Black Sheep
Black Sheep Photos
BLACK SHEEP ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Black Sheep
Recommended Reviews - Black Sheep
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Our overall experience was GREAT! Our waitress Adriana was fantastic, always looking to fill water glasses or get additional drinks. 5 stars for her!! We went to Black Sheep for a birthday dinner with ~14 people through a reservation. Overall the service was fast and a party of 14 did not delay anything. Black sheep does have a smaller menu so I would take a peak before going to make sure they have something you would enjoy. The drinks were good. Our friends that got the Hugo spritz and said it was one of the better spritz in MKE. A little more champagne and less elderflower would have made it perfect. The catfish was good but could have been more flavorful. The salsa on top brought color to the dish and was a great addition. The vodka rigatoni is normally served without steak but we added it for additional protein. It had enough spice for you to taste it but could have had more. Finally you can't forget about the Brussels!! 5 stars always!!
I went to lunch at Black Sheep with a friend and we had a lovely time! I love all the big windows that let a lot of light come in, the decor is very cool, the bar is beautiful, and I love the ambiance. Our waitress, Mattea, was so personable, helpful, and kind. We really loved her! For lunch I had the house salad with chicken and my friend ordered the tomato soup and grilled cheese- both were excellent! Can't wait to go back!!
I stopped in for happy hour on a Monday night. I was surprised to see that the bar was completely full! That's always a good sign that the food and drinks are delicious. We ended up being able to snag 2 seats at the bar when someone left. The $5 sangria and $10 cheeseboard were delicious!
Excellent place for a party! We had the private room in the basement- it was perfect. We could move around as we wanted and talk to everyone, we ordered food ahead of time. Drinks were made to order. Our server, Emily, was great. She was attentive, knowledgeable and had a lot of patience for our big group. Food was great! We had a lot of fun!!
Black Sheep is a solid go-to for a nice meal, a girls night, or when you have family or friends visiting! Definitely recommend a reservation, especially on the weekends. We've been a couple times but most recently went on a Wednesday night and were able to make a last minute reservation and get in. We got the beer cheese mac to start. Such a great starter and great flavor! I ordered the peanut udon and while it was yummy, I don't think it was worth $18 without a meat protein. My fiancé ordered the Nashville chicken sandwich which was pretty good as well! The place has a very positive vibe and great for having nice conversation!
It's the exact vibe I was expecting from a place called Black Sheep. Everything is just a little different, in the best way possible! I am absolutely OBSESSED with the cheese curds. They're pancake batter with maple syrup and I promise you, you need these. The cheese pull was immaculate. I also had the Lobster Roll (might've been called a Po Boy, I can't recall) and that was delicious especially with the addition of micro greens. The Parmesan Garlic Fries that were shoestring style and crispy were addictive. Ambiance wise, it has an eclectic kind of feel. Definitely makes me want to move to Milwaukee when I step into spots like this. And the staff were super friendly. There is ample street parking and it's not too far from a parking lot. A few of the buildings are under construction and look a little ehhhh, but honestly it's in a really nice neighborhood. I saw a lot of people out walking and tons of business-dressed people around.
Unbelievable happy hour. $5 martinis?! Say less. Also the best place to brunch - so much fun and happiness. Bubble machines, rompers, great tunes - you name it! 10/10 service at the bar. Solid Bloody Mary.
Go to Black Sheep happy hour, sit at the bar, order the dirty martini, talk to the bartenders, and order the Caesar Brussel sprouts. You will not regret your choices.
I've been to black sheep a few times now and always have a great experience, also love the happy hour offerings! I find that the staff is always so nice and attentive, which I greatly appreciate. It can definitely get pretty busy at times, but they have indoor and outdoor seating (when the weather is nice). Some of my favorite menu choices include the house sangria (red wine based), Caesar Brussel sprouts (literally so amazing I could eat them every day), and their charcuterie board offerings. I would also recommend trying out the cheese curds out as they're super unique but they're just not my favorite (I prefer classics). They also offer a wine tap bar option if you prefer to sample different wines and brunch too. Overall would definitely recommend Black Sheep for food/drinks as it is a great chill/fun vibe in the WP area!
We like the brunch menu and wish it was available every day instead of the regular lunch menu. The pancake cheese curds are a must! I like that they have full service coffee options as well. Servers are nice but sometimes it can be slower service, it could have been that maybe they didn't have enough staff? There was only one bartender and one server and they were splitting up the entire restaurant. I get it, that's normal these days...We weren't in a rush, but it took a really long time to order and we ran out of drinks and were never offered refills. Seems like the tables and bar could be split up in sections better for them to be more efficient when there isn't enough staff.
Met a friend here for happy hour (M-St, 4-6) and had an incredible experience. The bartender made me an alcohol free Aperol Spritz which was to die for! I'm still thinking about it! The Meat Board was a work of art, with the honeycomb positioned inconspicuously in the corner like a sweet little secret. The Brussel Sprouts were done perfectly, with the Caesar dressing making this healthier option taste indulgent. This is a great happy hour spot with an elevated, classy feel. I can't wait to go back!
It was such a nice day to sit out on the patio. The lobster roll was just like a chicken salad mix and I loved it! The sangria is one of my favorites, only $5 for happy hour. Service was attentive and the food came out at a great time. I would definitely come back for happy hour or brunch!
Had some great appetizers and drinks at the Black Sheep. Really friendly bartender made the experience fun. The atmosphere is pretty cool. Loved all the "Sheep" art on the walls. Some cool, some really funny! And the bathroom tops them all! (Male Playgirl magazine spreads with Sheep Heads - nudity covered). We had 2 apps, Broccoli and Brussel Sprouts.... Loved them both! Broccolini came with a feta cheese sauce and the Brussels came in a Caesar dressing, both very unique and both very tasty. read more
7 days ago
Alex was amazing... as someone who works as a bartender/server/manager I have never experienced more professionalism and knowing the menu and wine options as Alex has given. Just needed to say it. And it always a great place to be! read more
Went for happy hour at the bar! Bartender was great, very friendly and attentive with a full bar. We also tried the wine wall which is nice since you can get smaller portion or taste before getting a glass. Cute place and busy on a Friday evening. read more
Our overall experience was GREAT! Our waitress Adriana was fantastic, always looking to fill water glasses or get additional drinks. 5 stars for her!! We went to Black Sheep for a birthday dinner with ~14 people through a reservation. Overall the service was fast and a party of 14 did not delay anything. Black sheep does have a smaller menu so I would take a peak before going to make sure they have something you would enjoy. The drinks were good. Our friends that got the Hugo spritz and said it was one of the better spritz in MKE. A little more champagne and less elderflower would have made it perfect. The catfish was good but could have been more flavorful. The salsa on top brought color to the dish and was a great addition. The vodka rigatoni is normally served without steak but we added it for additional protein. It had enough spice for you to taste it but could have had more. Finally you can't forget about the Brussels!! 5 stars always!! read more
8 months ago
I went to lunch at Black Sheep with a friend and we had a lovely time! I love all the big windows that let a lot of light come in, the decor is very cool, the bar is beautiful, and I love the ambiance. Our waitress, Mattea, was so personable, helpful, and kind. We really loved her! For lunch I had the house salad with chicken and my friend ordered the tomato soup and grilled cheese- both were excellent! Can't wait to go back!! read more
I stopped in for happy hour on a Monday night. I was surprised to see that the bar was completely full! That's always a good sign that the food and drinks are delicious. We ended up being able to snag 2 seats at the bar when someone left. The $5 sangria and $10 cheeseboard were delicious! read more
4 months ago
Excellent place for a party! We had the private room in the basement- it was perfect. We could move around as we wanted and talk to everyone, we ordered food ahead of time. Drinks were made to order. Our server, Emily, was great. She was attentive, knowledgeable and had a lot of patience for our big group. Food was great! We had a lot of fun!! read more
6 months ago
Black Sheep is a solid go-to for a nice meal, a girls night, or when you have family or friends visiting! Definitely recommend a reservation, especially on the weekends. We've been a couple times but most recently went on a Wednesday night and were able to make a last minute reservation and get in. We got the beer cheese mac to start. Such a great starter and great flavor! I ordered the peanut udon and while it was yummy, I don't think it was worth $18 without a meat protein. My fiancé ordered the Nashville chicken sandwich which was pretty good as well! The place has a very positive vibe and great for having nice conversation! read more
It's the exact vibe I was expecting from a place called Black Sheep. Everything is just a little different, in the best way possible! I am absolutely OBSESSED with the cheese curds. They're pancake batter with maple syrup and I promise you, you need these. The cheese pull was immaculate. I also had the Lobster Roll (might've been called a Po Boy, I can't recall) and that was delicious especially with the addition of micro greens. The Parmesan Garlic Fries that were shoestring style and crispy were addictive. Ambiance wise, it has an eclectic kind of feel. Definitely makes me want to move to Milwaukee when I step into spots like this. And the staff were super friendly. There is ample street parking and it's not too far from a parking lot. A few of the buildings are under construction and look a little ehhhh, but honestly it's in a really nice neighborhood. I saw a lot of people out walking and tons of business-dressed people around. read more
8 months ago
Unbelievable happy hour. $5 martinis?! Say less. Also the best place to brunch - so much fun and happiness. Bubble machines, rompers, great tunes - you name it! 10/10 service at the bar. Solid Bloody Mary. read more
8 months ago
Go to Black Sheep happy hour, sit at the bar, order the dirty martini, talk to the bartenders, and order the Caesar Brussel sprouts. You will not regret your choices. read more
I've been to black sheep a few times now and always have a great experience, also love the happy hour offerings! I find that the staff is always so nice and attentive, which I greatly appreciate. It can definitely get pretty busy at times, but they have indoor and outdoor seating (when the weather is nice). Some of my favorite menu choices include the house sangria (red wine based), Caesar Brussel sprouts (literally so amazing I could eat them every day), and their charcuterie board offerings. I would also recommend trying out the cheese curds out as they're super unique but they're just not my favorite (I prefer classics). They also offer a wine tap bar option if you prefer to sample different wines and brunch too. Overall would definitely recommend Black Sheep for food/drinks as it is a great chill/fun vibe in the WP area! read more
We like the brunch menu and wish it was available every day instead of the regular lunch menu. The pancake cheese curds are a must! I like that they have full service coffee options as well. Servers are nice but sometimes it can be slower service, it could have been that maybe they didn't have enough staff? There was only one bartender and one server and they were splitting up the entire restaurant. I get it, that's normal these days...We weren't in a rush, but it took a really long time to order and we ran out of drinks and were never offered refills. Seems like the tables and bar could be split up in sections better for them to be more efficient when there isn't enough staff. read more
9 months ago
Met a friend here for happy hour (M-St, 4-6) and had an incredible experience. The bartender made me an alcohol free Aperol Spritz which was to die for! I'm still thinking about it! The Meat Board was a work of art, with the honeycomb positioned inconspicuously in the corner like a sweet little secret. The Brussel Sprouts were done perfectly, with the Caesar dressing making this healthier option taste indulgent. This is a great happy hour spot with an elevated, classy feel. I can't wait to go back! read more
It was such a nice day to sit out on the patio. The lobster roll was just like a chicken salad mix and I loved it! The sangria is one of my favorites, only $5 for happy hour. Service was attentive and the food came out at a great time. I would definitely come back for happy hour or brunch! read more
I've only ever been at Black Sheep for HH and it has to be one of the best in Milwaukee! Available Monday-Saturday 4-6, you can get great deals on apps and drinks. It's always busy with a fun and energetic vibe. Great place to meet up with friends. read more
2 years ago
6 months ago
Black Sheep MKE id always phenomenal. I dream about this Breakfast Risotto. It is always perfect. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, and the vibe is chill and fun. Reservations highly suggested. 10/10 would recommend! Great job Black Sheep! read more
Extremely good pork shoulder. Very tender and juicy, risotto is also good. The portion feels a little small with the higher price, but mainly paying for quality, location, and atmosphere. The servers are extremely fun and easy to talk to and they always have a good recommendation. read more
We have been coming to Black Sheep for Milwaukee brunch for years and it has never disappointed. I was shocked to realize I have never reviewed Black Sheep, so I am here to rectify that! Black Sheep brunch is next level. Hearty portion sizes, delectable flavors, and reasonable prices. What more could you want! On top of that, the staff are always super friendly, welcoming, and helpful with the menu. The ambiance of the restaurant is adorably sheep themed with some spiciness in the bathrooms. You have to visit to fully understand! After many visits for brunch, you really can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Some of our favorites include the croque madame, the biscuits and gravy, the risotto, the breakfast sandwich, and the chicken and waffles. Like I said before, you really can't go wrong no matter what you order! We are already missing our Black Sheep visit today as we drive back to Chicago. Looking forward to our next visit to MKE and Black Sheep brunch! read more
4 months ago
Black Sheep is a really solid spot! I have been for brunch as well as dinner, and was equalIy impressed both visits. For brunch, try the risotto that comes with sunny side up eggs on top, or the breakfast poutine if you want something super savory. The iced lavender latte was a hit as well. If you're a cheese curd aficionado, try the pancake-battered cheese curds served with maple syrup. It's a sweet-savory combo that I didn't expect to like as much as I did. I walked in during peak brunch hours on a Sunday, and was able to get a table for two without any wait time. They've always got a fun playlist going and some funky sheep-themed decor to spot when you're inside as well. read more
Black Sheep sits across from Purple Door Ice Cream, and it had been a spot I've been meaning to try for a while. It's the perfect brunch, lunch, dinner spot- whatever you want to make it! The interior design is chic, the lighting is kinda divine, and all of it is quite exquisite. It was a midday brunch on the chillier side for us and we happened to be the first ones there for the morning, so we had the whole place + service to ourselves. We picked sun spots right by the windows to stay warm and also got the perfect lighting for our meals (+ pictures, of course). The ambiance was light, airy, but also a darker, heavier combination of cello instrumentals in the background. We enjoyed a spread of Lyonnaise truffle fries (6/5, and on my eager best-french-fry hunt, these are some of the best truffle fries I've had in Milwaukee), Mushroom Melt (VG), Beer Cheese Mac (VG). Even though they missed the mushrooms in the first sandwich they brought out, they quickly whipped together another plate to make sure I could have an actual mushroom melt which our server did such a nice job of checking in on throughout our meal. The server grated and drizzled fresh parmesan onto our food which we also graciously accepted. The age cheese in the mushroom melt and beer cheese mac were absolutely Wisconsin core and worth getting for the table. Black Sheep does a fantastic job of incorporating a variety of Wisconsin fresh-made cheeses into their menu items, so if you're on the hunt of trying a good combo of cheese + beer, this is your place. Overall, a rustic, homey vibe here! read more
2 years ago
Black Sheep in Milwaukee is the lunchtime hero we all need! Walking in, you're greeted by decor so chic, you'll think you've stumbled into a design magazine. The menu is a delightful treasure trove of tasty options. Whether you're craving a sandwich that makes your taste buds do a happy dance or a salad that makes you feel like you're adulting correctly, they've got you covered. Love their shareable plates. Our truffle fries were . If you are a biscuits and gravy lover, you've come to the RIGHT place. The ambiance is perfect for pretending you're in a rom-com montage, whether you're with friends or flying solo. So, if you're in Milwaukee and your stomach is growling, head to Black Sheep. You'll leave with a full belly and a smile - Highly recommended! read more
6 months ago
Always love this spot for drinks, especially the martinis! Ordered the cheese board and was a bit underwhelmed at only two cheeses but a lot of fruit. Would have liked more cheese on a "cheese" board, though the two included were good. read more
Like, don't love this place. Food, decent. Drinks, decent. I'm sorry but there is nothing drawing me in for more. Service is kind, staff nice enough. Location is great! But nothing really wowed me. If you are in Milwaukee and looking for a casual bar for a decent drink, definitely check it out! read more
2 years ago
2nd visit. Caught Happy Hour which is amazing lol Got the sangria and a stolli lemon drop and the steak and mash sooooo amazing!! The vibe and atmosphere is nice!!! I cant wait to visit again and try something different. The bartender was great as well. read more
A great place for a decadent date night. All the food was perfectly prepared. Flavors are very rich, intense, and fantastically balanced. Not really much "light fare" to be had. Cocktails were similar, bold strong and balanced flavors. Love it. The ambiance is dark and tasteful. I like the lighting and the layers of design in the space. Service was good, but could have been a little more attentive. (They gave us a small 4oz water glass, and didn't refill the whole meal. With my spicy chicken sandwich, and jalapeño cocktail, I was craving more water to put out the flames.) My biggest complaint is the noise level. With the brick walls and hard floors, conversation noise bounces all over, and one must yell to be heard. Some acoustic treatments would help tremendously. read more
2 years ago
The food was incredible! I really enjoyed my pasta and my friend loved her salad. The fries were crispy and hot and the drinks were great! The location was great and allowed for a quick hop to Third Ward for drinks after. The location itself is well decorated and beautiful and we appreciated the ambiance and view to the street and the other patrons. Service is where it fell short a little, our server was quick to serve us at the beginning but went missing multiple times and it was difficult to get his attention to put in our mains order. Service aside the food was the star, and I would come back again read more
1 year ago
What a cute spot. So glad that we stopped in. Our waitress was maybe the best part. But a solid drink and cocktail menu, a lot of great dinner menu options covering all likes, and so very cutely appointed. It's a great menu. My ONLY issue is that, like so many restaurants that have vegan options - which I am grateful for - they make them so spicy. Everyone else polished off their food. And the service was truly exemplary. read more
1 year ago
We went to Black Sheep for brunch this past Saturday. You 100% have to get the pancake battered cheese curds to start. They were so light and airy. The maple syrup dipping sauce added such a unique spin on cheese curds. They were sweet and savory! It was my favorite dish at Black Sheep. I got the breakfast sandwich and wish it had more bacon on it. Only half of the sandwich had bacon on it. I also wish there was some type of sauce on it, like a spicy Mayo. However, it was still a solid breakfast sandwich and I had no problem finishing it lol. My fiancé got the hangover burger and said it was very messy, but had great flavor. I normally always try his meal, but it was so messy I couldn't really try it. My dad got the croque madame and was raving about it all day! He's a tough critic, so for him to love his meal really meant a lot. I look forward to coming back to Black Sheep. Next time we are going to check out their dinner menu. read more
Page 1 of 12
More info about Black Sheep
216 S 2nd St
Milwaukee, WI 53204
Walker's Point
Directions
(414) 223-0903
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.blacksheepmke.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Services
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
Ask the Community - Black Sheep
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
39 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
2 months ago
7 years ago
8 years ago
12 years ago
10 years ago
5 years ago
5 years ago
13 years ago
12 years ago
11 years ago
13 years ago
11 years ago
5 years ago
12 years ago
5 years ago
5 years ago
5 years ago
12 years ago
5 years ago
