Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Amish Acres

    3.1 (84 reviews)
    Open 10:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Updated over 3 months ago

    Services - Amish Acres

    Hotels

    Amish Acres Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Amish Acres

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Raspberry cream pie
    Odette M.

    The gift shop is great. I'm from CA so I got some cute souvenirs to take back. The wagon ride, carriage ride and house tour are a must. Fun to learn about Amish people and the way they live their lives. The restaurant was fabulous. Esther our waitress was super sweet, friendly and very knowledgeable. We loved everything we ordered. There happened to be a small car show outside. The theatre house we have to come back and see. They actually have live plays and you can do dinner/play combos. A definite must see!

    Dusk on the farm
    Brian M.

    We travel quite infrequently through northern Indiana, but when we do my wife generally has us seek out an Amish style restaurant. The grounds for Amish Acres are spot on for creating a great atmosphere. Aside from the restaurant, there are little shops and a building offering theater productions. The area around the buildings are nicely lit with holiday style lights in the evening and it just creates a nice ambiance about the place. The restaurant itself has a nice country store and the building has been nicely refurbished into the restaurant that it is. The appearance is about the end of the line for the Amish appeal. The staff are unlike anyone from the Amish communities I've previously interacted with. It seemed more like a few regular folks putting on somewhat rustic clothing. The wait staff (at least ours) certainly didn't talk as if they were Amish. The food is family style and is indeed all you can eat. They bring you small servings and you just need to keep getting refills until satisfied. We went with the chicken and ham combo. The ham was very thinly sliced and not the thick tender pieces I was hoping for. The fried chicken was just meh... The pricing was reasonable. Unfortunately aside from the aesthetically pleasing property the food here was just meh...

    My Tomato Bisque soup with sour cream and some black stuff. Soup was cold.
    Michael M.

    5-14-21 This place has New Owners now and the place is called The Barns instead of Amish Acres. Don't expect the same food that Amish Acres had. The Threshers Dinner is no longer ALL YOU CAN EAT (Except on Friday 4-8 pm, all day Saturday and Sunday from 10am to 2pm) which will be a Negative for a lot of people considering it costs $19.95 per meal and the portion size is small for the money. Just don't come on Friday between 11am-4pm like we did. The staff was friendly and polite so that was a was a plus. The Barns is very accommodating for people like me that are Vegans / Vegetarians. They replaced the ham soup with Tomato Bisque which had an excellent taste but the soup was barely warm. It definitely was not hot like it should of been. The meat was replaced with a veggie bean patty. The noodles with beef was replaced with Macaroni (My friend said there was hardly any beef with his noodles). They also gave me small whole carrots and whole string beans. The string beans where hard and crunchy which I don't care for. The stuffing had a good taste. None of the food was hot as all of it was warm to cold. I told my waitress the food was cold to slightly warm as she said OHhh. The waitress should of offered to take the food back but she didn't. I should of been more persistent. Also when we came here we thought the Thresher meal was all you can eat but the person on the phone didn't tell us that the All you can eat isn't until Friday 4pm to 8pm. We came between the hours of 11am to 4pm so we missed the Buffet. You also don't get a free dessert with the meal as that will cost you an extra $3.50 per slice. The drink is included with the meal at no extra cost. If you want extra bread before 4pm it will cost you $2.00 dollars. The only time you get the free dessert is on Sunday on there Brunch Buffet between 10am to 2pm. We also miss the pickles that Amish Actress had. I was able to talk to one of the owners. He was pleasant and listened to my complaints and suggestions. He ended up walking back into the restaurant and talking to the waitress and whoever else about our complaints like the cold and very mild warm food. The owner didn't offer us any thing for our cold food. Not sure I'll be back any time soon as I can go to other places a heck of a lot cheaper and I guarantee the food is hot. The food had a good taste for what we got for $19.95 but my biggest complaint was the waitress and two other people we spoke to there did nothing to rectify the cold food. Most restaurants I've ever gone to are eager to fix the problem but not this place. If the waitress would of fixed the cold food the stars would be 4-5. I hope the restaurant is successful but they need to listen to there customers. I hope the all you can eat buffet will have more food suited to the Vegans and Vegetarians out there.

    Mimosas?
    Joe S.

    Unfortunately, I think the low ratings for "The Barns" is from before the opening of the new FarmTable Restaurant. Totally underrated! We most recently had brunch here and were again pleasantly surprised. Of course no good brunch starts without mimosas and they were very accommodating to get us ours. Large glass of OJ and a bottle of bubbly from their in house winery The Vines. I had the chicken and waffles because I'm a sucker for fried chicken. I also sampled the chop salad and farm burger which I would have been happy to have for my own. Try it out! Just know the ratings don't do it justice in my opinion.

    Serving for one with refills available.
    Heather C.

    Another nice restaurant in Amish country. The food was very reasonably priced and you could easily ask for seconds. The waitress was a little overwhelmed with too many tables, but that is a management issue. The restaurant has lots of convenient parking nearby. It also overlooks a beautiful green park like area, so be sure and sit near a window for a nice view. The butter topped mashed potatoes were delicious! The lemonade was cold and tasty. I enjoyed this meal. The tables are very close together, so you might want to ask to be seated a little distance from the other diners.

    Ross M.

    Reasonable, great food there are many unique gifts in the shop by the restaurant. The 30 minute drive from US30, is will worth the trip. This is like a up scale Cracker Barrel.

    Threasher dinner
    Adranna P.

    What a wonderful meal! I had the threasher dinner! Each item was blue ribbon! Seasoned perfect! A lot of food! I congratulate the staff on service! The place was well detailed in cleanliness! I will tell many about this place! I will be back

    Outside

    Our family and friends chose the barns for our thanksgiving meal this year. Totally worth it!! A huge buffet selection of delicious food, and it was hot and fresh. The pies tables were amazing, and the hearty bread and apple butter were addictive. The staff was friendly, attentive, and professional, and the atmosphere was homey and easy going. It was our first time being at the barns, but it won't be our last!!

    Prime rib cut just for you!
    Brian V.

    Wow wow and wow for what the new owners have done with the Restaurant at "The Barns" previously known as Amish Acres. My Dad and I ate lunch here a while back and it was good, I don't think I yelped because it was brand new at the time and I think everyone needs a chance to work out the kinks (not the there were any my first visit). We decided to return to try the Brunch buffet. Plenty of food, plenty of fresh fruit and salad, and plenty (probably too much!! Lol) of everything else. The breakfast choices were good, sausage was fantastic, bacon was a smoky flavored delight, and the French toast had nuts and raisins and was the best buffet French toast I ever had. The gravy for the biscuits and gravy was good, but they need to work on the biscuits, they were dried up dust. (Thank goodness for the gravy!). Everything on the lunch side was very tasty. I sampled the ham and prime rib, I did not try the fried chicken or Tuscany? Chicken breasts. The ham was juicy and tender, with great flavor. The prime rib tasted great, but to be honest I had the rare selection, and it was very tough to chew. Still not a deal breaker for me on this great buffet. Over on the "Snack side they had avocado toast that was AWESOME! They also offered fresh (DELICIOUS) fruit, home made pies, cookies and pastries. They also had alcohol options but I did not try them. As far as Covid and the buffet, the staff worked really hard at keeping both us and the food safe!! Keep up the great work, we will be back!

    Fresh Baked Hearth Bread.
    Charles E.

    First time here and it was better than expected. For dinner, the meal is served family style. The food was excellent and there's was more than we could finish. Everything was very flavorful and served hot. The atmosphere is casual and perfect for the entire family. The building is rustic mixed with contemporary. The service was excellent and friendly.

    Amish Acres at sunset
    John H.

    Very affordable family style dinner.. what was unique compared to other places is the great concept of small portions. This helps to cut down on waste and keeps prices low. They will bring refills out very quickly even when the place is jammed. The soup is served piping hot, the pickles are too sweet, Slaw very flavorful. All the food is cooked to perfection. I have been to much much better Amish places, but this one is worth the price. The good part is you choose when to eat if going to the play, so you have time to relax in the picturesque countryside. So, many place shuffle you from dinner right to play.(not enjoyable when they put you on their schedule) The "Plain and Fancy"--- was a very enjoyable performance. Great message of how people from different walks of life can learn from one another ... it is delivered in a comical loving way... only negative thing is very hot inside and chairs are very uncomfortable.

    See all

    Photo of Pam F.
    0
    71
    0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    The food was terrible, service was terrible, the good food that I had was cold and the biscuits could be used to break a window

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Amish Acres

    Review Highlights - Amish Acres

    Fascinating house tour, complete with antiques and a guide to explain what everything is and how the amish live.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Hotels 526 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Lerner Theatre

    The Lerner Theatre

    (12 reviews)

    first time and will not be last…read more.. great price/seat... phenomenal show!!! beverages very moderately priced, friendly staff...

    Elkhart, Indiana's Lerner Theatre is celebrating its 100th anniversary in 2024. The theatre was…read moreopened by Harry E. Lerner on November 27th, 1924 and originally had 2,000 seats with vaudeville, big band, and theatrical revues dominating the schedule. As movies came into reality, the Lerner also hosted them. The Lerner has changed ownership several times throughout the years and actually went vacant in 1987 when then owner William Miller passed away. Eventually, the city of Elkhart bought it in an effort to ensure its preservation. A non-profit negotiated to actually run the theatre as a performing arts center and initial renovations began to include interior painting on the main floor, restoration of the Grand Lounge, ADA compliant restrooms, new carpeting, new seats and lighting. It became apparent, however, that the beloved Lerner needed much more if it was to become the downtown Elkhart landmark everyone wanted it to be. Over the next several years, studies took place and plans were developed. In 2008, the city committed $18 million to a complete renovation that was completed in 2011. The Lerner today is a magnificent theatre. The Lerner hosts everything from local groups to national acts like Rodney Carrington, Brad Williams, and a host of musicians and comics. In terms of accessibility, the Lerner Theatre has wheelchair accessible seating available for patrons and companions within regular theatre seats in multiple sections on the Main Floor of the theatre. We have additional options for seating in Main, Left and Right, Row AA, that would not be limited by the dimensions of the patron's mobility device. These seats are available for purchase, or upon request, from the box-office (in-person or by phone). As is often true of historic theatres, there is no wheelchair accessible seating in the balcony section. Restrooms are available and do meet ADA guidelines. The Lerner also offers a variety of assistive hearing devices. While generally animals are not allowed, exceptions include guide, sign or signal dogs to aide those with disabilities. The Lerner does offer concessions and you can take them into the theatre, however, they do ask that you open any items prior to entering the theatre. As the Lerner is downtown in Elkhart, there are dining options available and it's very possible to enjoy a night in downtown Elkhart. Fun fact: The Lerner has a 1924 Kimball pipe organ that is one of only three Kimball pipe organs currently installed in its original location. It was restored in 2011. Free parking is available adjacent to The Lerner in the Civic Plaza Public Parking area and Marion Street Parking Garage. Tours are available - reservations are required and tours are $10.

    Wagon Wheel Center for the Arts - Wagon Wheel set up for holiday performance

    Wagon Wheel Center for the Arts

    (18 reviews)

    The Wagon Wheel Center for the Arts was founded in 1956 by Major Herbert Petrie, his wife, and…read moretheir friends John and Kitty Butterfield. It was originally known as Wagon Wheel Playhouse. Fun fact: Major Petrie played trumpet in the Army band under the direction of John Philip Sousa. The original theatre started as a simple tent with a gravel floor, canvas chairs, and two old chicken coops that served as the scene shop and dressing rooms. In the early 60s, a simple structure was actually built. In 1970, Major Petrie retired and sold the playhouse to a group of Warsaw businessmen. In 1984, a new group bought it and in 1995 Bruce Shaffner became sole owner. In 2010, there was a corporate reorganization and it became a non-profit organization known as Wagon Wheel Theatre, Inc. The Wagon Wheel has a circular stage with 360-degree seating. Seating goes 10 rows high - so it's a fairly immersive experience. Free and general parking is located behind the theatre. Accessible parking is located in the parking lot next to Center Street and along the side of the theater facing the Wyndham. Accessibility options do exist here. I wouldn't call them perfect, though there's been an obvious effort. There's one accessible stall in both men's and women's restrooms. Accessible seating is limited to Section 1, Row G (this doesn't thrill me) - companion seating is also available. Accessible tickets are sold only through the box-office or by calling. Usher service begins an hour before the show - there's a preference here to remove unneeded walkers, wheelchairs, and larger mobility devices not needed during the performance (ushers will assist - again, not thrilled about this as one never knows when a device may be needed and getting it back can be disruptive). The AWS Foundation has supported Wagon Wheel in acquiring sensory bags and other items for those with light, hearing, and other sensory sensitivities. SuperEar Listening devices are available for those with hearing issues. This is free of charge. Service animals are welcome, though they must be in a clearly marked vest. In addition to regular shows, Wagon Wheel offers a variety of programs in support of its mission. They exist for all age groups. They are quite active in the community. Shows here are entertaining, the acoustics are strong, and staff/volunteers are nearly always friendly. Shows include live theater, symphony, concerts, and other types of shows. This is a Northeast Indiana gem. While there are some modest accessibility concerns I have, there's a strong effort to be inclusive and the theatre is absolutely a beloved gem for this community. The recent holiday show was spirited and impressive. Despite my concerns about seating, I will admit my seats were fine and the show was awesome.

    It is nice and fun. Their shows are always good. To the few I have been they have been really good…read more Would recommend for a low budget show.

    Amish Acres - hotels - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...