Love this cute local small spot. The vibe is very 90's coffee shop esque. My fiance always gets his iced french toast latte as its a regular on the menu and is always so so good. This is one of few coffee places I can drink their cold brew with just a little bit of milk and honey-its so so good. It fits in very well with the whole vibe of First Avenue in Atlantic Highlands and is an underrated spot! read more

1st Cup Coffee - Iced French Toast Latte & Cold Brew w/ Honey and Cinnamon - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

Have always loved this coffee shop, and the staff has consistently been amazing, except for my most recent visit a few days ago. The young woman at the counter, whom I had never seen before, was extremely rude for no apparent reason. I was genuinely taken aback. It's not the best look for a downtown coffee shop, especially when part of its charm is the warm, welcoming, and local experience it typically provides. read more

Delightful space, relaxed yet inviting. Excellent coffee. Parking can be iffy. Pleasant staff. Well worth checking out.

i just got given the best chai i've literally ever had from this place. it tastes like dreams. 10/10. you should get it with pumpkin syrup. this is so fire. they were also so friendly and the ambience is sooo cute!!! read more

1st cup Coffee is a great coffee spot in the Atlantic Highlands. They have awesome drink specials + baked goods. It's a nice spot to relax and enjoy your coffee. The French toast iced latte was unbelievable and tasted like the popular breakfast dish in every sip! read more

1st Cup Coffee - Beautiful coffee shop in Atlantic Highlands - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

See all

Super chill place for quiet time for yourself. The art work is amazing and the employees are very nice. They make you feel so welcomed. They do not trust their own coffee beans here. It's from a local roaster from Forked River in Ocean. They do carry almond, soy and coconut milk if you ask. I found another wonderful coffee place to frequent. read more

See all

I was looking for a coffee place in the area since my wife was at a function at the Shore Casino.. this place doesn't disappoint! Nice cafe vibe with some delicious options! I chose the Nutella Latte which was super yummy! They had fresh muffins next to the register, so I had to try the Pumpkin Crumb muffin AND the Zucchini Walnut Raisin muffin... dude, these were seriously scrumptious and moist! I will definitely be coming back when in the area! And the barista was super nice and sweet.. I didn't catch her name but she was just so pleasant! Sometimes when you walk into a new place, people give you the vibe that they are doing you a favor by serving you your order.. this place was so comfortable and welcoming, that I totally felt at ease and just couldn't wait to enjoy my drink and treats! Enjoy! read more

I've been to the newer 1st cup location, and I think I prefer this one. There's a cozier vibe here. Coffee is always good, and my croissant, though I usually love Balthazar croissants, was a bit stale, so that was disappointing. But if in the area, I would definitely come again. read more

1st Cup Coffee - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

love their lattes! I stop in ever morning halfway through the dog walk. The shop is always spotless. the staff are friendly, quick, will answer endless questions about the specialty drinks, and generally create a friendly, chill atmosphere. read more

Love this coffee stop. Right on First Ave and my go to when I need a coffee while at work. Their 1st cup shake is really great also. Give them a try! read more

This might be my favorite coffee place in Monmouth county. I know Rook dominates the area and they are good but I real as if this place just beats them out in every way. It's not too busy, there are plenty of options, the price is on par with every other coffee place and the staff has always been great. The cold brew is one of the best I have had. They will even blend it with a banana and make it like a slushie which I haven't had elsewhere. So points for that as well. Just another great place for Atlantic Highlands. read more

Love Bobby. Love the great service, great coffees, great conversations. Great vibes.

Everyone at 1st Cup Coffee is pleasant and helpful from owner to staff! A wonderful environment to spend time in alone or with a friend. Drinks and snacks are plentiful and yummy! Support small business in this great town! read more

Do NOT come here unless you are prepared to experience the absolute best dark roast, specialty drinks, baristas, and artsy vibe in Central New Jersey. I absolutely love this place and owner Bob is the best. read more

Still the best up of coffee in Atlantic Highlands. Try the first up shake with a bit of peanut butter & chocolate, it's my favorite drink to order. The owner is always greeting you happily and remembers all his regulars. The staff is always super nice and welcoming. Pre-covid it was a great spot to sit and drink your coffee. During covid, they have maintain a safe & clean atmosphere and is one of the few places I will go inside of. read more

Great local spot with wonderful owner but lately it seems the employees cannot show up on time. Shop is supposed to open at 6 am but it rarely is which means they lose my business to starbucks. I was there yesterday (6/2/23) at 6:25 am and while the shop was open nothing was prepared and no coffee was brewed. Today I was there at 6:15 am and the door was still locked. read more

Simply the best coffee architect in Monmouth County/ Bob knows coffee and customer service. And the artwork - as cool as the vibe of the shop read more

I was always content drinking coffee from a Keurig or making a quick stop at Dunkin' Donuts. That was before my girlfriend told me about 1st Cup Coffee. Now I'm ruined for life. No other can compare. When I'm not down the shore, I have all week to drink subpar coffee and daydream about this place. The owner, Bob, is about the nicest guy you'll meet (and he'll remember your name, too, even if you've been in there once). 1st Cup has a variety of all those fancy offerings, but what stands out is a regular hot cup of either their medium roast or my favorite, the Kenya Dark Roast. Seriously, stop by here and throw out your Keurig. You'll thank me. read more

This is certainly one of the best cafes in Monmouth County; it is quiet and unpretentious, with small treats from local bakeries. It's also closely tied-in with the community; local artisans sell their work here, and there is a monthly open-mike. This is the spot for hanging out and chatting in AH. read more

Coffee before beach walk , beautiful decor , lot of options for coffee and very nice staff , will visit again read more

1st Cup Coffee - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

See all

Great coffee, good prices, and everyone who works there is friendly. The owner, Bob is super friendly as well and is happy to chat with everyone that comes in. Also a great place to come with a laptop and get some work done for a few hours. read more

Staff is incredibly friendly!!! I got the honey cinnamon latte with oat milk, and got it iced. It was delicious! Will definitely be going back read more

I love the warm cozy atmosphere, great coffee and wonderful staff. Great place to meet friends or business contacts for a delicious cup of coffee and snacks! read more

First Cup of Coffee always makes a great cup of coffee. I'm a huge fan of their coffee and I'm very picky about coffee. I personally, buy my own beans and make my own blend using Lavazza Beans. I have a full on espresso machine. In another life, I think I might have been a barista. So when I say this place has great coffee, I mean it and I know what I'm talking about. Not to mention their space has a great atmosphere that makes you want to hang for awhile. read more

Needed a calm place to study over the weekend and 1st cup was a great cafe for that. The service was great and inviting. The chai latte was delicious. read more

1st Cup Coffee - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

See all

Amazing coffee and super helpful and passionate barista! Pleasant surprise

Fantastic first visit today on our way home from Sandy Hook. Barista was one cool cat, our drinks were fantastic (coffee and a chai latte), and a very cool vibe for this little shop. I'll definitely be back! read more

1st Cup Coffee - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

See all

So usually on my way to Sandyhook I stop and grab a decaf . But the last couple of times I have stopped at the DD near Sandyhook and have been truly disappointed. Not sure what is the issue with DD in this town and went on a search for a coffee place in town. Came across this place via yelp. And I will never stop at a DD on my way to Sandyhook, as long as this place is open. Literally 10 minutes from Sandyhook and so worth the visit. I ordered a large decaf latte and it was perfect. I was also impressed with the young lady behind the counter. She knew most of her customers name as well as there orders. read more

Great atmosphere and great coffee! A true hidden gem. The owner has been in the coffee shop biz for many years is very creative with the drinks. I recommend trying the cold brew & banana blend. It's pretty bangin' read more

1st Cup Coffee - Great atmosphere and great coffee! - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

Coming from North Jersey where we don't have anything but chains, I'm in love with this place and so glad I got to try it! This is my first time here, and it definitely won't be my last. I went to get a cold brew, but unfortunately they were out. Instead, the guy here made me an Americano over ice, and charged me the same price as a cold brew. He was outgoing and quite friendly, and this is what local businesses are all about! The coffee was excellent and it was well worth the wait! Please try this place the next time you're in the area! Open 6am-6pm everyday, even Sunday! read more

1st Cup Coffee - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

Very cozy place. You can see some pictures and arts created from local artists and photographers. Cold Brew coffee was good. Also they have variety of milk options. So glad, they have almond milk. This place is also great for people who want to relax at a place for reading, work or even study. It can really keep your mind focus and calm instead of some chain coffee shops sometimes. read more

I don't think you can go on a lengthy review, but it's a coffee shop with some god damn good coffee.

Fantastic coffee, excellent and friendly service! The fresh pasteries from Balthazar's are a temptation to say the least! The cold brew was refreshing and flavorful! Bob amd his baristas are friendly and know how to read a room. read more

1st Cup Coffee - Great live music at First Cup! - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

Cool place. Went late on a Saturday afternoon and they had open mic going which was cool. Heard some good music and got some good coffee. They have some unique drinks there that you won't find at other places. read more

amazing place. took us in after closing, the kid running the place was already cleaning, and made us two fabulous caramel iced lattes. we will be coming back regularly :) hopefully before closing though. super cool shop supporting smaller business and house made goodies. brought a smile to my face!! read more

Great coffee and owners are very friendly and personable. Try the iced caramel latte or their specialty drink, "1st cup". Its an iced coffee and banana frappe. read more

I love this coffee shop. Firstly, everyone that works here makes you feel at home. The coffee is much better than anything you get at Starbucks and the atmosphere is really Welcoming. I ended up doing some computer work here and socializing for the afternoon. I felt at home and at ease. I ended up meeting lots of local people from the surrounding areas everyone was so nice. I highly recommend the Dirty Chai latte, Berry Banana smoothies, the Sumatra Dark coffee, and the Cold brew Iced coffee (before they run out into). Needless to say I will be back! Finally a nice place to get coffee in the area and its open till 6! read more

The workers are very nice people, and the prices are reasonable. They also have great coffee and tea drinks and I had a honey and cinnamon late and it was very good. Highly recommend read more

Awesome place! They have good coffee and the stuff is very friendly.

Great coffee, a fantastic selection of pastries, and a quiet atmosphere if you're looking to get some work done or do some reading. In a genuinely warm and inviting atmosphere, the owner Bob and his team made me feel like a regular from my very first visit and have never once let me down. The best way to start your morning in Atlantic Highlands! read more