I was recommended to my long-time ophthalmologist to Dr. Cohen for an upper blepharoplasty. I went to see him for a consultation and he told me that I should also get my lowers done and recommended additional procedures that I hadn't considered.
Cliff Notes: I had an upper and lower blepharoplasty with Cohen and two additional corrective procedures. Almost a year later, I now have seen a corrective surgeon who told me that I need a skin graft on my left eyelid that is too short to close all the way naturally, (likely) permanent nerve damage on my other above-eye area (it's numb almost two years later), and fat transfers on the lower eyelids since Dr. Cohen broke the cardinal rule of lower blephs and removed my fat pads. Price tag starting at $15k. I've requested a full refund from Dr. Cohen.
Pro: Dr. Cohen has a kind bedside manner.
CONSSSS: Have a seat. In Nov 2021, I went ahead with the upper blepharoplasty and Dr. Cohen's recommendation for a lower as well. Dr. Cohen told me that it would take up to two years for the swelling and such to be back to normal. Then the nightmare began.
After a couple months to allow the swelling to go down, my eyes were two different shapes and eyelid weights/sizes. I went back to Dr. Cohen and he said he really had focused on my right eye during surgery because the right brow was higher than the left. I was surprised he'd admitted to that but OK...part of why I liked him. He performed a second surgery on the other eye (left) and then was told to wait months for the bruising to go down. He also told me that he cut and pulled my eyelid extra tight to match the other and it would stretch over time. I've sine realized that this seemingly is an admission of his surgical error.
Then I went to a work function and saw my photo on a giant screen. I realized that my lower lids looked worse than before the surgery. I went back to Dr. Cohen again (this was now Aug 2022) and he agreed that an adjustment needed to be made (also had commented on the heaviness of my right eyelid) and did the procedure on the lowers that weekend. He said that he had moved my fat pads in the original procedure and had to readjust them, and it'd be simple and painless without major bruising. Note he didn't address my upper right that he said was still too heavy.
This "corrective" lower bleph was more painful than the two preceding surgeries, and the bruising was far worse than the first one. Dr. Cohen also said he took out my fat pads, which I've since learned are critical as they are what keep your eyes from looking hollow--the whole reason I had the procedure that HE recommended. Fast forward a few months and I went to a top aesthetician for a facial and she recommended that I have a lower bleph. I told her I recently did and she was flabbergasted. I told her that Dr. Cohen told me that he removed my fat pads and she was irate and said adding plumpness to lowers is WHY you have the procedure and he did the opposite. The aesthetician referred me to a corrective ocular plastic surgeon--one of the few who will address other doctor's mistakes, ie, BOTCHED jobs.
I paid for a consultation with the corrective surgeon who told me that I had a lot of botched issues. 1) Need a skin graft for the left eyelid that was pulled too tight. 2) Dr. Cohen likely clipped a nerve in doing the right eye surgery and the area near my eyebrow will likely be desensitized forever. 3) My right eyelid is still too heavy. 4) I need a fat transfer for a permanent solution to my under eyes, and Dr. Cohen made strange incisions, and I can get filler but it will be expensive for my lifetime and Dr. Cohen didn't properly address the wrinkles.
This corrective surgeon's quote would start at $15k--I didn't have them put together a formal quote because the doctor wanted me to try manually stretching my left eyelid that Cohen made too short because apparently the skin graft is horribly painful. Stretching isn't working, and my eyelid still doesn't close all the way. And the new MD wanted me to try a non-invasive eye drop to see if my right eyelid would open more. Then he recommended that I get filler in my under eyes to see how I'd like it.
This new corrective surgeon was trying to find effective and inexpensive ways to help me as he said that the doctor who did my procedures (ie, Dr. Adam Cohen) seemingly had no idea what he was doing and I was "botched". FIND ANOTHER DOCTOR/SURGEON!!!
Also please note that this review says my location is San Fran but I lived in Chicago at the time of the first surgery. read more