I have been wanting to try A Mano for awhile now and finally did. When I first walked in the restaurant was packed and buzzing with excitement. I entered the front door and was greeted. I said that I had a reservation at 8pm and gave my name. I thought it was a bit odd that the first thing I was told was that they did not have a phone number for me, so they were not able to confirm my reservation, even though I made the reservation through Resy, which has my phone number and email address. We were seated along the wall, which was a bit close to the tables on either side of us. Definitely not 6 ft apart (not sure if that is still a thing?), but we were fine with it.
I loved the atmosphere of the restaurant: warm, intimate, and energetic.
We decided to go with 2 appetizers: the beets and the burrata with prosciutto. They were both extremely flavorful and delicious! The freshness and flavor of the beets paired with sour cherries was amazing. The burrata was creamy and also so good. You could tell the prosciutto was high quality. I don't always love prosciutto, but I loved this! The pesto was also delicious. I did think the beans were a little raw for my liking. Anyway, at this point of the meal I was sure I would leave a 5 star review.
I overheard our server telling the table next to us that many of the ingredients come from a farm in New Jersey. I'm an advocate for sustainable food and for eating local, so this is a plus in my book.
I was originally thinking, after the 2 appetizers we would be fine with the smaller portion of pasta and the trout. Try a bit of everything! Our server was pretty persistent in suggesting that we should order the large portion of pasta. I completely understand that servers want to upsell meals, but he was definitely too persistent for my liking and made me feel uncomfortable. After I said we were going to share everything and we would go with the smaller portion, he then asked me what I would like for my entree. I thought it was clear that we were just planning to share everything we ordered. Despite that, I did decide to go with the larger serving of the Lumache pasta. However, I was pretty disappointed. For $30, I was definitely expecting high quality pasta. I thought the flavor of the sauce was very good. It had corn and mushrooms which I thought were very sparse. For that price I would have thought it would have been homemade, however I'm sure that it was not.
Finally, when we finished our pasta our server came back and asked if we would like dessert. However, we did not receive the trout yet. After apologizing they brought it out soon after. I thought the sauce was absolutely delicious. The fish was was a bit bland but in combination with the sauce it was very good. The vegetables I think were not cooked enough and seemed almost raw.
When our server returned at the end of our meal he asked if we would like dessert. We declined but he proceeded to tell us the desserts anyway. I admit they sounded delicious, but we were full at that point and decided not to indulge.
Based on other reviews it looks like most people received focaccia, which appeared to be delicious, however we did not receive any.
I really wanted to give A Mano 5 stars, but overall I was left feeling disappointed. read more