I visited again. I can't compliment this place enough. I love the downtown building and the various bar, table, booth and high top seating options. Service from Tahlia was excellent. I had the cheese bread, which is incredible. (It's so difficult to choose between the cheese bread and the pretzel.) I tried the wrath burger. It was good and would have been even better if I had gone with the egg sunny side up instead of fries. The fries are out of this world. I'd make the hour drive just for them. read more

We had the supreme pizza and it was delicious. The crust was especially good. Service was good as well.

They had me at fresh cut fries cooked in beef tallow! Wow. What a difference without the oiliness: a hearty mouthfeel and great texture; bursting with flavor, and even the leftovers reheat pretty well. There is no 'meat taste' at all so get in here and give these a try. I had a feeling I would love it and I did. It's a large yet cozy venue with the number 5 featured prominently in assorted art as well as on the tables. The building is historic, lots of wood, brick and brass railings plus a stunning Victorian bar back. We ate at the bar which was very comfortable. Little sliding wooden trays to make it convenient for eating, then just move them out of the way when you're done. They have 10 or so craft beers on tap and a full bar. We had the opportunity to sample a couple brews and we both enjoyed our beer choices and the food. Prices were fair, and tax is included in the menu price. I really want to shout out our bartender/server. Didn't get her name but she had round glasses with eyeglass chain attached and was on the shorter side. She was very customer focused, answering all our first-timer questions, attentive, appropriately conversational, and definitely on the ball as she was handling tables too. Top notch service. About those railings: unless there's a special back entrance, the venue may not be wheelchair accessible. There are two or three steps at the entrance, and if you want the bar instead of booth or table, another three or four. Both have sturdy solid handrails. I do not fault them for this; probably the historic building is exempt, but just wanted to note it for anyone needing that info. All in all a five star experience and I hope to return soon. read more

See all

Last time I was in here was about 3 or 4 restaurants ago when it was called Jag's. I hope 5 Arch will stick around for awhile! Character-rich atmosphere with a brick arch inside and a beautiful historic back bar. I'm a bourbon drinker, so didn't try the beer, but was very happy with my Old Fashioned. My e-star burger with mushrooms, Swiss, onions and pickled cabbage was delicious, and the serving of fries was extremely generous. A great spot for dinner with friends. read more

5 Arch Brewing - E-star burger and fries - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Indiana

First time in the area and stumbled upon this place due to the positive Yelp reviews and it did not disappoint! Very cozy vibes, friendly service, and delicious food. I went with the burger and fries but it was a tough call due to all the delicious-sounding options. Would definitely come back again if I'm in the area. read more

5 Arch used to be 5 stars for me. But my standards have increased a little, and their standards have decreased a little. The star here are the fries, by far the best fries around. Get em loaded or get em plain. After that, the salads are pretty dang good. The pizzas used to be outstanding but have fallen into "decent" range in the last couple years. The burgers and BBQ have always been a little above average. The cocktails are a little underwhelming and the beer is also nothing to be too excited about. Service is good. Atmosphere is Good! The woodwork on the bar is gorgeous and the space has lots of open brick archways which make it pleasant place to eat and be with friends. read more

We stopped on our way to Ohio. It was well worth the drive. Delicious food, charming atmosphere, good service! We'll be back!

Unforgettable Experience at 5 Arch Brewing! From the moment we walked into 5 Arch Brewing, I was captivated by the warm ambiance and friendly service. The Onis burger - a juicy burger on a freshly baked bun, topped with bacon, brie and bramble jam, served with fresh cut fries, was a flavor explosion, and the Brussels sprouts were perfectly prepared. We returned for a second visit in less than a week and shared Pretzel Bites and an Onis pizza. My husband ordered two different beers - Perfect Hibernation, a Russian Imperial Stout which was chocolatey, with hints of coffee. I don't recall the other, but it was a lighter more citrusy beer, not my favorite but still good. The delicious food and beer, combined with the friendly service, make 5 Arch Brewing an unforgettable experience that easily outshines national chains. Don't miss out on this incredible local treasure. read more

See all

We about froze to death there today. Had to hurry through lunch because we were so cold. Food was good, as always. The fries alone are worth the trip, even with the meals' higher prices. read more

5 Arch Brewing - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Indiana

Food and atmosphere is amazing, don't go if in a rush but when it comes it's great ! The owners are great, pizza is really good and beer is great. read more

After a day of exploring Richmond, we stopped at 5 Arch Brewing on the way home. What a wonderful experience. We ate at the bar, and enjoyed chatting with the bartender Lily. We tried a few beers, with the Onis and chocolate Mausolud being our favorites. We only had appetizers but they were amazing. The fries were delicious and the homemade jalapeño poppers fantastic. Two thumbs up for atmosphere, service and food! Well worth a stop if you are heading anywhere along that stretch of I70!!! read more

See all

Some of the best food we've had in a very long time! Couldn't ask for better service or atmosphere. The only down fall is that we live two hours away but definitely worth the drive and will be going back. read more

We stopped here on the way home and were blown away. The ambiance is wonderful, the building is old and has so much character. Our server was really great and attentive! The food was delicious. Some of the best chicken bacon ranch pizza. The dough is light and fluffy and so good. The brisket and burger were good too. So glad this isn't too far from home, we'll definitely be making another trip out here. read more

Great atmosphere and quick service, had refills before even got close to empty. Food was amazing, had two different burgers and fry styles (beer cheese and truffle). Many only issue was too many fries and could stop eating. Not a familiar with area as first time in town, but so glad made stop here for lunch. read more

Always look forward to checking out breweries when traveling. The reviews I read talked so much about the food and they were not wrong. It was delicious! The beer was not as flavorful as I would've liked but would absolutely eat here again. read more

See all

Made a return trip today and the experience was as awesome as the first. The aesthetics of the multiple brick arches, the extremely cool ceiling, and the beautiful bar itself are unlike any other place I have seen. The service was fantastic. Kelsee, our server, was kind, attentive, and efficient, which was also true of the other employees who assisted her. The food is excellent! Our Margherita Pizza ($13 w/mozzarella, basil, grape tomatoes) was great again. My father-in-law's E-Star Burger ($14 w/mushrooms and caramelized onions) looked outstanding and he said it was very good. I highly recommend the fries, which are probably my favorite anywhere right now. My Mausolus Stout ($6 16oz) tasted amazing. And our Jody's Apple Dumpling ($8) to finish things off was terrific. Throw in I realized today that the menu-listed prices include taxes and that for every beer you order, you receive a small disc/chip to place into a container for 1 of 5 different charitable groups they have set up to support, I so wish we lived closer to be regulars here. The only 2 knocks we have would be: (1) don't love the exposed light bulb fixtures over each of the tables and (2) wish they had more non-meat menu offerings for my pescatarian wife like a veggie, fish, or shrimp based item. I realize they are proud of their Centerville home, but maybe they could open another site an hour or so west? read more

It's unfortunate that the price keeps going up while the service keeps getting worse. Almost $20 for a burger and fries. Waited forever for drinks, appetizer never came out, and our order was wrong. Server only had 2 other tables but hid out in the little service area. Never offered refills. Never offered dessert. Left the bill without saying one word. Only 1 tv was on at the bar and it was blocked by a wall and the music was quiet so the atmosphere was kind of awkward since you could hear other guests conversations. I think this was our last meal here. read more

Fries are yummy! Chicken strips and chicken sandwich were tasty. Burgers weren't great. Service and atmosphere were good.

Well, currently, we have sat here for 45 minutes. We have our drinks still waiting on our food not a happy camper with this place. It's got nice atmosphere and they have nice merchandise hanging on the walls but service here is horrible. I'll finish my review when I get my food. The tile fries are really good. Well seasoned some some of Myrtle on the burger nice onions, tomato the burger bun is pretty good dill pickle spear, which I won't eat. This may change my mind on the long wait. OK my friend says this coleslaw is vinegar. Has a nice salty taste. Mother friend picked up the wooden salt shaker how to turn the thing to make salt come out so we had to show him. It's like bringing a toddler to a restaurant he's actually older than both of us. Having an off day it is Saturday. It is 120. We did wait a while but I think the our main problem we have with restaurants as we go to Mexican restaurants a lot and usually get food brought out immediately so maybe because they had to cook the fries and tallow and make the burgers fresh maybe that's why it took longer. I'm gonna give it four stars not happy about that but my friends are all giving me dirty. looks as they don't want me to give a bad rating thank you. read more

My husband and I decided to try 5 Arch after we were nearby for an event. The staff was amazing. There are burgers that have the same names as beers and those are the ones that pair well together! We ordered a flight of 5 of their beers and enjoyed all of them. The pulled pork and onion strings were delicious. My husband also enjoyed the cheeseburger and fries. We shared the brownie at the end. After your meal, you are also given a wooden nickel to choose a charity of your choice. At the end of the year, 5 Arch donates to those charities. We will definitely be back! read more

5 Arch Brewing - Flight - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Indiana

See all

Absolutely loves this place. It's located in an interesting old building. The staff is great and the prices reasonable for such good quality. They have a large variety of "pub food" like BBQ, loades fries, pizza and salad. They make a lot of their things in house. The apple dumpling dessert was amazing. A bit of a drive, but definitely worth it. read more

5 Arch Brewing - Pulled pork platter - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Indiana

We will definitely be back! The place was cozy and super neat on the inside. Our server was quick to grab our drink orders. The burgers and fries were amazing! So were the poppers! Hubby loved the beers. We cannot wait to go back and try some new stuff. A must try for our small town IN. read more

See all

If you travel a lot, you've no doubt come to the pleasant realization that one of the great things about this country is the proliferation of craft breweries. The smallest of towns just might have a craft brewery. Little Centerville, Indiana, does--5 Arch Brewing Company. Check their excellent website for what's behind the name as well as their history, impressive people, and business philosophy. But you'll have to come to little Centerville and 5 Arch to appreciate the brews, the food, the space and the people. They are all good. I'm glad I made the trip. read more

5 Arch Brewing - Enroute on the flight. - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Indiana

If you enjoy brewery hopping like we do, you need to add this one to your list. The ambiance inside is incredible, beautiful brick archways and the bar back from the Chicagos Worlds Fair...it was stunning. The fries appear to be hand cut and the hamburger was tasty. They make their own buns for the burgers and it shows. The bartender went above and beyond answering our questions, we DEF will be back! read more

In all fairness, this is strictly a beer review. By looking at some of the other reviews it appears the food is decent. I'll adjust if I find the food is palatable. Located on the Main Street in Centerville. Named for the 5 arches within the building. They have a very cool bar. The back of the bar/liquor shelves are from the 1800's. A world fair I believe. Bartenders are always friendly. The beer is average at best. They have 6-8 on tap. Had the lemon-wheat beer on this occasion. Almost tasted like a Hefe. Just really no creativity in their beers. Same taps as I had tried a few years ago but maybe one. Having been to hundreds of breweries I prefer to frequent places with rotating taps and more seasonal infusions. May stop in again to try the food though. read more

We live in Indiana, my parents live in Ohio. 5 Arch Brewing was a great meet-in-the-middle place. Pretzel bite apps were ok. Could have been hotter and I would choose spicy brown mustard over honey mustard for dipping. But the entrees were great. Pizza. Burgers. Everything made in-house, even the buns. Generous portions. Reasonable prices. Staff was terrific -- very patient and personable. For each drink you order, they give you a wooden nickel. Then you drop the nickel into the bucket of one of 5 local Non-profits. Each wooden nickel is worth 5 cents and the charity is given a check at the end of the year. Pretty cool. I am sure we will be back. read more

5 Arch Brewing - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Indiana

See all

Got sausage pizza brought home. The sausage was overcooked and crispy. It was not good. The sauce had a strange taste. I grew up in Chicago and I know good pizza. This isn't it. Caseys in Centerville makes a much better sausage pizza. read more

We visited mid afternoon on a Saturday. This place is beautiful on the inside! It doesn't look like much from the outside, but the brick arches and the historic bar back make it so pretty. Service was a bit slow for not being super busy, but that could've just been a staffing issue. The servers were very friendly. We ordered the Bloody Mary, which came with a house made pickle. The pickle was tasty, but the bloody was a bit bland. We added bit of Tabasco, salt & pepper and it was good. I would try something else next time. I had the grilled cheese & tomato bisque. It was delicious! Homemade bread with Muenster cheese was perfect! The soup was very flavorful. My friend ordered the poutine fries and an Onis burger. The burger was a bit small, but she said the flavor was amazing! She loved it. We would definitely eat here again. The story of the bar is really cool. They have a great website. Every drink ordered received a wooden token to use to choose a local charity to support. Tips are appreciated, but not required as they are paying their servers a living wage (still, tip please!) and all prices include tax. read more

Where do I begin? The burgers, the pizza, the chicken sandwich, the wings, the fries, THE POUTINE. Everything is so good here! Always have great service!! read more

We stopped by after shopping near Richmond. We parked in the back and I could see the smoker barrels with smoke coming out. I knew this was legit. We split the Kitchen Sink platter. The brisket was tender. The pork was as well. The smoke flavor was intense and we enjoyed that. You can tell it wasn't done on a pellet smoker. The wings had great flavor but were a little burnt. We still devoured them! The wait staff was great. The prices and atmosphere will keep us coming back. It's an hour drive for us but well worth it. read more

5 Arch Brewing - Kitchen Sink Platter - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Indiana

A local shop owner recommended 5 Arch and so glad she did. The food was fantastic. The Brussels were perfectly roasted. Crisp yet tender and flavorful with garlic, bacon & ghee. The burgers were juicy and packed with flavor. The Onis had Brie, bramble berry jam and candied bacon. The Leloo had ghost pepper cheese, onion straws and cilantro. They offer a junior size version which was perfect when paired with the filling quinoa salad. The fries that came were cold but, still delicious hand-cut fries. We're looking forward to our next visit. read more

See all

Waitress was very nice! Food was excellent! One of the best burgers we've had! Very clean!

We were in town just for the weekend and used yelp to find a place. I have food allergies so I always am careful what I choose. This place didn't disappoint. They had plenty of options for me and I could make alterations where they didn't. We ordered 3 appetizers, burgers and drinks and EVERYTHING was out of this world delicious. This is the largest menu I have ever seen at a brewery. Go check it out, you won't be disappointed! read more

We recently revisited this place for the first time! We used to eat in this location several years ago when it was a different restaurant. We loved it then and we loved it now. Still has great ambiance and is a great place to sit and have a few beers and visit with old friends. If you're in the area I would make it a point to stop in grab a bit. Also the old architecture in this place remains a treat for me as I really dig old buildings that keep the old craftsmanship on display! read more

Phenomenal! The Onis burger never disappoints! Service is always great! Carry out is not always available but understandable when they're always busy! read more

What a wonderful place! My husband & I came across 5 Arch Brewing while returning east from a cross country road trip, and we are so happy that we did! We sat at the bar where we not only enjoyed the company of the bartender/owner & also a friendly local, but also could easily admire the beautiful & historical bar itself (a late 19th century antique from the Chicago World's Fair). We discovered that 5 Arch not only offers local Indiana beverages including beer, wine & liquor (highly recommend the limoncello martini) but also delicious food. We enjoyed their roasted brussel sprouts, a quinoa salad & a burger with truffle fries...all were fabulous. In addition to offering good food & drink, 5 Arch Brewing is also committed to supporting their local community, giving patrons a chance to decide where donations should go. Our only concern is that we live too far away to be regular customers! Thank you Marianne & 5 Arch Brewing! We hope to be back someday! read more

5 Arch We ordered carry out from 5 Arch Brewing one hectic night while visiting family. Hectic for us - new baby, family in town visiting, other family leaving, new puppy, the list goes on! We were all hungry and our sister in law/husband said they had amazing food. We accessed their menu online and put in the order. We had a fairly large order. Made fresh to order, our food was done and ready for pick up about 30-minutes later. We arrived to the restaurant and parked in their designated carry out parking spots.  An employee brought out food out shortly after - several bags. It smelled amazing. We took the food back to the house for sorting and consuming. Our giant order was correct! Do you know how exciting it is when restaurants get your order correct?? It's amazing! No one is left disappointed that their order was incorrect. And 5 Arch nailed it!! The food - keeping up with the theme here; the food was fabulous. I ordered the Spectacular Burger and definitely was Spectacular! It was probably one of the top burgers I have ever had in my life. Let me say this - the portions are huge! HUGE! I could have shared that burger with at least one person if not two. They are half pound burgers with beautiful, tasty, fresh toppings; bacon, muenster, lettuce, tomato, onion, aioli, a home made pickle on the side and glorious french fries. Three others in our group ordered the Spectacular burger with spectacular reviews too. We also ordered tacos, brussel sprouts, & a keto double patty burger (He didn't realize how big they were!). We all had leftovers. Have you ever been stoked to eat leftovers? We were with these.  This is my new favorite spot when we visit Centerville....it will be yours too; I'm sure of it. read more

See all

Worth driving 45 minutes every other weekend for the scrumptious hand-cut French fries, pizza, and beer. Seriously the best fries within a hundred miles and that's coming from folks with that as a life mission. Onus pizza with bramble jam is absolutely killer and everything is served with a smile from co-owner Mary Anne. Absolutely the best food and the best folks - cannot recommend more highly. read more

5 Arch Brewing - Titillating, mouth-gasm of fry bliss - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Indiana

Wonderful surprise! Smoked wings the bomb. And those yummy fries. Definitely will be back - a lot.

Had a really good meal and experience. Everyone else enjoyed the wide variety of local brews.