I absolutely loved and appreciated the service here! Staff was quick to get me seated and offered great recommendations, answering questions, and checking up on me--making the dining experience even more enjoyable. I specifically came to Zarletti to try their Calamari Riplieni, which is baby calamari stuffed with jumbo lump crab, wilted tomato, bread crumbs, braised in a white wine tomato sauce, and chargrilled bread. This appetizer was a hit! I even ordered more bread to soak up all that juice! I also ordered the Gamberi Pancetta, which was on a rosemary stem! For the main, I ordered the Pappardelle con Funghi and added grilled chicken breast. For dessert, I ordered the Banana Semi-freddo. Can't wait to be back for the exceptional service! read more

See all

My husband and I went for a date night and it was amazing. Customer service was great! The hostess was nice and our waiter was kind. The ambiance and vibes were great. The food was delicious! I did not take a picture of my dish but my husband's pasta was yummy and so was the steak. We did not have time to try the dessert but definitely coming back to try it! read more

Zarletti - Bruschetta - Italian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This is a nice place for dinner. They have the option to dine inside out in the warmer temperatures. The service is great and the restaurant it self is clean. They always have great specials on the menu, and they never fail always taste great and are on point. read more

Zarletti - Pasta and duck dish on the specials menu... sorry forgot the name but very delicious. - Italian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

We had a wonderful dinner at this charming Italian restaurant. Service was really friendly and attentive, and we enjoyed the food and cocktails immensely. We particularly appreciated the pasta, excellent salads, meatballs, and really good bread. We would definitely return when we find ourselves in Milwaukee again. read more

EXCELLENT! Can't recommend highly enough. I'm not into wine, however my friends were duly impressed.

Food overall was good. A little salty but still delicious. Lots of vegetarian options for pasta dishes and then you can add protein if preferred. The banana desert was absolutely amazing! Service was slow but our waitress was very nice and sweet so definitely made up for it. read more

Zarletti - Banana Semi-Freddo - Italian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

The best tiramisu in Milwaukee! Occasionally I will stop by and just grab a dessert to go. However, love to come here and have dinner as well. Cute Italian vibes. Must try the calamari! As it is stuffed with crab and so different than your typical starter. Service is always great. Make sure to put in a reservation as this place is busy all the time (yes, even on a Monday)! read more

Small and charming place! We had a 5pm reservation so it wasn't peak of the evening. Our server Callum was so kind and made the experience seamless. Drinks were delicious. The bruschetta and ceasar salad were great! The carbonara was really good, but the duck ragú fell short of expectations as the duck was a little tough. As I was eating I was wondering what kind of pasta they use, homemade, dried, fresh. Overall positive experience! If the opportunity presented, I would be back. read more

See all

Very very good homemade ravioli. I have never had a ravioli so large and packed full! Highly recommend the ravioli. The carbonara was unique. There was something off about it but couldn't put my finger on it. Nonetheless it was cute, accommodating, and has very knowledgeable staff. The cocktails are outstanding as well read more

See all

This restaurant has a drawback or two but it's a great place to eat. Drawbacks would be space and price. It's a bit cramped, so much so that a waiter accidentally bumped into me and other patrons took a beat to figure out the best path to exit, it's probably a minimum of $50 per person to eat there after tax and tip. For starters I had their old fashioned. It's one of the best I've had. They use amazing bitters. Of note was the periodic emergence of a cinnamon taste throughout the drink. Lovely. For appetizers we had the gamberi (shrimp) and bruschetta. They did not preload the garlic toast with the bruschetta which kept it from being soggy. The tomato basil garlic balsamic had a perfect balance and did not overpower. Only thing they could improve on the gamberi is making it tail off and 100% peeled but it was delicious. We split a house salad and picked the balsamic dressing. It came lightly dressed and not over powering with a very interesting raw cucumber capellini, cherry tomato halves, and croutons. It could have used more cherry tomato but was a good and slightly unique salad. I had the veal al limone for my entree. It came out perfectly. It had a wonderful crispiness. They served it with one of the best reductions I've ever tasted. I tried to make out its contents: lemon, of course, perhaps white wine, at times it seemed like carmelized onion then pecorino Romano. It was an amazing flavor experience, a true workout for the palate. We finished with the bananas dessert and the almond flour chocolate cake. I had expected the cake to be dense but instead it was fairly fluffy and cake like. We preferred the bananas dessert of the two. It had a cookie-like base, a sweet vanilla Carmel cream, and banana slices. read more

Highly recommended by Desk Clerk (Ken) @ Drury Plaza. He was spot on. Greeted by an exceptional hostess (Amanda) who was most welcoming & pleasant. Cozy establishment with plenty of glass to look out. Wesley our server was excellent? Knew the menu & very attentive. We went with all his suggestions from apps to entre's & weren't disappointed. Food amazing. Nut crusted halibut was terrific so was the stuffed mushroom ravioli with sausage. We'll probably duplicate those selections next visit. No joke we'll l travel down from Sun Prairie, WI to dine here again, It was that good. Compliments to all on an exceptional experience. Can't forget a tip of the hat to the water server who was so personal & took obvious pride in his duties. read more

This one was on my wishlist for a while. To start, I entered the restaurant with a group of my family, and I had walked in first. Received a palatable dirty look by the hostess, who didn't say a word to me but smiled at my family as they succeeded me. Off to a good start. Then, we are sat and greeted by our waitress and a trainee. They ask for our drink orders and then come back to pour us water. The trainee is handed the pitcher, and then reaches for my glass. She begins pouring the water all over the empty seat which was infront of her (thankfully no one was there), and my brand new purse was not spared. I grabbed my bag which she had soaked only to receive a meek, "Sorry..". The waitress was more helpful with this, but I was genuinely pretty shocked that the trainee was so unapologetic. Seemed like she had to force that sorry out of herself. All of this occurred before we even had food infront of us. The caprese appetizer was good, as was my main course, the ragu. For dessert we had the banana ice cream, which was very good. It's a shame that the food was overshadowed by the overall experience here. read more

Stopped in for dinner last night. We sat outside to enjoy the weather. We decided to start with moscato and water as our drinks. As an appetizer we went with the Calamari, It was better than what I thought it was going to taste like. The service was excellent! read more

See all

Best food ever! Great service and we met amazing friends at the bar! Tiramisu was so yummy! We started off with Brushetta--A MUST! read more

Any time we are in Milwaukee, we always make a reservation here and is the absolute best! Again, went there tonight and we're blown away by the amazing service, drinks, and food. Brian and Karen are the absolute best and so accommodating...made it the best experience we have ever had there. Top notch! read more

I had the Vitello al Limone Strauss and my wife had the Ragu Della Casa. Both were delicious and just the right portion size. To drink, I got the Downtown Old Fashioned, which I also enjoyed. The server was attentive and checked in regularly. read more

See all

Terrific food, awesome Italian wine list, by the bottle and by the glass. Service is excellent. Constantly rotating menu of classical northern Italian dishes. Valet parking Wednesday-Saturday. Warning! This place is very popular with lots of regulars. Make a reservation. Don't assume you can walk in and get a table. You might luck out... But don't risk it! read more

Another high class restaurant in the area turned us away because they overbooked. We were distraught and were able to walk in to this place just in time for the last table. They were welcoming, the server was kind. The place was full but not loud. The food was excellent. My wife had the pasta and I had the daily special. I would come here again and again if I could. Everything looked and smelled wonderful. Next time, I will take pictures. read more

This restaurant is incredible! A few things to note - we had a celebratory ladies dinner and called an hour before our dining to try to find a table. The restaurants host was kind, attentive, and polite. She was able to find us a table last minute that would fit, and asked if outside was okay. I shared it was, as I thought the temperature would stay warm, and we really wanted a nice dinner that was close to our hotel (The Pfister). We arrived at our reservation start and the outdoor patio was beautiful, however we quickly realized how chilly it was once the sun set. The host greeted us right away and helped start drinks and appetizers. Our server arrived and he was perfect, efficient yet friendly. We had a situation with one of our ladies who needed to leave the dinner, so our group shrunk to 7 due to an unexpected situation. Due to the weather and size adjustment, we asked if there was room for us inside. They helped us move our whole table into the bar (which was perfect for our group) and ended up finishing our meal inside (THANK YOU FOR HELPING US MOVE INSIDE!). Finally, our bartender (new gentleman) was so attentive and polite, while creating some fun banter with our group. The food was UNBELIEVABLE, and the drinks were perfect. We had the absolute best time given the circumstances and would absolutely come back. Thank you to Aileen (host), John (server), Dan (bartender), Karen (manager) for making our night so special. - the ladies who caused a ruckus! read more

See all

I've been here twice, the first time about a year ago and it was phenomenal - but I visited a few week ago and was disappointed. The service at the bar was pretty good and the drinks were great, but the food was underwhelming. I ordered the aglio e olio with sautéed shrimp and the pasta was almost inedible. They had overpowered the dish with so many herbs/ seasoning that the pasta was difficult to eat. Every bite was as if I had been eating an entire jar of Italian seasoning. For a pasta dish that costed $34 I was pretty upset. I'm hoping that it was just an off night, and I'll likely be back to give them another chance. read more

One of the best places to get pasta! I took my wife and we had a great time and the food was fantastic! not to mention the lemoncello huge fan!! read more

We went to celebrate two birthdays and the staff and server were outstanding in recognizing the event and giving us great service throughout the meal. We started with the baby stuffed calamari and some olives. Appetizers were good. For the main course we had the pistachio crusted grouper and the mushroom ravioli. Both entrees were outstanding and will definitely be what brings us back to this restaurant! read more

We had a great dinner at Zarletti! We had a reservation which I would recommend and we wrapped up what we were doing early and showed up around 20 min minutes early and they were able to accommodate us (our reservation was at 5:45). They had quite a few specials available and both of us really enjoyed our meals! They started us off with bread, oil, and Parmesan before we had our main courses. The service was awesome and the restaurant had a great ambiance to it and it's both indoor and outdoor seating options. I would definitely recommend Zarletti for any dinner, but especially for a special occasion! read more

Zarletti - Funghi Portobella alla Griglia - Italian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

One of our favorite restaurants in Milwaukee. Short walk from the Pfister hotel. The italian food served is always great. Nice wine selection. We prefer to sit inside rather than on the sidewalk and reservations are suggested especially in the Summer months. read more

Zarletti - Ragu Pappardelle - Italian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

1. Such a fun restaurant. The menu is incredible. So many wonderful choices. Most of the pastas were homemade and you can tell. The panzanella was wonderful and so fresh. The osso buco was tremendous. 2. Our server was so fun. She made great recommnedations. 3. Just a great spot in downtown Milwaukee. I am ready to go back. Honestly one of the best italian restaurants I have been to... read more

What an excellent find. Had dinner here before the Counting Crows show this week. A bit early so we were able to eat at the bar - my favorite place to eat. The bartender was personable and on her game. Provided recommendations on the menu as well as local things to do. She was very helpful, and wish I had gotten her name! The food was outstanding. My Osso Buco was delicious. The texture and flavor of the veal created a mouthfeel that's almost illegal. Lol. The owner comped us limoncello that was made in house. Omg, took me back to my visit to Florence Italy. Very generous. Raviolis were house made and equally delicious. Overall, an excellent dining experience. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Food: I have never tried calamari that wasn't fried so this was a new fun experience. The calamari was chewy but delicious, especially the stuffed crab. All the chewing was worth it! Im not the biggest fan of tomato sauce but this was doable. The best part of Ragú was the hand pulled duck. The noodles were long and satisfying but the sauce lacked. The mushroom pasta was the best meal. Everything in the pasta complimented each other perfectly. Service: We had a trainee waitress and she did great at taking orders. A trained waitress was there to cover anything she missed. While the waitress checked in often, there were big waiting periods in between when all we needed was the check or our leftovers. Towards the end, my group got cold waiting for the waitress to come back. Ambiance: We had a table outside and it was a pretty chilly evening. The tables were set up nicely and had a candle to set the mood. If I go here again, I will definitely get a table inside since the staff will not let you go inside if you're cold. read more

See all

Food was good here. The service was great as well. Started with meatballs and stuffed calamari appetizers. I thought the stuffing calamari was going to be more tender than it was. The carbonara was good but we prefer without the addition of the little lemon flavor. The short rib ravioli special was very good. The chicken saltimbocca and Ossobucco were good as well. The banana dessert was one of the best desserts I have ever had! read more

See all

Went for a fun girls night. Ordered shareables, pizza was good just wish it was a little more crispy. We enjoyed ordering different drinks and trying them. Would definitely recommend the barrata cheese!! read more

See all

We went for my boyfriend's birthday. They knew ahead of time. Gave us a great window seat! Food, service and ambiance was wonderful! Will so be back! read more

Zarletti - Italian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

We had a party of 20 that they were able to section the back for us to be semiprivate. We were seated in an L though. However, we had great services and portions were large. The best part was the dessert selection. For our party, we decided to try a flight of different desserts. We were satisfied read more

Third time eating here. Service is superb. Food was outstanding. Server helped us celebrate twin birthday with homemade Limoncello! Exquisite! Keep it going. read more

I ordered what Karen, the bartender recommended, and it was a 10 out of 10. The service is always top-notch. It's pricey to go ($80 all in). However, that includes all courses and drinks. Totally worth every penny. read more

Zarletti - Noodles with sausage - Italian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This place is amazing. Friendly staff, good food and great service. We had a late reservation for 8 people. We arrived early but our table wasn't ready yet so we had to wait outside or across the street at a bar. It was chilly out so we chose to wait in the doorway. But sure enough 845 rolled around and our table was ready. The waitress was really nice and very personable and she got our humor. There was a variety of dishes ordered. And the portions were manageable and not overwhelming as some Italian places. I loved my pasta carbonara with fresh pappardelle pasta, pancetta. It was delicious and I wished I had more. My bf ordered the special of the day veal ossobucco with gnocchi. The veal was outstanding and very tender. The bone marrow melted in my mouth. The place is small and you have to make a reservation to guarantee a table. It is worth it. I will definitely eat here again. read more

Zarletti - Veal Ossobuco with gnocchi - Italian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Enjoyed a delicious birthday dinner at Zarlettis. My husband and i both had had the salmon with vegetables. I had a house salad and my husband had a cup of minestrone soup. The staff were pleasant and knowledgeable. We sat at a corner table in the back, an ideal location. For dessert we ordered the chocolate cake and banana custard. The banana dessert was delicious! Better than the chocolate cake. The seasonal vegetables were asparagus. Very tasty! The Salmon was a large serving and delicious. read more

Zarletti - House salad with vinaigrette dressing. Minestrone soup and warm bread. - Italian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

We visited this place last Saturday for the first time and wow....this is a great little Italian restaurant! I would definitely recommend making a reservation (which we had). We really liked the ambiance of the place (for us at least). Our server, John, was outstanding throughout the whole meal. The homemade pasta was delicious, as was the dessert. Definitely recommend this place! read more

See all

I travel to Milwaukee once a year for work and every time I have to get food from this restaurant. Every time I am extremely pleased with the quality of food. I recommend it to all of the people I work with who visit as well. Excellent job! read more

Came here with a large group and had an excellent time. Service was great, friendly...we tried a number of apprizers (arancini - 4 stars; polpette - 4 stars; calamari - 2 stars (chewy and sauce not great); burrata - 4 stars). My wife also got a half Italian chopped salad and that was excellent (5-stars). For the main entree, I had the cavatappi salsiccia Marsala and it was excellent (5-stars), had some spice to it, was creamy, flavorful, every part of the dish cooked perfectly. My wife enjoyed the wild mushroom ravioli as well. read more

My husband and I booked a reservation for my birthday at Zarletti and had a very good experience. We were both blown away by how delicious the food was. It really exceeded our expectations! I had a truffle oil and mushroom pappardelle and my husband had the bolognese, both were exceptional. My favorite dessert of all time is tiramisu, which a lot of places get wrong, but not Zarletti! Their tiramisu is an old family recipe and it is obvious in the taste. A really satisfying tiramisu with lady fingers well-soaked with coffee. My only critique is that the staff should be more knowledgeable about the wine list than they were. Our server did not seem to know much about wine and struggled to recommend a wine to my liking. I was not pleased with the recommendation as it really wasn't aligned with what I said I was looking for. I was much happier with the wine I selected for my 2nd glass. It's a small thing really. Overall we were very happy with our experience. read more

Visited Zarletti for our anniversary. The restaurant was so charming & romantic perfect for an anniversary! My husband ordered Pasta allá Bolognese & I ordered Pasta Salsiccia al Marsala and they were both very delicious pastas after a few bites I just think the walnuts in my pasta got a little too sweet & overwhelming. I definitely want to go back and try other dishes though :) read more

Zarletti - Pasta Salsiccia al Marsala Pasta Bolognese - Italian Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin