Favorite bbq ever--best brisket I've had anywhere!! Delicious pulled pork...The fully dressed…read morepulled pork sammie features a generous portion of well seasoned, smoked pork topped with their Granny Smith spike slaw, dry rub, cheese sauce and bacon!! So good. Meats can be purchased by the pound or as a platter. Delicious corn bread. The slaw is so good! Only complaint is that the pasta in the mac and cheese is usually under cooked. This place is a must, but not much time to eat in...it's primarily take out.

Best BBQ in town! I crave their cornbread. Just the right amount of bbq sauce on every bite.read more

Walking in the smell of BBQ hits like a roadside stand in the middle of no where. The place is…read moreclean and wasn't real busy on a Friday afternoon. The waitress was really friendly. We tried the 1/4 lb platter. With fries and potato salad. The pulled pork was amazing. Great flavor and very tender. The smoked sausage was as good as any smoked sausage I have had in upstate NY. The chicken was also very tender and had a good smoked flavor. The ribs had a lot of flavor and were not over cooked like some places do. The brisket.... Was brisket.... Maybe it wasn't made today which is fine. It tasted more like a roast than a brisket. My wife and I differ on our opinions of BBQ houses. I like to try the meats before I put any sauce on. My wife like it covered beforehand. This place doesn't smother it but does put it on before I got a chance to try the meats. The potato salad was ok but not bursting in flavor. The pieces in it are cut fairly large. It was ok. Fries are fries. A little over salted. But they did have malt vinegar. We might try this place again.

I was not happy with the food here. I ordered pork ribs and brisket. The brisket was nasty:…read moregrayish, and unpleasantly fatty. (It's supposed to be fatty, but not like how it was.) I wondered if it had really been barbecued. I didn't finish it. The ribs were okay, but not enough to make up for the brisket. The only part of the meal I really liked was the broccoli, which had been cooked with bacon. The plate below, with ¼ pound each of ribs and brisket, cole slaw, small corn muffin, and broccoli, was $47 including tax and tip. Price, service, and atmosphere were all acceptable, I have no complaints there. But the food was not good enough to bring me back.

We found this restaurant on Yelp and we were not sorry. My brother is a conossueure of smoked meat…read moreand he loved it...we all did! The portions were good sized... Only complaint was that the trays were too small for the sandwiches! The onion rings were sweet..a little greasy, but I'd order them again...great on the Little Butchie sandwich! Dylan served us so efficiently and with a positive attitude this afternoon. He always had a smile on his face, got our order correct for our party of 6, and offered us take home boxes at the end of our meal. Bathrooms were clean and neat too. Don't miss this great spot!! You won't be sorry!!

This was the better barbecue in Corning. All the meat was good and pretty, tasting pleasantly of…read moresmoke. Look at the nice red ring on that brisket! Nickels Pit provides three or four sauces you can put on. The tater tots were crisp and hot. The corn muffin was large and tasty, with a coarse crumb. The greens had some sort of cheese sprinkled on. I liked everything I ate. I ate as much as I could, and had the cold leftovers two days later for breakfast. It was still good. The service was great. I was the only person in the restaurant (Monday night in winter) and the server was very willing to help. He improvised a hot toddy for me, which they don't have on the menu, and it was very pleasant. Cost was $51, including tax and the toddy ($8), but leaving out tip.

I highly recommend EVERYTHING! Good raspberry tea, french fries and chicken!!!!…read more The kids had fish sandwiches and their meals came with ice cream. If I had room left after the huge bowl of cole slaw and mashed potatoes, I would have tried the peanut butter pie. It looked really good and judging from the Reese looking candies on top, it was homemade. If we had stayed in Elmira longer, we'd have eaten here again! No doubt, to quote my husband's familiar baseball slang, "Winner, winner chicken dinner!" But I think that was because, they got to eat food when they won the baseball game. It still works, right?

Quite disappointed with what used to be a very good place. The Cole slaw was not like it used to…read morebe. Someone who apparently was in charge was rather rude to her employee in front of customers something I am not fond of in any way at all. Understand a need for communication at times but never in front of patrons.

Butcher-shop quality meets pit-master soul! Rating:…read more If you are anywhere near Sayre (or even just passing through on Route 220), do your stomach a favor and pull over. This isn't just "good for Pennsylvania" BBQ--this is legitimate, high-quality smokehouse craft. The Food: Coming from a butcher shop background, these guys clearly know their meat. * The Brisket: I'm picky about brisket, but theirs was rendered perfectly with a beautiful smoke ring. No knife needed. * Pulled Pork: Super juicy. I highly recommend getting it with the Southern Sweet sauce. * The Sides: Don't sleep on the Salt Potatoes (a local staple) or the Sweet Potato Biscuits. The biscuits are a total sleeper hit--slightly sweet, fluffy, and perfect for mopping up extra sauce. The Vibe: It's a classic, no-frills BBQ joint. It's clean, the staff is incredibly "small-town friendly," and you can tell it's a local favorite by how busy the takeout counter stays. There's a nice outdoor area if you want to eat in the fresh air, which is a big plus during the summer. The "Be Aware": They are closed on Sundays and Mondays, so don't make the mistake of driving out here on a weekend whim without checking the calendar! Also, the Burnt Ends sell out fast--if they have them when you walk in, buy them immediately. Verdict: Huge portions, fair prices, and meat that actually tastes like it spent time in a smoker. I'll definitely be back for a full rack of ribs next time.

The BBQ meals are exceptional!! I ordered out. Food was prepped as ordered and hot. The…read morerestaurant is quaint and all I would expect at a BBQ restaurant. When in Sayre Pa it's a great place to enjoy lunch or dinner!

We stumbled onto this authentic roadside BBQ on our returning trip from Seneca Lake to NYC. We…read moreordered a sampler, which includes a chicken leg & 3 baby ribs, a side order of homemade coleslaw and buffalo mac n cheese. The order is absolutely filling for 1 person, but it is also great for 2 of us. Chicken leg was smoked perfectly without broken skin, juicy, with flavors. The baby ribs were BBQ with perfect smoke and just falling off the bone. The buffalo mac n cheese has the right amount of spicy and sour to give a good kick. Its coleslaw salad is just as good without saggy of juices. Cost was $27 with tips. P.S. The staff who took our order looks like the all American from Norman Rockwell's painting, great smile and great attitude!

Was in the mood for bbq and decided to stay local and try local bbq. Ordered the chicken and…read morebrisket. We open the brisket and it looked burnt. No smoke ring for smoked brisket. Looked dry with juice poured over it. Son took a bite and said it tastes like pot roast from a crockpot. I take a bite and agreed it was overcooked and obviously kept in some type of heating element which continued to cook it. Call back to see if they would do anything and I was told they never had any complaints before. They were not willing to exchange or refund. Very disappointing for bbq. This is not what brisket is supposed to taste or look like

Absolutely delicious meal. John was our server and recommended the best meal! He was terrific…read more Super quick arrival of the food. Ribs were superb, greens and slaw were amazing whiskey sour from scratch! Not to mention the cornbread I stole from my hubby. No photo, the food disappeared too fast!

Awesome spot downtown. Great atmosphere, nice bar area with outdoor seating. I get brisket, it was…read moreamazing, tender, juicy and flavorful. the sides were good as well, but the stars were the home-made barbecue sauces at the table, each with a unique flavor sure to suit everyone's pallet. Great service and great iced tea! Cant skip the mac-n-cheese, it was creamy and had great flavor.

Pretty awesome BBQ place that I saw driving in, decided to give it a shot…read more Food: since I wasn't from the area, I asked a local who said that their go to is Swamp Fries so we gave it a try. This was simply one of the best covered fries I have had. A solid pulled pork over some fries with a decent cheese sauce makes for a good time. Service: unfortunately the food takes a LONG time after you order. I know I had quite a bit of people in front of me, but 45 minutes is a long time. Aesthetic: roadside stand with a cool, rustic, barn-like feel. Definitely seems like a great spot during the summer months.

The chicken was great, bbq'ed perfectly! Drove by hundreds of times and glad I finally stopped.read more

We had this at a wedding a few weeks ago and it was great so I had to hit them up since we're 10…read moreminutes away. The BEST bbq around... only issue is I can't get it everyday. The pulled pork sandwich and brisket are amazing. The Mac and cheese is like mama's, made with love. The cheesy corn has got a little spice to it. It's something I've never had before. It's all fresh because, we'll they're only open one day a week. This is certainly going to be a regular. There's a family across the road that was pressing apples to make cider, they gave us some and it was great. They're planning to open a country store to sell their goods in right next door. Small town at its finest, friendly folk

Smokey Legends catered our reunion 7/21. Everything...food, service was fantastic. Would recommend…read morethem to anyone. Thanks to the people at Smokey Legends, Glen Aubrey.

My girlfriend and I visited here for lunch recently based on the reviews. Very understated…read morebuilding, but very clean and very comfortable! Outstanding menu, I wanted to order all the things! The french fries are absolutely probably the best I've ever had. They're fried with beef tallow. If you know, you know! The pulled pork sandwich was outstanding in their Carolina barbecue sauce is pure gold !! can't wait to go back! Outstanding and friendly ownership and staff as well!

Stopped for the first time today. Not much to look at from the outside (or inside) but when you…read morewalk through the door the smell of BBQ hits you. It was crowded which is always a good sign. I hadn't had lunch and tried the pulled pork sandwich (to go). Also ordered a half rack of ribs for dinner and a container of Mac salad. The pulled pork sandwich was tasty with a generous portion of meat. Had the ribs for dinner and they were fall off the bone delicious with great bark. Would definitely go back based on my first experience.