there. read more

Good size portions, but heavy food and you're going to pay a good amount for what you get. Wasn't much impressed and was a bit hard to digest. read more

This restaurant is to die for!! The first time I walked in there I was received with a warm welcome! I was so amazed at all the food selections! Whenever I go there I order chicken noodle soup or rice, it depends what the soup of the day is! The chicken noodle soup/rice is made with noodles or rice, broth, carrots, celery and chicken. This soup is the best soup you will ever have in your whole life! The last time I went there I tried something different. I ordered buffalo wings, which I normally don't. It was a little spicy but not too spicy, the perfect flavor your craving for. I have been ordering at this restaurant for 3 years now. It is one of the best dinners that I have been to. The waiters and the manager are so nice to all their customers. If your in the area make sure to stop by and check it out! read more

Super sweet and cute place. Amazing service! Food is incredible! Drinks are awesome! I haven't had diner food this great in many years... Hands down the best diner on the island, and better than any diner in Brooklyn and Queens. From the second you walk through the doors till you leave. Absolutely incredible. 1000% recommend! read more

Had a great burger at Andrews Diner today! The big surprise was how the fries had a nice crunchy outside and moist inside. Also, following Covid-19 guidelines, checking temperature of everyone entering and they even give you a bottle of hand sanitizer on your table. you can see it in the picture. Also, they seemed to know everyone coming in, very friendly staff and George is hands on. read more

Andrew's Diner - American cheese Burger Medium well and a generous side of fries! - Diners Near Me - Staten Island, New York

LOVE IT HERE!!! The minute you walk in it feels like home. I started coming here over a month ago. And I was finding myself coming several times a week. Before SI shutting down areas again due to Covid they were operating magnificently. Clean, attentive and prompt! Service is incredible, food is tasty and portions are HUGE! I hope they open back up for dining in soon. They do have take out available. read more

$26 for a pastrami sandwich and fries? Sure as hell wasn't Katz's pastrami or anything close Very disappointed At one time I would have given 4 stars but as the prices have risen the quality of the food have fallen read more

We have been coming here for years. Staff is amazing and food is great. Probably the best dinner in Staten Island

Decent neighborhood diner. Consistent food and service at reasonable prices. Parking a little difficult at times.

We have been going for years and ordered for Thanksgiving. It was the worst experience. Not enough for 5 people. The turkey was dry and the food was tasteless. We had to go back to get more. How do you give a little tin for food that you promised would be enough. Hard earned money wasted. Bad business. When we got home, we realized no stuffing. Ruined our Thanksgiving. When I called to complain few days later, the owners answer was to give me the missed stuffing. What an insult. We will never be back. They lost very good customers.! Covid has been hard on all, but bad food and bad business is just terrible!!!! read more