Came in for 2 slices of pizza with mushrooms. $5.50 each. Not much to say look fine on the display. Sauce was mediocre in flavor, pizza dough was dry at the edges. Mushroom were ok, really nothing exciting to say about lunch. I happened to be walking bu on my way to work, decided to give it a try but there is no reason to come back. Nobody makes good pizza around the west 57 st side. Sad, i am in NYC eating some sorry tasting slice. Oh well life goes on. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Take out slice cheese mushrooms pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Came to Amore for a quick late-night bite. There was a good variety of slices and plenty of seats and tables, which is always a plus in the city. We ordered four slices, and all of them were quite fresh. My favorite was the pesto, tomato, and vodka sauce slice, it was an exceptionally good combination of flavors. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - slices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The service is so quick and friendly, and the pizza is SO GOOD. This is the best vodka sauce I've ever had, and it in pizza form is INCREDIBLE. The rainbow pizza is my favorite thing ever and I think about it so much. The pesto is perfect and the marinara and vodka sauces are perfect and so flavorful and not chunky. I would get this every day if I could. There has been ample seating room each time I've come. Highly recommend! read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Rainbow pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

We enjoyed this place! We did a little "pizza tour" and visited several pizza shops in NYC. This one was clean, friendly, and had delicious pizza. They even had one with noodles on it! How fun! read more

See all

I stopped in for dinner. Was a pleasant surprise to see such a diverse menu, everything from slices of pizza to salads, sandwiches, and seafood. Ultimately, I was enticed by the several pies that were on display and ended up getting a couple of slices. Both were amazing and hugely portioned. I couldn't even finish the two. I also picked up a fresh Greek salad that was generously filled with feta cheese, black and green olives, tomatoes, lettuce, cucumbers, and a bit of onion. They have several dressing options. I think I tried the Italian and it was perfect, not too tangy. My cashier, Mo, made the experience even more delightful. His fun and friendly demeanor will surely keep the customers coming back! What a friendly and fun guy! I took my order to go, but there's definitely space to enjoy your meal within the restaurant. It's a casual atmosphere and the restaurant was clean. I highly recommend Amore Pizza Café.! read more

See all

3.5 it is. Pizza is just ok. It's spacious and there is seating which is nice, drinks & also salads. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This has been my neighborhood go to. Good prices, good food Be careful with the credit card scanner. It's set up to automatically add in a tip on top of the fact that they charge you for using a credit card. This is new....so a $21 order became $27! Everyone is out to scam you out of an extra buck read more

My family & I absolutely loved this pizza place. As we were leaving NY we decided to stop by here for some pizza. The place looked nice, clean and friendly staff. I was unsure what I wanted to get so I asked for advice and guided me with their trio pizza with pesto. It was all vegetarian & my daughter got a classic pepperoni it was fresh and the crust was light thin and u could hear the crunch it was delicious. Next time I am in NY I have to stop by and get me some more of that slice(trio). We also ordered a side of grilled chicken and it was super moist and fresh cooked to order. I absolutely recommend this place. It's been Nikky approved! read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - My trio pizza it was delicious! - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I like this pizza spot. It's conveniently located on the corner of 58th and 9th ave. I always order on seamless it's just easier for me and I'm always in and out. So far I've enjoyed their mozzarella sticks, garlic bread, beef patties and their slices with pepperoni and extra cheese. Everything was perfect. The mozzarella sticks were large and cheesy, the garlic bread was garlicky, the beef patty was meaty, and the slices were so big and extra cheesy; just the way I like them. I definitely try to come here at least once a week to get my carb fix. See you soon Amore Pizza! read more

See all

I was in the area and wanted a slice of pizza because how do you go to New York and not; so I stopped in after reading other reviews. The restaurant is what you'd expect from a pizzeria and the atmosphere is average energy, nothing loud or quiet about it. The service was quick, just like NYC and the prices were on par with what you'd expect. I will admit that after I ate my slice, I did get another because damn it was good. When you've been to so many restaurants in New York, it's hard for a restaurant to stand out but pizza wise but Amore Pizza Cafe does. They're menu has a lot of items on it so you should take your time. However, I believe no matter what you get, it's going to be great. I would definitely recommend Amore Pizza Cafe for the food, the atmosphere and the reasonable priced food. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I ordered pickup from here on a weekend. I appreciate the wide variety of items and varieties for sale. The website gave me at 15 minute window for pickup. They gave me my food a few minutes after the pickup window ended, so they were running behind. The interior is a little worn down but clean. Maybe it's because they had the door open, but there were so many bugs inside. The food is a little pricy, but it's in midtown, so you get what you get. I will say the portions are large and the food is tasty. I would return here again for pizza if in the area. read more

Pizza was good, staff meh. They were out of pepperoni and cheese slices by 8 pm on a Friday and trying to get us to buy one of the other flavors that were still left . Saw the server cat calling a group of women passing by which irked me. read more

10 out of 10 . Buffalo hot wings are delicious. Prices are reasonable. It's a nice walk from Columbus Circle and Central Park. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Disgusting and overpriced Seriously tasted like frozen pizza. First and last time here. Don't bother Blech read more

Might feel a bit incongruous, but sometimes you just want a slice after a long night at the opera. Conveniently located on the cusp of Hell's Kitchen and open late. There are lots of slice options here, but the classic cheese is a delicious choice. Cheese Slice: Most notable trait is that this was nice and saucy, which is great since some slice places can be a little dry. Also, lots of gooey cheese. Thought the crust wasn't as firm/crunchy as some places, but that was fine. Quite filling for $3.27. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I'm disappointed to say this went from being a 5-star place to being a 2-star place within a year. Amore used to be our go-to every week for almost two years! They had the best NYC pizza and consistently got our order right. Slowly, this turned into poorly made pizzas, incorrect orders and rude service. Not sure when management and staff changed, but it happened slowly throughout 2022. We haven't ordered in months since our last pizza showed up with the wrong ingredients and over 45 mins late. We used to be able to pick up when we lived closer, even then they would mess up our order but at least fix it. Now it's just become overpriced with poor service and quality. I'll admit, walking by it looks bright and welcoming, but stay away and do your stomach a favor! read more

Lots a great topping choices but the pizza is terrible. Mushy doughy crust. Very bready and soft. Not good at all . Also the guys that work there always seem a little mean. Not great vibes from them. Better pizza at many other places nearby. read more

I used to go to school around here some years ago and didn't remember this spot being here but I'm glad it's here now. I was super hungry after the ballet and wanted something quick preferably pizza. I found this spot on Yelp thank goodness and it was open late. I got a margarita pizza and they prepared it quick. Wow what a slice and the price was right thank goodness there are still some reasonably priced places in manhattan. There was plenty of seating too. If you're in the area check them out read more

The Good: A large selection of delicious pizza The Bad: A huge menu of other things no-one orders The Ugly: My wife eating pizza with a fork and knife We were going to go to Bleeker Street Pizza because it is supposed to be the "best pizza in town" but an Uber ride would have cost more than the dinner. So we ended up at this place not too far from our hotel at Lincoln Center. A classic "pizza by the slice" restaurant that you see on every street corner. Pick your slices and wait a few minutes for them get re-heated. I you dare to venture away from the many varieties of pizza available they can accommodate you. This place is on a busy corner so if you like people watching this is a good place for that. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Multi-meat and pepperoni slices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Better pizza option in the area. Love their rainbow slice. Plenty of indoor seating with AC. Friendly staff and good prices for the location. Will be returning to try their other options, I see their menu items are all priced really well (mostly10$ or less). read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Plain - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Every so often, there will be a pizza place that blows your mind in terms of quality and selection when you may least expect it. Earlier today, my wife and I found this spot on 58th St. while in a rush to make an appointment. On first glance, we instinctively thought "this is just another pizza place" but we were sorely mistaken. We ordered a slice of the macaroni pasta pizza and a slice of chicken Parmesan. Both slices work big, well moisturized (did I really just say that??), and delicious tasting. There are enough pizzas to wrap around the entire open glass viewing area and it's obvious that with four major ovens, this place generates a lot of volume. Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of other places in the local area that offer pizza but for some reason, this corner spot stands out. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - a man standing in front of the counter - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I popped into Amore Pizza Cafe to grab a late night snack. I ordered two Grandma slices, and then I grabbed a seat. The slices were very fresh, and very tasty. My bill with a bottle of Stewarts was $14.18. I'll be back! read more

Well, the place appears clean, well-lit, and nicely managed but I absolutely disliked the cheesesteak sub I had here, disappointing!!! Not seasoned. I added salt which brought out the very alien taste of the sparse portion of "steak" meat. I think they use Velveeta cheese bc that's what the "cheese" looked like and tasted like! Perhaps, some of the other dishes are ok though read more

See all

This place gave me food poisoning; called months ago to make sure their bolognese sauce wasn't cooked with cheese (allergy) and it wasn't. All of a sudden, after the last two recent orders I was crazy sick - I called to ask again, and the guy who answered said yes, they're made with Parmesan. When I told him what happened, he put me on hold and then said they're not made with cheese. Yeah, right. Also, this is the only pizza place in NYC that doesn't serve vegan options. What's the opposite of Amore? read more

Fam and friends used to grab a quick bite at Fluffy's as our neighborhood spot, which Amore replaced. Finally tried it for pizza and it was good and busy. Will try a sandwich or pasta next time. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Meat Lover Pizza and Mushroom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Small shop that sells pizza, sandwiches, and pasta. The pizza is decent pizza here, you can grab by the slice. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Great service, great pizza, good vibes! Come grab a slice from here please! They have lots of exciting flavors read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - 6. Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Amore Pizza is a very cool place. Everyone there is friendly and excellent customer service. Best of all is the great pizza! In a cool part of New York near Columbus Circle. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Amore Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Honestly everything I want in a pizza cafe. The staff are nice and welcoming even though it was near midnight when I came in, and they still had a lot of options. I forget what I got, but it was a solid piece of pizza ($4.50). Keep in mind they have a surcharge if you pay by credit card, but it usually amounts to 10-20 cents if you buy one slice. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The pizza was awful. Cakes incredibly stale. Inedible. Would never eat again even if it was free.

My boyfriend and I were staying at the Empire Hotel around the corner. This place was walking distance and looked busy when we came by. I notice a lot of recent 1 star reviews, but those are on non-pizza items. Get what this place is clearly known for. It's Pizza. We came here not once but twice during our two day stay because of how delicious it is. Not to mention open late. If you want yourself a classic slice of NYC pizza, I would consider this place. Sad I won't be able to have it again for a long time. read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Classic Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

We came here out of pure convenience because it was late and we were hungry! It looked bright and had so many pizzas on display. So we took a chance. At 2am they were stocked with pizza, cheesecakes (from Juniors nonetheless), and other treats. Decided to get pizza and it was not good at all. Zero sauce and just too much cheese and the other slice was buried in mushrooms. Both were so bad. Slices range between $3-$5. The only positive is they are open late and have a single restroom. read more

See all

The price of a slice of Pizza is absurdly expensive The people working are ok but cannot understand English read more

Good pizza and Italian food. They always make you feel welcomed there. Try their Chicken Parmigiana Vodka Sauce Sub.

they can be good or they can be terrible , depending on who's cooking or what your ordering , I had a delivery of a pasta dish that was made all wrong , I called and sent it back and they made it over , two versions both terrible , I threw the second one in the garbage , I would have called grub hub to get my money back but when you do that the restaurant calls you back and yells and abuses you on the phone so I didn't do it .I rather pay more for a better restaurant, they are not good with some dishes but I noticed they used to be decent but not anymore , I wasn't really happy the last time I ordered either , so downhill and I won't order anymore from them , I ate the roll for dinner that they gave and they ruined my dinner! read more

Extremely rude worker, so unbelievably condescending. He was mocking me and did it for a little too long. I don't think workers who do this realize that we understand that you're being a jerk, they think its funnier because they think the customer is so dumb that they don't know what they're doing... I knew what you were doing, I just didn't say anything back because I'm not a jerk like you. Disgusting. I've never even left a yelp review before, which goes to show you how rude he was. read more

Every night on my walk home I stop here for 2 slices and a hot chocolate with Carmel and hot pepper flakes #seconddinner #amazing read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Tiramisu Slice Pizza with 2 Toppings Chicken Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pizza was good, can't complain about a spot that is open late. I had 2 slices on my way home and they were good. I had a chicken and broccoli slice and an eggplant slice. My only complaint is when you ask for a slice, pizza places always go for the 'smallest' slice and then I gotta be like "hellooooo I wasn't born yesterday, can I not get the Chuck E. Cheese size slice?" I got a look cause I asked for a bigger slice. And you know what, for $5 a slice, I got that right. The eggplant slice was a little sweet, but I did like that they were nice and friendly and openly had the oregano, pepper and Parmesan cheese out like I wasn't going to put it in my purse and take it home. I'll try you again, Amorino. Likely on a late night. read more

I never go out my way to down play no business but my expectations were so high vs to what i received when i order out for the first time. I went back to try & get my refund & they told me i had to call them immediately vs me going to store myself. It was just poor customer service & the pepperoni roll wasn't up to part. read more

See all

When I moved to the city this location hit the spot. We thought this would be our pizza spot but after ocasional times that They delivered the pizza has been burned and hard. On Tuesday the 18th of Jan I ordered food the excuse was they had so many orders and they send out my pizza all burned and hard my kids and myself couldn't eat it the next day Wednesday I spoke to Fatima and she will send another pie but I got it and it was all burned again I'm very disappointed because the service is great in the store and why not when they delivered. You truly lost a customer So disappointed read more

Amore Pizza Cafe - Disgusting - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all