Really great experience with Andolini's. I'm always extremely satisfied. The food is consistently excellent and the service is top-notch. A real highlight this time was the general manager, Tyler. He was super accommodating, charming, and knew the menu inside out--his suggestions for what pairs well were spot on. I usually love eating in for the atmosphere, but I was home sick and opted for delivery. The delivery was quick and the food was just as good as being in the restaurant. Highly recommend this place. They do a great job all around. read more

First time here. Friday evening before the rush. We had a party of 3. They seemed to be short staffed as the hostess had to do double duty and clear tables in between meeting customers. We had to wait about 25 minutes to get our table. They did have a group of five people come in and got seated immediately in their outside dining area. We were not offered that option, so we were a little upset about that as we would've be seated in about 10 minutes vs 25 minutes. Our server was good, but hurried. Our drinks and pizza order was placed. Once our drinks were delivered, we noticed the syrup to carbonation ratio was off. We spoke to one of the managers and the situation was rectified immediately. Our pizza arrived and it was very good. The crust was real thick, but had a good chew and the ingredients were quality ones. We were kind of shell shocked that we had a large 3 topping pizza and sodas and it costs over $50. It's getting even crazier with these prices. read more

Might have been a bad night or draw on service. It started off with the waitress teetering on snarky, because we wanted to wait until the rest of our party arrived. I tried to order two different beers from the menu, both apparently out. I finally just asked for the house beer. I figured that would be in stock. We ordered , and I didn't really notice that the service person was not being attentive to the women . They did . Next , the food was just okay. We ordered a child's portion of fettuccini , which seemed crunchy and salty. We figured they grabbed the wrong shaker, and we took it off the ticket, all good. We finished and I paid. The server took off without a tip, which was fine , it wasn't tip worthy dining. Nor worth the almost $90 price for pizza and a couple subs and mozzarella . The girls only had water. I'll never go back, but the sign out front saying top dining experience in Tulsa area didn't match up to what we got. read more

This Pizzeria is located on a nice little strip so parking is on the sides of the road. We didn't have any trouble finding parking. When we walked in it wasn't really busy and we were seating quickly. The waiter was very friendly, professional and offered good recommendations. The ambiance was nice and a good place to sit and enjoy your company. We ordered the garlic knots to start with. They were good. I ordered the Italian Cobb salad. It is a very delicious salad and big enough to split with someone else. We ordered a 20 in pizza which was big. The slices are big. It was very good. I like thin pizza crust and that is exactly what it was. The sauce was good and had just enough with huge pepperoni slices and spicy Italian sausage. If you are ever in Tulsa this is a nice little pizza joint to have dinner at. They also have gelato, which I love but I was too full to enjoy one. It's also in a nice area to go have a walk after you eat with little shops around to visit. read more

See all

I actually have never tried Andolini's until today. The location on cherry street is too busy. I like the location in Broken Arrow due to more accessible parking. The pizzas were not only huge but tasted great. The quality and value were there. It's really a great place for pizza, coming from someone who's not a pizza person. Is it my favorite pizza place? No, as Little Caesars gives me 30+% off my order and it's way cheaper too. read more

See all

Food is great including the on tap root beer, service was pretty good except for the hostess trying to seat me near the front door when it was freezing outside & I did not relish the idea of feeling that blast every time the door opened. She literally argued with me for a bit and then said "do you really not want to sit by the door?" Lol. I had pretty much already stated that. Ambiance was cool. Side note I do think charging $2.50 extra for each little container of marinara to dip the calazone in was a bit much. Especially when they absolutely need to be dipped to get the right taste. read more

We were hungry and wanted some pizza, and were told this was the place to go. We decided to sit inside and had a table near the window. Our server was friendly and told us about the menu - so many choices it was hard to decide. We ordered the eggplant appetizer and fried mozzarella along with two pizzas. The apps came out quickly. Who doesn't love mozzarella / so good. The eggplant appetizer was good but a little thick and hard to cut. We finally decided on a cheese pizza and one with mushroom, onion, bell pepper and pepperoni. When the pizzas came out they looked amazing and tasted good but neither one was hot. I usually cut the first few bites until it cools, but this was disappointing when I took the first bite. Our server was new but she was great. We always had drinks and empty plates removed. We had to get boxes because we ordered too much food. So...yes the food tasted good but the pizza wasn't hot, and the eggplant was a little thick. The indoor and outdoor seating was nice and the service was very good. Maybe we just had an off night, so we will try it again sometime. read more

See all

I'm a New Yorker so I take my pizza seriously! I'll say that Andolini's definitely passed my test. I had the Peppa pig, which had, peppadew peppers (sweet piquante), pancetta, genoa salami, ricotta, and spicy honey *chefs kiss* 10/10 would recommend. Our server was amazing and the place was nice and clean. read more

See all

Some of the very best pizza compared to pizza in NY and Chicago! Crust is crunchy but very flavorful! Service was very timely! Garlic knots were amazing with plenty of garlic and butter. read more

In the phots in our today's order... the spaghetti was off today. I haven't had the spaghetti in a while, maybe something was changed? It is bland. Hopefully they add some broth to in later visits.. We had to ask for refills on drinks.. haven't had that before. Maybe this was an off Sunday. Pizza nailed it! Bruschetta, I wish there were actual Roma tomatoes in this go-around.... That was off too. But the bruschetta needed something else too... more "oomph!!" read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, the sauce had just the right balance of tangy and savory, and the cheese was gooey and flavorful. read more

Food is the highest quality ingredients, made in house where possible. Service is always impeccable and the beer selection is expansive! Just try it. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Over time in Tulsa, I tried out andolini's pizza chain and it was AMAZING! I love their aesthetic, authentic look, making it seem you live in Italy, terrific bar, great entertainment on Tv while you're eating or drinking, her seeking and polite employees, fantastic pizza!!! I ordered a basic cheese pizza with mushrooms and roasted red pepper (btw the roasted red peppers were GENIUS! So sweet and lots of flavor! I would recommend anyone that is visiting Tulsa or trying out something new, this is the spot to try it out! Plus there are more locations in jenks, downtown Tulsa, and the last one is a few minutes outside of downtown. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Cheese pizza with mushrooms and roasted red peppers - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Good beer selection. Service is great! Ambiance is awesome! Food - Italian sandwich is TERRIBLE, probably the worst Italian sandwich's I've ever had. ALL BREAD! ALL HARD BREAD! No meat, an absolute disgrace to an Italian sandwich. The owner and manager should definitely try this sandwich, and not as an owner or manager, secretly order this and try it out! I'm basing my 2 stars on tonight's dinner only. Sad part is my wife and I left a lot of sandwich on our plates thinking they would ask if everything was ok, but no one asked. To me, this is a missed opportunity for a waiter to get input on food if a plate is coming back with food on it and then offer a discount. Pizza here is GREAT, every one we've had was awesome! read more

Outstanding food and service! My "go to" pizza place...highly recommend, you will not be disappointed guaranteed!

My husband and I stopped by for the weekday lunch special. The price is very reasonable for what you get. Unfortunately, my husband and I did not like the pasta. The meat sauce was minimal and very watery, and the texture of the meat was odd. My husband had the caesar salad and said he would not get it again. First, it had almost no dressing on it so he asked for more, then we actually got to taste the dressing he said the flavor was very strange. For the good, the pizza was delicious! Thin crispy crust, delicious sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese. I would get the pizza again, but the pasta and salad were a miss. read more

I've come back to give credit where it's due and praise Andolinis for taking their customers feedback serious! The company took it upon themselves to reach out, and attempt to get us in for a second time. Which my husband and I agreed to. We do not believe that one bad experience represents the company and so we set a date to come back. Yesterday we were seated with a waiter named Brett who immediately displayed amazing customer service. He filled us in on the details of what they're most known for (Demarco Pizza - gotta try it!) He was attentive, friendly, knowledgeable and quick! We ordered appetizers and he made sure to mention that one takes as long to cook as a small pizza and made sure that was okay with us (which we were) He then came after appetizers were done to deliver a sample tray of their gelato and presented it so nicely, with the talk track of wanting our favorites! So personable. We enjoyed this little treat in between the pizza arrival, which came out in excellent time and the presentation was lovely as well with the oil drizzle after setting it on our turn table. Brett kept checking on us, making sure we were good (and the best part is he had no idea of the reason of our return - so he was simply doing a phenomenal job as a waiter. Which we praised him and informed him of this and tipped him accordingly!!) The food was 10/10, hot, and full of flavor! this was redemption in our eyes. We ended with two cups of gelato (our favorites were the cheesecake & Nutella) We will be returning and give thanks to Andolinis's team in going the extra mile. Big thanks to Brett for being awesome and I hope he gets recognized and rewarded for his excellence. read more

See all

Food was excellent!! Fair pricing across the entire menu Service was friendly, helpful, and courteous read more

Andolini's is great. We love their pizza & garlic knots. My daughter's love the dough they get to play with while waiting on the food. Service is always fast. Wait staff are kind. Ambience is fun & upbeat. Today the staff were dressed "western" for just the day. It was cute! Also, they have a lengthy bar menu, including a long list of beers. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Half pepperoni pizza & half Chelsea pizza - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

Excellent service Best pizza I've ever had in my life homemade ranch sauce is awesome 5 stars incredible

Ordered Stromboli to go while in town visiting friends and the best food with great service!

Ordered to-go Combo pizza tonight. Pizza was fresh and delish. Luv the Christmas decor! Service was quick! Highly recommended! read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

Visited Andolini's after about a year, for an early Valentine's date with my hubby. It was pretty busy with a couple of large groups but the staff was still attentive and friendly. We asked about a menu item I used to get all the time that has since been removed from the menu, the Maccheroni Pizza. It's basically a white pizza with their (on menu) Opulent Mac & Cheese on top. They were able to make this for us and I was excited! It took a little bit for our pizza to come out, because it was a specialty item and they were fitting it in between multiple to-go orders. We ordered some fried mozzarella to snack on, which were good but I remember them being a little saltier. Pizza finally came out and it was just as delicious as I remembered. Paying was quick and painless with the QR code payment that several places use. We appreciated our server being attentive and answering all of our questions. We'll be back soon, probably for their Monday night to-go special - it's an awesome deal!! read more

See all

Pizza was undercooked and cold. Service was actually so slow that it was entertaining. Don't waste your money or time here.

Excellent pizza!! We purchased ours while enjoying a beer at Broken Arrow Brewery. Andolinis delivered to the brewery and the pizza was still hot and delicious. Highly recommend!!! read more

Review of Andolini's Pizza in the Rose District Our Sunday night visit to Andolini's in the Rose District hit the spot, delivering pizza perfection in a cozy, family-friendly setting. From their classic pies to the new deep-dish offering, it's safe to say Andolini's knows how to serve up some seriously satisfying pizza. The Food Let's talk about the star of the show: the pizza. Deep Dish Pizza (ROMAN Custom): My wife and I decided to give this one a shot, and it did not disappoint. Thick, cheesy, and loaded with toppings, each slice was a comforting, indulgent bite of pizza heaven. The crust had that perfect balance of crispy edges and a fluffy interior, soaking up just the right amount of sauce. We chose double Candian Bacon and Fresh Mozzarella for the three toppings. It's safe to say we'll be ordering this again. Classic Medium Cheese Pizza: Andolini's does the classics as well as they do the bold experiments. The cheese pizza was everything you want -- a perfectly made crust with just the right amount of crunch, and bubbling cheese. It was a hit with the teenage "I only want Pizza" kid. Even our pickiest eater was happy, which is always a win! Cheese Pizza (Kid-Approved): For the little guy, the cheese pizza delivered simplicity at its finest. Gooey cheese, a flavorful tomato sauce, and a thin, perfectly cooked crust -- no complaints here (they will give the kids dough to play with before the meal gets there.) The Vibe The Rose District location has a warm, inviting atmosphere, with twinkling lights adding a festive touch to the space, they have their own take on "the chute" overhead. The service was friendly and efficient, and even though it was busy (as you'd expect on a Sunday night), everything came out hot and fresh. Final Thoughts Andolini's is the kind of place where you know you're going to get a consistently great meal, whether you stick to your tried-and-true favorites or venture into something new like the deep dish. Their attention to quality ingredients and perfect execution shines through in every bite. If you're in the Rose District and craving pizza, Andolini's is a must. You will have to drive around for a bit to get a parking spot up close, but I think we call could afford a few extra steps after a big meal like this. We'll definitely be back for more -- especially for that deep dish! read more

See all

They delivered my delicious Stromboli to Broken Arrow Brewery which made for a perfect ending to a great day

I ordered from this Andolini's again for the first time in a few months. I still think the pick up situation is a little weird (when you place the order online, it doesn't mention that there is a curbside pickup area in the back, just tells you to park where you can and they'll bring you your pizza) but I knew where to go from past experience. My pizza was hot, fresh, and delicious. My only complaint is that I asked for no hot honey (personal preference, not an allergy) and it was included on the pizza; that being said, it didn't take away from the pizza. Service was quick and friendly, my order was ready on time and was brought to my car promptly. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Triple Pepperoni Jamfest...with a couple of slices missing. - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Salvating. Just thinking of this place! Always good experiences here! Great rustic feels, wonderful service...and the food is just awesome! Andolini's pizza is my favorite. I really love this location over Jenks (for me!). And cute Main Street to do a little shopping! The Caprese Antipasto was so delicious with its fresh, fresh mozzarella and tomato, roasted pepper...yadda yadda yadda combination. SO good! My friend and I had the pepperoni and Buffalo Chicken pizza. Marvelous, people. Marvelous! I have to come back! And soon! read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Half pepperoni and half Buffalo chicken - delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

As someone who has grown up in BA and has spun pizzas, won pizza awards, and tasted pies from nearly every state, I approached this restaurant with high hopes. The ambience here is fantastic--warm, inviting, and perfect for a relaxing meal. However, the pizza didn't quite hit the mark for me. Every time I've ordered, whether to go or dining in, the pizza has been undercooked and overloaded with cheese. In my book, a true wood-fired pizza is all about balance and simplicity. Unfortunately, this spot's style and toppings just don't do it for me. True delicious pizza has a "less is more" vibe. I would love to see them lessen the size, reduce the cheese portions, and stay true to a more simplistic wood-fired approach. With these adjustments, I believe they could really elevate their offerings and create something special. read more

We ate at the restaurant yesterday afternoon around 4pm. I've had food from Andolini's before so I know the quality of food is very good. However, I must say in person was EVEN BETTER! The food came out piping hot, which is expected, of course. All was cooked to perfection. Our server explained everything in detail of what we were going to be getting as our food choices. Brett was an attentive server who also went above & beyond by offering Gelato samples before our meal came out. He shared info about the origin of some of the ingredients in the dishes which was very informative. Definitely recommend!! read more

The unlimited lunch for 13.49 is one of my favorites splurges. The Caesar salad is delicious, every single 'za is magnificent, and the staff is always so attentive. Plus, you can't beat the ambiance of having porcelain busts of Julius Caesar staring at you from above. read more

I tried this for the first time, and I really enjoyed my pizza. I wasn't sure which one to try but this pizza was great. The crust was perfect. They were very friendly they cooked order and those are a little over priced pizza is great. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - White pizza with sausage and prosciutto. You could tell sausage is homemade. - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

I'm LOVE pizza. This pizza was so good. Great beers on draft, local, seasonal and all time faves. Sheldon was wonderful, very attentive and made sure we were completely satisfied. We will be back for sure. read more

Always great, always prompt and courteous. Your waiter looks like the guy from Stranger Things!

Cool location in quaint downtown Broken Arrow location. Staff was very friendly. They gave a full bar with numerous local beers on tap. Pizza was awesome. I love they had gelato that looked homemade. I will definitely return. read more

Their Alfredo garlic meat pizza was amazing!! Got through half the pizza and decided I would put a review in. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Half the pizza - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

The absolute best, most delicious pizza!!! Every bite felt like the first!! And, the customer service was incredibly welcoming and one step ahead always!!! Mille grazie! read more

We came for my Granddaughters 9th birthday party. We ordered the 20" New York Cheese Pizza. So good. Plus garlic knots mozzarella cheese sticks and chicken pizza. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

The new DeMarco pizza is amazing! The sauce is the best I've ever tasted. Everyone needs to try it!