As a mother of three, it is rare for myself and husband to get out and spend a special night together. We had heard such good things about 6Smith and to get a reservation ON the patio on such a beautiful night...well, you can imagine how excited we were to enjoy the evening just the two of us with good food, wine and each other. So here is how the actual evening went.
Arrived for our 7:30 reservation and stood in a very long line. That part is fine. It only made our anticipation of enjoying the atmosphere and food that much more. We got to the stand and it seemed like chaos. Yes, we have your reservation but we have a chair shortage happening...so if you can please wait we'd appreciate it. Hmmmmm, Ok. Good enough. Gave us a chance to soak up the beautiful space and people watch. Got to witness the manager getting berated by another guest who had been sitting at the bar for 45 minutes waiting to be seated. So tensions seemed pretty high already. After about a 20 minute wait, we were finally seated. The girl who sat us was pleasant.
We were seated on the patio on the far end. I had a view of the action, while my husband had a view of the serving station. Needless to say, if the serving station was in order, it might have been ok. But it was a mess.
After about 15 minutes sitting there we were FINALLY greeted by our waitress, Molly. She was pleasant. Nice enough. We asked a few questions about cocktails. While she could answer what was good, Mojito, Margarita, she couldn't answer on any of the New School drinks. "Haven't had, I don't know." So we asked for a couple minutes to decide. A couple minutes turned into 20 minutes. She came back. We ordered the Wind Cries Mary and Passion Made Easy. 20 minutes later we get our first drinks. Received the Passion Made Easy and a Bloody Mary. NOT what we ordered. "Oh, I must have put that into the system wrong." 15 minutes later we get the RIGHT drink as ordered. I'll be back.
At this point, our ice waters are gone. So my husband sees the carafs of water on the serving station, gets up and pours us refills.
Seeing how things were going, we placed an order for 6 oysters on the half shell and a bottle of wine. Simple enough, right? Well, drinks finished and about 20 minutes later we get our oysters, no wine. Finished oysters. Wine came. Bottle ordered was effervescent and smelled of vinegar. Sent back. Then she offered a taste of the Newton that came 10 minutes later. At this point we then just opted for a GLASS of that wine for each of us. We then asked for specials, recommendations, thoughts on certain things. Her knowledge of the menu was low. And while being pleasant, it didn't feel like the kind of service you would expect from the prices that we were about to pay.
So at this point, after an hour and a half, we have had 6 oysters, two drinks, one wrong drink and a refill of water that my husband procured.
We then ordered the spare ribs and beets. And while the oysters were great, hard to mess up what mother nature prepares, the spare ribs were fine. Inconsistently cooked at best. Some tough and over cooked. Some moist. The beets were pretty, but under seasoned. No description from our server. Something like "we like to keep the skins on the retain flavor" or anything like that. My husband makes better beets than what we payed for.
As annoyed as we were at this point, we decided to order ONE entree IMMEDIATELY as we could see how long it was taking to get drinks, oysters and appetizers to the table. The dinner came FAST. It took longer to get plates in front of us because we were sharing than it took to get the meal itself. Finally, plates in front of us. Scallops looked nicely cooked. Gnocchi, looked good. Tomato? Really. Maybe 2 little pieces and a shriveled up leaf of basil. So we dug in. Again, maybe our expectations were set too high. We know the chef is famous for what he does. His restaurant concepts are way up there. This food did not match expectations. When we needed to salt and pepper the Gnocchi, you know there is a problem.
Then, one piece of Gnocchi left on the plate in front of us and Molly, our server, comes over and asks if we are going to finish it. And stands there. And stands there. And stands there until my husband stabs it with his fork and eats it. She then grabs all plates and runs. THE fastest part of our evening. And rude.
Then the check comes. Nearly $200 because she left the first BOTTLE of wine on the check. My husband needed to find and call over Molly to say something. Just the perfect end to an already crazy dinner date night. And still, payed nearly $140 for a two and a half hour evening meant to be memorable for a whole host of other reasons...this night was certainly one to not forget. We couldn't wait to leave and find our way to a Culver's for ice cream. read more