Ordered Crunchy Spicy Tuna roll Naruto roll, nigiri eel, seaweed salad, and Jersey roon the all you can eat menu. Everything was fresh and well done. The naruto roll was my favorite, though I wish they had cut it thicker, as it was thin enough that half the pieces fell apart. Still tasty!!! This is an excellent value using the AYCE option as in addition to 2 nigiri and 3 specialty rolls, I had miso soup, ginger salad, And a soft shell crab appetizer. Everything was extraordinary Service was superb an although the place is small, it was very clean, even the restrooms. read more

I got "all you can eat"... The place is nice inside, and the service was very good. Other than that, some of the food was just OK. I liked their Shrimp Tempura. I got Squid Tempura which was ok... never saw that on a menu before. The Miso Soup was a little anemic (needed more miso paste... kind of weak in my opinion), and the Eel in the Eel Avocado Roll was chewy. That was pretty gross. I did enjoy the salmon, yellow tail, and red snapper sushi pieces much more than the rolls, for some reason. I probably wouldn't return, though I recommend you try it for yourself if you like to check out different sushi spots like me. read more

One of my favorite all-you-can-eat sushi spots. Everything we ordered came out fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The specialty rolls were packed with fish and not overloaded with rice, which I always appreciate. The dumplings were crispy and delicious, the chicken teriyaki is delicious and the salads with the ginger dressing is The service was also quick and attentive the entire night. They are always so sweet to my son... they give him the kiddie chopsticks and give a super cheap price for kids. read more

A Sushi - 94. Chicken Teriyaki - Sushi Bars Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

See all

Came here for 'all you can eat sushi' and was really surprised by how many specialty roll options they have available. Everything tastes really good and is definitely a bang for your buck too. read more

The food was pretty good, but unfortunately our AYCE experienced was tarnished. We were greeted promptly by a very nice waitress who gave us a sheet to fill out what items we wanted for the all you can eat special @ $33 per person. The atmosphere was pretty quiet here, but I don't really expect anything crazy for a local sushi spot. We picked 2 salads, a couple of apps (gyoza, chicken katsu, teriyaki shrimp, mini ramen noodle cups) and then 4 sushi rolls. We were served our salad, then waited quite a while before our sushi came out. Thought it was weird because usually at AYCE places apps are served first and come pretty quickly as they're ready, then sushi is the last course, but I thought maybe they just did things differently here. The Jets roll was great and the Godzilla roll was second best. I wouldn't recommend the salmon lovers roll. Some time had passed so we flagged the server to see where our apps were - at this point it had been about an hour and our stomachs were settling so we were starting to get full. Turns out the apps chef never saw that order and didn't make any of it. We decided to change it to just the chicken katsu and gyoza since too much time had passed. Both were good, but not enough to really save our experience and have us coming back. I will say they let us take our last few sushi pieces and gyoza home in a small box which was very nice. The servers were very sweet and the food had some highlights, just hope you catch their chef on a good day! read more

A Sushi - AYCE 4 sushi rolls - salmon lovers, jets, garden state and Godzilla - Sushi Bars Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

The sushi was so fresh I thought it would twitch. I wish steamed gyoza were available. FYI, parking is tight. Folks are very attentive. read more

So decorative and flavorful sushi dishes. The waiters are very patient and pleasant. The ambiance is for a casual good time of conversation and quality dishes. Oh yes, this my new favorite. read more

A Sushi - Outstanding 77. Spicy Kani Salad - Sushi Bars Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

See all

I absolutely love walking into a sushi restaurant and being greeted by a pleasant aroma, free from the distinct smell of fish. The sushi was incredibly fresh, and their special rolls were simply delicious. Good options for all you can eat sushi and great service. read more

A Sushi - 36. Garden State Roll 53. Firecracker 62. Scorpion - Sushi Bars Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

Way better then aragato. Some of the best sushi around. Fresh sushi superior service as well.

A Sushi in Carlstadt is a new place that just opened recently. The service was very good from the server to the people making the sushi for you. Everyone greeted you when you enter and when you leave. I think that's a very good impression for a Japanese sushi restaurant because not a lot of places do this. Honestly, this might be the only one around the area that has this kind of good service. By far, this is THE place for AYCE sushi compared to all the other AYCE spots in the area/county. The price is slightly higher than the rest, but... it's in the quality of the service, the fresh sushi, and the food... Oh, so good... Their Salmon Lover is a must on the menu. The way that it melts in your mouth... I have no words to describe it. It was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Located conveniently right on Route17 South, so it's super easy to find and access. Plenty of free parking in the building complex, so you don't have to worry about where to park or paying for parking. Overall, I'm really glad I gave this place a try, and I'll definitely be coming back! read more

See all

This is a great option for all you can eat sushi in the area. Service was friendly and attentive. The sushi spot has a touch of Marvel theme on the inside, they also have a tv and good music playing! They have a ton of roll options included in the all you can eat as well as different apps and sides. Price for all you can eat is a good value for the size and quality of the rolls you get. As with most all you can eat, they do note they will charge for uneaten food. The spicy Kani salad was good, nice portion size for one or two people. The rolls were fun - a couple New Jersey theme ones including sports teams and town. They also had some Marvel/superhero named rolls. Two of my favorites were the Naruto and Cape May. The Naruto was wrapped in cucumber which I never had before - was super refreshing. All the fish tasted fresh, they weren't drowning in sauces like some places do. Rice ratio on the roll was also good! Will definitely be coming back here! read more

A Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

Went here for date night and had a great time. The ambience was casual and friendly. Everyone was very polite when serving us. Service was very prompt and even though we ordered more than once we were always treated politely. The food was excellent and great quality for the price it's a great deal. read more

See all

Just a update on hours they stop taking customers at 9pm not 9:30pm. Walked in at 9 pm on Tuesday and turned me away.

Having been to many sushi places. A Sushi is definitely a sushi place that will impress and make you wanting to visit again and again. They have a huge selection of different sushi's that have never been seen or created before. Each sushi roll seems to be handcrafted to taste and ingredients carefully selected to make the perfect sushi. Atmosphere: A Sushi is located next to a busy highway amongst New Jersey commuters. Make sure you do not miss the exit to pull into their parking lot. When walking in you'll notice a lot of figurines of The Avengers. Hence where their logo spin off came from. The place is quaint with only a few seats. Luckily we got to visit this place during what seems to be a slow session during dinner. The whole restaurant is painted with black walls and an open concept kitchen. Staff: Staff were very friendly and patient because we definitely stayed past closing time. They were very catering because half our table were made up of kids. A Sushi will not disappoint. Recommendation: CJ Roll, Peter Roll, Parker Roll & I'm Iron roll. read more

See all

Food was really tasty, the quality of the fish was good, staff was friendly and very attentive. read more

A Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

See all

Came again with my family! I have been coming 1x a week for the lunch special, but I had to share to my extended family about this place. We enjoyed an abundance of food (this is just one picture of SOME of the rolls lol)! Still recommend this place, still love this place. Thank you A Sushi! read more

See all

We're here at least twice a month! It's very good sushi at a very affordable price. The lady is also ever smiling and have been surprising us with complementary dishes! Highly recommended! read more

The food is okay and the service is good. The issue I have with this place is they quite obviously half-ass the making of their rolls if you opt for AYCE. I understand the mindset of "it's unlimited, so stop complaining" but I believe if you can't provide quality at the price you're charging, you're doing something wrong. Serve half rolls for AYCE and actually make an effort in making them if you're concerned about cost and waste. Or up the cost a bit to a level where you're comfortable providing a more thoughtful meal. Either way it would lead to a better experience overall. Note: food I received looked nowhere near the photos that are on this yelp page and a couple rolls Ordered were missing ingredients read more

Very good sushi and good assortment! Will be back! Salmon teriyaki roll was very good.

Sushi was fresh and delicious and the staff really welcoming and attentive. Great value for the AYCE menu, we ordered several rolls (beyond what's pictured in review) including the Salmon Lover and Parker rolls which were sooo good! Started off with an order of gyoza and takoyaki which were also tasty! The Avengers theme of the place was fun with various decor pieces inside and superhero-named rolls too. The only thing we didn't realize was it seemed to be BYOB and for sure will be bringing a couple Sapporos for next time! read more

A Sushi - 81. Vegetable Gyoza, 86. Takoyaki - Sushi Bars Near Me - Carlstadt, New Jersey

See all

At this restaurant, PATIENCE IS A MUST. The parking was insufferable; very frustrating for my boyfriend since he drives a bigger car. Once we finally managed to park, it was about a 15-minute wait to be seated. The restaurant is small, with only about 12 tables: was set up with about one for a larger group, four for groups of four, and seven for groups of two. It's mostly run by one woman handling the front end, while about four visible cooks working in the kitchen. Overall, the pricing was great, and the all-you-can-eat deal was worth it at $33 each! My boyfriend and I tried eight different sushi rolls--some were better than others, but we enjoy experimenting with new flavors. It can be a little hard to get the woman's attention since she's managing everything upfront, but she was very nice and made sure we got everything we needed when asked. The food did take a bit longer to come out, but it was definitely worth the wait. read more

See all

A sushi was a delight. Clean space, friendly service, and if you're like me and are going to eat at least 3 rolls then the all you can eat special is well worth it. The presentation was beautiful and the food was tasty and fresh. I will be back. read more

We came for the all-you-can-eat option, and while the rolls were small, they were actually quite good. Unfortunately, the experience was frustrating overall. The restaurant gives you 90 minutes, but it was so crowded and slow that we stayed over 2.5 hours and only managed to order three times . We arrived at 6pm and left at 8:30pm -unacceptable. If you plan to visit make sure it is way before 6pm and not on a Saturday. Orders were delayed, we received rolls we didn't order which can be harmfull if you have a gluten allergy like me even after I told them numerous times , and staff continued seating more customers even though the kitchen was clearly overwhelmed. We ended up paying and leaving out of frustration, and the couple next to us did the same--leaving hungry. The food has potential, but the service and capacity management really need improvement. read more

A Sushi has AMAZING sushi, AWESOME customer service, and FANTASTIC prices. Their all-you-can-eat is well worth the price ($33 per person), which includes special rolls. My wife and I have our new favorite sushi spot! What are you waiting for? GO! read more

I just came from Vancouver B.C As far as i feel its the capital of sushi in North America. This place compares to the great sushi i had in Vancouver Highly recommend that you take the time to come enjoy some great sushi at the place Staff is fantastic it just adds to the great sushi and great service read more

Good sushi for good prices. I ordered 2 regular rolls and 2 special rolls via lunch special. Will do so again!

I was there once to pick up an order for me and my wife and we were totally disappointed. Food quality and flavor was fair but definitely not worth the money paid for such small portions. I don't intend to ever go back. I do not recommend this establishment. read more

First , the positives. Very good service. Nice selection of rolls. The negatives are, no sashimi on the all you can eat menu which is a deal breaker. Also, no eel. I go to sushi village on route 46 but live in Rutherford so I was hoping for a closer place. Not happening. This place can't compare. If they don't add sashimi and eel to the all you can eat menu they will be out of business in 6 months. read more

Awesome sushi at all you can restaurant! The service was attentive however when they get busy it really slows down. This is the only negative about our meal. It took a very long time to get the main plate out. The ambiance is pretty basic but that's part of the charm. However, the food was to die for! I will be going back again and again. read more

Good sushi great service. Went there a few times and will probably go back again. Definitely worth a visit if you're in the area