This is my love letter to Amsterdam Sushi: in my humble opinion, the greatest establishment on earth. As a regular, the all-day 2-roll and 3-roll specials with soup or salad are a godsend. I can only speak to their maki as far as the menu goes due to my commitment to ordering this special, but, their spicy tuna rolls NEVER miss, and they have quite the diverse menu. Spicy salmon, spicy yellowtail, sweet potato, oshinko, inari, eel skin, SALMON MANGO.... all delicious and satisfying. I am deeply grateful for their incredible spicy mix formula: the perfect amount of crunch, sriracha, and graciously light on the mayo. I find that many sushi restaurants are way too heavy on the mayo and it overshadows the fish! Not here! The spicy tuna especially is seriously perfect. The wasabi and gari are both great and the miso soup is perfect. (I have to attribute at least half of my deli cup collection to this order.) The interior is charmingly antiquated--it appears to be converted from an old Subway and retains several features of the old interior. They have a great in-house deliverista, sushi chefs who are always locked IN, and a cashier who I found charismatic, attentive, and careful, even when they were bombarded with orders at peak hours. The cashier simultaneously works like a MACHINE to package the takeout orders, which are always neatly and perfectly packed, with a recycled piece of cardboard to keep your hot soup separate from your fresh sushi. If you call to order, the phone operator will remember your last order and address for next time. (To order online, use Beyond Menu instead of the big corporate apps for no fees! And call directly for delivery!!!) I've also eaten in several times and it's always a pleasant and charming experience. The immediate area is somewhat of a food desert as far as affordable and nourishing takeout goes, so this place was a lifesaver when I lived around the corner. It was the first meal I had after moving in, and would become my ol' reliable for all of my time there. Missing this place is truly the saddest part about moving out of west Harlem. I will crave it for the rest of my life and hold its special place in my heart forever. LONG LIVE AMSTERDAM SUSHI!! read more

See all

This is our go to sushi spot when we want sushi that's fast, affordable, and guaranteed fresh and tasty! read more

Amsterdam Sushi - Party Tray 1 - Sushi Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Good prices for the sushi! And we got it delivered and it was good quality. Would highly recommend the avocado rolls, dumplings and the dumpling soup!! Super delicious. It also arrived super quick :) read more

My go to sushi spot. Literally have to force myself not to come here every time I'm in the area. Service is great, from in person to their delivery service. Small spot with limited seating but still I've always managed to grab a seat when I wanna eat in. THE BEST for cheaper sushi that is still great quality. I love u Amsterdam Sushi..... read more

Amsterdam Sushi - Two roll special w/ Spicy Tuna Roll and tuna avocado roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - New York, New York

This is my favorite sushi in NYC to date! I order here via Uber Eats often, for the past few years actually, and I've never had any issues. Sushi is always fresh and the rolls aren't too big which I like! My favorite thing to get here is the "buy two or three rolls" which comes with a side like miso soup or a salad for a really affordable price. It's been my go to on the busy or lazy days. Thank you Amsterdam Sushi for providing an outstanding service! read more

I usually order from here and it is quite delicious very fresh. We recently ordered the meal for two people and went to pick it up. I recommend this place because it is my niece's favorite. They are also nice and told me they can make anything we want. This place is mostly take out and I would not eat there. read more

Amsterdam Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Subpar sushi. Not the best but certainly not the worst. I ordered their 3 rolls for $16. Wish they came with more dipping sides. read more

Amsterdam Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Their delivery is absolute garbage. Do not order delivery directly from them. Delivery person refused to come up to the apartment so I had to come all the way down. I also have ordered from here before and they have just charged my card, I wasn't told this wasn't the case and that I would need cash. I had to go all the way back up to my apartment and grab cash. When I came back the delivery person was GONE. Had to wait an additional 20 minutes for him to come back. By the time I got my food everything was mushed up. read more

I'd choose this atmosphere over my own home some nights. Assistive, humble, and genuine. The restaurant has an appealing setup. Each dish outshined what came before it. I cherish this place and will definitely revisit. read more

This is my go to spot. There are sushi places on every corner and some are better than others. My favorite spot is in Greenpoint. Amsterdam sushi offers some nice combo options or individual rolls at affordable prices. It is always fresh, the staff is friendly and our food is always ready on time. So, when in Harlem I like to come here, for the quality and simplicity. read more

This is my favorite sushi restaurant to order from. I love the spicy salmon roll and the sweet potato roll. Great edamame. The sushi is always fresh and delicious. read more

This is hands down some of the best sushi you can get in the neighborhood at an unbeatable value. After ordering delivery from here a few times, I've figured out my favorites-- though honestly was not disappointed by anything. The sushi pizza has officially replaced Crispy Rice Spicy Tuna as my favorite spicy tuna indulgence: it has a similar appealing contrast of textures and temperatures between the disparate ingredients but is leveled up thanks to the added bonus of seaweed salad and the flavor of the scallion pancake: don't miss this one. I also enjoyed the tartare and dinosaur egg apps for some hefty dose of sashimi chunks with avocado but now I just order two sushi pizzas since my hubby and I are obsessed with it. The "any three rolls" for 16 bucks is a wildly good deal-- and comes with a drink, soup or salad. I like to get the salmon avocado roll, spicy tuna, and spicy salmon or the Alaska roll. All are excellent in their own right but I really am always impressed by how fresh and buttery the salmon is. And the miso soup is good too: no skimping on the wakame and tofu so it's legit. Toss in some gyoza and you are set for the night. I haven't eaten in person, but the delivery is always so prompt and the food so fresh I haven't yet felt tempted. Give this place a try: you won't regret it. read more

I ordered from here on uber eats the other night, for the price it was pretty good. Not the best sushi I've ever had but it was decent for price, time I ordered and the delivery time. The spicy crab roll was pretty average, spicy shrimp was okay, spicy tuna was my favorite, although none of them really tasted spicy compared to other places I've ordered from. The rock shrimp was really good and the mango Kani salad was the best thing. Their miso soup was good and flavorful! Overall it's a solid choice read more

This used to be my favorite local sushi place, but the quality has gone down hill. They're super fast, but the quality of the fish isn't what it used to be, and there's usually something missing. I hope they start to go back to the place I loved a few years back. read more

If you like sushi and bubble tea, you'll like this place. There are so many options for sushi and bubble tea. I got the cream cheese fried sushi and red bean milk bubble tea. I was in a explorative mood. The red bean milk tea had the funky taste of red beans and the milk and sugar gave it a drinkable taste. The sushi was really good; the combination of the cream cheese and fried batter on the outside was a good combination. There are a few tables but the workers were mostly working on take out or delivery orders. There is no bathroom. read more

Amsterdam Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - New York, New York

I've ordered here multiple times via Doordash and finally went in for a pickup. Cute store, small and they didn't have seating when I went, and my order was available upon arrival. Every time I've ordered the food has been fresh and delicious, it's my go to sushi for delivery. read more

ordered takeout as usual. and have to write this review to commemorate that on this date september 20th 2025, the last night of summer, with the autumnal equinox almost upon us, we received the best, most incredible sushi ever. the miso soup was all one could wish for. the tempura appetizer and edamame were top tier and the complimentary spring rolls positively raised the roof. our most sincere compliments to the chefs. read more

This is a fabulous restaurant to get real authentic Sushi & Sashimi. Best to take advantage of their delicacies.i just love their Scottish sashimi, fire Dragon roll and their takoyaki is so delicious and to add the Miso & seafood soup to your entree is eating in style. Please have a meal at Amsterdam Sushi to have a experience of fine food read more

I Got the lunch roll special. 2 rolls n miso soup for 11 dollars it was very good and fresh and definitely will go back

Ordered from them so many times for delivery but never go to the restaurant itself. The food is good most of the time. Fish is as good as the price can be. No complain. read more

I am simply dumbfounded that this place has such high reviews. I ordered a bento box and the two roll special. The bento box chicken had black veins running through every. Single. Piece. Of chicken. Every piece. I've never seen such an occurrence in chicken breast. The gyoza were soggy and broken open on the bottom but the seamed end was so hard/dehydrated it could break a tooth. For some reason they included a container of ketchup? Sushi + ketchup? The rolls... visibly slimy. Browned avocado... it could be because they packaged the cool sushi on top of the warm bento box without consideration. Yum! This may be why I have food poisoning. I ate three bites of rice and one bite of gyoza from the bento box, one piece of sweet potato roll and didn't even touch the tuna roll. My body is SO angry. How does this place have four stars?! read more

Fast & fresh delivery. Smaller rolls but they are tasty! Packaging is secure and environmentally sustainable

Great sushi as always. Fast & quick delivery also. Always recommend they're consistently good

Of note, the shrimp tempura roll is not on the menu and normally, you get two tail pieces in a roll but it came with none which kinda felt like a cheat. It also didn't taste all that fresh but for the price, what was I expecting? What I really didn't appreciate is that the first time I came, I ordered bubble tea and wanted to pay with a card, lady says there's a $10 min. I come back to sit and eat and when someone else orders food, she says there's a $15 min for card. That's unprofessional and a cheat. She let him pay with a card when he was about to leave though. Very upsetting. Their taro and almond bubble tea is delicious, however, they put too much damn ice, all the way to the top of the pretty small cup. They are cheaters here man. read more

The women at the front does not keep her mask on to protect against covid. She touch her hair, eyes and skin and then packages the food. It's disgusting. One of the men at the front slicing the fish has his nose uncovered (anything can drip from you nose). Who knows what they (or anyone else) is doing in the back kitchen area it's so gross. It makes me pray God is protecting your food because they are not. I thought this would change since this is an update to my last review. read more

Best sushi in the neighborhood. Amazing and affordable. Favorites: sashimi rolls, summer rolls, pork dumpling soup.. you can't go wrong with this place. read more

This is my go to sushi spot for take out in this neighborhood. Sashimi is fresh. I love the Tuna Sundae I order it almost daily. Their cooked sushi are pretty great too. Definitely better than other sushi take out spots here in the neighborhood. Glad I tried them, I'm a loyal customer now. Please don't let me down. read more

See all

My new fav sushi place. I believe it's a old Subway, so the inside looks kinda weird, but the food is very good and a good deal (My grubby ass can get three sushi rolls and an appetizer for under $20). Because its a converted Subway, def not a date-night Japanese place, but there are seats, if you need to grab a quick meal. I mainly do delivery or take out from here and the delivery is pretty quick. I've spent many a discretionary dollar here and plan to spend many more. read more

They make very good sushi - try the sushi deluxe - and they also have good appetizers

I ordered the salmon skin hand roll but received the wrong order. So I called the restaurant and she delivered the salmon skin hand roll. It was disgusting looking. It was greasy and the cucumbers were yellow. The salmon skin were rubbery and greasy. I felt sick after one bite. read more

Amsterdam Sushi - Salmon Handroll. - Sushi Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Don't eat from here. I received raw chicken & got so sick from it. I went back to the restaurant to let them know & brought the food back. They were trying to tell me that the chicken wasn't raw ... eventually they gave me a new order but I should've gotten my money back. I was so disgusted. In the picture you can clearly see the difference between the white (cooked) meat & the pink(raw) meat. I had already taken a few bites before I noticed & got food poisoning read more

Amsterdam Sushi - a close up of a tray of sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This has been my go to takeout (and sushi) place in NYC throughout COVID. It is such a good deal for 2 or 3 rolls and soup, and good variety of options (even for vegetarians!). Pretty solid portions and delicious. They tend to be quick with delivery too. I also love that I can get boba here. It's not the most amazing boba ever but its also a good deal and tastes pretty good. I do wish I could adjust the sweetness of the boba but otherwise I am very happy. I already know I will miss this spot and deal when I leave NYC! read more

I ordered a chirashi and some unagi sushi. Absolutely delicious. Got here fast. Will definitely order again.

New favorite sushi place in the neighborhood! This place is very comparable to Geisha sushi, but more convenient because it's across the street from CCNY. Both have the 2 and 3 roll specials. Geisha has a student/Yelp discount, so I would go there to get the lunch specials + discount, or to dine-in. Amsterdam is more of a take out place, has the specials all day, AND WHITE TUNA included! I go to Amsterdam if I'm craving white tuna or it's not lunch time anymore. The owners are friendly as well, such a welcome addition to the area. Side note: Amsterdam sushi's prices and variety are much better than at Sushi Sushi (which has a more expensive lunch special, a laughable selection of rolls included in the lunch special, and no student discount). Not affiliated with any sushi places, just my two cents as a student living in the neighborhood. read more

My go to, take out place, sushi is delicious, cheap and convenient ! Every-time i feel like having sushi at home, I order from here, never a disappoint ! read more

Great little spot in Harlem on the Hill Real quality grade of sushi and freshness, with great prices to match, ideal for the college crowd on a budget or other fiscally conservative adults who love sushi well done!!! Friendly staff as well...... read more

This is my go-to sushi delivery place! Delivery is typically quick and the sushi is always fresh.

Good deal, delivery was earlier than eta... my friend hates sushi he tried it and loved it! Any 3 Rolls: Shrimp Tempura Roll, Salmon Avocado Roll, Spicy Tuna Roll. Vegetable Gyoza and miso soup. All was delicious. The gyoza is well seasoned. read more

Amsterdam Sushi - Any 3 Rolls: Shrimp Tempura Roll, Salmon Avocado Roll, Spicy Tuna Roll. Vegetable Gyoza and miso soup. - Sushi Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Shrimp tempura roll is our fave Ordered multiple times here already. Shrimp siumai was also ok. read more

I order from here when I want a light but filling sushi roll meal. Their three rolls and a soup deal can't be beat. Sometimes I get a bubble tea too. They're fast, efficient and consistent. No frills but satisfying. read more