Let me begin this review by saying I'm from Southeast Texas, visiting this area due to RV repairs at Thor. With that being said we are accustomed to flavorful cuisine. We dined here on a Sunday, so it was buffet only, which we were not thrilled, but stayed anyway. We did not have a wait, but when we were seated it was at a table next to a bin full of dirty dishes left by the busboy, when my husband pointed this out to the hostess she move the Bon a few inches behind him, so we requested another table with a better view was the excuse we used. Well the next table had a dirty dish rag in the window sill, which hubby called it to the attention of the busboy. The roast beef was tender, but other than that the food was at best mediocre. Our conclusion we will not dine here again l, unless we our tastebuds change. read more

Very disappointing visit to the steak house. Extremely slow service (nearly 2 hours) coupled with an awful steak. I had a ribeye that tasted like a cheap grocery store steak with a ton of fat. Will not be going back. Worst meal I have had at that price point. read more

On the way home from Michigan with my Brother and Sister we stopped for lunch. My family has eaten her before and recommend it. The food was very, good!! I recommend a new dish washer though! We had to send back dishes and silverware. Totally grossed me out!! Service was slow but other wise friendly! read more

Bagged food, disgusting kitchen, old food used and reused. Someone's going to get sick if they already haven't. Avoid the buffet!

We just finished having the Threshers Dinner. We had. Broasted chicken and turkey for our two meats. The chicken was good as was the turkey. It was a meal that is very filling and tasty. But nothing leaves you saying I can't wait till next time. We came for the play and got hooked into the meal. Next time we might just do the play and try another of the restaurants in town. read more

The place is definitely a tourist trap however I was here to try the food. I came for lunch and it wasn't that expensive. I had the beef and noodles (which was a starch fest since they put it over mashed potatoes) however it was really good. I also got green beans for a side which were well flavored. I also had sassafras tea which was very good and a bit different for this Texas boy. Like mixing tea and root beer but I definitely approved. I also tried their Kolsch beer which was an incredibly smooth and tasteful ale that was well balanced. Finally I had shoo-fly pie which I found to be well crafted and tasty but didn't fully fit my own personal palate for preferential status. read more

Amish Acres - Shoo Fly pie - Hotels Near Me - Nappanee, Indiana

See all

Going to an "Amish" restaurant,i expect good homemade food.We arrived 15 minutes after they opened.and it took us 20 minutes to get seated(4 people) When we were seated,we notice over 75% percent of the tables empty.Apparently making you wait gives you time to buy stuff in the waiting area.The"Amish" girls had tattoos and dirty aprons. It was buffet sunday,the chicken was okay but the ham was dried out deli ham,Yuck!The mashed potatoes were made from instant and the bean soup was from a can and they threw in the nasty deli ham.The noodles were not fresh made and very watery. Service was horrible as they only have 1 girl for food,one girl for drinks and 1 girl for desserts,they need to assign a waitress for each section.When we went to leave,we were told we had to go to the end of the line where people were lined up out the door to get a table.I refused to get in a line for 10 minutes to pay my bill.I heard they usually have you pay before you go in but they didn't have us do that.We left a tip,only to find out they automatically add it to your bill. I will never go back to this restaurant read more

Very poor management. My chicken was bloody at the bone the manager when I showed him said looks cooked to me. I pulled two pieces of chicken apart and he could care less. After some time the waitress came to me and said the cook changed the pan of chicken. Won't be back especially for $17.00 buffet and to be treated rudely! read more

We were on our way to Elkhart. IN and decided to dtop and have lunch at this Amish restaurant. It was Father's Day, so there was a buffet for $16.95. Beef and noodles, fried chicken, mashed potatoes were all very tasty. Found out the chicken was broasted, that's why i loved it. read more

I've been to this place several times throughout my life (school trips, family get togethers) as a kid I always hated it. I went there recently to see nothing much has changed. There's nothing special about this place that screams "come back". There's nothing significant about the food or memorable about anything here. Oh P.S. don't bring your kids unless you want them to be bored out of their minds. read more

I unfortunately have to give this establishment three stars only because there really wasn't much to the place. It's hard to explain but it was as if something was missing like magic mountain without any amusement park rides, roller coasters, log ride, kids rides just a place with a few standing structures. Don't get me wrong everyone working there were extremely friendly and helpful happy to interact talk share stories with you but the overall experience wasn't memorable. I mean let's face it when you advertise yourself as Amish Acres Historical Farm and Heritage Resort that sounds like a big deal I mean you're expecting the wow factor. As a visitor to the state of Indiana I can at least say that I experienced what they had to offer at this location but I will not recommend it nor will I be back. read more

This is my second visit. The last one was 25 years ago. Good memories from that visit, not so much for this visit. A 45 minute wait to be seated and dining room is 1/3 full. My first impression was nobody knew what they were suppose to do. Very disjointed. Then we get the waitress who got up on the wrong side of the bed. Bitched and complain. That's all she did. We had to ask her to take our food order Refill our water glasses, bring us dessert and the check. Her name was Shelby. Talking about the food is the same as many people state. Canned, cheap bottom of the barrel. Cheap cut of ham and turkey. So-so bread and low quality desserts. Potatoes were blah as was the gravy. Sweet pickles way to sweet. Just a poor meal at a place that's living off a memory. Take a pass on The food and gift store. Nothing is made on site. Some of the buildings they sell food in smell moldy.(Fudge store). read more

The Round Barn Theater at Amish Acres focuses completely on musical theater. I have been to some musicals before that haven't been done in a major city that have been hard on the ears, to say the least. This is not true of the productions at the Round Barn Theater. The actors and actresses can sing on-key (or at least on-key enough for a tone deaf gal like me). The costumes and sets are simple but fit with the musicals that they're performing. Overall, it's a fairly impressive show for the price you're paying. And, it's less of a pain than hitting up a show in Chicago. read more

The manager of the restaurant is a very rude man. I brought to his attention the fried chicken was not cooked properly because there was blood. He was checking with a thermometer, placing it incorrectly on the chicken by the way. Upon addressing him he kept his back turned during the entire time of trying to show him the chicken that I and my 6 year old almost consumed. All he could tell me is that is what cooked properly, which was not the truth. There is an extremely small menu of choices to eat also. The girls at the register also have no clue what a whoopie pie is! Also no real Amish people or animals other than two horses, a donkey, a turkey, and some peacocks. Not coming back read more

Not what I remember. Service was poor. As mentioned by a few others no one seems to care. For the price you pay you do expect great food and service. Ask for some extra bread and told we could not get any as they were afraid of running out. This is at 5 pm. Took 15 minutes to get seated and place half empty. Manager did provide assistance and she was very polite to us. Wish I would have talked to her sooner. read more

I had the family style dinner with chicken and roast beef. Everything was very good. The pie was also very good. It's a nice place to eat, the food is great, the service was great, and the food came quickly. read more

We like the area's Amish meals of broasted chicken, mashed potatoes, etc. Good comfort food. Bur Amish Acres was not terrific. One of the biggest problems was that nothing was hot just warm. The chicken was brought out with two little pieces on a plate. Not appetizing, It was near the end of the evening so that may have been the problem. read more

Everything is very expensive. They have their own cider mill but the cider they sell isn't even their own. It cost $6 just to go out to the pumpkin patch where you can then buy a pumpkin read more

My husband and I have been coming to Amish Acres and the surrounding Amish area for over twenty years and look forward to the broasted chicken meals. Unfortunately, we were very disappointed with the Thresher's Dinner we were served on 8/1/18. The service, despite the restaurant being more than half empty, was very slow. Our waitress was very pleasant and did apologize several times for the slow service; but, did not give any indication as to any issues with the food, etc. While the slow service was annoying, our real disappointment came with the meal itself. The broasted chicken (which keeps us coming back to the area time and again) was dry and tough. The roast beef was dry, the dressing was dry and dark brown on the bottom and the gravy had visible flour lumps. The dessert tray was not refilled between guests, so your choice was limited to those pies not chosen by the previous guest. We observed one of the trays sitting out during our entire meal - not ideal for cream pies. In addition, three pieces of silverware on our table that had encrust food that had apparently not been removed in the dishwasher. I sent an e-mail two days later and received a response from the Chief Operating Officer indicating he would contact me the following Monday or Tuesday (this was the weekend of their art fair and he was understandably busy); however, it's been over a month and I have not been contacted by him. In the past, we've enjoyed our experiences at Amish Acres; but, after this dinner experience and lack of promised response we will not be returning. Since this posting we have been contacted by the Chief Operating Officer with an apology. Since my previous rating was based in part on the lack of response, I've changed my rating. read more

It's a place for tourists....we went for lunch. It was alright, but a little too pricey for what we got. It wasn't bad, but nothing special either. read more

Worst service ever. We were a party of 2, and had our order taken. It went downhill from there. Our food was brought out , and it was not what we ordered. The waitress, there was only one, did not come back. Ever. She catered to the larger groups of people, returning to their tables several times. I'm guessing, but I suppose there are more $$$ in tips from the larger groups. We paid for what little food we did receive, after arguing with the cashier about what we owed. We would not pay for food we did not receive and that seemed to make the cashier mad. We left, never to return. It's a stretch to give this place one star. Awful, awful place. Do not recommend. read more

The fried chicken was awesome. The rest was ok but nothing stood out. However, the Strudel from the bakery shop was phenomenal! We didn't get past that to try the pies but if they were half as good, they were great. Heat the strudel before eating it because it's so much better hot! I'd probably skip the meal and stop at the bakery. read more

This place is okay, if you are okay with NOT seeing a single Amish person. No Amish people around. They have few buildings that used to belong to Amish that they show you which takes about 15 minutes. You can ride tractor wagon on their property and horse buggy into the woods, and that's it, definitely not worth 20 bucks. Their restaurant has food way below average, not worth another 20 bucks (per person) Amish acres are much commercialized just the fact that they take credit cards should speak for itself. Save yourself time and disappointment and look for REAL Amish farm. read more

The tours, are great at Amish Acres. The food is very bland, and not worth the price. And it wasn't served hot.

Took my son here for Thanksgiving. Super long wait and super worth it. Only think I didnt like was they took 2 meats of their menu for Thanksgiving but not a big deal. read more

We were in Granger, In visiting family and they took us to Amish Acres. We took the Farm wagon ride, house tour, and thresher dinner. We enjoyed the tour and the thresher dinner. We did have a long wait to be seated and the service was slow. There was a wedding reception going on so it reduced the number of tables from the public. The lemonade is delicious. The pie was so good too. read more

All.... A very pleasant and r e l a x e d setting with the most gracious and helpful folks anywhere. A wonderful setting and harmonic.... Slow down and make the moment last... it's worthy of your contemplation. Come to know it for what it is.... and the worth it brings into our world. Enjoy.. And be refreshed. ,,,,,ATF read more

We just had our wedding at Amish Acres and we couldn't have asked for a better day. Everything was perfect! Becky and her crew put alot.of time and effort into making it a day not only we won't forget but our guest won't either! Our guest can't stop talking about how amazing the food was and how beautiful the venue was! We highly recommend Amish Acres! read more

We got the Sunday family style meal. Food was average, but the service was very poor. The waitress never stopped to check on us. She never checked in. She forgot about our requests. And the place wasn't even busy at the time. Plus the process of paying on your way out was incredibly inefficient. read more

My brother and I used to come here before the new owners took over, so we were curious to see the changes and to try the restaurant (renamed the Lasalle Farm & Table). They have changed the menu - instead of a thrasher style meal where the server brings out separate dishes, including the meat choices, they now have what is called the Farm Feast. Each person can pick his / her own starter (salad, soup) and meat entree. The meat entree has also increased to include meatloaf, beef brisket, and fish. The server then brings the entire meal to you on one plate. We were surprised at the generous portions (I couldn't finish mine) and how delicious everything was. Everything was tasty, fresh, and didn't have that canned / processed taste. I was even able to take my leftovers with me. We were so impressed that we decided this will be our go to place for meals when in the Nappanee / Shipshewanna area. It was even better (much better) than Das Eisenhaus in Middleberry. We highly recommend trying it out. read more

Terrible service, serving tasteless food. They actually bill it as the thrashers dinner, family style served homemade food. What a joke, maybe if you never cooked anything you might think something was homemade. Instant mashed potatoes and Luke warm un seasoned green beans. The bean soup is the only thing they may have made on site, not just warmed. For a party of two they served us 2 pieces of chicken. I ask for another piece of chicken and eventually after asking the second Time she brought 3 more pieces. Good enough 5 pieces for 2 persons is fine but the sides are not even edible . Never again, did not meet one interested staff member from the time we walked in until we left. Seemed there was no one in charge and no one cared. read more

Disappointed! Perhaps I misinterpreted the web site. I expected to tour a working Amish farm, to eat a home style meal and my daughter wanted to see soap making and to ride a horse-drawn wagon. The glitzy web pages should have alerted me; glitz is not the Amish way. One enters the restaurant through the souvenir shop, complete with its very non-Amish "credit cards accepted", electronic cash register, telephone and PA system. The meal was good and plentiful but not great and everything seemed to be freshly prepared, not canned. Our server was probably the most attentive but unobtrusive we have ever had. Too bad she spoke so much English (non-Amish) teen slang (awesome! like super! no problem) My daughter's expectation of a horse-drawn wagon ride and soap making were dashed when we were told that the soap making had been cancelled today and the horse in the web site photos had been replaced by a very non-Amish tractor! The tour guide had to use a very non-Amish PA system to be heard over the noise of the tractor. The tour itself consisted of a quick circle of the grounds with a stop at the now defunct schoolhouse, about ten minutes total. The guide may have been Amish; she at least was in costume. Her script was delivered in an unpleasantly shrill, bored and boring, rapid, expressionless voice. She was so well practiced and bored in her role that she could point to each feature of the tour behind her back, before we reached it, without turning toward it. The walking tour was led by a yawning teen, equally adept at reciting her script in the manner as the other guide but fortunately she did so in a pleasant tone. Her recitation was interrupted by frequent, open mouth yawns. I suspect she, too, was bored. During both tours, we helpfully were informed that the gift shops had items of interest for sale. The shops were typical of tourist traps. Lots of tacky, over-priced junk that can be found elsewhere along with a few items perhaps unique to Amish Acres. Who knows if any of it is made or produced by Amish. I have no idea who owns or runs the very non-Amish Amish Acres. I doubt any Amish are involved except perhaps a few employees. One would get a better "Amish experience" by parking in the lot and watching REAL Amish riding by in their horse-drawn buggies. Please, no gawking, pointing, etc; they are not on display. And no photos of them, either. Respect their dignity; they have more of it than Amish Acres. Amish Acres wreaks of commercialism. It is a tourist trap. read more

OUT-OF-TOWNERS -- READ THIS: First of all, do a little research before lashing out at Amish Acres. This is NOT a working Amish farm, though Nappanee is a very Amish community. Anyway, Amish Acres is still a historical destination and certainly worth the visit. Take note that many of the buildings (cider mill, etc.) have been relocated to this destination in order to preserve their Amish histories and to share them with visitors. Yes, there is a brief buggy ride, and yes, the guide speaks over a loudspeaker. Yes, there is electricity all around. No, you will not observe Amish families from behind a glass casement as they milk cows and care for their young (give me a break, folks). Yes, if you actually take the time to drive around Nappanee, you will probably get stuck behind an Amish family in a buggy. And yes, if you live nearby, the Amish will happily butcher and prepare your chickens for a small fee, as they have done for us. But as for Amish Acres itself, simply consider it Nappanee's educational museum/restaurant. For small-town Indiana, this place is fascinating. My husband and I went here yesterday for his birthday dinner. We ordered the chicken dinner ($14.98 per adult). Another reviewer complained that they only give you two pieces of chicken. Well, true--but YOU GET SECONDS. AND THIRDS. It is all-you-can-eat. If you want more, just ask for more. Also, the broasted chicken was amazing as it had a wonderful flavor. The food was overall outstanding. The service was friendly. Would I recommend that you visit Amish Acres? Absolutely. I would also advise you to take the time to read the history on the back of the menu and, following lunch or dinner, explore the grounds and read the histories posted at each building as well. Try to appreciate what Amish Acres has done in preserving as much Amish history as they could. **I would also like to add, this place is not a tourist trap. You might run into some foreigners or folks coming out of the theatre, but it doesn't mean it's a tourist trap. You aren't elbow-to-elbow trying to get around the place. read more

This was our second visit. The first time was Mother's Day with a wonderful buffet. However today's meal was served family style and the service was poor. Had to ask her three times for additional food, drinks, etc. She could not , or would not, focus on her job. After asking for additional plates of food, and waiting at least ten minutes, she came back to our table to ask if everything was okay. Still no additional food. She brought refills for drinks to two members of our party while ignoring the other two who needed refills too. All in all it was a very frustrating dining experience. If it hadn't been for the fun people we were with, the whole meal would have been a bust. The dining room wasn't even half full; No excuse for the lack of service. I don't think we'll be returning any time soon. read more

The Little Mermaid play at Round Barn Theater is a must! Everyone was amazing . We laughed the entire time or smiled!

This was a nice time on a beautiful fall day. I left with two adorable Amish dolls from the Round Barn Theater and a large grocery bag of takeout from the restaurant. It's not a huge place, but enjoyable regardless. Give yourself about three hours or more to take it all in; there is a carriage ride around the property, a farmhouse tour, a half-hour documentary film, tractor ride, restaurant, museum, huge gift shop, and several food shops full of goodies. read more

Arrived at 5:30 pm, 6 other people in restaurant but took quite a while to get seated. Ordered our food, family style and everything but the chicken was cold, ice cold. The mashed potatoes were hard, the gravy lumpy, the beef and noodles tasteless, don't waste your money here. Very overpriced at $19.95 a person. We asked for more stuffing and they brought us chicken, we asked for coffee that took 10 minutes before we got it, ordered peanut butter pie for dessert and got a piece of coconut cream pie! Very disappointed! read more

Wow! Dinner was awesome! Hubby and I were out for an early anniversary weekend and had one of the best meals. Ordered the family style Thresher's Meal and was not disappointed. Chicken was cooked to perfection and delicious. The beef melted in your mouth and the rest of the dinner items were yummy. Finished our meal with pecan and shoofly pie. Had a wonderful server as well. Will definitely be back next time we're in the area. read more

Very tourist oriented. The hotel was clean, nice and included a hot breakfast bar. Tour including horse and buggy was good. When we went to Restaurant on site, it was EMPTY on Friday dinner time suprisingly so. However, the Thesher Dinner was small portions (yes they do give you more when asked but the first attempt was small for 2 people and it was pricey at $20.00/each. Also the food did not taste like a REAL Amish meal that we have tasted at other areas in Indiana. It was bland, (soup was cold); the bread and desserts were the highlite of the meal and the buildings selling fudge ($18-$20.00pd), were over priced. The Barn with the play was EXCELLENT. The Play was an Amish musical and very good actors played their roles well. It is worth to see the play and stay at the Hotel and tours. I would not recommend the Restaurant. We would rate that a 1. read more

I thought the place was very pricy. The movie they show at first is boring, And the Amish house they show is empty, just bldgs of what the Amish live like. No Amish people on premises. Wagon ride and Horse and buggy was a rip off. But the restaurant was very good and good service. The tours were overrated and overpriced. The website says demonstrations but none were available. Probably will not return read more