The food dishes are outstanding with large portions for us big guys, and for those little guys enough for lunch the next day. All the soups are made from old school recipes. I have eaten there several times and is now my go to place for Italian. The only drawback is the staff is overwhelmed by the numbers of customers, but when your good this is how it shows --lines out the door and down the sidewalk. Old school N.Y. italian read more

We got the 12" simple pizza with a few toppings and an order of calamari. It was fantastic! We did carry out but service for pick up was great. It was extremely busy but everyone seemed happy and satisfied. We'll definitely be back! read more

Honestly, not sure what the hype is about this place. Walked in at lunch. Two tables occupied and maybe 4 tables still had still not been cleaned from previous guests. Was told to take a seat and someone would be over. Had to have them wipe the table down we chose even though it was set for the next guest. The waitress came over and didn't even greet us, just asked what we wanted to drink. Again it wasn't busy at that time. Ordered brick sandwiches. They were okay but nothing to write home about. Lunch was reasonably priced but doubt I'll ever visit again. Another table had to ask to have their table wiped down again as well. I understand maybe some people had good experiences here but just wasn't for us. read more

driving from Tampa to Naples, right off of 75 in Venice is a gem of a local Italian restaurant we stumbled on. The place was busy on a Friday evening with locals. The food was top notch with large portions well worth the very reasonable price. The owners are from Brooklyn, NY so they clearly know quality Italian food. Leave room for desserts-displayed by counter. Highly recommended. read more

We had a party of 5 today for lunch and everything was great! The meatball sub was huge and those meatballs are exceptional, very big and lots of flavor. My friend had chicken piccata which she loved. Another friend had the sausage peppers sub, again huge and very good. The pasta fagiole soup was the best I ever had and I order it a lot everywhere. I asked for a little bowl so my friend could try it and they gave her a small bowl of it. It was the best she has ever had also. Another friend had the minestrone, it was so good she took one home. My eggplant rollatini was very good, The only criticism would be thicker eggplant slices and more seasoning. If you love sweets.... Lookout because their showcase of sweets is amazing. Thank you for wonderful food and service because we had a great time and will be back! P.s. please work on the acoustics... it's so noisy that I couldn't hear conversations. read more

I'm late to the game trying 500°, considering I've heard rave reviews for months! Decided to go yesterday with my parents for my birthday lunch, and believe me, the cuisine lived up to the hype! Mom and I both had eggplant rolitini, as it's one of our faves, and the eggplant dishes were highly recommended. It was quite possibly the best I've ever had... very lightly breaded, stuffed with ricotta, and smothered in delicious sauce and mozz. This $20 meal came with delicious fresh bread with a garlic dipping sauce, a house salad, and pasta and will easily be three meals by the time I'm done with leftovers!! My Dad had the meatball sub and loved it... note it was huge and he took half home for dinner! Already sent the menu to my other half so I can pickup takeout next week! read more

Sandwiches are massive. Pizza is decent. I'd go there more often but it's a Snowbird trap during season so I have to wait till it's a ghost town in summer. read more

The food is excellent . We have been there twice . My husband had two different pasta dishes and they were both excellent . I had the pork chops in garlic both times and took one and a half of the chops home. They are excellent . The service is very good and everyone is very nice and they took our reservations . Don't miss this excellent Italian food . Our friend had the pizza , which was also excellent read more

Best Pizza Ive ever had !! Went twice during our recent visit to Florida. Food was great both times. read more

500 Degrees Italian Eatery - Meatball and Mushroom Sicilian Pizza - Italian Near Me - North Venice, Florida

Have dined in and a takeout recently. Veal parm and seafood were delicious. Portions are beyond generous. Service prompt and friendly. Everything excellent. Thank you 500 read more

Very good food and service. Owner apologized for our reservation not being able to be sat at the time we requested so she sent us over complimentary goes d'oeuvres read more

Authentic New York-Style Pizza in SWFL! This weekend, I had the chance to try 500 Degrees for takeout, and I was impressed. I had a pepperoni pizza and a plain cheese pizza, and both were among the best New York-style pies I've had in Southwest Florida. The crust was spot-on--thin and crispy on the outside with a perfectly chewy inside. The sauce was rich and slightly sweet, complementing the generous amount of mozzarella cheese on top. Folding a slice in half, the way a true NY pizza should be eaten, felt just right. 500 Degrees clearly knows what they're doing when it comes to pizza. I can't wait to return for a sit-down dinner to see what the table service is like and try out more of the dishes on the menu. Salute! read more

We were excited to try 500 degrees given the high rating. Unfortunately it's very noisy and the metal chairs are uncomfortable. The salad itself was crisp unfortunately the dressing is bottle with the Italian extremely sweet. The prices are fair and reasonable. I truly don't like to give any negative reviews to smaller self-owned non-corporate businesses. Unfortunately, given the high ratings I think it's only fair to give a fair review. read more

Calamari was fishy smelling and didn't love their Italian dishes. Wanted to really like this place, but it was a no-go for us. Sorry!

We ate here right after they opened, wrote I review but somehow it is gone. the staff was wonderful, we encountered at least 5 people working here, they all showed true concern to make sure we were happy. we went with a pizza and were happy. good sauce, good crust, good taste. going back to have something else. always nice to go to a place with the owners being there read more

Some of the best food you will find in Venice! Focaccia bread is made daily in house and nothing but the best ingredients. If you haven't tried this place you should. Haven't had a bad meal here since this place opened. read more

See all

We were at the brewery next door and my husband stopped in to pick up something sweet for us to take home. We got a piece of tiramisu and rocky road cheesecake. It was by far THE BEST I have had around here. DELICIOUS!! We have been wanting to stop in to eat and will definitely be in once season is over!! read more

Very Disappointed in this newly open Italian place. Wanted to like the food but it's just not what I thought. Everything they serve is like they are saving money on ingredients. It's always so little. Sicilian pizza for example had very little toppings including cheese. It's like having bread. The white pizza was so dry and almost burnt. Cheesesteak beef was OK but too much bread and barely any cheese. Focaccia sandwich chicken, pesto with roasted red peppers was so very small. Sad to say but if things do not improve they will close the doors soon. Good Luck read more

See all

First, the owners and staff were so wonderful! The sandwiches, Stromboli look amazing and huge! My wife's salad was awesome. But, the Pizza was disappointing and normal. Really love the location and casual nature. read more

Food always good. Service excellent ! Ambiance is not quite fine dining it's a bit more open feeling and casual . Overall excellent !

Had lunch here today. 3 of us had sandwiches and they were all excellent. Two Italians and one meet ball. Fresh bread. Service was good and prices were good read more

Food is awesome! Last time there, shared a Stromboli with a friend and it was delicious. Even brought leftovers home.

Only open about two weeks and already a runaway success. Fabulous food cooked and delivered by family owner operators.

Our first visit today and was very pleased. The food, service, prices, cleanliness all were great and the foods were all delicious. Keep up the great work, we'll be back! Special thanks to the son that gave the place a warm and welcoming, down home atmosphere! read more

We've been going here since they opened. The food is outstanding and the service is excellent read more

Really fresh & delicious Italian food. The fresh baked bread served with olive oil & a chopped jardiniere starts the meal off perfectly. Minestrone soup is scratch made & the tomato sauce fresh & pretty perfect. Plus lots of Italian pastries! read more

500 Degrees Italian Eatery - Capellini with meat sauce - Italian Near Me - North Venice, Florida

Bunch of young adults serving tables with no clue about elegant service. Food is average. The worst is the nasty arrogant attitude you get when you mention that your meal isn't up to your expectations! They must have skipped the course "How to listen to your client" . lol read more

If you unseat people from a table to sit another couple then have a host or hostess. When it's open seating and you have NO clue how long WE were waiting then do not request we get up Will not be back read more

Last night we decided to try the Sicilian Pizza.... Pepperoni, sausage and black olives. Alert ... This delicious pizza can feed an army, is a great value $ , our server Mave was a real sweetheart! This was our second dine in experience and definitely won't be our last...keep up the great work read more

We have tried it once when they first opened and had a lovely dinner. Brought friends a few weeks ago and had a terrible experience. My husband's spaghetti he said "tasted like the sauce came from a bottle." My manicotti looked like it has slid off the plate and they slid it back on. The first time I got 3 manicotti pieces on a platter. The second visit it was two pieces. I'm not sure what happened because when I looked over to another table they were 3 pieces on a mother persons plate. I went in again on Sunday (we always give restaurants 2-3 chances before we make a final decision) and ordered take out. I ordered takeout this time. I ordered the manicotti again and received 2 pieces, salad and had to ask for the bread. After eating one piece, I got food poisoning and was sick until it all was out of my system. I/we will never be back. We certainly do not recommend. It's a shame because at first we had high hopes. read more

Did not stay for lunch, walked in and out. Tables and chairs small made of metal with no cushion. Not a place to dine in but a working person's lunch spot. Would try a takeout. read more

Everything was amazing. Soup was delicious and served hot. Bruschetta was the best I've had since leaving Rhode Island. Main course was 5 star. Service was great. Thank you for a great meal and a relaxing dining experience. We will be back. read more

We've eaten at 500 Degrees for dinner and we're pleased with the regular menu entrees. We decided to get pizza takeout the other day with high expectations and boy were we disappointed. We spent $30 on a large Sicilian pizza. As soon as I opened the box I knew it was gonna be terrible. No joke, this thing was 4 inches high. Each slice was like eating a loaf of bread. Sauce and cheese was skimpy. Sausage was ok. I thought about returning it but I didn't feel like dealing with any drama. I thought they "specialized" in pizza?? I'm worried about this place. Not sure they're gonna succeed. It's a shame because there isn't anything east of 75. Hopeful things improve! read more

We ordered a bunch of food for the local Amazon Delivery Station, and the food was excellent!! Sal knocked it out of the park with both quality and expedited service. I will continue to forward our business into him in the future. read more

The food was great. The chicken parm did not disappoint. The amount of chicken was wonderful. We used to frequent the establishment down the road until we tried 500 Degrees. The prices are better, the portions are bigger, the staff is friendlier. You can't go wrong. read more

Noisy,crowded,placed order and waited 45 minutes to be served. Food is menza menza. Needs more help.

Went there for the first time and was pleasantly surprised. Service was excellent food was great and dessert was outstanding. Will go back.

Party of 4. Food ok but nothing special. Service left a bit to be desired. 2 apps were good. Antipasto platter and calamari. Had to ask for plates for the table. Pasta fajoli soup very dense/thick but taste acceptable. Pizza was ok, but a bit doughy crust. Lasagna just ok. Had to ask for a plate to put shells that were in the my seafood pasta. Bread ordered, never arrived. Water had to be requested., which I did, but it never arrived. Seems like the staff doesn't think ahead when they are putting food on the table what is needed in order to eat it. Husband's pizza (his dinner) arrived 10" at least before the other 3 dinners. Very noisy. Glad I tried it bc I heard good things. But won't be returning any time soon. read more

Pizza is good, everything else is pretty disgusting, smothered with cheap jar tomato sauce, presentation is below average. One star road side diner. read more

I hate to leave a negative review. Went to 500 Degrees last Sunday with a group of friends. Has a cute small market vibe. Seated after a small wait. Ordered wine to start. A couple of the wine glasses were dirty (one returned because still had lipstick on it). Nice wine selection. Table ordered different dishes. Myself and a friend ordered cesar salad to go with our rollitini. Salads were nothing great. I noticed a little different taste/texture on the Parmesan cheese on the salad. The rollitini is eggplant Parmesan rolled with a ricotta cheese. I couldn't taste the eggplant. Just the breadcrumb mixture. Overall it was just mediocre experience. The rating of the 1 is due to the food poisoning me and my friend got from our dinner. It was AWFUL! No one else in our group got it. So we limited it down to our dinner or salad. My friend reached out (through Instagram I think since no contract info) to let them know. Responded but then no follow up. Just think it's important for people to know so it doesn't happen again or to anyone else. read more