Ordered delivery first time. Food was delivered hot and fresh. Very unique menu items. The Philly cheesesteak was good but the lik jawn egg rolls were delicious. read more

See all

Rady and the server behind the counter were "eggcelent" in their service and hospitality. From start to finish, they checked-in occasionally to ensure that the food was to your liking. I emphasized my take on the elote fries and Rady was kind enough to take my suggestion to heart. The burger was excellent in that it was perfectly cooked, flavorful, and the egg on top was cooked perfectly runny, which enhanced the umami of the overall burger. It was definitely a pleasant experience and their menu is so expansive that I can't wait to come back to try more of their other selections. For the elote fries, I hope they'll elevate it even more by making it more similar to actual elotes, by adding more corn and coating the fries a bit better with actual elote condiments and cheeses. Highly recommend giving them a try if you're down for a simple yet delicious burger! Thank you for reading and best of luck! (: read more

The Buttery - Hot Dogs Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

The milkshakes are great! My friend and I got the og burgers. I asked if they could wrap mine in lettuce and they did. Thankfully a place that seasons there burgers. Only down side was they burnt my friends bun and the fries made us nauseous. read more

The Buttery - Og burger in lettuce, fries and dulce de leche shake. - Hot Dogs Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I went here yesterday unfortunately didn't take any pictures. I was looking for a place that didn't use seed oils and this place popped up as they cook with beef tallow. The Works chicken cheesesteak was delicious. Their cheese fries were well priced and the staff were friendly. I really enjoyed the wall collage on the left when you walk in of different characters eating burgers. It appeared to be very clean inside although I took my food to go. If you're in Staten Island I definitely recommend giving them a try! read more

It's all made to order so you wait a bit but it is sooooo clean in there. Not really a welcoming environment but it is a sort of fast food type of vibe. Maybe that's why? Not sure, however the food is great. Never had a complaint. We only go to the Buttery because of the oil they use. They use beef tallow. Which is AMAZING. Try them! I don't think you'll be disappointed. read more

I have to give The Buttery a 10/10. It's rare that I get a burger and fries and don't feel the need to either season or douse them in sauce. Despite not needing it, the cashier remembered that I asked if they had honey mustard and it was unquestionably included in my order, which was appreciated. I ordered the Mild Chick Burger, the Sweetie Burger and Golden Tallow Fries and each of them were cooked to perfection. Everything that needed to be crispy was crispy and none were greasy. All in all, if you're in the mood for a juicy, flavorful smashburger and a cute, clean spot to grab a quick bite in, The Buttery is the place. read more

See all

Me and my girlfriend came here and we split the Sweetie burger along with the mild chick chicken sandwich, some fries, a peach lemonade and a Salaam cola. We immediately regretted we didn't come here earlier. This place is delicious! The staff is very attentive, the vibe inside has a classic burger spot feel and overall the pricing is very fair especially if you pay in cash. I WILL be coming back here often, probably the best burger I've had in the island that isn't from a more traditional pub. read more

The Buttery - Sweetie - Hot Dogs Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I had their food twice. My boyfriend has been coming here a few times. Their food is tasty. Staff is always nice and friendly. I will coming here a bit more read more

See all

I got a cheesesteak paired with the Raspberry Lemonade, It's dangerously amazing at a great price. Came with my family and we all left with full belly's. I definitely am coming back soon. The staff were kind and quick! The restaurant has a really great environment come by and try it out. read more

The Buttery - Cheesesteak and Raspberry Lemonade - Hot Dogs Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

The burgers were good, and the chocolate milkshake was excellent. My friend found the cheeseburger slightly overdone, but I enjoyed my chicken sandwich. Removing one star because the wait was a little long for two sandwiches and a shake. I expected it to come out quickly, but we were waiting close to 30 minutes. Also, the walls are covered in AI art which was a little disconcerting when I first entered. read more

Love this place! Idk what the other reviews are talking about. Ofc there is a wait as it's a small business and newly opened. The wait is definitely worth it! The freshness and quality is great. I love items like the jalapeño and cream cheese hot dogs and the elote fries. Nothing is skimpy either! You get two hot dogs in every order and the fries are filled to the top! I love the the fries aren't too salted so you can add as much salt for your liking. 10/10 a staple! read more

The Buttery - Chicken sandwich - Hot Dogs Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

CASH ONLY OR SIGNIFICANT CREDIT PREMIUMS GrubHub premium for pickup even more crazy. So walk in with cash. Walked in (thankfully) and ordered classic dog and classic burger. About $20 cash with tax and a counter tip. New and clean store. Brought home and they were both ok to good for the price. Other options and cheesesteaks available which I will try one day walking in with cash of course. So they add $1 for each item for credit card. Yes each item no matter the price. CREDIT CARD PREMIUM 5-17% wow! Cheesesteak $18.95 to 19.95 "only" 5.2 percent Burger 10.95 to 11.95 9%! Dog 5.95 to 6.95 16%! Fries 11-17% Lemonade 14% Cookie 17% GRUBHUB PICKUP MORE CRAZY. 30-46% Premium! Yes GrubHub charges high percentage and many businesses do charge something more for the convenience but 46% is nuts. Dog 5.95 to 8.69 46%! Burger 36% Cheesesteak 18.95 to 24.94 31% Fries 43-46% A cookie 46%!! GRUBHUB UPDATE 10/19/25: Looking now, Grubhub pickup prices are now just $1 more per item. Better now. So just 5-17% similar to walk-in $1/item for credit. Unless that changed also. read more

The Buttery - Menu with $1 credit card per item. - Hot Dogs Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Delicious burger, bad service. I brought my sons here because the last takeout order I got was delicious and the service was fast. This time, the server seemed to have forgotten about the order. We were #39 and when #41 received their more complicated order, we went up to ask. He fumbled around, went to the back twice, and then finally emerged with the late, now cold order--no apology or comment about being late. Maybe Monday evenings aren't the best time to go. My sons were disappointed and they do not plan to return. read more

So, this place "Sprang up" out of nowhere. And it created a "Flash mob" of Burger enthusiasts almost immediately. It's in a very difficult spot (especially for parking) but there is a "Legendary Pizza Spot" right across the street. To my surprise, no lines and only 2 diners in house? I realized rather quickly that this is a "Muslim Owned and Operated" establishment, which is AWESOME because I love Halal food, and I'd love to see the Halal communities spin on The Classic Burger Place. It was impeccably clean, very friendly and knowledgeable workers. Price wise, it's definitely on the "pricey" side. The Classic take on The Oklahoma Onion Burger, and beef tallow fried potatoes. The food in general was fresh and good. But not on a "Higher plane Good" somewhat disappointing. It's good, it's just missing that "Kick"! Everyone should still give it their own opinion. The Burger and Pizza world has WAY too many different opinions! Always support small businesses! And always give them a fair shot! For me. I have to be honest to my craft. I wish them nothing but success! read more

Bad service and pricey sandwiches. I had pieces of cartridge in my cheesesteak. umm.. why? Hard to park location. Directly across the street from Joe & Pats. read more

Impeccably clean, excellent customer service, and excellent food. We tried the classic double, eggcellent, chipotle chicken sandwich, chopped cheese burger and the disco fries, all 10/10! read more

The burger was delicious,tasted fresh not frozen. I enjoyed every bite. The only thing is that it's small, $11 for a this size burger is overpriced. Maybe a $7-8 burger. Maybe they should do two for $11. The hotdog was also delicious, good taste and the cheese sauce great, no need for katchup or mustard. The fries are great, very well priced and three can eat from this amount of fries they give you. Service was good. love the setup, ambiance is great. The place would be great for sporting events, they have several good size tv's. Overall, the food is great!!! read more