Our first visit to 1875 Winery for a bottle of wine and appetizers was such a treat! Our server was attentive but not overbearing- wine was a tad sweet for me, but my husband isn't a wine drinker and loves concord wine. The food was exceptional! Can't wait to return. read more

1875 Winery - Arancini and charcuterie board - Wineries Near Me - Hartville, Ohio

See all

This place is fun! They have a variety of sweet and dry wines, plus some cocktails. This way everyone can partake. We did not eat. So I cannot comment on that. But the slushie Carmel apple drink was yummy. We sat inside. Patio looks fun. Lots of people on a Saturday afternoon. Service was good. I thin food prices are a bit high. Drink prices are in-line. Service was good. Lots of parking. It is a definite return visit. read more

Beautiful property and the wait staff was very friendly and attentive. Their wine is on the sweet side which is expected from Ohio grapes, which was thoroughly explained by are awesome server in advance. A must have is the pizza!! read more

1875 Winery - Wine board - Wineries Near Me - Hartville, Ohio

This place has a nice patio with a lake view. Plenty of seating outside. The food is good and the wine is good as well. Our server, Grace was fantastic! Quick and friendly serivce. However the inside of the winery is sort of bland. Not much atmosphere. And the prices are somewhat on the higher end. read more

See all

We decided to try this place for my mom's birthday, but what a mistake that was. With the glowing reviews, I expected a much better experience, but what we got was beyond disappointing. From the moment we walked in, our server seemed like she had a personal grudge against us. Getting water felt like pulling teeth--multiple requests just to stay hydrated! The real kicker? She didn't even know what alcohol the bar carried. When we asked for specifics and got conflicting answers, we literally had to walk to the bar ourselves--only for her to argue with us about what they had. It was absurd. As for the food, it was a joke for the price. I wasn't expecting a fine-dining experience like Gervasi, but I certainly didn't think I'd be paying premium prices for grocery store sliced cheese. The only thing remotely edible was the pretzel, though I'm still scratching my head as to why it was served on a banana hanger. Seriously, who thought that was a good idea? This restaurant was a major letdown, and my mom's birthday dinner deserved way better. Save your money and avoid the headache--there are plenty of places out there with better service, better food, and staff who don't treat their guests like an inconvenience. read more

I am disappointed to update my review for 1875 Winery after our last visit to this establishment. They have a no children policy at the Winery and I fully agree that this is an adult place and most patrons probably enjoy the no children policy. However, We were absolutely appalled at what happened to a couple probably in their early 30's with one of their set of parents on a mid week afternoon around 4:00pm. The foursome was carrying a very young baby in a car seat covered with a blanket not making a peep. The young couple was visiting from out of town and had a reservation for a table. When they approached the hostess stand the young lady very rudely said we don't allow children here so you have to leave the winery immediately. I was within ear shot of the conversation so I could hear everything that was said. The mom very calmly told the hostess the baby was just fed and will be asleep for the next several hours but if it did wake up they would immediately leave. The hostess said again they had to leave immediately and we were shocked that she would not check with a manager to see if an exception could be made since it was so early in the day and the place was practically empty and they said they would leave if the baby woke up and started to cry. Again, I don't like kids running around a restaurant and I agree with this policy but the way it was handled was horrible and I felt bad about how they were spoken to! On an upside they did tell them to go to Maize Valley Winery just up the street! I hope they took her advice because Maize Vally is a very nice Winery! read more

See all

The pizza was good...I wish it had a little more "wood fired" brown around the edges, but that's just getting picky! The flavor was good.... Especially with the arugula salad on top. The grounds are so pretty. Wine...not to our taste, but I'm sure sweet wine drinkers enjoy it. They had some liquor, so I was happy to get a gin& tonic. We will be back, because I want to see that bagful fireplace lit at night!!! Now, I don't 5 stars out lightly, so don't think we didn't enjoy this place. By the way, Grace, our server, was very sweet, as well as the young lady at the bar...I don't know her name! Stop by and enjoy! read more

See all

It was a very nice day to visit the winery. Enjoyed all the vendors at the craft show. They were really nice vendors.

Such a beautiful new place. The outside area is perfect on a nice day, like when we went. They told us they fire up that fire pit in the picture every night. My wife got a wine flight that included a wine slushy which she enjoyed a lot. The meatball trio is a must try. The pizza was awesome, the dough had good chew to it and just enough char from the wood fired oven. They make their dough fresh daily and you can tell by the quality. We will definitely be back and plan on going at night to enjoy the fire pit. read more

See all

This was a great accidental find. We were going to go to 1285 and the whole time I was thinking it was the same place, but I kept saying 1875. This place had just opened recently. What an amazing find. They had food and was greeted when we walked in. The lady behind the bar said I've seen many people walk in here but I've never seen anyone TALL that I could see them walking in and was like wow. We sat down order food and the Italian Panini and appetizer buffalo chicken was extremely good. We tried 4 different wines. Each of the wines were very good. From Dry too Sweet. Hazzard was my favorite on the reds. It had a unique taste to the wine, which is a good thing. Very happy we stopped and will stop here again when we are in the area. Our waitress was absolutely amazing, she was friendly and stopped by constantly to check on us. read more

See all

4 stars = liked it, will come back Services was very good starting with the hostess and our server. He needed to hand clear but that is the only fault. Sat on the patio which was well designed and has a post and metal fence with waist high shrubs. Gives the area a well defined space and separation from the parking lot. I hate seating that is basically in the parking lot. Pizza was good but needed to be crispier with more toppings - sauce and toppings didn't go near enough to the edge. Flavor was good. Liked the shrimp and grits and would order them again. Sautéed tomatoes added a lot of flavor and grits had a good amount of cheese. read more

Service was great... it was Valentine's Day and very busy but the bartender was very nice and helpful. Sitting outside with the heaters was very nice and they had the fire going too. Will definitely go back. read more

Such yummy food, good vibes & great service!! Devin was amazing to us, made our time more enjoyable. Definitely a place to check out! read more

1875 Winery - Jalapeño stuffed risotto ball - Wineries Near Me - Hartville, Ohio

Not super impressed. It's a beautiful. But the wines all taste the same and the food was sub par. They were having a cookie class upstairs and the lady teaching it was so loud I could hear her In the bathroom stall. Not really the experience you want to have. We go to a lot of Ohio wineries and the wine is not impressive. None of the flight I had popped or stood out and they were sweet wines all served warm...the garlic bread had zero flavor besides cheese. Better places around. read more

1875 Winery - Wineries Near Me - Hartville, Ohio

The atmosphere was lovely and our waitress was attentive. The food was also good, but does not warrant the high prices. I eat in Los Angeles frequently and Winery1875 charges prices similar to that of a big city, not Randolph Ohio. Also, I was not happy to get home to discover that they passed on the credit card SERVICE FEE percentage without telling me beforehand. It seems tacky to get nickel and dimed at an "upscale" place like this. At least tell someone you are charging an extra fee. read more

Lovely winery with nice decor. Our server was friendly & attentive. The food was very good as was our wine flight. We will be back next time we are in the area. read more

We tried out the new winery in the area Beautiful place, they've put a lot into inside and out and have great taste on making it count! Nice setting for just about any type of event, get together, date, etc Wine had a variety, but it is typical of what you find In Ohio wines. The sweet palettes prefer Gatsby. While the others enjoyed High and Tight. No one was a fan of Hazzard The menu had a nice selection without being too big. Lite appetites to hefty and vegetarians all found something to eat The apps were great, pizzas were tasty. The entrees are just ok. There are some policies for this winery that could impact your visit. Adults only. Reservations only. Have to choose inside or out etc The person taking reservations on the phone seemed tired, unfriendly and irritated. Enough that I almost skipped this place. She was no way welcoming or service oriented. However. Our actual server was wonderful, friendly attentive and helpful! To improve and compete with other wineries close by, I hope 1875 will eliminate their list of policies and focus on service, wine and food. Just make it easy for us to visit and enjoy the setting and the wine! read more

Food had no taste I had the horseradish crusted salmon, very dry and didn't taste horseradish at all. The Parmesan risotto was like wallpaper paste. The house dry wine was sweet, all and all a pretty bad experience. Very unfortunate it a nice place but they need a new chef. read more

The staff was very nice & helpful 10/10 The ambiance was barn rustic, very clean. The patio is truly very beautifully relaxing another 10/10. Unfortunately the wine was all too sweet to drink and the beer list was very very weak 3/10 at best The cocktails were the alcohol bright spot however a little pricey 8/10. One last note we got there about 7:00 PM on a Saturday and they were sold of the first three items we picked, ended up just doing flat bread pizzas which were very good. read more

Enjoyable experience from wine to service to delightful food and atmosphere! Went for lunch and between my sister and I we purchased a case of different wines to enjoy! read more

The food, service, and decor is amazing! I had a wine slushie and the blackened salmon and they were botit was delicious! HIGHLY recommend this place. read more

See all

We love this place! The wine is amazing and they made special accommodations for our table to be special tonight and took amazing care of us! We will be back and recommend to everyone! read more

1875 Winery - Wineries Near Me - Hartville, Ohio

This place is amazing! See the pictures attached. Huge outdoor fireplace, water wall! Take a walk to the pond after dinner! We had a great time last night! The hostess and our server were both very friendly! I had the mixed berry wine slushy , so good! We had the fried cheese and the cheese board for appetizers and both were fantastic. After ordered the build your own pizza and one the best pizzas I had around here, a most to try!!! The kids ordered the Italian panini and grilled chicken with roasted potatoes and asparagus! They all loved there food! The menu is short and great! Overall go visit this place you will not be disappointed!! 1875 is going on my favorite list!! read more

See all

This is a beautiful location and very friendly and accommodating staff. The food was delicious and quick. I would recommend a visit.

We took my family here for a birthday dinner. Very nice facility, seemed 'upscale', however the entrees left a lot to be desired. Salmon was over cooked, sirloin dinner was sub-par at best. Overall nice atmosphere, just a shame the food couldn't match - especially at these prices. read more

Absolutely the most beautiful winery I have ever visited. Our waitress was wonderful, the food was amazing and the wine equally as good. My new favorite place, I can't wait to visit again! read more

See all

First time here and the ambiance was great! Caesar salad was huge and my husband really like his pizza! I also got the strawberry pie wine slushy, which was amazing! read more

1875 Winery - Strawberry pie wine slushy - Wineries Near Me - Hartville, Ohio

See all

First time trying 1875 and I was so pleasantly surprised on how nice it is! You can't tell from the road at all but they have a gorgeous patio and they had fires burning and live music when we went on a Thursday. A friend of mine and I enjoyed a bottle of wine together and had such great meals! I got the chicken parmesan and she had one of their pizzas and both were delicious! I can't wait to go back and bring more people to try this place out! read more

Cute spot! Got the Gatsby wine, Along with a margarita pizza--delicious! Awesome atmosphere. Nice waitress. Would definitely recommend!

Great food and wine. The atmosphere is fantastic. But for the first time ever, I was told that our party of 4 would need to leave soon because another party had our table reserved. And there were at least 3 tables open when we left. They encourage ordering drinks and appetizers but then you run out of time and can't order entrees. So I can't comment on the entrees cozy none of us ordered any. This was after an hour and a half AND after the waitress, a very nice woman named Devyn, told us they were out of pizza at 6:45 pm so we couldn't order pizza. ( but they may have just wanted us out of the dining area so they could seat another party if 4) Overall a great place but very questionable end of the evening. read more

Food was amazing! Service was excellent! Atmosphere perfect for date night. We will definitely be back

this winery is beautiful, great ambience and delicious wine. the girls are sweet and helpful.

We visited for my birthday and had a large party. Grace C was our server and did an outstanding job! She was friendly, knew the menu and kept our drinks filled. I can't wait to go again. read more

Wine was way better at Maize Valley. The wine slushies were good tho here. Wine selection was slim. Semi sweet red was not on ice. Food was waaay over priced and you're really just paying for the atmosphere. Go to pay and their automatic pay is 20% tip as the lowest recommended. Nice try but no. Service was good but not stellar. Better food selections at MV. read more

Rating for 3.0 -here's why. I'll start with the positive comment. It was our first time to try the restaurant and went for their Valentine special-package selection- it was GOOD! Appetizer nacho chips and. cheese-dip with corn was good, prime rib was good (also a good size 16 oz?) and cheese cake was good. Server was good - for checking on us regularly for what we need. On a NEGATIVE NOTE- we arrived for early dinner (around 5-ish pm) and WAITED for our table for ALMOST 2 HRS !!!! (ok- maybe 1hr and 50 mins)?? Yes, we were sitted aroumd 7pm??? They would sit parties with 4 to 6 people ahead of a couple / 2 people waiting on a table. There's heaters and tables outside but no chairs at the bar (inside) - just order uour drinks then stand or sit by the entrance door while waiting for your table. BTW - no reservations allowed - first come fist serve (does not apply for couples) . Dont know the best time for dinner -to get seated quickly ... or probably have 4- 6 people ... COUPLES dont have priority sitting ! Hopefully the owner thinks of a better system during winter time ... Maybe Summer time maybe different - more tables and seats outside? Hopefully? read more

Amazing winery with fantastic food and service! Highly recommended! The barn and grounds are gorgeous. If you like sweet white wine, try the Dollie and don't get me started in their homemade garlic bread! Yum! read more

1875 Winery - View from silo - Wineries Near Me - Hartville, Ohio

See all

The grounds, the building itself, the service and the wine-all wonderful. However, the food-not so much. From appetizers to the dinners-I can only say...meh. If 1875 works on the palatability of their food-I'm headed back in a hot minute. Also, good on you if you like country music, however, it's not my gig, and it was also a bit loud. read more

Chris B. We have been 3 times to the winery, loving the ambiance - good food and wine! However, this Sat. night, when we brought our son and daughter in law , visiting from Columbus, with their two kids, ( we were excited to show them our area's newest winery)...We were informed NO children under 16 and had to leave...Seriously? You have a menu ( pizza, etc.) conducive to younger folks. Other local wineries we frequent allow children - like Gervasis... Don't get this. Want to see you succeed, but this should be resvisited for sure. read more

Great food and wine! Their wine selection isn't huge, but I enjoyed every wine I tasted. Make reservations if you go on a weekend! We didn't and we weren't able to be seated for a bit, but we could grab a drink at the bar while we waited. Beautiful atmosphere. read more

See all

The service was sad! The dessert was ok! The build was dark no natural light. I was not impressed with this winery