I visited this place under a different name the last time. The main difference between NY Pizza & Pints and 5BB NY Pizza & Beer is the pricing structure. Back then, everything was a la carte. I could order one or two slices and a drink. Now, they have a combo pricing: a slice, a salad, and a drink. The salad options are House or Caesar. I chose the Caesar salad. At first glance, it seemed like a decent portion. But when I looked closer, I realized it was just a single layer of lettuce. I found it easier to scoop the leaves with the fork tines than to spike it. I would have preferred saving a few dollars and skipping the salad altogether. On the positive side, the time I spent eating the salad would have been spent drinking the fountain soda. When the pepperoni slice arrived, a generous amount of my favorite Stubborn Agave Vanilla Cream Soda was still remaining in my cup. The pizza slice was just as big as before. Unlike typical New York-style pizza, the crust was brittle and cracked when I folded it. Also, the cooking process prevented grease from seeping onto the paper lining. As a result, the slice itself was a bit dry, which is not my preferred style. read more

5BB NY Pizza and Beer - Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

See all

24" pepperoni pizza feeds 10-12 people. Not a bad pizza, but not the same crispy NY crust pizza. Very greasy and cheesy. New ownership means different pizza of course. Same size offering of pizzas. Just a different taste and quality of the pizza. Had the pizza delivered I felt so bad for the delivery driver who didn't know how big the box was to fit in her car lol read more

5BB NY Pizza and Beer - 24" pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

See all

New name, same menu, same steep prices, but dramatically worse quality food. The pizza crust was super thin, floppy and flavorless like something out of the freezer, the cheese was not tasty, and the toppings were skimpier. I also still paid $12 for the Greek salad but it was considerably smaller. read more

I had a ginormous craving for the juiciest piece of pepperoni pizza- I had to go here- years ago my bestie got me a colossal slice from this place for $5 and I believe it came with salad, a pickle and maybe a drink? Could be wrong there- I ordered two slices, extra crispy and it was $14. The man was SOOOO nice and kind. I'm so sad that my pizza was not warm or crispy at all. He was sooooo kind, truly. I was just so sad that the pizza was not piping hot! It was not really even warm- but the sad part was that it took a minute to get my food- what happened? So sad. read more

They changed the menu and the combos are no longer.... Also they took out the cream sodas. Pizza isn't the same anymore.

Pizza and beer! Caught my eye on my way to work. Thought id step in for lunch and didn't disappoint. Stepping in i noticed a huge 4 tv display and thought hell yes! Sports! I got the number 1 which is a caesar and a slice. Ordered a tall beer. Beer was cold. Caesar dressing and salad was fresh and flavorful! Slice came out and it was a huge thin crust slice with a pickle on the side. Hot and fresh slice with just the right amount of ingredients! Definitely coming back again! Music and vibe was on point as well! read more

5BB NY Pizza and Beer - Pizza Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

Good pizza!! Very much a hit. Especially with their frosty mugs. Their 24" are humongous!! Kids love the cheese. read more

5BB NY Pizza and Beer - 24" NY Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

Horrible. It was a good pizza, I guess they sold it, but it's awful. Frozen pizza is better and the service is bad. Lots of better options. read more

Craving a slice and so I went to a pizza and beer place. Well the place appears to have new owner and name. Probably better. Last owners' pizza tended to be salty. Well I ordered 2 slices (pepperoni and supreme) with a 24 oz draft Yeungling. Price $24. Ouch. Naybe a pizza beer combo would be nice Okay. After rubbing the bruise in my wallet, I can say.... This legit NY slice. Nice thin crispy yet foldable crust. A beautiful char. Just perfect! It was not salty like previous establishment and I tasted the veggies in the supreme as they were cooked "al dente". If you prefer more salt then the parmasean cheese will add flavor and saltiness! Try a little parm on pepperoni slice. Yes, do it. The slices were good size so that did massage the wallet bruise. Not sure if real mozzarella but it tasted good. I did get a hint of floral taste to pepperoni pizza. Detergent residue from pizza pan? Not sure , I noticed but not a biggie. The cold beer was good. I give this a 4 star! Now about that pizza slice beer combo... Stars: 1 - Just go on a fast or eat dirt 2- Crazy hungry or someone else paying 3- Not bad and not great 4 - Yummy Yummy 5 - OMG! I ate my fingers too! read more

See all

NY Pizza is a misnomer. There was next to no tomato sauce and it was basically cheese on bread. If you want a specialty pizza that is typically not sauce based or if you have horrible taste in pizza, you might enjoy - but, if you want a traditional NYC style pizza then this is not the place. read more

This was just not good pizza, much less NY style pizza. The cheese was very plain, was already congealed fresh out of the oven and the toppings weren't great. It looks nothing like their website photos. Staff was friendly read more

5BB NY Pizza and Beer - Pizza Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

I posted after my wife and I ate the for lunch today. We both have had very painful stomachs and diarrhea all afternoon. Seriously everyone be careful eating there. We miss the old owner, he was so kind and always checked on us. read more

Pretty solid for a slice and a brew. New owners know how to run a business . Food was good, service was great . Recommend.

I usually never leave a review, but I felt as though I have to and I hope leaving this review will lead to change. My husband and I used to love this place but after the change in ownership, food and service dramatically went downhill! We came in tonight expecting that the food would take a while to come out because things were made fresh to order but to our amazement the food took extra long and was not worth the wait at all! The pizza was okay, but the biggest disappointment were the garlic knots. The garlic knots tasted as though they were sitting out all day (not fresh whatsoever!), they were hard, and we also did not get our full order of garlic knots (we asked the manager if they only served 3 knots per order and he said "we usually serve 4 but one did not look good, so I threw that one out and we cannot make more since we ran out of garlic knots". We did not get refunded nor were offered anything else for the lack of garlic knots (not worth the $8 we spent for the knots). Unfortunately, I do not think our family will be coming back here for a very long time unless things change. read more

Very disappointed. First visited early September and it was awesome pizza. More expensive than others but the pizza was really good. Best crust We ever had and quality toppings. Since then we have had their pizza about 8 times (we like pizza), but very inconsistent. It definitely is not worth the price anymore. read more

Best pizza I've ever had, great service, and owner is super friendly. The cheesy bread is also amazing and obviously a great bar. read more

5BB NY Pizza and Beer - Pizza Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

We ordered a margarita pizza and it came out cold and without tomato sauce. The classic margarita pizza comes with fresh mozzarella cheese slices over the sauce with basil leaves. Also the dough seemed premade and not fresh or hand tossed. This used to be my go to place for good brick oven, but it's obvious it is under new management and they have made some major changes in the ingredients. read more

Great pizza and service. The staff is always so kind. My family loves coming here for our pizza fix! read more

5BB NY Pizza and Beer - 24" BYO Pie - Pizza Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

We LOVE coming here!! The service is personable and staff are all great. The food....OMG the food, so many different pizzas and I've never had 1 I didn't like. You can taste why this is worth forgoing the chains and it's even worth me getting out of comfies to got pick up or eat in. read more

5BB NY Pizza and Beer - The Hawaiian with red peppers - Pizza Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

Best PIZZA in town and friendly services very good atmosphere highly recommend, double bacon Alfredo pizza the best

Obviously this place is under new management, this was the worst experience I have ever had! Pizza tastes terrible and leaves a bad taste in your mouth, the girl at the register had a terrible attitude, they didn't even have ice for their soda machine, they were out of certain sodas, with no sign on them, saying that they were out. When I told her root beer was out, she copped an attitude, and said she ran out of it 3 days ago. Hence my wife and I will never return. My advice is save your money! read more

Food here is absolutely delicious! NY pizza is authentic, taking me back to my youth with oregano, amazing sauce and XL slices! Service is always 10/10, we tasted their new Double bacon pizza with a hot honey drizzle was sooo goood! restaurant is clean and spacious with good games on the tvs. read more

I was excited to check this place out because we live nearby in Castle Hills and have been meaning to try it. When you walk in I see couples having drinks, families dining in and I liked the vibe but sad to say my first experience will be my last. My 3 yr old was super hungry so I ordered two combos with Greek salads for each. Bad moment #1-They have this cute patio section out front with turf and umbrellas so my husband, my baby and toddler and myself go out to sit there while we wait only when I go to sit down I fall hard and am stabbed hard in my back and hip. I was in shock when I looked down to see the bench split, completely broken. It was evident as you can see in the pictures that it had already been broken and had been attempted to be glued back together. I have no clue how long for, you'd think they would have placed a sign as a precaution or idk but it actually really did hurt. I'm thankful I wasn't pregnant or had any other physical impediment that might make me fragile but what if I had?! The worst part is that when I go to let the manager know the two ladies (one was at the register and one was waitressing) they let me know they're out of all the fixings to make my Greek salad and ask me if I'm ok with them just adding some vinaigrette and idk what else (I can't remember now) to a house salad. I said no because I wasn't ok with that. I ordered a Greek salad because I love a Greek salad exactly as it comes. Not a big deal. I wasn't upset they couldn't make it so I asked for a refund and the waitress with curly hair and tattoos on her arm rolled her eyes and kind of huffed, looking visibly surprised and annoyed that I would ask for a refund. They both got quiet, didn't make eye contact and just handed me my money. I just asked for a partial refund because I still wanted the pizza. So i thought their response was rude and unnecessary. They actually were upset that I wanted a refund for the item I wasn't getting? I can't understand that. So as they handed me my partial refund I reminded her again that I had asked to speak with the manager (about the broken bench outside). I could tell she was reluctant as she just nodded and walked towards the kitchen where I saw her approach a man. He looked over at me warily but eventually walked over after I waited a few minutes. (At this point I had been waiting 30 min for my food and had already politely asked for an update on when it was going to be done. I felt I was being patient but I also had a hungry 3 yr old with me and my baby and husband waiting for me in the car and didn't understand why two single slices of pizza were taking so long. Anyway, when the manager came out I kindly let him know what happened when I sat on the bench (I didn't even complain about the two waitresses giving me a rude response though I thought about it. I just let it go. You never know what people are going through you know?) The manager did come out to inspect the bench and just said "oh wow, yeah sorry about that are you okay?" And then just brushed it off and walked away. So while he did ask once if I was ok I honestly felt like he was faking caring. Maybe it's just my expectation that good leadership in that moment would have shown more empathy and even asked about my order or heck offered a free drink or coupon or something so I wouldn't leave with such a negative experience of the place. But maybe that's just me. Again, I could get over the waiting 30 min for two slices of pizza. I could even get over having hurt myself on the broken bench but to not have been met with a more courteous, respectful and empathetic response to me says a lot about the training of the staff and their care for customers. But maybe that's the problem, I was just one customer who had asked for a partial refund so they didn't care about my experience. Oh and when she brought out my pizza she said nothing to me, no smile, just a quick hand off and I had to remind her that I had asked for it to go. So then she has to go back and put it in a to go box. The pizza itself was thin, the cheese was sparsely divided. Nothing special. read more

See all

the service was fine but the food it's self was unpleasant. I ordered the Barbacoa pizza and when it arrived it was missing half of the things that were said to be on it?? and the whole reason I order it was for the bbq yet there was none. on top of that the meat it's self was very little , if I'm going to pay $33 for a pizza it better be too teir , and honestly I could've got a better pizza at dominos . The wings weren't great either , the sauce amazing but the chicken it self was over cooked and over all ruined it for me . I did enjoy the bread sticks though read more

Service was great. It was my first time and the young lady at the register was very helpful and patient and accommodating. Fun atmosphere great food and great desserts! read more

I wouldn't be surprised if this place is closed within a year. Ever since it was sold to the owners of 5BB, everything has gone downhill. Way overpriced. read more

Love this place! Great food and service. Pizza slices are huge, Hawaiian with hot honey is my favorite. Wings and pepperoni sliders are go to appetizers. Beer selection is great too! read more

Every time I have been here the customer service has been top notch and the food is amazing!