Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Hill Valley Dairy

    4.8 (22 reviews)
    Closed • 2:00 pm - 9:00 PM
    Updated 2 months ago

    Hill Valley Dairy Photos

    HILL VALLEY DAIRY ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Hill Valley Dairy

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    A classic board
    Warren D.

    Date of visit: March 28, 2026 This was our second stop on a birthday date night and was a lovely little find! While the menu is limited and not cheap, staff were very friendly and walked us through everything before we selected a couple of things to try. Pretty much all of the cheeses and accoutrements were fantastic! One of the cheese on our plate was the espresso version of Bellavitano, which happens to be one of my favorites, so that was a nice little bonus for me. In addition to the board, we also went with the ricotta bites, which featured one sweet and one savory option, both of which we also really liked. The shop is cozy and if this was somewhere that I lived walking distance from, I could totally see myself coming here fairly regularly and having a little cheese and ambiance. During our time there we saw both couples on dates and old friends gathering for a drink and a nosh, all of which I found just wonderful. Really the only thing keeping this from a five star review was that the side items, such as the crackers were not plentiful enough for the cheese. I know that ratio can be hard to nail but it was not quite on the mark here, unfortunately. However, that would not be enough to prevent me from returning!

    White Wine Cheese Board
    Patricia K.

    We came in on a Thursday afternoon when it first opened and the place was totally empty. Staff was super friendly and gave us recommendations based on our preferences. I ordered the White Wine Cheese Board while my husband got the Hibiscus Margarita with the accompanying cheese. I was surprised to find the Harbanero included with mine wasn't super spicy which I appreciated! I think the wine choices paired very well with each cheese. I wasn't crazy about the Hill Valley Cheese included with the board, as it was a little too strong for my palette. The place itself was super relaxing and we enjoyed our cheese and drinks on the couch. There's also board and card games you can play with friends too! All in all, good experience and a relaxing way to experience the cheese Wisconsin has to offer

    Emily M.

    This is the cutest spot! Perfect for a cozy date night or just meeting a friend to catch up! I was intrigued that they served crafted mocktails with NA spirits (love that more places are doing this), and was dying to try it out. The drinks did not disappoint and each is paired with a piece of cheese, which is the most fun idea! We also ordered the smaller cheese plate for a light snack and got to pick 3 cheeses from the case. The owner/cheese maker brought it out to us and was so friendly! They also have a retail section, and we grabbed some cheeses for a party the next day. Will definitely be back!

    Nolan H.

    Very nice, fun, calm place with an amazing vibe. We got an appetizer essentially here before dinner on a Friday night. We got the Red Wine & Cheese Flight. The cheese is absolutely amazing!!! The wine is great!!!

    Bar/seating area
    Alex S.

    What a lovely little spot! We stopped in for a pre dinner drink, and we're excited to try their craft cocktails & cheese pairings. While I don't remember the exact names of our drinks, I DO remember the delicious pineapple foam on top of mine-what a treat! There is a small retail area that has all of the essentials to make your own board. They also serve their own! I'll be back to try a Bloody Mary, sangria, or both

    Snack Cheese board
    Jessica O.

    Very friendly staff! I came in knowing nothing about cheese and the staff helped me pick the best board. I tried black pepper cheddar, ancho chile & coffee alpine, and 7 year aged cheddar. All were delicious! I also got the rose (strawberry kiwi) sangria, which was also delicious. It was a great place and I'll definitely be back! I have a nut allergy and they were very accommodating!

    Rick R.

    I met a friend here last week and had a great experience! Julia was our bartender, and she provided excellent service and helpful suggestions. We ordered the white wine & cheese flight and red wine & cheese flight, and we each ordered a cocktail that was also paired with a cheese. I ordered the Babcock Boulevard, and my friend ordered the Hill Valley Bourbon Old Fashioned Sour. Everything tasted great and paired well with the cheeses. The atmosphere is loungy, and it is a great place to wind down, catch up with friends, or to take a date. Check it out!

    Lisa N.

    Seeing everyone post about the new cheese bar at Hill Valley Dairy and had to check it out. It did NOT disappoint!! With delicious cocktails. Including the best bourbon old fashioned I've tried. (I prefer brandy sweet.) And the rum based Autumnal Beach Vibes. Each with a cheese pairing. The Classic Board was a perfect mix of salty and sweet treats. We ended up grabbing a couple of our favorite items, the Alina cheese and Bourbon Flank Steak to go! Staff was very knowledgeable and helpful in picking out things we'd like.

    Blackberry Gin specialty cocktail
    Maddy K.

    Hill valley is such a fun spot to stop at if you're looking for unique Wisconsin cheeses to try and beverages to pair with. It is also in a super convenient location in the Walkers Point neighborhood as well. We had a great experience, everyone who helped us was so kind, and I love that it is a relaxed/chill atmosphere. I went with a friend to catch up and we got their specialty cocktail of the day and split their classic charcuterie board which featured a bunch of local products such as cheese, nuts, crackers, and more. It was SO delicious and I felt that the board serves anywhere from 2 to 3 (maybeee 4) people. I greatly enjoyed my fruity cocktail choice as well. They also offer different flight options for wines and cheeses which is a great idea if you can't decide what to get! I would very much recommend stopping at Hill Valley if you are a cheese or wine lover and are looking for a new/different experience!

    White wine flight
    Katie G.

    Met up with some friends here. The environment is clean and modern. Staff are incredibly friendly and cool. The wine and cheese flight options are very cute and all the wines and cheeses tasted fantastic. You can even get a view of the cheese making process!! This would be a good date night, girls night, guys night, or even just an after work hangout spot

    Cheese board with olives, meats, peppers, cheese, dried fruit and a side of chocolates
    Deborah W.

    First time enjoying this local cheesemaker and will be back! At the suggestion of my daughter we visited the "cheese bar" and it was simply amazing! Staff immediately greeted us as we entered - entire team was very friendly and knowledgeable. This made for a wonderful night out with my grown kids. We enjoyed wine flights that included cheese pairings and nibbles. My daughter enjoyed a unique fresh and fruity cocktail with a delicious banana foam. The cheeses and wines were carefully selected and paired. These were great quality and decent pours. The server took time to explain each of the items included on our cheese board and flights - a real expert and we could tell they loved the cheese like we do! This would definitely be a great place to bring visitors to our city. We enjoyed a variety of cheeses and agreed they were all so good! We even got some meats, snacks and salted dark chocolates. The interior was clean and very pretty with comfortable mixed seating- we chose plush lovechair and chair seating. They sell the cheeses they serve - all are local and they make cheese on-site! The retail area is inviting with wines, cheese and local items for sale. It doesn't get fresher or better than that! Overall great experience and looking forward to our next visit.

    Bar view
    Melissa S.

    Great new addition to Walkers Point! Stopped in for a lunchtime visit and had the Classic Board which was served with 3 cheeses, Lake Geneva Country cured meats, fruit, nuts, jam, Intelligentsia chocolate and cookies. Delicious and plenty for 2 people. My favorite cheese was Luna - cave rind offspring of alpine and Gouda. The soft Brie and 3 year cheddar were also very good. I never thought to pair chocolate and cheddar but it was so good. Location is a beautiful remodel of former cheese shop with a new cocktail bar vibe. Speaking of drinks, the menu of specialty cocktails, wine and beer was more than I expected at a cheese shop. I'll be back in the evening to try some of these. They offer multiple wine and cheese flights to choose from along with some additional food items. Staff was friendly and helpful. Met the owner/cheesemaker and learned a lot about the business and process of cheese making. There is even a window viewing area to watch them make the cheese. They were making fresh cheese curds when we were there. Finally you can buy Hill Valley Dairy cheese and other cheese makers products in their deli cases. Top tier stuff! Overall this new kid on the block is a must try if you love cheese and want a fun night out. PS they also own a shop in Lake Geneva which is equally great

    Classic cheese board

    See all

    2 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Josie H.

    Josie H.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Josie H.

    Josie H.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 2
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Awesome spot in Walkers Point. Delicious cocktails and cheese. What more could you want

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Josie H.

    Josie H.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Josie H.

    Josie H.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Josie H.

    Josie H.

    Thanks for stopping in and we appreciate your review!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Hailey G.
    3
    114
    22

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Josie H.

    Josie H.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Josie H.

    Josie H.

    Thanks for your review! We appreciate it!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Hill Valley Dairy

    Review Highlights - Hill Valley Dairy

    “It was SO delicious and I felt that the board serves anywhere from 2 to 3 (maybeee 4) people.”

    Mentioned in 6 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Cheese Shops 1,116 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    West Allis Cheese & Sausage Shoppe - Delicious Muenster grilled cheese sandwich on sourdough bread

    West Allis Cheese & Sausage Shoppe

    4.4(120 reviews)
    0.7 mi•Historic Third Ward
    •$$

    As you walk up, you know that you're in for an incredible Wisconsin treat. West Allis Cheese &…read moreSausage Shop is located inside of the Milwaukee Public Market. Which, gives it that festive feel that you crave! It feels as if you've stepped into a European market with a Wisconsin twist! We always order the fried cheese curds with a side of marinara sauce, and let me tell you. This ties everything together for one unforgettable treat! Which, is a one of a kind Wisconsin treat that you'll never forget! They also sell a huge variety of cheese, dairy products, and cured meats. Along, with spices and local goods! Every time I come here I leave with something new to spice up my life. They also sell drinks and alcohol. So, they cover everything! If you ever need help with anything, everyone is super helpful and knowledgeable!! Fried Cheese Curds- These cheese curds are crispy and crunchy on the outside and squeaky and chewy on the inside! They are a perfectly well balanced one of a kind Wisconsin treat. That you'll enjoy to the last bite! Marinara sauce-this sauce is full of spices, heat, and tang. It has the perfect balance of sweet and zesty with a kick! I absolutely love this sauce. It's smooth with just a hint of texture. Which, pairs perfectly with your fried cheese curds. So, If you're looking for a fun and exciting new market place to try, then come to The Milwaukee Market! Trust me, you won't regret it

    The location in Milwaukee Public Market was a cluster*. I visited the market as a tourist and I…read moreguess I got tourist trapped. They seemed understaffed and very stressed. There were two registers but only one was staffed. I tried to ask for things from behind the case at one register and the cashier told me I could only get them at the other register. So I waited for a few minutes before realizing nobody was ever going to show up (there was nobody in the hour i spent there.) Then I went back to the first register. I sat down at the bar that is right in front of the cash register since I wanted to stay and eat. It seems you have to stand directly in front of the register in order to get service or else they wait until nobody is getting in line at the register to acknowledge you at the bar. There are only 4 seats for the whole place, so it seems you'd want to get your seat quickly, but they do expect you to stand until after you've ordered. I asked for cheese from behind the case and they said they were no longer slicing cheese (an hour before closing.) I asked again for a sausage from behind the case and it turns out they actually can reach behind other cases than the one they are directly in front of and I neednt have waited in front of an empty register for no reason earlier. The wait was long and the food was disappointing. At least it wasn't too expensive. I tried poutine here for the first time and can't tell if I just dislike poutine or if it was very low quality. It was just some fries from the freezer with basic brown gravy and unbattered cheese curds. Eating the cheese curds felt like eating a rainboot. The whole thing was inedibly salty. The usingers sausage stick and bourbon sausage I got were basically sticks of salty lard and really didn't have much flavor other than that. I threw almost everything in the trash.

    Photos
    West Allis Cheese & Sausage Shoppe
    West Allis Cheese & Sausage Shoppe - Delicious cheese curds!

    Delicious cheese curds!

    West Allis Cheese & Sausage Shoppe - Specials of the week

    See all

    Specials of the week

    Charcuter-Me - Finished Product

    Charcuter-Me

    5.0(4 reviews)
    1.1 mi•East Town, Downtown

    I recently attended a Charcuterie workshop held by Charcuter-Me through the Mequon Rec. department…read more Amanda walked us though placement of items, recommendations of meats, cheeses and accoutrements, and how to style the boards. Such a fun workshop and it was neat to see how everyone's boards turned out!

    I had such a wonderful date night thanks to Charcuter-Me! I have worked at wine bars and cheese…read moreshops and gained an appreciation for both - nothing made me feel more proud than watching a table post pictures of a cheese board I'd created for them. Well these boards make mine look like preschool drawings. I ordered the Date Night board, which says it feeds two or snacks four. It was just two of us so picked up a couple bottles of wine to accompany it, and attempted to take credit for doing the whole thing myself. After obviously being called out, I couldn't wait to dig in! The board contained four different kinds of (all awesome) cheeses, four different kinds of wildly different meats, cheese-stuffed olives, dried and fresh fruit, chocolates, nuts, honeys, and jams. It was such a great mix of unique ingredients that I haven't tried - while still hitting those familiar notes that I like. After initially worrying we'd devour it and not have enough, I was pleased when we couldn't even quite finish the board! The only thing that I wish were included that wasn't would be a little ramekin of mustard. Prices were fair, pickup was smooth, and quality was through-the roof. With other boards like dessert, charcuterie cones, and endless possibilities, I will definitely be ordering from here again!

    Photos
    Charcuter-Me
    Charcuter-Me
    Charcuter-Me

    See all

    Lumpia City - Shrimp taco Lumpia

    Lumpia City

    4.1(8 reviews)
    1.4 mi•East Town, Downtown
    •$

    We were at Third Space Brewery and they were parked there for dinner. We tried the Mac n Cheese and…read moreCarne Asada (I didn't try the meat one) and both were very tasty! Because they cut them in half it makes it easier to share. One sauce was a ketchup base and the other I can't recall, both were very good. Looking forward to seeing them around!

    Lumpia City is a new food truck to the MKE market. We happened to catch them at the Pabst Brewery…read moreopening - one of their first few events. If you're a dope like me and don't know what lumpia is - well - it's a delicious Filipino creation that reminded me of a spring roll. They're crisp rolled sticks filled with yummy fillings - some pretty creative ones from this truck for sure. The menu is changing obviously but they make meat, veggie and dessert lumpia. An order of 6 (cut in half so 12pcs) was $10. I got a mix - 1/2 were seasoned beef which was honestly pretty boring and the El Carne version which adds veggies and some heat. That one was delicious! Sadly, I missed out on siracha pork. The lumpia were served hot, crispy and with a nicely flavored aioli for dipping. Despite the crowds, the staff was on point. Everyone was nice, my food came up quickly and it was quite tasty. Definitely worth a stop if you see them around town, or stop at Sugar Maple on Wednesdays where they'll be hanging this summer.

    Photos
    Lumpia City - To go order

    To go order

    Lumpia City
    Lumpia City - Mac and cheese, pork, and chicken poblano lumpia. Served with fries.

    See all

    Mac and cheese, pork, and chicken poblano lumpia. Served with fries.

    Glorioso's Italian Market

    Glorioso's Italian Market

    4.6(634 reviews)
    2.0 mi•Lower East Side
    •$$

    I have been wanting to try their Italian beef for so long and I'm so glad that I finally did! I got…read morethe regular size, it was fully loaded and way more than enough. The beef was perfectly tender and well seasoned. I got the au jus on the side which I'm glad I did because as fresh and delicious as the roll was, it was pretty soft and not sturdy enough to hold all of that flavorful beef. The flavor of the au jus was incredible and it was nice to be able to dip and pour a little on top as I gobbled down. I also got the tomato salad and marinated mozzarella. The tomatoes were super fresh and juicy and all of the vegetables were crunchy and fresh! I only got one cucumber slice but at the same time I also ordered the smallest size so that's just how the cookie crumbled in terms of ratios. The mozzarella might have been the best I've ever had. The seasoning on the outside was amazing and the freshness and moisture was absolutely perfect. I tried the pizza slice at Brady st fest and it was pretty solid. The sauce had a slight sweetness to it and there was a very nice cheese to sauce to crust ratio. I love a good thick layer of cheese and this definitely had it! The Italian sausage was cooked perfectly and the seasoning was on point! The staff was super friendly and helpful. The inside of the store had a really unique feel, almost like I was in another country. I can't wait to go back to their deli and try more of their delicious food!

    I'm so glad that the Market is back! I love visiting and…read moregetting stuff from the fresh deli shop, I grab the food for my family and everyone enjoys it! We just wish it was closer so it was hot by the time I got it home! They have ready to cook meals too and a variety of Pastas, Wines, Italian condiments, Gelato, Cheeses! Lots of Sweets as well & Caviar as well! You won't be disappointed!!!

    Photos
    Glorioso's Italian Market - Interior

    Interior

    Glorioso's Italian Market - Cannoli galore!!

    Cannoli galore!!

    Glorioso's Italian Market - Greek pasta salad

    See all

    Greek pasta salad

    Bavette La Boucherie - Previously retired 80-yr old butcher

    Bavette La Boucherie

    4.5(463 reviews)
    0.6 mi•Historic Third Ward
    •$$

    I was excited to be in Milwaukee today, given the many restaurants that have earned recognition…read morefrom the James Beard Awards. Most of those spots only open for dinner, so I was thrilled to find that Bavette La Boucherie now serves lunch. My friend, a local, told me the restaurant originally began as a butcher shop. While that's no longer the case, the space still pays tribute to its roots -- shelves lined with kitchen knick-knacks, butcher-block counters, and a display of local provisions that hint at its past. Chef-owner Karen Bell leads the way here, and you can feel her touch throughout -- from the creative menu to the casual-elegant vibe. The décor blends exposed brick and warm wood with soft light and a friendly hum from the open kitchen. Our server, Matthew R., had only been with Bavette a couple of weeks, but his background in restaurant management showed. He was knowledgeable, attentive, and offered great suggestions. Before our sandwiches arrived, we shared a cup of pork and tomatillo pozole topped with cabbage slaw and a dollop of sour cream. It was piping hot, bright, and deeply flavorful -- the kind of starter that makes you stop talking for a minute just to enjoy the next spoonful. Having read rave reviews of the Korean steak au jus, I nearly ordered it, but Matthew suggested the roast-beef with cheddar since I'm not a big lunch eater. Excellent call. The sandwich was divine -- tender, flavorful beef layered with melted cheddar on a crisp, perfectly toasted roll. The beef-fat fries had great depth of flavor, though I'd love them even more if they were twice-cooked for that extra crunch. Being more of a gin or vodka drinker, I couldn't resist the Gin Old Fashioned on the cocktail list. It was delicious -- smooth, aromatic, and balanced enough that I happily ordered a second. Great food, warm service, and a welcoming atmosphere. Bavette La Boucherie is a gem I can't wait to revisit.

    Was in town for the weekend and TikTok said the only things I should do in Milwaukee were Discourse…read moreCoffee and Bavette. LISTEN... The only crime here is that this place isn't a chain and it's miles away from me. Our waitress was amazing, the vibes were perfect, everything felt intentional in the best way. The heirloom tomato salad was so fresh and delightful. A full 5 out of 5. And those beef tallow fries were unreal. I am still thinking about them and genuinely wish I could figure out how to recreate them at home. TikTok actually delivered on this one. Very happy we ended up going.

    Photos
    Bavette La Boucherie - Fresh-cut roast beef w/pickled veggies and brown mustard

    Fresh-cut roast beef w/pickled veggies and brown mustard

    Bavette La Boucherie - Everything here is SO delicious!

    Everything here is SO delicious!

    Bavette La Boucherie - Charcuterie Plate

    See all

    Charcuterie Plate

    Hill Valley Dairy - cheese - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...