Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    173 Webster Cafe

    3.7 (6 reviews)
    Closed 7:00 am - 9:00 pm

    173 Webster Cafe Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - 173 Webster Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - 173 Webster Cafe

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Cafeteria 2,245 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Porto Salvo - Lobster pasta  not on the menu, but it was my favorite!

    Porto Salvo

    4.5(251 reviews)
    1.4 miMelrose
    $$

    This spot has become one of those places I genuinely look forward to returning to again and again…read more Every visit feels easy and welcoming the moment you step inside. The team here knows how to make you feel taken care of without ever being overbearing--just warm, attentive hospitality that sets the tone for a great meal. The menu is full of dishes that feel thoughtfully prepared, and everything I've tried has been consistently flavorful. The lamb entrées are outstanding--tender, perfectly seasoned, and incredibly satisfying. Their steaks are just as impressive, cooked beautifully and full of rich flavor. It's the kind of food that makes you slow down and enjoy every bite.What really stands out, though, is the atmosphere. It strikes that perfect balance between relaxed and elevated, making it ideal for a cozy dinner, a laid-back evening with friends, or even a casual drink at the end of the day. There's a lot of intention in the details--lighting, décor, textures--which creates a space that feels both comfortable and polished without trying too hard. Every time I leave, I'm reminded why this has become a favorite. Great food, genuinely kind service, and an environment that makes you want to stay a little longer. Absolutely a place worth recommending, and one I'm always happy to return to. 5/5.

    #whereisweekes....@ Porto Salvo celebrating with me bestie Diane and the Birthday Man Davied…read morealong with their cousin. The vibe is a laid back chilled mode. The food was good but the Turffle Fries tasted oily. The calamari, shrimp and friend cauliflower was seasoned. The drinks ok, had to ask for a shot extra to taste the liquor. The service was good. They came to check on us, making sure everything was satisfactory. Over, all we had a great time. I do recommend and will be back. It's a cute restaurant in the cut.

    Photos
    Porto Salvo - Friday vibe in the restaurant section

    Friday vibe in the restaurant section

    Porto Salvo
    Porto Salvo

    See all

    Harlem Public - BYO Beef Burger

    Harlem Public

    4.1(1.3k reviews)
    2.6 miHarlem
    $$

    Here on a Wednesday afternoon/ early evening & everything about this spot is great!!! I'm glad I…read morestopped in today!!!! The bartender Meh is dope & a vibe!! Good energy and she made me feel welcomed (that's some southern hospitality in the Heights; wow ok I see you guys). Her suggestion on food was on point as well!! I had the Daddy Mac (Will make you jump) burger and it was delicious!!!! Thank you again for the excellent service Meh!!! I will definitely be back through!!! If in the area ask for Meh & tell her David 125 sent ya!!!! Dope staff!!! My guy Chris is dope as well!!! They gave me a southern hospitality feel frfr!!

    I can't understand how is it that the same person owns this place an At The Wallace and give the…read morecustomer such different experiences. I have been treated very poorly at this place in the past, however the people of At The Wallace told me to go back because servers have been changed and Chad had improved the overall experience. Since I care about the folks at At the Wallace, I decided to give them a chance. The first thing was that the waiter, an apathetic hipster, changed my seat because I was seated in a table for four people, nothing outrageous or out of the ordinary, but then I see him separating the table to allow a couple to sit there. Which made me wonder why I didn't get that treatment, but whatever. I order a medium Spicetown USA burger and a Seltzer. A different waitress brings me the seltzer and basically drops it on the table spilling some of the drink on the table. She didn't apologize for the abrupt gesture, she just turned around and went back to another table. After waiting for 30 minutes for the burger, I call another waitress (this one was friendly at least) and ask the delay, turns out the original waiter didn't even put the order. She talks to him and apologized to me. The burger comes over, but well done, instead of medium. After the two bite check up, I pointed out to the waiter who LITERALLY shrugs and goes to another table. Despite not being my desired temperature the burger and the fries were very delicious, so I will give them that. However, the service here is unforgivably bad. I don't understand why, At The Wallace is right next door, the servers and bartenders are super nice and it's also cheaper. I don't think I will go back to this place again.

    Photos
    Harlem Public
    Harlem Public - Hot Fried Thigh

    Hot Fried Thigh

    Harlem Public - Mac and Steez, chicken 8 Wings

    See all

    Mac and Steez, chicken 8 Wings

    Sofrito New York - Tres Leches

    Sofrito New York

    2.7(764 reviews)
    2.9 mi
    $$

    Came here for a Sunday brunch with a group of about 15. There is a pre/fix menu to choose from that…read moreincludes family style appetizers and then you choosing your own entree. The calamari and the beef empanadas were decent for the appetizers. I didn't love the pork chunks, they seemed over cooked. For my meal, I ordered the steak and eggs. There's a $7 upcharge for skirt steak, which I picked. I asked for my steak medium, and it was much closer to medium well and well done. The steak itself was juicy and flavorful, and the chimuchurri really helped. The potatoes were soft and not seasoned well, could've used some more time on the stove. I asked for my eggs to be fried and it came out weirdly made. Only took a bite and then left it. We did have bottomless drinks but the service on that was slow and not consistent. I had 2 mimosas in the entire 90 minutes, and I had to flag down a staff member to even get my 2nd one. It is a loud restaurant with music playing, but I guess that sets the mood and ambiance. They are strict with the table limits and will ask you to leave after paying.

    We recently visited Sofrito NYC on Sunday, March 29 to celebrate our 19th wedding anniversary, and…read moreoverall, we had a really great experience. This place holds a lot of nostalgia for us--we actually celebrated our wedding after-party at this same location 19 years ago (back when it was a rented venue), so coming back felt really special. Booking through Resy was super easy, and even when we had to push our reservation back by 30 minutes, it was handled smoothly. From the moment we arrived, everything started off on a positive note. The valet was friendly and efficient ($20, which is pretty reasonable), and the hostess welcomed us warmly. Once inside, the vibe immediately stood out--there's a lively bar area and a beautiful waterfront view that really sets the tone. We were seated in a comfortable booth (perfect for our kids), and everything felt cozy yet vibrant. The bathrooms deserve a quick shoutout--clean, fresh-smelling, and even had an attendant offering napkins and lotions, which added a nice old-school touch. We started with drinks (Pinot Grigio for me, seltzer with cranberry for my husband, and sodas for the kids), then moved on to appetizers: chicharrón de pollo and empanadas. Everything was beautifully presented and photo-worthy. Our server, Nicholas, truly made the night special. He was personable, attentive, and went out of his way to congratulate us on our anniversary. He recommended the skirt steak with shrimp, rice, and beans--and that ended up being the highlight of the meal. The steak was absolutely delicious. My husband had the half chicken with rice and beans, my daughter happily stuck to her favorites (mashed potatoes, fries, and chicharrón), and my son enjoyed his burger. The food came out quickly, and we had a great time just relaxing, laughing, and enjoying the atmosphere. By sunset, the ambiance shifted beautifully--candles lit, music flowing (lots of salsa and Spanish classics), and just an overall great vibe. For dessert, we had tres leches, chocolate chiffon cake, and ice cream for the kids--all a perfect ending to the night. Our total came out to about $325 for a family of four, which felt fair for the experience. Why 4 stars instead of 5? The biggest reason is the branding vs. reality. The restaurant promotes itself as authentic Puerto Rican cuisine, but the menu felt more like a mix of Dominican and Puerto Rican (overall Spanish cuisine). Not a bad thing at all--but it should be represented more accurately. Also, the rice (both yellow and white) was disappointing--hard, grainy, and not what you'd expect, especially during peak dinner hours. It was the only item we didn't enjoy and didn't even want to take home. That said, everything else from the service to the ambiance to standout dishes like the steak was excellent. We'll definitely be back, this time just the two of us, to explore more of the menu. Thank you to Sofrito and especially Nicholas for making our 19th anniversary feel special and memorable.

    Photos
    Sofrito New York - Beautiful ceiling design

    Beautiful ceiling design

    Sofrito New York - Apps

    Apps

    Sofrito New York

    See all

    173 Webster Cafe - cafeteria - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...