We've had this cookie shop on our "try next time we are in Edwardsville" list, so we stopped in today.
Google said they were open until 10pm. When we pulled up the "OPEN" light was off (1pm) & no one was inside so we called, no answer. I decided to go ahead and try the door, and they indeed were open.
Ordering: The menu is up really high and off to the left of the order counter, not behind the order counter where a menu would typically be. Theres pamphlets at the counter I assumed were menus...but nope! There was also a tray w cookies and labels but a lot of the cookies were missing the labels. When I asked what one of them was the staff did point to the menu which was helpful. Apparently you can make the cookies into ice cream sandwiches which we didn't realize until after we had ordered and saw it mentioned here on Yelp. There may be an option to ice cookies too based on menu but - that wasn't clear.
Price: we did an 8 pack of regular cookies and a 4 pack of deluxe cookies, the total was $30ish.
Taste: Some good (especially the snickerdoodle), some pretty grainy tasting.
Cleanliness: pretty clean!
Packing was interesting, the 4 deluxe cookies crammed into a small box and the 8 regular in a huge box.
Overall, we probably won't be back for the price, overall taste / quality & customer experience, but did enjoy the Snickerdoodles! read more