There are contenders, and then there are pretenders, when it comes to the New York pizza scene. This one is very much a pretender. I got two slices, a Plain and Meat Lovers, and both of them are as bland as vanilla. No personality. No character. The crust on both are incredibly chewy and the cheese layer is too much. The sauce has a weird tang, a weird sweetness. The meat on the Meat Lovers has absolutely no taste and very little character. I ate the whole thing to give it a fair shake, but there is nothing fair about this pizza, except for the fact that two slices and a can of ginger ale cost me $12, which is a good deal. The pizza can be passed on, seriously. Nothing memorable and nothing was gained by eating here, except maybe my waistline, but even then that is regrettable. A total bust all the way around. Just anger and drowned sorrow is all that remained after the slices were eaten. Best to go to Ceres further down the neighborhood or the newest location of L'Industrie. This is the pizza you get when it is 10 pm and nothing else is open. Because what else are you going to do? Pizza rating: 1.8/5 read more

My son wanted to try this place he heard was great on social media. Its located in China town, NYC. Small space with limted seating. We sampled a cheese slice and a pepperoni slice. The crust was crispy and light, but needed more sauce. Cheese was ok. Nothing impressive or unique that a special trip needs to be made here, but if in the area and craving a slice, maybe try it, but so many other options are available. read more

See all

The Pie Guy Pizza 83 Baxter St. New York, NY 10013 Pepperoni Slice This slice was topped with an abundant supply of pepperoni cups; there was pepperoni in every bite. It had a flop, but was still tasty. As a bonus, the wall art of celebrities being served by the mascot was nice touch. #ThePieGuy #thepieguypizza #pepperonislice #chinatownnyc #chinatownlowermanhattan read more

The Pie Guy Pizza - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

If you're craving pizza, this place will do the trick. Nice thin slice with a perfect crust. Got the Margherita and a sausage... all fairly quickly as they had it in display and just had to warm it up. Interesting decor with pics of famous stars that are eating pizza... unclear if they actually came and ate here. The person serving us claimed that Trump has eaten here but smart move not featuring here. lol! read more

The Pie Guy Pizza - Really Katy Perry, Brittney, Kardasians have been here?? - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I've walked by The Pie Guy dozens of times but never had the opportunity to try it until this evening. Because it's Pi day, I figured I might as well enjoy a slice of pizza (or two!). I opted for a vodka slice and the spicy rigatoni. Both were pretty solid - the spicy rigatoni had a light spice to it (no major spice tolerance needed) and the sauce was good on the vodka slice. The cheese on the vodka slice wasn't the most flavorful, but I still enjoyed it overall. Slices were heated up quickly, service was friendly. The space itself really only had 1 table and a standing table to enjoy slices, so definitely a quick eats type slice house. Glad I tried it! read more

The Pie Guy Pizza - Signature Spicy Rigatoni Pizza, Vodka Sauce Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Another great visit! Affordable, fresh, clean and quick! What more can you ask for from a pizza place. read more

See all

Walked in & ordered a margarita pie for take out. Pie Guy guy says "gimme 15 minutes". No problemo. In the meantime I observe the slice window & everything looks copacetic (except the fried chicken rolls looked pretty tired). 12 minutes later I get the "Hey Buddy". $24 & a $3 tip later I'm on my way. Open the box at home & have a still warm slice. The sauce is delicious & the crust has an excellent flavor (properly proofed). I guess my only thought is that it could have used another couple minutes to crisp the edge a bit more? All in all this hole in the wall Pie Guy is making the real deal! I recommend a visit! read more

The Pie Guy Pizza - Da box! - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A nice, small place to get a couple of basic slices. Not much space so you may need to take it outside to enjoy.

This is a tiny takeout place in Chinatown just south of Canal. Food (4/5) - very interesting menu of items you don't see in many places. Got a chance to try out two of their slices: - Margherita- it was ok - thin and decent crust maybe bit too flimsy and needed a bit more burn. Sauce was good balanced tang. - Spicy Rigatoni- a novelty pizza and interesting for sure... the spicy rose sauce was pretty good Rigatoni was bit overcooked. Hard to eat this one without a fork and then it's hard to cut tbh. Service (4/5) - not all slices are available at all times so try and time it around their peak times. Friendly servers. Atmosphere (3.75/5) - not much too it... basically pick up place with some wood tables out front. Overall (4/5) - ok place and worth trying out for some of the novelty pizzas. read more

The Pie Guy Pizza - Signature Spicy Rigatoni Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great selection of different pies and slices with a variety of toppings. Had a meat lovers slice with a great assortment of toppings was a heavy filling slice a little salty tho Also had a vodka slice with a special sweet tart slice with creamy cheese flavor smooth combination of flavors with the added saltiness from ham that cuts thru The margarita is always a classic slice used as the measurement of how good a pizzeria is The sauce is a great combination of sweet and tart adding a refreshing punch. There could have been more basil on the margarita tho read more

See all

This place had a 4.9 on Google reviews, which is crazy higher than any place else in the area. I will say it has very good pizza. Crunchy and crisp. Very tasty. There is only a few seats at the window, but that is a New York thing. read more

See all

I recently saw this place on Baxter street and decided to try their pizza. I ordered two large cheese pizza pies ($18) to go. The two cheese pizza pies came out different. One was overcooked and dry and the other pizza was soggy (cheese was all over the place). I ordered their pepperoni pizza ($24) a week later. It was better. So it might have been their cheese pizza or I went on an off day. read more

See all

Walking into Pie Guy in NYC is a spiritual experience, mostly because you're shoulder-to-shoulder with a crowd that's collectively decided that a paper plate and a fountain soda are the highest forms of fine dining. The vibe is "organized chaos meets flour-covered basement," where the staff moves with the kind of terrifying efficiency that suggests they could fold a pizza box--and possibly your laundry--in under three seconds. It's the kind of place where the decor is mainly just steam-fogged windows and the faint, beautiful hope that you'll find a stool to sit on before your knees give out. But then you take that first bite, and suddenly, being elbowed by a tourist named Gary feels like a small price to pay for such a masterpiece. The crust has more structural integrity than most modern skyscrapers, providing a crunch so loud it could probably be heard in Jersey. The cheese-to-sauce ratio is a scientific marvel, defying the laws of physics by staying perfectly attached to the slice instead of sliding off onto your clean white shirt. By the time you're finishing the crust, you're already planning your second trip, fully prepared to fight another crowd just to be reunited with the Pie Guy himself. read more

Disgusting. Inedible. They took 1.5 hours to deliver, freezing cold pizza. The delivery man was rude. read more

FAKE AND PAID REVIEWS. The pizza at here is worse than a $1 slice. The crust was soggy, the sauce was bland, and the cheese tasted rubbery. Save your money and order elsewhere. read more

The pizza itself is good but the service is borderline unethical. I ordered delivery and when the food arrived things were missing. Ordering through Slice, an intermediary I called and said there was something I paid for that was missing. The restaurant claimed they tried to call me to offer a refund (they certainly did not) and refused to issue a partial refund. The pizza is decent but the business seems a bit shady. read more

Love how awesome it is to have their pizza feed a whole party full of people. The cheese slice is great and a classic NYC staple. Can't wait to have them again! read more

Incongruous placement next to a string of Vietnamese restaurants in CTown but I was pleasantly surprised. It's good pizza that's got a soft, mildly sweet dough. It was like biting into a cheesy pillowy cloud. Great spicy little pepperonis on one slice, bits of buffalo chicken on another. Reheated a few minutes in a hot oven at home, it was a nice little meal! read more

The best pizza we ever had in City!! The pizza was so delicious and with so many flavor could choose that we even visited the pizza shop twice in the same day! You could just take away or standing finish your pizza in the store. read more

A seriously good slice for only $2.50. My very picky 7 year old that eats nothing including pizza asked me to post this review because she's on her second slice and loving it. To quote her "say it's so cheesy. And it's very big. The sauce is very tomatoey". read more

The Pie Guy Pizza - a little girl eating a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I think I found my local NYC pizza joint. Their pizza was great, prices was good, and worth a visit. If you're hungry for something heavier and unique, try their spicy rigatoni pizza. Otherwise, their slices tastes like what I expect from a NYC slice. read more

The Pie Guy Pizza - a menu for pie guy - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Our go to spot whenever we're in Chinatown. The pizza is SO yummy! Service and ambience are great! Check it out. You won't be disappointed.

This has got to be the most underrated pizza!!! Idk how its so good i think its the sauce ! I get the supreme and my goood its definitely delicious!!!! Highly recommend! Born and raised in Queens read more

Really enjoyed the quality and hospitality from The Pie Guy Pizza! The pizza is tasty, with a flavorful sauce, just the right texture for the crust -- and the experience is further uplifting by great service. I first tried them when they provided pizzas at a Filipino community event earlier this month, and it's awesome to see that they are involved in local happenings. Will happily be a repeat customer! read more

This Pizza place is the best! We had a huge order for 20 pies for a student Denim Day March to raise awareness about sexual assault. The Pie Guy was the only shop who was quick to respond and help us secure our order the day of. He was so friendly and accommodating when we came to pick up the order. The pizza was delicious and the students loved it. Huge shout out to Pie Guy Pizza and for taking an order even though he wasn't open- he took the order and it was the day before their opening day. Much success to your business in the days to come! We'll be back. :) read more

Good eats! Great Service! Chill Vibe! One of the best pizza spots in NYC !!! Stop by when you're in the city for a bite. (: read more

Sets a high bar for the classic new york slice. The crust was just the right amount of crunchy while still being chewy. The cheese was well marbled. The sauce was good, not to sour like some of the cheaper places. Service was quick and the price was reasonable. The slice was heated to a good temperature. read more

I often pass by for a quick slice. The staff is super nice and the pizza is absolutely delicious! A MUST try!

A great addition in the neighborhood. Good pizza and friendly staff. Can't go wrong! I would recommend this place.

Best pizza!! Generous portions of toppings, great tasting crust!! Always our family's go to when in the area!

I came here on a whim, and I'm glad I did. This place has a great classic plain pizza. And for my father who is a old-time meat-lover heavily enjoyed the spicy rigatonis pizza, one of the best, potentially better than Chicago's Nancy's. read more

Really great spot. Great food and the vibes were really nice. Will be back again! Great service as well all the staff were really nice.

the perfect pizza to satisfy your cravings!! Highly recomended in terms of service, ambiance and the food!!

Delicious pizza!! Stopped in for a slice and can't wait to go back for more. Great staff and overall great experience.

This pizza is amazing!!! we had a great experience with delicious food and great service. can't wait to go back!!

On top of good food and nice staff that is involved in the community.

Great selections of topping to cheese for pizza. excellent pizza and great service. Will be ordering again soon.

Delicious pizza! Great crunchy crust, no flop. Great flavor. Some of the best service!

My favorite spot for pizza in NYC! Their Spicy Rigatoni slice is incredible! Must try! I enjoy their classic slice as well, can't go wrong!

Ordered the meat lovers and went outside to eat it. The pizza was so fucking good holy shit. Devoured that and then came back for seconds. The guy working there was super nice and quick with getting everything done. Jury duty was the only reason I ever found this place and for the first time ever I'm happy jury duty is a thing. This pizza was so good it changed my stance on the judicial system. Amazing pizza if I am ever in the area again I will be coming back read more