We were in the area and wanted pizza so we thought we'd give this shop a try. I've tried popular…read moreNew York style pizza places and hate the thin crust and lack of cheese. When we came in it's just a mom and her son and the we ordered a general pizza with pepperoni. I cannot say how much this pizza satisfied my entire families taste buds. Truly amazing. There enough cheese and pepperoni and the crust isn't flat. Safe to say... give this place a try. It might be hard to see the entrance because it's down some stairs but just walk until you see it.

((3.25 stars)) the…read morepizza is a-okay at Madison Street Pizza imo. obviously that is subjective but not every pizza slice you get in NYC is going to be the greatest or worst. to me, it's very much in the middle--this would not be my go-to spot or a place to avoid. it's very much a neighborhood pizza place in the Two Bridges area on a quiet stretch of Madison Street. the walkdown pizzeria is in a small place below street level with a few seats squeezed into the space. the place is clean but has that worn-in coziness. the counter has a variety of pizza pies and slices on display. ordered a plain cheese slice to go. the ladies who worked there were very nice, quickly heated up my slice, and served up a hot out of the oven pizza slice on a paper plate. there's plenty of mozzarella cheese and sauce on the plain slice and had a fairly crispy bottom. however the slice really didn't come together for me--the flavor of the sauce was a bit too sweet and a bit tomato soup-y as there was too much of it on the slice in my opinion, the cheese was nice and melty, and the crust's bottom was crispy but the slice's crust was a bit thicker than a usual NYC slice and had a bit more readiness and chew to it. overall, the slice was fine as a quick bite. the style of the slice probably is more attuned to what the neighborhood wants than my preference in pizza. would i have a slice here if i were in the neighborhood? probably, but I wouldn't make a special trip for it. pizza preference is ultimately subjective and this place has its fans in this locale...so i ain't gunna hate. ha. also the prices here are not high for a single slice...they are reasonable. service was friendly. when it comes to pizza--to each, his or her own!

Grand Street Pizza was on my list of pizza places to try while visiting NY because it was close to…read moreour hotel (walking distance) and we really wanted to try pizza by the slice, local style. There are many places in the area (Lower East side), bur decided to go with Grand Street Pizza due to proximity, good reviews, photos and also it has some seating (a couple of tables inside and bar area and some outdoor tables as well) - after walking a lot to sightsee we couldn't eat standing like you need to do for other places! When we got there, we were able to snag a cute table inside with a corner table, nice candle on it, perfect for a date night! The place is small, it's more like a neighborhood hangout that plays cool music, a couple of locals around, fun casual atmosphere, not a sports bar, not a dive one either. It was perfect! Great pizza by the slice selection, we settled on pepperoni, margarita and soppressata! We shared 3 between us and it was enough food! We loved the last two slices in particular, the burrata and the basil on the margarita were so fresh and tasty! Loved the salami and all the ingredients on the soppressata, more unique! We also got 2 Guiness-es on tap. Reasonable prices, great customer service, the gals working here were very nice. We loved Grand Street Pizza a lot, nice atmosphere and great pizza (I'm sure there are other good places to try), and decided to come back for our last night in town! It was a rainy day, so we wanted a cozy spot. We were lucky to find our favorite table available. Pizza selection wasn't as good, but went back and got 2 soppressata since it was our favorite and shared a white slice with pesto which was amazing, loved the fresh toppings! Ordered the same beer and my husband overheard from a local lady that they made cannoli-s here, so we put an order (they make them fresh) and enjoyed a nice dessert. Some of the best we ever had. Other folks were working, also very kind and nice. Beautiful atmosphere! Not loud, just cozy and friendly. It is a small spot, lots of take out! But very popular and has great pizza! Great choice for us while in town!

One of the best slices of around…read more Love that they use the type of pepperoni that curls up into little cups, gives it a more elevated taste in my opinion. Honestly, I have nothing more to say other than it tastes amazing. The store itself is pretty small but is very clean and modern it has bar seating and two tables by the window and some outdoor seating as well very friendly to eat inside or out if you wanna grab to go or finish here. The only caveat I have is that it is on the smaller side for a slice. But the reviews were not kidding seems like a lot of local kids and students have this as a must stop. And since it's on the smaller side maybe that's an even better excuse to get two slices instead hehe

Something possessed me to order chicken bbq even though it's not my favorite, and OMG it was so…read moregood. Not greasy, the chicken was not rock hard, the bbq was clearly present but did not take over the pizza. Best bbq chicken pizza ever. Should I convert...? Service was efficient, pizza came out quickly, and there us a $5 minimum when using card. Any of their signature pizza slices are $5/slice so that worked out.

$4/slice is a bit pricey for a plain slice but I must say, Andrea's Pizza is a VERY good slice…read more This place used to be called Proto's, not sure if there is an owner change or not but it is now called Andrea's Pizza, except there is no woman named Andrea around. PS: I grew up a block away and have never entered this pizzaeria and I am unsure why. It used to look like the $1/slice pizzas on the corner of 4th and 2nd? Anyhow, the pizza here is now pretty good but I just hate that it's $4/plain slice. Although not as thick as Joe's, the sauce is there, and the bread is bubbly and the slice is thinly crunchy. It's rare to see a lot of pizza nowadays with very bubbly pockets. If it does, it could mean that they really took the time to use a good amt of yeast and put in the work to make it properly fermented, which pays off. This store generally draws in a young crowd in its cozy indoors. On a very cold day, it is good to grab a slice. I could see that on a hot day, this coziness can add a bit of challenge if the AC is not running. Overall, I would rate Andrea's pretty high in the neighborhood in comparison to the 3-4 pizzerias nearly.

Excellent, excellent pizza for lunch that is walking distance from Union Square. No seating? No…read moreproblem! Just cross the street and enjoy your pies at Union Square while everyone is jealous at you for getting such a great deal on such a fantastic pie. Yes, it is four slices to a pie, but the pies are so light and flavorful that it would not matter. They also make sandwiches, but that is a review for another day. With that said... The Margarita Pizza is their tried and true. Wait a little bit to eat this or the pizza toppings will slide right off. I think that is because the pizza is still cooking in the box. Once it cools a little, then you can enjoy. The crust is incredibly chewy, but the beautiful red sauce and cheese make it all okay. After all, this is one beautiful looking pie. The Quattro Formaggi is another beautiful pie. All four cheeses (I will not list them for the sake of brevity) come through beautifully without each one overpowering the other. This time the crust holds all the cheeses and flavors without bending and breaking. Quite remarkable indeed. -- In case you are wondering, I did not eat all 8 slices. As I was walking with a box, I saw an interested passerby and seriously considered giving the rest of my pizza to her, but so not to be creepy I withheld. Instead I just put it aside someplace where if someone wanted the rest, it was theirs. Could I have easily eaten all 8? Absolutely. Overall pizza rating: 4.4/5

This is one of those places that treat you like family as soon as you walk inside. You order your…read morepersonal pizza, they make it fresh for you in an open kitchen where you can see all the way back, and if you decide to dine in (which I would recommend, even though there are only standing tables, because it'll be way more fresh) then they'll deliver your pizza straight to you. I loved how fresh the pizza tasted and how light the dough was. You definitely end up with a lot of dough at the end, so if you're not a huge crust person this might not be your type of pizza, but it was so nice to eat a personal pie that was made so fresh like this. They were nice enough to offer me a chai panna cotta, which was absolutely delicious and melts in your mouth. Would 100% recommend if you're looking for a different kind of pizza in NYC!

Great pizza and an even better price! Loved the cheese slice and had a great time getting pizza…read morehere with my roommates and taking it to eat in the park.

The buffalo chicken was one of the best ones I've had. The chicken wasn't dry and there was enough…read moresauce. Also can't go wrong with a classic pepperoni

Took myself on a solo date the other day to see Jurassic World: Rebirth…read more I was looking for a sandwich spot to have a snack at the theatre and I came across Unregular Pizza. This place has been on my list! I order the vodka parm on a croissant. This sandwich was EVERYTHING! Buttery, cheesy, the perfect amount of sauce. The chicken was juicy and flavorful. I'll definitely be back for the sandwich and the pizza. Service was amazing as well. The person that helped me was kind and welcoming.

1st time at a Unregular. Stopped by on a rainy Sunday afternoon at their 4th Ave close to Union Sq…read moreand various NYU dorms area. Bright well decorated space. Friendly staffer. Window sign says clearly this is Roman style pizza. Got a plain slice $4.5 plus tax. Ovalish pie/slice. Cheesy. Not much of an undercarriage but slice did not slop. OK tasting but just not my style. They are definitely not your neighborhood everyday pizzeria but also not your fancy pants special toppings place so somewhere In between. Same standing area to eat inside. Closes 10p every night except 1130P on Fri and Sat. Worth a try but not in rotation for me.

Grabbed a slice as we waited for our dinner and you legit cannot go wrong with cheap 1.50 slice…read more. the crust was crispy and thin!!!

Super solid independently owned dollar slice joint that also has hot dogs - as their name very…read moreaccurately described. Seems to have opened recently within the past few months. On Avenue A between St. Mark's and 9th. Their $2 topped slices are delicious and really hit the spot. I had a chicken bacon ranch slice, which was a perfect 4pm pre-dinner snack (yeah I'm fat). There's a number of other tasty looking options on offer besides pizza and hot dogs - chicken sandwiches and beef patties. Open late until 5am, 7 days a week. Cash only under $5, ATM inside. Give 'em a try!

((4.25 stars)) Pizza…read moreCafe is very much a neighborhood pizza joint that caters to residents and the frequent visitors to the Dimes Square area that don't partake in Scarr's. while the space is pretty small only a few seats inside and a couple on the bench outside...the pizza is good and does its job which is to extinguish the "hanger" with enjoyable calories. there's a variety of square and round pies served here...almost too many imo--plus beef patties and other side items like wings. stopped here a week ago or so and grabbed a plain cheese slice, and enjoyed it for what it was, not for what is wasn't. the slice had a nice thin crispy crust, solid sauce, and lots of melted mozzarella. what i really i liked is this pizza is very much a throwback to the classic "orange slice" of many of our childhoods in NYC...orange-hued slice served hot, with a thin layer of pizza sauce oil (but not greasy and doesn't require napkins to dab it off) atop melted cheese and no flop on the crust. the pizza slice held together as i ate it. will this pizza change your life? no, but is it a solid slice when you're in need of calories? yes. there were two different pairs of parents with their young kids who were enjoying pizza slices while i was there. though kid tastes are typically trash, all of the kids were scarfing down their pizza and not fussing about eating which is a good sign when it comes to pizza. the service was friendly enough, and the guy at the register is appreciative of tips unlike many other places which seem to think of it as a given. stop by for the pizza but stay in the neighborhood to soak in the vibes!

I love this place! They have great hours and open very late! There's a lot of slice and pie options…read moreand the service is very friendly and quick! They do thin, Sicilian, and "deep dish" styles. The Margherita, hot honey pepperoni, pepperoni, and margherita with mushrooms are all delicious! Their pesto is also nice, but I like the others more. They also sell sandwiches and garlic knots. There's a handful of places to sit and they take card!